← Library
High Court of Punjab and HaryanaCRR/4973/2015dismissed

Sombir And ORS v. State Of Haryana And ORS

2016-05-28Mrs. Justice Manjari Nehru Kaul8 pages



    

"#$%&' ()* + ", -#.

$& #$%/ 

      



     

      

        

           

      

  

 

   !" 

#    !" 



# $% & '''    $

  !   (

    )* )* *+), 

  $   $ 

 -( # . .



  $      

 (

   "!"     

   / )) *+)010 )) *+)0 

  -"$ (  2 3$

# . 



(   !     / )) *+)0 .

"!" (

  /*//*00,*,+5  " /023

   " /*/23 $      6 

  

,++1 " /*023 $          

     

,++1 " 0,*23 $           .    

,++1 " ,+523 $               

,++1 $$

  !

     ""  $ # $

 "

 

"     72 8 9:  )9 * *+)+ )0:)09)0;/*//*0/*,0,*,+5 /023$"

  <

. (

(

""



 "$ !



$

"$   $ = ):

) *+)+     ;

++1;

/+ 

 

.

 "$  .



       2

 .

- > -(   

 #  (  $% !   .    

  6   

(     - >-(  



$$

""

 



.



# ( 

. 3  7) *

$( .  

 "$      .

 .

.



" !



# .

$( "

   

   .

$$   # ( 



  .     #  (  



. 

# ($   



.  #  (  





 $ $"



 

"$  ""$"

%( ( , : .

 (  $ $"

 $.



=

( 

  " .

"

"$  $  



""

<

  !





"" .   5

(? $ @ $"

 .



.

"

.

=

 

 "

 "

 . (

 !

(  ""

<

 " ($ 

 .

  

.

 1 



( $  "!

.

!



 . "!

  "$   !

(  "

$$    "  ):/ 33.

3 "

" !  

 ""

   !     "  *+: 33  ""($ "

(  )0:)09)0;/*//*00,*,+5 .  " /023 .    (

 ""

  .

"

 $     ($   "$  $ <

 

"  6  A ) 

 .

 "

!





" 

$(.

  .    $.

 . " A *

$



 

"  !

    

""

""

"





A /

.

 

 . 

 $$

""

$ 6$

 

     A 0 # ( A , &

. A 5  $A :B( A 9% $& .

 " ($$ .

$$  $("$$ 6

. 

A ; C.

$ 6 2

     "  /)/ 33

""

    $$

 $$ (    $   "

 .

!

   ! . $ 

""

A ) 

     

    $

"$  D6 A )1   !



 2  "

6 

  (   $ !(

     ""

 "$  6 "

A *

!

" ""

"



""



"$ 

   



$



A /

A 0# ($  



$

"$   !

 

 $"

 

   .

$$   

    

  A , &

.  

  

 

""

"!

   ! E    D6 A,1   A 5  $.

 "$ !

"$ D6 A51   

( 

 !



 2  "

6 

  

((

    

( "

 "

$ 

( (. "



$ $? !



 

 

((

     ( $ . $"

 $

$ $"

 ""

 A : B(   

(

 $ 72 A :1   

 

 D6 A:1# A 9% $&  

( ! D6 A 91 .



""$$

 " ($$ 6 





     

   2

  

  3

  

3

# (  $ $ 3 (  $ 3 (.

$ =

  !  "

 $  $ 3  "!"

""



 " !

(( !





  "!"  

   .

$$   "$  $   $   $ 

 -(  # .  $   $$  3  

  $      

""

.

!



 $     

 "$  .   $ ""

  "

  )* )* *+),

 $3   (!

(





"  )09)0;23  ""($

 $$ 3 

$

($  

$  )09 0,* .  " )0;23/*/ .  " )0;23/*0   " )0; 23 /*,   .   "  )0; 23  ,+5   . " )0;23

   !"# $%&'(  

   



 



)    



* +,,#-    

 

   

 

 



   "#    

   



 



 $.&'(

)    



* +,,#-    

 

   

 

 



   "# $   

   



 



 $.&'(

  



* +,,#-    

 

   

 

 



   "#  $+   

   



 



$.&'(     



* +,,#-    

 

   

 

 



   "#  +,/   

   



 



$.&'(

  



* +,,#-    

 

   

 

 



  

   1  

  2 2    

 

 "" "

 $

  !  = ** )* *+),  3  .

"(

 "    "

$



$$.(   !(

  

     1

 



      ,+ 

   0



 3

  45   5    

   

  

     1 

  

 

  

 3

 5 $5$++,/  3

 $5&'(5  4  6

  (

5  5 



  0  1  5   

  

      1 

   

 

    (   5   

 1 



 

  8 15      1 

    

 5 (   

 

  





 ,,/  :

  2 2 ! . 

 

   $  "

$ 

$



 .

 "

$$ (

(

     

 

 .  

"

 

 $   (  

 < "

$

" ( . (  ? 

$  "

$ 

     )  ""



    $$ $  $   @ " $

 

$  $@ 

  $$    * -(  . $   $ 

 

    

    $@ 

  /  $     !($  $@   0   $    

!($..



  $@

 "

$ 

    (

.  6

  *  

    "  

  5

*+ "$(

 

"

((

 



$"



 

 ! $

"$  

"  (

" 



(  "

 $ "

)9 * *+)+.



$$ ( "   ""

 .  

"

 

 $   ( 

2

$ "

$

 

( (

(

< 3 

"



 !"# % &'()*+,* % -,.// 

!

   !+ ( 

       

    :      

5 

   1

  1 

   

 

        



 



 



 $ 5&

  1 



1

     

5       

  





 8 15   

  

 * ,5,,,#-                 

 1  53  1 2 2

 "

  " %

-   ! "#  %0 1 (2/2   * % -, ((+ .

 ""

 .           (

  /F 

 . "

 

$  (   $$

"

-3%4!%5  !"# %0 1 "&6/)#"&'(&4!74!4"%+(('&'(& 3 

 "

""

 /*//*9 /*523

  <

" "

 "

.

 !



!$!



"

6"

 

   (

. 6

 . 

  "    6

"$(

3  (

 " 

    "

 $ "

 *+)+

  ! "!"  

 "  "$ .

" 

  " $   6

"$(

2

  "

(



!"  " <

3  

 "

 .$     

 "!"  

   

.  

 "

 

$  ( 

""($.

 @( "" 

"@(

"!" 



3  $. 

$ <

  !    



.

  "

 

 $   (  

.

!



    

)++++1 "

 "   

 "$ !

!

 



3  $.

<



 

"      

!

 =   



0++++1   $



$$  

 "$

*9*+)5 ' 01 )* 2