High Court of Punjab and HaryanaCWP/10575/2013allowed

Naresh Kumar Kataria & ORS v. State Of Punjab & ORS

2015-07-30Mr. Justice Augustine George Masih9 pages

!" #! $ % # &'

($!!"!

!"

) #! $* +,- #" $

!"

!. #! $ %

$

!"

)! #! $

!"

/"$ #! $

& $

!"

)! #! $ '

!"

!! #! .

(

!"

$ . #! .

) )

!"

! #! .

$

!"

/ ) #! .

*+ $

!"

.") #! #$

!"

$. #! ) ,

!"

.$) #! &

$

!"

!$ #! $

!"

,( 01, 2

11 3 3

' # &%4%4 '5%67 % 9 '

3 :;9<

= 7 # 9 3

'

= $ 3 3 3 :;9<5

'3 ;97 9 3 < '=

- ).! . * /.

+ ) &/.

+

), /.

+ )*. /.

+ )0 1/.

+ )' $/.

+ ) &

$/.

+

)*( /

.' !"

), (/.

.

+ '

/ !"

11>* 1-(?

1

"

$ +

/

" + +&

/34/ 45/64/3/3 //5/44/63 5/ 534/5/534

1 + "

$+

7

++

/

+

/

6

8

&

9

$

8 + & $

+ .

0"

8

$

+8

/

:+

/

;.

< =/

&++

$ 8

8&++

/ & / "

<

8

"& +

+

1 $

& 8 8"

/

8<

/

;.

< = .++ $8/

&

8 <

& 4 . $ 8/

& "

8

+

6

/

8/ +

$ $

.

& "

'

+

&( "

$

+

&

+ +

+

8

"8 >

/

"8

& &

+8

++ +

/ + "

!

+

"8

/

;.

< 4=1 &/

"

." 8

"

$

;.

<

4=/ & +

$ +

/

$

? +

+

? + / & "

+ / & $

;.

< =

+ 8/ /

+

"

+

.++ $8/ +

& !

+

>& "

<

/5

+

$

-

! !

"! #

# $%&% $'

( (

(

) ! (

#

* ( #' + ( , -* .* ( ,' ,! #

( ! #' ## *

( ! ( , -* ,! /

' #

# ) !

( + !(

0

# ##

0

# ( 1 ( 0 2%34%

50" %2 ( ( 2

( ! !(

7

#

(

, -*

.* ( ,' ,!

( ( 3

/ ) !

# 3%

% &530 % 3&( (

0

# ( !

! *

! ! #'

( ( *

#

$%&% $'

!

"!

% #'

"! / "!

/ "! #

/"

"! 1 !

8(

+# %* %9 ! ("!

1 !

+# %* ) ! "! # ( : #'

*

( ! ( , -*

.* (,' ,!

(

( * (

#' +

( ( !

/

: #' * / #

(* 5:

(;

$

( ! (

0

# / #

! ! #'

$%&% $'

"! .* (

! #'

* !

(*' 9 #

# #

(

#

' #

&33

<!= ! (

> .*= ( /

(

(#= ! (

> .*= ( /

&

" ( = ! ( > .*= / 323

= ! (

>= .*= (

&2

<!= ! ( >

.*=

( ! * ( , -* ,! / #

! *

(

* #

*

( #

#

3 / (

0

#

( ( 1 ( 2%34%

50 %2 ( ( 2

(

, -* .* (,' ,! ( ( 3

5

( * (

) ( #

/(

*

) ! #' /

( ! #

* ( *' #

&33

<! = ! (

> .*= ( /

(

(#= ! (

> .*= ( /

&

" ( = ! ( > .*= / 323

= ! (

>= .*= (

&2

<!= ! ( > .*= / #' .

("# /

#

(

* #

#

.

( 7< + /

+

$

;.

< 4=

+

"

." $

"8

;.

< =/ $

+

6

/ +

$

6 /&

"8

9

8/ &

++

&

> +/ $ /

++8

"

8

& "

"8

"

+

"8

'

$ "

$

+

&

5

>& "

"

$

/

- 7='/ #

* * ' #

! #' # (

( # !

# !

#

(

## ! ( ( #

*

( ( *' =

!

* ( !(

(

#

(

#' ( ;

1 "

$ / <

" +

? +

7*

( ! ( , -* .* (,' ,!

(

( * (

#';/

8+8 +

+

!

+" +

& ,

+ +

+

1"

$ /

&

9

8/

;.

< 4=

*

+

:

/ +8 ++ + &&/&

+ +

+

8

/ +

"

/

$ & +

+@

"

"8

$ $

/

+

& /

+

+

<

+

*

11-