← Library
High Court of Punjab and HaryanaCRM-M/6135/2018dismissed

M/S Ufipl Infrastructure Limited v. State Of Haryana And ANR.

2019-07-01Mr. Justice Manoj Bajaj12 pages

     

 !  !"#$#%& '()* +  

   

    



   &, -.       

  "# $% &' !  &%&'   &'# $%&'

  ( "

%)&*%



   #'&$$

"%&' 

(+         "  ,-+.

.  "" $ '

 /0/+1/-2&

3 04

 5&

" 6$%

"%! 5 '   $  1+-+1/7 8/9.

.

5



"  8/9 .

. "5

   (+08 /,8+119%

 ,10%,+1%,0:%,07%,0-%,7/ /+1;.% $  " 

".'"  %

"

 <

" $



 5"!

24   '5=  ""





 ""

% (+08 /,8+119 ,10%,+1%,0:%,07% ,0-%,7/ /+1;.%!

$  "

"%.'"

%) 

"!

""$ 

!

!

&

" 5  

   !

"  > "

  %!!

$'  

% 

"%24 " *  ?

=   * @ 24; '

* ! "* @ 24  

#  

  & $ 

% "* ; '

* ! 

"  

 

!



 

#%   > "* 2)  4

 $    "

       

  &     ""  2  /,7+11-4  "

 

3 ",8

"2!

 "

%/,

":

+/

"/+

 

'   '""

$

    "

7

"/0

  '   ""

$6 #

%<"A) 

"4 3!    " " 

/17:

& ,7: !

5

  

 

 "!

53 1:/+119?

  

 = "* $ " 3!  %!' % !

3    !

 '

"

5"<

% )   

$    = !    " 



3  "" /,7+11-!

 !

"

    $ 5  

     "

" 

  !

 

"  

 (!

6 " ". %!  

3 & $    

% 5  "  *  ; '

 *    

"

 " $! " $ " 

%

"%  

   $!

""$  "*  

 =  "! 

(!

6 " "

 /+:  %!' % $ ""3

   



/97  % 5  $

  7+ = !

""$  "* !

""

     "  

 "

 

%5""3 5 

<

""$     

'

  !   "'""    ""       

 & $

 % '$ !



 5 " 

"  /78.

.!

5 +///+119  ""  

   !' % 5B "% 

" !

  "   81,+1// =

 '$  !

""!5 . % 5  $ '$  5   !

 "

!

   %!' %

/ !

5

#  

     

 <$ '

 

3

  "

!

"5   

 "5*"   '

 % 5   

(7719, 1/9+11-)

  '$ %    !

          ""$    

 (7719, 1/9+11-!

$  %! 5 

" ! "! 3! # 

"?

 $ '$ %

"



$    //8+1/,%   /782-4 .

.!

  " 

 " < # %

#  

 %   %   * %

 < ="

%

(!

6 "

# 

 !

%

'$ % "" !  

 " 5'    & $%!  !

$5 

 $ 

$% 

  $2?4  /7//+1/8  !

  3  5!  

#  

  %       2  

4        

    2

4%! 5 

 =

  /1 

!

 ""

"" ""    "

  !

"$'  ?<'"   

  

 

"

'  ,7: % "5.

!

"  5!

 < 

"  %

#  

 

(!

6 " " 

 5

$.

 -,8/+1/,%  .

-,8++1/,    .

87988+1/,  '" 5 . B  $  2&

3 /4  $

? . '   +8++1/0 ""!

B  2&

3 /4B   <   +8++1/0!

 "" $5!

  5   C5"  

  .       5    .

  5       !

'  +0-+1/0 24

  (+ 

"  

"  .     6    $ .   !

       5   !           ""    /,7+11-% !

" B   '$ & 

%

 9"

=!

 $

 $

 -+-8.

.!    %!' %5B " #  '$ !

3 5

".    5

!  9"

= !!



5 " !  -/%111   B   $!

  "    $$     

"  

%  " "%    !

"



 5 "<

" !

' 5  =   ""

"



 $      (+

"  .     <  6  $

/ ."

%

"'  +,8+1/72&

3 /4

  

 ""! 

"

5

$

 $ -+-8.

.  ?

 %

$  ! 

 

  "  24 &

 $      

$%   

    '  3   ! %

"%"(

"%6

(   =  ""

 ?

5  '  5

 % 

"      8/9  .

.  !

  ' 

 $  

#  

 %  % 

(!

6 " 

".  

"   "!' %  

" !

 "  (+

.  "

!

$'    2'4 <   "  .  

 3  $     "   

 (+ 

" 

  2&

3 /4'  1+-+1/7)  !    1+-+1/7 ' !



5  . &

" 6$%

"  !

 '  /0/+1/-2&

3 04 <

.





  "" $ $  /0/+1/-

   "

$ 55 

.

   

5 !""

  % '

 3# 

'  $ ' "

$  9"

=!

5   (+%!!

" $

 

    ""     /,7+11-     %     '"'   !

 5"    !



 ' 5$

.  '  

 $ 

0 -+-8.

. 

   $

   5 '

   $  

   "

!%     !"  5      '    !

(+ 5 " ""$%!!



 " !   

   "   

       "  $$   $'   (+   $ '"' 

%  %  8/9.

.!

$" 3 5  

 

5

'

. 5    5   ?

      % 

    

  5  "

   "

$ 5 (+   (+!



  !

5 

 

""35! 

      (+!

 "  $! 

"" /,7+11- 

 "      5

"

%!   "" ""$ 

  $ "* %; '

*   %! !     

  "      "      

  .



'" ' 

 !

     ' "   

.



'  /1 

!

 "

 B     B %  $ ''

  ""%

"

"! '"5 $5



.

!

"!



 " (+ 

 .   +,8+1/7   '$  $    (+ 

 .  "  " & $    

$  

'  8/9.

."   '5 '=

   '5 & $%"

   "

$ 5

.

   ' 

$%

'  8/9.

. 5 '= B  3 "  5  !!1'2 !!134$.  ! 56)75!$6 +8.9     5



   8/9.

.



$

  &  

$  "

   "    

%    !""  5

     "  !     '      (+  $



5"  

"      8/9  .

.  &  

"

3 

  +,8+1/7 ' " !

  '$  $

 C $

$

  (+

  !  (+!

 

 "%!!



$5 < %

$

"

 " (+   +,8+1/7   

$ '     5" < %

"  8/9.

.!



5"

+ D"3  $   %    B  !

 "%  "'  ""$     

  '"' 

         ""    /,7+11-%!      !     

%

"% "* %; '

*   @ "%  '$ % ""$

!  $





'     "3

' *"   '

  &



".   

% 

! " ""$ @

" $

  "" /,7+11-  "% " '  9%11%111

   ' "     5  "

      "         

(+!

5   

"

 !

$

   "" /,7+11-   '5  " $!  )

$ %"

 

 "  "  

  /7//+1/8!

   5!

 

    B 5 . &  " ?  ="

 

 

  $ ,7: !

  < "'

?  

   

    

  



  !"# !

$"

 !

"

% " 

 &'()*(++(+++,-  

     ."

 !. $/ "$

!"  0++1-0++2 3&4!"

!"!(

 3&4!$5 (3&6."5 "

3&% !78!"

$!" %

 #%"  $$E < 5'" '   5 (+  ! '      "" B <?!

"$ 5 .

  5 !""% '"   

  

5 $5.

!

&

$

 

(+  ""

 

% "  

5 $5"' '"' (+ ""$ <   /,7+11-!

5! !



(+!

 " !     

   !

3 

   "

  

  /1 !

'5 

  ? 3   "  $

!"" "$ 5'%"

  " 

5 '$  $  $

$

  (+!



 

  

9"

=5 (+

   !



  

 <  

      ?   "    $      

   

(+ &

 

  %   $     5

$  $

$   '"' (+  

 $

$    

      3       "     <

'

3     ! %

"

"%

D8=  ""

5 ' !  " 

! 

(+



    !"  $  

"

 !

   """          !

  $   5    (+  !   

  .

       !

 

  5    .

  

(+< " '

  !

 " '

"

5"5  $$ $ '"'

(+5  



  " "

! 5#!""""

! 

'  8/9.

.

 5 '=   "  

  53  "  5" <. 

";   C5" 

.  75!!1.#%:64$.  ! '%;<%5 6!7$ /8 87#=#%(9   "

""

!

 " 3 

 8/9.

. !

" ! '  $$ 



   !!



5  %.   



"  8/9.

. & $%!""5  "  #$

5 C5"

. 

F

         !  75!!1  .#%:6C     2

4  !

  ""!    ""! 5 '

!  

  9!#    

  "

 ."     "

 !  !

"   .!

"  "  .$ :

  %" 

.! !%"

% ."%/  

!%  ! 



" #!"  

$$" &

%          

7  "

   !

"  ;<2 & &    #!" "

  "7 !"

"%

!"  !"  # 

"

%"  7".  !"      %"     :

      ( "% 

 "

  "  !  /"(        

% "! $$ !  "

 !

";<2& &&     "!

: " 

 .!

" ( 7!     %  :

  !  "

   $!



7"  :

  " !  !

"6" !"     



    (  !&&=%   "  !%   !     > !    !%

 %!"#

 #(:   

 !  !

"   "  > "      .!

" (  !

 #  ":  (7 $   ".! !

"&= .  $

%     !"" "

5#%.   " $   3#  ""! $

"  8/9 .

.  '         1+-+1/7  !   $    B  

 %  '

 $"3  '

    " "% $   

! $   /0/+1/-2&

3 04 ;  

 $  !    #$       "

      5 '

  

5' "" 5  3



    "%! $ <

"  5 1/6"%+1/9 8 9 >#;)$#;

  D  = $  G( D 5" G(