High Court of Punjab and HaryanaCRM-M/26633/2020allowed

Rahul Verma And Others v. State Of Haryana And Another

2021-02-24Mr. Justice B.S. Walia6 pages

! !"#$#%& ' ()*+!,-%. ,$ /! # #%!,$ +!,$)$ 0 ! ,1%%.% (!, /!$2%.!% $

,!$!% & ,%-1 )2 3.4" ! , (!2! # #%!,$ ,+#4!5 ()(%3..* 3 ,1% , ,4# 6*,3.4" ! , (!"-2*#%% 777

' ,1!,#% (!2! # #%)%.!,0!" #%8 , #$ ,9)$(#%:

''3 . !. '; ,!:#$ !,!. )%.!, 0!" #%$ 3 %. ;8 *#"! 0 #% )$%3 #$ ,#" !<,# *%: <# ( ** "%$!9)!% #* ",#-#%* 2,"!!.#%:$ !-% #%: (!,! ,- % (! =$#$ "-2,-#$!3 %%!>),! ? . !. ; 3 $ <!** $ (! .!"#$#% %@=*! (!0)2,!-! ), #% !" # $ %&'%( )) *(+$<!**$ !, %&&+ % )) --- A!,%!. ")%$!* , (! 2! # #%!,$ "% !%.$ ( -,,#:! =! <!!%2! # #%!,'%.,!$2%.!% <$$*!-%#B!. !<,#% '8 <!4!,3 (!,!#$%"(#*.) (! ,!-!% #%!.<!.*"5 %..)! .#

!,!%"!$=! <!!%2! # #%!,'%.,!$2%.!% 3 (!,! <$- ,#-%#*.#$2) !3$,!$)* <(#"(3 (! ,!-!% #%!.<$

: ,!:#$ !,!.=1,!$2%.!% <!4!,3%<<# ( (!#% !,4!% #% ,!$2!" =*!-!-=!,$ $"#! 1 ,-= ($#.!$3.#$2) !$-%:$ (!2, #!$ ($ =!!% -#"=*1 ,!$*4!. %. "-2,-#$! %%!>),! ? . !. ; !>!") !. =! <!!% 2! # #%!, ' %. ,!$2%.!% $ 2!, <(#"( 2! # #%!, ' (. :,!!. 21 % -)% $3

? ,!$2%.!% #% )** %. #%* $! *!-!% ** "*#-$3 ) <(#"( $83

? <$ 2#. (! #-! ,!",.#%: (! $ !-!% #,$ - #%%; =!

,! (!*!,%!...# #%*,#%"#2*).:!3-#*1

), 3 ),):,-3 $C3

? <$ 2#. (! #-! ,!",.#%: $ !-!% $!"%.- #%=!$#.!$=*%"!-)% ($*$=!!%2#.$ 2!, "-2,-#$! (! "-2*#%% !"!#2 )** 21-!% $ 2!, "-2,-#$! #$ "5%<*!.:!. =1 *!,%!. ")%$!* , (! "-2*#%% ? ,!$2%.!% A!,%!. )%$!* , (! 2! # #%!, $ <!** $ *!,%!. ")%$!* , (! "-2*#%% ? ,!$2%.!% $ ! ( 2, ,- $3

?(4#%:=!!%2#.=1 (!2! # #%!, ,!$2%.!% 3#% !,-$ (! "-2,-#$!3 2! # #%!, ' %. ,!$2%.!% (4!=!!% :,% !. .!",!! .#$$*) #% -,,#:! =1 (! ), (! *!,%!. ..# #%* ,#%"#2* ).:!3 -#*1 ), 3 ),):,- % ' 8 2),$)% (!,.!, (#$ ), . !. 8 ;

0 !-!% $ (! 2, #!$ <!,! ,!",.!. =1 (! *!,%!. ..# #%* #4#* ).:! 0, #4")-0)= #4#$#%* ).#"#* :#$ , !3 6$*#%; ; $2!,<(#"(,!$2%.!% ?"-2*#%% ($$ !. ( $(!($!% !,!.#% "-2,-#$!<# ( (!"")$!.#%,!$2!" ''. !. ';,!:#$ !,!.)%.!,0!" #%$;8%. ,!.<# ( 0!" #% *#"! 0 #% )$% ) (!, <% ,!! <#** %. 4*# #% %. <# ( (! $$#$ %"! <!** -!%#%: !*.!,$ %. ( #% (! "#,")-$ %"!$3$(!.!$ % <% "% #%)!%1 2,"!!.#%:$ :#%$ (!

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

,- ,! 9)$(!. % (! =$#$ "-2,-#$!3 %%!>),! ? . !. ; 3 $ <!** $ .!"#$#%$ %@=*! (! 0)2,!-! ), #%

. $ . !*!4% !> ," $ (! ,!$#..!"#$#%$,!,!2,.)"!.$)%.!,&

" #

() *

(+*

$ ,-./!-0 12 3%)444& +5""67+8

(; *

<<= 5

;7>= 0 "

;7>=

* #

<<= 0 " ' F (4!(!,.*!,%!.")%$!* , (!2, #!$%."%$#.!,!. (!#, $)=-#$$#%$ .-# !.*13 # #$ (! .) 1 ), !%"),:! :!%)#%! $! *!-!% - ,#-%#*.#$2) !$#%4#!< (!.!"#$#% %@=*! (! 0)2,!-! ), #% . % #%) #% ",#-#%* 2,"!!.#%:$<)*.2) (!"")$!. :,! 22,!$$#%%.2,!E).#"!.!$2# !

)** %. "-2*! ! $! *!-!% %. "-2,-#$! <# ( (! 4#" #- % $)"( $# ) #%3# <)*.=!)% #,%."% ,,1 (!#% !,!$ E)$ #"!=!$#.!$ =)$! 2,"!$$ *<# (!2,"!!.#%:$,!**<!. "% #%)!3.!$2# ! $! *!-!% %."-2,-#$!=! <!!% (!4#" #-%. (!<,%:.!, C %"-2,-#$!** (!2, #!$$ %. :#%%.%%!#$*$!, %*1.!$"-2,-#$!=,#%:$=) 2!"!%.(,-%1=! <!!% (! 2, #!$ (!.#$2) !=) (!2, #!$,!*$=*! (!- -4!%#%*# !%. =)#*. (!#,*# ! ,!$("",.#%:*13 5#%:#% "")% (!

!%"!$)%.!,

<(#"( (! ($ =!!% ,!:#$ !,!.3 $ *$ (! " ( (! 2, #!$ (4! -#"=*1 $! *!. (! .#$2) ! =1 <1 "-2,-#$!3 "% #%) #% ",#-#%*2,"!!.#%:$<)*.=!%!>!,"#$!#% ) #*# 1 8 "",.#%:*13 #% (! *#:( (! 2$# #% % !. =4!3 "-2,-#$!3 %%!>),! ? . !. ; $ <!** $ (! .!"#$#%$ %@=*! (!0)2,!-! ), #% $ . 3 #%$ % 2! # #%)%.!,0!" #%8 , #$%.

''3. !. '; ,!:#$ !,!. )%.!, 0!" #%$ 3 %. ;8 *#"! 0 #% )$%3 #$ ,#" !<,# $ *$ ** "%$!9)!% #* ",#-#%* 2,"!!.#%:$!-% #%: (!,!

,-,! 9) (!2! # #%!,$ $

,%(%&%' ?.#

@= A

C @E