High Court of Punjab and HaryanaCRR/3704/2016disposed of

Atul Sood v. Cholamandlam Investment And Finance Company Limited

2017-05-30Mr. Justice Sudhir Mittal9 pages

!

"#

!"#"

"#$ % # "

&

'#("

)* # (

!"#"

"#$ % # "

&

'#("

)* # (

!"#"

"#$ % # "

&

'#("

)* # ( $ % &'$ ( $ ( + "

(,"!"-"

.%'"

!( /"!( ".%'"

( 000 12

!

'## .

!"#"

"# $ % # "

&

' #("

)* # .

!"#"

"#$ % # "

&

'#("

)* # "

!"#"

"# % # "

&

'#("

)* # "

3

4 ( 2 5 6 . -

4 -" (" +7

! "

# $ $% &&' $ !

$%

( ') $ $ !

%

$

*)'+ 12 4"

" "

4"# .68.6.8 97.

# # -" "

%"3- !("

"

"

"# . .6 .

97-" 2 ( "

' " 5 6 . /"

!( ". %'" "(("

3!" ! ( 7 &

' #("

) "

"# ! "

"

# :#"

" # . .6 .

97!"%" ")3

'" !3)! ( 7&

'#("

)"

!

4

-"

! ( -" ' % ' "

' 3) ! 3- "

! ( '

#

"

%

!"%"

"4"

! 162 (("

). 3! ! ("

!"% "# '"3) % !

' % )3)-")

4

# # ! "# !" " ") 3 "' ( ( 7 &

' #("

) !" '

4 "!" - ! ! ( ' ! ( !"

3

4!'

#

" %

"

!" 4!

4 '

!

!3"

'#( # 12 *"

' ! ( 3) )

4 (

!""#! $ %%% &'

( ) '*

)) !"+"+ $ +,-' !"%

" ;" /4# ' % ' "

'.( '"

'#(

4#'!"

#

# ' 4 "3 $ ' " !

' " !

4 '!< !"%

'#( " ) (

"

! 3 4 % ( ' ' '#" %#'!"

#

' "# "'

% - 4-!

'!

!" 3 '!

"'

#

"% .! .!(

) !34 % '#( " )#'!"

#

1 2 *"

' " ( .

$

'& / * 0 '

!"+" +1"2 & * ./ / )3 !"++! $ !1,"

' !"!'#( #

< -

)4

4-") 4! !#" " !

(3- ! ("

"

- %" % "

4

!

"% =!

> '

-3

' '- !! (

'

!4 "3$ '"

.

$

'&4 &)

182 % - "

"

.> "

'( '

8 !4 "3$ '"

'

!"%3"

") ' !4 "3 '34

- ! 3 "

'" "

'!

'" 3

4 !( ( '##

'"

4!"! ( %

!"( %"

( ! ( "

)!

4' "

!' ) )! "-.! . (

"

'#("

' 8 !4 "3$ ' '"

3 3)-") "'#( #

(' % "

)!

"

'

4!( %

# '

("

'"

=! '!# ' " - !

( ' "" (' "

" ( %

'"3

4! "

3 4" "

" !" "

# 3 "

%4 "

"4 ""- ( ' =! "'#

#

' !4 "3$ '3

4! ('

" "--( %"

% 4 ""- 152 &) )

)

'

+122+-%+.!? @3(> -!

"

- ! ! ( %

"

"

4"4 3 "

'" 3 %

-

4#"

+ , $

-$. / &0 ,

$

% . % $ +$ $

% $

$

$ $

+1 2

%

$

$

$

%

$

% % $ +3

%

$

-$. / &0 ,

% $ $ / ' 4 5 ,

"

,

% $

%

$

$

$ %

$ $

$

% 2

%

$

$

$ %

45 ,

"

, *# %%

-$.%

$

$ ++ 1 2 =! >( 4 " "- "

('

" "- "

" % # "

"("

'"

3/'"- !3)

(' %"' !" ( 34 '")"3"

) "-" 3

44 ""- ('

""- A ().!

' (

!"3 ' 8 ! 4 "3 ' " 3/'#" -!

'!'"

3"- !

!$ "=!>( ('

""-"

' !$ ".'"

3"B

#"

) "'# -!

'!'

"

!

' #" (

!"3 !$ "=! "3 '

"

3) ' 8. 5. "

! 4 "3 '"

' #(" - !"

'! -

' #("3)$ "=! .'

! 4 "3 $ ' - ( %"

% ! '!#

'

4' 12 - ! < "

! ( "

!"%

#"

'' 3 !

!

'!)"

"

4 "-")

# ! /

' ! 3)

4'"

"%"

!3

3 "

'"

# ' !4 "3$ '.%

- !

3 ! 1 2 =! "-"

"

"''((

'

(!" ! " B"

- "("

'"

(

. #")! ! % "- !!(

-!

'!"

3)"

) !("

$

"

'" ."< !"

!"-!! "

"%"

4 " ) # "

"

!"%

4 #"

'' !

.!( '"

! ( ( ' "- !'

!4 "3$ ' <" !

4 !'#("

!3"

'#( # - !

43 ! "

(

# 12 =!/

' ! '

"- ! '

! $ "

" =! " "-"

!"-! "!

4 <

3

"("

'"

" !

.! ! "# !3

!" % ) " !

.!-% .>'( '"

3'"

%

% -

! /

' ! " 3

4 "3 "

! ('

" " '#( " )#'!"

#$

#)% -."( "4#" '"(( "'! !3"( " ' "

! 4" 3- !("

!

'!

'" " ('"

'#(

4!

' ' 8

!4 "3$ '- !!"

' !

4 "3$ '"

3 "

)!' '

' ! "' -! ! /

' !

%B ' =! #3"

4

' !4 "3$ '"

!"#"B !

' ' 8 !4 "3$ ' 3

' "

# ! #"

' (

!"3 !$ " 1 2 % - "' "

'

'# "

' !'" . "'#

4 3) ! ( "

"%"

4 " )

#)- "

'!

4! !( =!

4 '#( " )#'!"

# 3" " "

- 3)!(>

.

$

'&4 &)

!

" ('.'" ) 5

)5 0 / &

)5 '

!""- %2,# &(

'"

3 . -!

("

" ! /4# " " +7 3 % $

/ 6 7 $

$

8

$

2

%

+ 162 &

4 ( ! 3"

'#( # %

(

4! #)

!

'!) #"

"

"3

% - 3 %" #"3)

&)

"

6 5 7 &( '

!"++2 $ !#+% "

4

'

" .!

!% -!".! 3/'#"

!'#("

!" 3 '#( 3)-") "# '"3

' % ).! .! ! 3"

)

#( #

#! "

43- !("

"''

) '!

'" ). #") 4 %

! 3" 3 3- !("

12 % - "

"

. #(4 /4# (" 3) 3-"

! 3) "

'.!"# !" 3

# # .! .

% - 3 %"

#"

.

$

'&4 &)

.( 6C

!'!<"# ! 3)-"

%

/ ' 1 2 :

( "''

4) ) $ (* 6 (

' +,,- ./(012 / +,,- 0-34 /