← Library
High Court of Punjab and HaryanaRSA/3158/2005dismissed

Kulwant Rai v. State Of Haryana, ORS

2017-11-03Mr. Justice Tejinder Singh Dhindsa16 pages

       

  





 !

""

# $%&'( ) (

"""""**&&( ) +,"

)() - (./( ( (

)0.,

"""",*  ), 1!

 23 1"

 

1 



  

    

     

1 





"



 "  #   $%% & &  $'%(  "&&# 

  

 

 $$ %+ +%%,    - .  )    

"$  &#  /



/

 

 +0 %, +%%1  2 & . 3. -4 )

&   

"! &# 

+ )  



     "5# /

 6 

   3/   4 5    378 *$4 

 



 / 

:

*

; : 1  /  6 "

#





) 

  



 

  

< )

=  



%$ %1 $'($

 /



 )

) )   /    $'(,

  

= -

 



2 ) & )    

"2 ) &#

/ 

 ++ %+ $''>

? 





)/  

  /   +1 %+ $''>

 1,@ A



=     



 /A

5B )  6 /

 * : 1  2; $+ %$ $'', 378 -*$%4

/

 +C %, $''1 378 -*>4  !  &

* ; : +



* ; : $ 

=     /



 

 

 /   

 )  





  



 

 

  

?  )



 $% %> $'($ /   %$ %> $'($ 1% %> $'($

%$ %1 $'($

 





    $'(, 

= -  )/ 

 

/   +1 %+ $''>

 1,@ A



 

=  ) 

> 



  -  ! &

 



! 

  

  

  &   $+ %$ $'',

<





   

=

 ) 



 /

) B 

 

/ )





   





=

)

) 



 





  

=

   

< <    "  

= ! 

=   #

     8 

  



 

) 

   )







   ) 



/     

   /   

 /   $% %> $'($





    8 

> ?    )  !   /

 * $

D   



 / 6E ?

+ D   



) 

E ?- D   





 

 

;    $+ $% $'',E ?- >



, =   



D*$

  /

* *$

*

=  *+

*

2

 %+ $% $''C *1 *0 *

 

*C *'

*

A/  

?   8  -D* $

)

 &A

)   /

   * -*$ * 2 %, %0 $''+ -*+ * 2 $0 $% $''+

-*1 * 2 +0 %, $''1 -*> * 2 +C %, $''1 -*, * 2 $( %, $''> -*0 * 2 +, %C $''> -*C * 2 

 /    ! ! &

-*( * 2 %C %' $''> -*'

* 2 



  / 

 /  

78 -*$% * 2 $+ %$ $'', -*$$ * ? -*$+ *   -D*$

)

%> %' +%%+

 A

  

  

!   : $ 





B 



  

/A







 

= : +







    

 

 +0 %, +%%1







 

  ! & 

/ $    

 

 $$ %+ +%%,



 

 !

   

 

  $      : $

 !  / )

 

/ )





5    < <  5

  

=    

  ? >$

 +C && )





 )

 

/ $ 



 A 

78 -*$+ 3  78 -*$14

(



'

=

 2 & $  

 /

/



  



) 

   ? >$

 +C &&

= 

 



   +0 %, $''1 -*14

# /

 $  





 



B  





     A  

)

 

  = 

 

 $  

< <   ) /

  

 

8 

< <  <

)  

    



  

 

G)  

0(7'()

(.,(

(

)0., +,"

&0

)() .(& +&*8 ) .*.()

3$''%4 $ && 10$ ?      *      

    

 

!  -   &4

 / 

 $'',B   

"

 $'',#   

/ 8

 /    1%'

&  

 !  - 

6 : %0 .

  $'',

  



 8 37 $>4  

 < 

8

" 



 = ! 

= &  #

 





  

  

   

1$ $+ +%$$



 )

$%

    ) 

  )A

   

 

 /

)  <

 

 

* 34 D $  

 /

/



  



  ? >$

 +C &&E 34 D 

    "5#  "

# /  



< )E

"

$$ 



    <

   /

/ )  

 



 )

  

  

  



   )  )  

>

,  /  

/

  -*$+ 

  

: ) $  

  )

78 -*$+





  

78 -*$1  

  ) / A





   %( $% +%%> )

 /   



$% %> $'($





  !    



 

    

)  $ 

/

  8 





   $$ %+ +%%,  )





  

 



  





  

<  

/

 ) 

 

 

$0  

 

  

* "

/ 



 *     



* 

   









  )  *  !     

 



 )  

/



*

   8 



  

/



 * 



  

8)

78 -*$+ # !  A $  /

/

  8 )





    

 ? >$

 +C &&

  

"

$+ !

   



 * : 1* 

 / 

:

/   %$ %> $'($ 1% %> $'($



  $'(, /  / 

!   

 ) /   +1 %+ $''> 1,@ A



   



 ) -  ! &



      )    

A/   !

$0 

 

  

* "

-  A

 



 ) -  ! &

!               

 

 

   # =



 *

  

     $+ %$ $'', 378 -*$%4



 : '> /    

 / 

:

-

$1 =        378 *$ -*$$4  / 6 * : 1

 

 C,%*$+*(C%*7H*$>*'>%  

/ 

)

   

  )  /



* "$

/ )

 /  / 8     /A       /  +

)    



  - 





/   G     /

   

 /     

   /     



/      / 

      > =       /

    

,

/ 

  

 /

 

 

 

 

 

 

!  - 

/      

  &  ?  -#

$>  / 

)   A

  )



 $+ $% $'', /    

)  

   



     



 

   

 

  1$ $+ +%$$

 

 )

 





 / 



 %+ $% $''C 378 *+4 

  "5# )  

   









  



 

      $C %+ $''(





   +0 %, $''1 378 -*14 

  



)



7

 /



)    



    /

 <   

 B ) 

 / 

) 

 

    

  



/

   )  <

!   )/ 

 

  





<



 $'', 



   2 &

$  /



 * < <  

8

 )

  

 $'',

!     



 8

 $'',

  

* %& #*":  



   <  

8   8     <

   >

  8 

   <#

7 : $>    8 

* **

:

!  

5 ."

"

, 7 ()

- *,), ( 8

;%(& -

()

(

:*.

 4

- ( /4 -.

. . .% )8 ) ( 8

<%(& -

()

(

:*.

 4

- ( / -.

(** )8 ) )0.

)0( =/

. . .% )8 ) 8(.>,4

- ( / $ + > , $ $1

$> 34  

 = ! 

= &    34 



34

! G 8     $>   )     < <   <

 " #  

 = ! 

= &   

/ " <#

  

 +34

 $'',

/ 

* "-

 

  /  /    



 

 =





 # 7

/      

 B  /



"

# ! <  )   $> 8*H 

 G< <  G    

 



  

 $ 

  )



 

$,

 

8 

< 



 





) 

 

 $'', / ) < <    

  8 

<  <  =!=

 /A /   %$ > $'($   $'',

  / 

 

  ) /   +1 %+ $''>

  6







 /A  

   /A

     1$ $+ +%$$

  

  !  / 



 

6  5 /

 

 )



$0

   H

  3  

 

G)   .)(./4 )() - $(. ()(>(

)0., +, 8( +

(

)0., ?

6@  

    /   

,> "

     /        /  

 / /   /     

#

 

 )

G)  )() - (A(,)0( (

)0., +,"

(/( 3(& (

)0., 3+%$$4 + && >+'

   0(7'()

.(,( 2,  3

    & H I G - 

 

 

+$

  -

G  / 

*

6 "!   

 &   A  

J 

  )  

 

 * A

/A  =      

*  5   

  I

- 

   - 

&  )  I =  H

   -   - &

- / - D2 - 

7    J  A

!  /  8 

  & H I

-G  A  

J    

 

   

     / /   $ , $'',   )   

     *

 !   

 

$C :      $(

=    )    



&<  

 

 $$ %+ +%%,    - .  )



$'

H    / 

?1 



@



""

# - D  A ; 

9;:

D

 9;: