Sukhbir Singh v. H.D.F.C. Bank Ltd.
!"
#$%$ & $ '$ $$
!"
#$%$ & $ '$ $$
!"
#$%$ & $ '$ $$
!"
#$%$ & $ '$ $$
$ & $
$ & $
$ & $
$ & $
&( & )*+$,-.
&( & )*+$,-.
&( & )*+$,-.
&( & )*+$,-.
/0123/42*/2/032
"
*0*
& !
%16(
*,7 $+8 9%6 # /
# & /
& &/$ $+8 9%6 # /
# & /
& &/$ $+8 9%6 # /
# & /
& &/$ $+8 9%6 # /
# & /
& &/$ " " " " (+ /0
(:0-$7 )( (2
/(*2/-& ,0(;$7 )( - ;
$&//012<-$7 )( (2 %1
=>=>=> =>=>=> =>=>=> =>=>=>
# & /
& &/$-#
# & /
& &/$-#
# & /
& &/$-#
# & /
& &/$-#
*((
**7 )( 74*((2 ))0 ) )((2 ,0*23 07 / )( ?@(2 4(3 *(0 (*$)(-@@*2(9(2 $)(9
"
2*3
* 7(07 4*, ,* ;
7 ( ,; A )* * ), *( ( (2
),(8 &!%1)**(2 *7 7 (0(), *((0(2 07 4 *, ,* (
% )(* (2( (2 , 27 * 7 (2
*A-B-@C8 )2 &!%1(,0)2*
2)
"
,, (;7 0( 7,; (*( (* (2
(2 )(3 .- 0( A-?-C8 D* 0(*(744*(2(2 (2
))0(* 7 ( 7*)24 2*3(;-2 **0 7)2 E0 (2 *70( 7( 7 ? .- F23( ),(8%1 2 4 ,*( 7 (2 )2 E0 ) )( ( (* 2(1 %)2- (2
* D* (0 7 0,7 D( *0) ( 07* (2
))0((2 8))0* &!%1) 70,(2
, (1 47(2 ,; ((2 )2 E0 (2042 4 () 7( 7 .D2)2D** (3; 4*( 7,*((2
77 **, 73;2((2 ( )0((2 4
(* 2 4 7(1 E0*(
,; (- ),(8 &! %1 (( 7 ,)
74* 07 / )(?@(2 $)( (2*)0( 7(2 ) )( (2 <074 (7( 7 .
?,**
#07)4*(( *(**- 2(177 * 7( .
?
) )(77 * *(7*
<074 (7( 7@ ,** 7/ *** #074 - 2(1
?
7 )0* - ( (2
; 0(* (- 1 * *(( ((2(2 *(**4(2 ) )((2 (*
-2D
-,;* ( D(3 (1 * 47*E0(0*
*0)2 47-(*)( 7(2( * *, )) , * 07 (2 7 ") 70 D2)2 3 *(2 0((* , *D2 )(*3 )2(2 7 ,; (), *( (* )( 7(2(**(2 *03*((
*
?
*, ,* (*)) 7-(2 * 2* 7;3
07 4
E0 *( * 47* ), 0( ( ,* 7D7* 3 )27 ,; ( *(*4 *8( 4 2
$ :
5<;
2
$ :
5<;
2
$ :
5<;
2
$ :
5<; :0-? B@ :0-? B@ :0-? B@ :0-? B@-(2 93 /0, 0( 277 (D(2, )* ;*0)2**0 7272 7*D*+ G?
703( 7;-(2 **, )), *(2
7 D2)2 3 *(2 )0((* , * D2 )(* 3 )2 (2 7 ,; ( *( / )((2 , * )(D2)2(2 )0()(1 (2
; D2 ))0* 72*3
* 7(,;
" * (2 ( *(( * 2D ( 7 D(2 *(0(D2 7 0(* *, *)3 / )( 7*(20*+ G H(
;
H(
;
H(
;
H(
;
I H2 2*3
* 7(,; -(2
)0(,**4(2 * ;(1 )(
;(2 (2 3(2(2
D4D;*-(2(*(*;-(;I **0 D((2
;(2 0(3;
(()2 ( 7 * ; 3 ,, (;
44((2 J 3**0 D(((2 )((2 7*()(- 0(2*42( * 0(* * 7
0 (2 3 3
,, (;-3(2-(2 7 0( + " 7 (2(- (2 * 7 )(* (2( ((2 -(2 *2 ,* 7- 7 *0)2 2* 07 4 D2 *0)2 ,* ( 0(-)0(*2**0 *0)2D(0 **- *, ) **(3 )7 7D(4-(
)*7 *( ) **;*(7-0 **(2* 7 7 (2 ,; ( F, * * *(0((2 07 / )(?.
/((
( ; 1 0 40(4(2 D2)2D(*07 )0* *038* )( (3 )0( 7- 7(2 *0;7 (;)* 7 3;;, *(2 (2(2 *, )(;,, (;(()2 7 )0( *0)2D( ? H2 )0( **0 * D( ( (2
)(07 )0* 3*038* )(-(2
)(*2 * 0())7)
D(2(2 D (4 (
; * 7
0 - * *0)2 D( D ) ()( **0 707 *0)2D+ " 7(2(*0)2D(*23 )0( 3; (2 *( 7 ( ,* (2
K / )(?(2 , *
; ; ;(2 (2 ,;3 3; (0 ;
7 7 07 (2 7(2
;D2)2 *((2 D* F, **;, 7 , *( D7 73;)0()(2*)( 4;
/ )( ?*;*(2(*0)2 ;*23
3 *(
/ )(?(2 7*(20*+ G? ? ? ? ;7 7(3 ,7
3 * ;7 7(3 ,7
3 * ;7 7(3 ,7
3 * ;7 7(3 ,7
3 *
I
I
I
I$; ;(2 (2 ,;3 3;
(0 ;7 7 07 (2*7 -7 (27
;D2)2*((2 D*
F, **;, 7-*23
3 * (D + " 7(2(/ )(*2-(*,,)( (7 07 / )(?-3; (0 (2* )(-3 )*(0 7*(2 , *(*038 )(/ )(-( (2 D7*7
40 * L07 / )( ?.M- (2 D7* 7 40 *L7 ,; ()*(*07 / )(?M273
* ( K
20*- 2*(43)1* )((2
7
;), *(7 )( 7(3 ,7 3;(2 )0( !(2 ,0,* 7
;- *(*,0(,D(2 /
:
$ $33* :
$ $33* :
$ $33* :
$ $33*
/$
/$
/$
/$ / )(B(2 7"
7 *
7*( E0( 7 3 )0* ( , * * ,* (8,; (
( 7*(20*+ GB / ,* (8,; B / ,* (8,; B / ,* (8,; B / ,* (8,;
I
I
I
I
;)* ,0*23
D(2,* (*D * -D2)2(2
** 7( -D2 D(2 D(20(,* (-7
;)* ,0*23 D(2,* ( - D(2 ;-D2)2(2 ** ( -(*23 ), (((2 )0(D2)2 * *0)2 ( 7 )( 3; (2
(2(-7 ((2 - *2 *0 ,* ( ) ( ( - D2)2 ,* ( *2 3
F) **;(2 ,* ((D2)22
;2
3
* 7(D2)22 ;3
3 07 )0((*
K B 3
, **D F 73;(2*0( 5<; /77: $
5<; /77: $
5<; /77: $
5<; /77: $
B+? $ # +B/ B
B+? $ # +B/ B
B+? $ # +B/ B
B+? $ # +B/ B
$( E0(4(2 -(2*0( < )( 7(2 *03** (2( D2 * 7 0( ,; ( *(7 )0(- )0* );
27(/ )((2 3 )0* * , * 34 (2 )0( ( D7 7 0(
2*0(3*
7(2(*0)2 D* (1 -(2
;3< )(*038* )(?/ )(?.
D07 3 0*(( 7 7 (2 )( ,( D073 7* D2(0*;
.
H *, )(0; ))0 D(2 (2* :
:
:
:
%2*1 %2*1 %2*1 %2*1
/1572;%-./ /1572;%-./ /1572;%-./ /1572;%-./ D2 )*7 4/ )(?.?(2 (2* 0( F, ** 7(2((2 #07)4*(( (2
!*(**D (7 ), *((3 ,7( ),( 0( (2 * 7 (2
),(D3 * D2 (2 )2 E0 0(
F)
7(2 *7( *0)2)* ),( D074 (;(2 F00(0,
*
(20*73 )0* #07)4*(( !*(**)* , / )( (2 7 ,** * ,* (( ( F)
74(2
*- ( F)
74 * -C8-3(2(2 *7 0(*D) * 7( * -C8 2*0( ) 7(2(*0)2)* *(2 4*(( )
(
4
) (2 ),(3;(14 *(( / )(?.?(2
@ 7 3 27 7 )(4 (2 ))0* 7 ( ,;
*( ( (2 ),( * ( 4
2 7( **(
( 2*4
)
*/ )(?.?), *(*D7 7 **<0;*0 *70 ((2 )( (2 ))0* 7D2)22 ** ; 7 -7 )(4), *(-*,** 7-(D073
((; )(
( )07 3 7 D(20(;
,, * 7( 7
*
)* E0 *)* (*83* )
K
(2 42((2 7)(077D3;(2 $, F0(- )( (* 73; 7)0* (2 (2( 7 (), *()07(2
D7 7-* < )(
% (2(*(;-(2 )*7 7 D(2*0(-
.
( ( *03**7 3; 7)0* ,, 4 70)(* (*)) ,()
)0*(7; ) ()( 0*2 7 3; (2 7 /(( )0* 7)( * (2( (2 , 2* 7; 07 4
*03*((
* *, ,* (
07 / )(?@(2 $)(
D(2 47((2 * ;
*, ,* ( D7 7 (D7* 7 0( *(-(2 2*07 4 )0*(7;, 7
F) ***F(2* 2*) 7(2 ,4*( D ,, , 7*( 7 )7
, **(( 7(3 3 78 (2 ;
$&/ /012<- 7 )0* , (4 (2
),(8 &! %1 7 * ( * 0*; ,,*
*03** 70)( * ,* 7 3 )2 ,; (), *(0(
-2D
-*03(*(2((2
( *( &!%1(
(2 ), *(0(3
* 8407
.
(2 42((2 7*)0**3
-(2 *((
* , ((*,(;)) ,( )((2 ** 07 / )( ?@ (2 $)( * 0,2 7
D
-(2 * *, ,* (D7 7 0( ), *( 0( * 70) 7 ( (2 , 7 7; 07 4
( D07- 2D
- 3 , (2
*,7 (8 &!%1((1 )0* ))7) D(2D* 47*
; ), *( 0( A )* * ))
@
"
-D2**(( 7(3 )0*(7;(&*()(#-
@ 2(1-3 * 7(2D(2
**7*,* 7(2 *7( *
# & /
& &/$
# & /
& &/$
# & /
& &/$
# & /
& &/$ $,-. $,-. $,-. $,-. # &
# &
# &
# &
/ / / /
( +
( +
( +
( + H2 *, 14C * 7N '
*C H2 ,(3 N '
*C