High Court of Punjab and HaryanaCRR/4963/2015dismissed

Gurcharan Singh v. Jawala Singh

2016-12-07Mrs. Justice Manjari Nehru Kaul7 pages

!"

# $% &'( ) *( + - ' .

) *(

,

+ ,!"

1 ((0 %2 ,(

)

0.

%2 ,( , 3( (

, 0 ,, , 4' * 0

2 ,

) .' * % + ,

/( #5(

,4' * , ,

60

.'

*, ,

%

40' 7 5, % ,( ,(

,.

) *(,( ,

,,

6%,(

&'( ) *(

,

(

' *#*( #/ #/ # *8( ,( ,,

' *$#*( #/ % ,'

,-

9( %3 (

40' % ,,+ ,

2 * 5%(

%%8" , 5,( 0

,+

&'( ) *(

, ', *

*,

# 6

0,#

, )

,* /,(,( 0 , ) ,57 ;%9, %7 '

2*'

,'

0 ,7 ;%

40'

,*

0, *,( ' ,/,(,( # # ; ,( :

,( <'

, 0 % ,( ,"

0

, , ', *, ,

6 , 6 2, ,( , , % /, *

$%,(

%%8" ,(

, $% ,( 0

(

0(5

0 ,(

<'

, ,,( ,2'(%,(

*/,(( ,0 ,( ,

' *$ #*( #/ ,( *

5#

0'( ,,( "

%

5%= 4,) *(%)

0) *(% - ) *(%&' ) *( &'# ) *( 3( '

, ',

<'

(( ( ,( / ,* /,( ,( # # ; 6%,(

,/ 5 /

*,*

', *, 0 5 ,#

, %#', , 0, , ,(

'

',

#5"

&'# ) *(/ 0 *3( % <'

, ', *, , ,(

6,$ /, *,,(

6 %,( 00

<'

,

,, (

(/ ( # ,5,*

', *, '

, 4' , ,( ',> ,( ',

% ,(

$,$ 7 $%,(

,( 00

, ', *

*, %#',( ,

,( /'

* ,(

', *, 5 #5* *

, /, *,,( 0

,1/ %,

$% ,

,,(

>,/ ',(

,, # (,

,,

6 '# <'

, /, * $% 6

> ,( .'

5%$"

,( %

5% = 4,) *(%)

0) *(%- ) *( &' ) *(%/(

#,( ,( %( # 5'0

<'

, /( 0

;

#',,%,( 5,

5( 0'(

,( 3(

' /,(,( "

/,(,(

,#5 ', *,(

6$

#5* *,(

, ,

6 ',( 0

,2

" , , ,''0,( ' ,

0 #5,(

,,,(

, 5> ,(

%

,(

0

,, ' /,(,(

, 2, * 0

5

,( ,"

0

,%

,# ' ,

,

) , /,() , >+#5

*, 63( , %0 "( *

( * "(

,(

> ,( 0,"( *

5"

,3( , %, , '

) , +/ /((,( 50

,

5/ 0

3(

;

,

, * # ' ,% /((/ 0 ,* #(

> ,(

5 /, - 4' * , 6%

*, (

<',, %

5%= 4,) *(%)

0) *(%- ) *(% &' ) *( &'# ) *(% #', (

,( 0

&'( ) *(*' ,5 * 5 , (

0' (

'

) , >+ -

6%

*, (

,( 0 , *0

0 ,

5 ,0 5

%8" %,',( '

*0

0 ,(1/ %,( 0,

,

', 2** ,,( 4' * %,(

# ',) %#',,(

2 ,

) .' * %+ ,

4' *

>, ,( ',

%,( ( 0 0 , 0 ,, # ,(',

# %%/( , 0 ,, '0( *# ,(',%

'

,( ( ,

, ,( /,( ' , * #,(,( ',#

/1 ( *' ,,,(

',#

/ (*( 2'(% , , / '

#5,(',/,( ,<'

,'

5 '

,( ( *'

', 5 '(% *,( ', 5,( ,( *,( * 5

0

* 5 $%,(

,

', #5

',# ,,(

5'

* 1 ',( '#,, ,,

5# ( 53( 0', # ,/

,

5'#4 , ,, ,* , *'

0 * ,(',

'

,( ,% ,( ,( ( %,('*( , 0', ', 5,(

5 ,* , ,/

,( 0 , % #', ( *'

,( , ,( 0 ( ,, ' /,(,( '(%

5 <' <'

,'

0 '0 ( >(

'

,( , 3(',( ', ?

0'* 4' * ,0 #5 ',#

/ /

,(

, ' ,

0 ,

/,(,( 0'* 4' * ,0

#5,( ',#

/ %

'

,( (

,(

, ,( (0 ,,(

,<'

,'

5 1/ % 0

,( ,( ,( *

0

* 5 $% ,,

@ 5#

( 5@ ,,(

%( ', 5 5

5%,(', ,(

'

,( / *(, % ,( 0', # ,/

,( 0 ,

5'#4 , ,, ,* , *'

, , *# ,(', > ,(

!"!## $%"

&'())*+,- + . /-(01%,(',%, ; * , , ,( *

0

*,(

,5 @/ , '

,@ 0 #5(

5'

*

,(

,(',,,

5 %(

0 ,,(

5'

* #5( 1 A#

(1*(', ,( $

/

!"!

## 2**3+,-+ . /-2*(%/( ,( ,

) , %$%6 $>+% (

,,(

5'

* #5( *,(

5'

* '#, ,

,/'

# <', (, ,(, *,( *

, 5 ,( ,)

#

0, #5,(', . / 4!$ $25)5$%())1 ,,

/ 4.

!"!## $%"

&' 2 * 5% , ; * , , ,(

0

,( 4' * , ( # % ,('*( , ,( '0(

#',,(

0 '0 ('

) , >+ ,,(

5'

* #5(%(/ %/,( ,(

3( #

', 5,(/,(% , <' 5,( B,(,( , ,(

0 ,, ,

!"

* ',, B( 0 ; *8 ! B(

0,

!