High Court of Punjab and HaryanaCRR/3843/2016dismissed

Pawan Kumar v. State Of Haryana

2018-11-13Mr. Justice Arvind Singh Sangwan24 pages

!"#!$

%$& '% ( )(( * +!,!-$

" #

$ !

"# % &$ ''(()*+,-

. /

"# %-% &$ '01' '01()*+,-

$ !

"# % &$ '((*)*+,-

$ "" %

" #

"# # 2 $ )

% &$ '((*)*+,-

)(( * . 3 "4

# 5 # /# #

# +6 *0 )*+,

#)*+, # 8 & )9 *) )*+9 " " #! " # : 8 #

+6 *0 )*+,

# . "

# % &$ '01')*+,-" % &$ '01()*+,-"

% &$ ''(()*+,- % &$ '((*)*+,- # '*, # '1 4 &% ;4 &;-

3 8 #

" 8 # <4"

# =:

! "#

"$ "

%" #&

# "'

# "

(# (" " $ "

%" # & ) "

""" *%+%&%(%,%-# . " "

"# "

## /'0# " # "# ) " #$ " ) ) "/ ) "" "

) " " "

# " " "" # "

" 0 121/ 1 0 3# ) "

# " 4 # 5 %" # " ) # " "

#$ " ##

% ## '

-6. (# # # %) " " " #

# "

" ) # " " " #

# ) " "

#2 " "# "

" "# "

# "

"7 # )

## # "8 181/ 1 0 9 #

) " "# "## " " # (

:; "## "# " "

7 <"

) " "

" "

"=' , ,

" %

(# "$ "

%" # & (# (" " )4 !323$ "

%" #

%" #& " " #

" ) ) "

" " %

(# ) "181/ 0## "

%" # # ( :;

(# (# ! " " $ "

%" # & "

" >044 ) " && ! > " " 181/ 1 0 " ## %7 >>1 # ) "

" /1874 " # " "

" ?7 ?7

-.%# 4 "& "

-. " "

" 7 < $

( " :%7/93%

# "") ## %7>>1 "6 :%7>2

)

) #" "

" # 8 # +9'&

& *9 *1 )*+(

" +6 *0 )*+,"

&# # '*, # '1 ## ## 8 " #

7 =:

) " "

" " #

" " " "

)

# < " ) ") " #" 7 # " #

" " 31/ 1

# " # " #

" "

2/ 1 0 311 # 4 # %" # " " # #

" #" " 9/ 1 0" 44 #

)

" #

" @" " "

" /> "# % " ""

) "

# " " 118 1 0 318 1 2 "9> 1 2 "

) )# ## # ( )

# "") # =/18 "

/074 # "

"A '

" "

& >

8 <4" # 8 3 " #> # +6 *'

)*+0

$ >

8 " # # +6 *'

)*+1

+' # *, *'

)*+1 4 8 # " #> :#8 >

# 8 #" "# 3 +1 *, )*+( 8*+ *' "

# 8

/ 8 # " " "

! ##

4 3 " #

! ! %

- # #> " #

8 # 8 "8 ##

& 8 >

#8 # #

# # # # # +9'&

& >

<4" # ## *( *'

)*+1*0='*"

8 8 1:( 4 8 >

#> " # 8 8 " # 8 # 4 8

# # 8 # # 8 # #8+' " *, *'

)*+1 4 # # +6 *'

)*+1

+' # "

# 8 #"// "

## 3 " #>

# 8 4 )( *'

)*+1" ## 3 // " # # +,+&

& " ## " >

& %- 8 # "

4 8 3 # # +,+&

& % ? (-" > & %- 3 # +1 *, )*+("8

# 8 3 3 8 8 # # # #8 ,

& %-> 8

<4"

" # # 8 #> ##

# %- / ! "

121+#3#42

@8 & =:

%% 7 """ "

" # ?7 " "7

" ?7?7 " "

"< "" 03 44 7 )

; # "?7 # #

" /18 " 90-.74 7 90-.74 " " "

" ?7 ) '

" " 7 /1874 ") # #

" "

" ## " " "

)

" "

" /18747

7 " ) )

# " "

) "

= " " ""

" ""

"B ?7

B ) "

;

" "

)

"" " /1874 #

) "

"" 90-.74

B ) " C" # ?7 " ) #

) " )

" /18 " 90-.74

" " 4 &

'( ) * # + '( $%,,%-%./0/ -0 .1213%,,4 55 %00116 "

< ?7 "" %4 ?

4" < "

4 "

" 03 44

= "< "

< " # %- / # 7 #

21+#3#42 /"

@8 & 8 =:

2 , ") # " 4 ) "

, 7

$ %,,6 -1.00812

" " /1874 "

" < " )# " " "D ""

D 4 ) # "" "" "D

D ) #

" "## " %9 7

$%,,6

-1.00:1%

" " /1874

" " "

" " E$ #'

" " " '

- "D "D

. "# # " "#$ "$ " # " #

# '

, " "7 "

E %% 4 " " D #D" 1>74" " )

" /18 #

# " " 4 " "

# " #" " %4

7 /

) 0

-499%. , 00 ;%2 4

" #" ") " /1874 "

" "" :; )$

" " )

" <

" " " " "" " <

" "

" " ) " " "" " " %< " 4 " E% "" #

) ### " )"

" ""

< ##

) # " "

" ""

" #

# " "

) "

) ## " " " "

" " " "

E %1 ) )

" " " " "

< " 26

993

"" ) " ""

"" "D ""

" # , " "# "" 44

" " # #

" #

" # " " #

" # , "" "

44 ;" ;'/ "

# " "

" " " " #

" # D " "

D :)

" "

D ""

D " "

D "D

D" #

"#" ") # # #

7 ##

"" < ## "

7 "# "

) " " ) "" " 26

993" < " " "

> 6

993 %# " " " )

# ) " " " )

" )"" "## " " " " > 6

993 ;

# ) "

993 " "## " " >6

993 "

" "

< 2 6

993

) " "" " "

" " # 8 #8 #

%- 0 !)#

121+#3#42

@8 & =:

4 0

-"! <0=>.499,-8./0/-0 .%,;3 -499,.%;00;96 " "

#4"

# "E

E "E "

E 4 " " )

" : D "

# : " '# " '

# "

: " "" "

# %# ) ) #

" B ) "

" ## " ) "

" " "" 4

") " /1874 # ## 7 < ) "

" " " ## " " # ) """ "

## " " 4, 7 " " ""

" "

''"

# ) "

) " "

# & )"

# B

@ "

; #

#) )

) "#

" # " /1874

" 7

" ) #

) 4<

" # " /1874

< " "

# "

1% %

" "

# ""

4 " %

" 4 "# 8 & # " " 8 8#

# # 2 $ )% &$ '((*)*+,- # 3

## #

8 #> " 8 " " # # # # /" 8 #>

"# # +,+&

& )* *, )*+("

*1## # 8 # ! $#2& A 4 ##

#! '9 #

& # 8 /" # # 3

*1## 8 #>

8 " #

& # 8 # // " )* *, )*+(

8 !

4 # " # ## " 8 ##8/ & # 8 # #> 8 #

# # 2 $ ) / / # ! ?

/1 21+#3#42 "8 @8 & =:

54;

" ; "

" /9>44 # "

;

" 4?

" /9>44 " #"

"% # "

" #

" ## "

" " # "# "

## "

/ #

#4"4 # " 4:

! )

# "

" /9>44

)

"; # "

" "

" # " )

" "

)

7 "

# 4 %# ( " #4 " "%- 1 .9 44081 /9>44 )

"" ";

" " /

/9>4")

"; # "

" "

"# " )

" "

"" " # @"

" " "

7 ) "

# 4 # )

) " " "

)

"" " ) " #

) "

" "

; "

)

; ) #

): " )"# " # FG /

' " # )

)

# " "

; " #

"4 # " ; ) "

" "

; B4 "

< #"

" "

) # ; )

":) # # ") " "

"44F 4, 4 > "" "

"" "" ; "

" /9>

; < #" " 34 4 > >- . - . -/. -9. - /. ; "

E > ) "

" "

" ) /9> " 03 4" "

"; "

)

% " )

) "

# 4

# ""; "

"< ; "

" /9> 03 4" #

> .

# 4" 03 4"# #" " ; "

)

< #

#" # 3 4" " ; " )

# " > .4 "

# "#" ""## "

" "

# " ) " "

# "

4# >/.

4 ""

!# ; # ) " "" " "" ) # < >9. % )

)) ; # ) " "#

""# #

" " ) H 4 "

" "

> /.I ; B ) "

"4 "#

" #

4 ;" # "

) " " "#

"# " #" # 4 "# %- 8 3 "// / " #8 # 8*+ *'

# # *, *'

)*+1" # +6 *'

)*+1"

*) "

" " & # # # # 8 #

& > 8 "

# 8 # +9' &

& "

! " #

# # #

# "4 8

" "4 8 "

- .

7 "" " #"

(# (#

" -.

7 ) =#

)

" " " #

J , #" J 5 )

" &)" (# "

# #" " 118 1 2 , (# "

1 "1/# ) " 5 )

"&)"(#

" ) %

(# 121/ 1 0 " #

## #

)

# ?7 -.

:) #

) /"

) # " "

(# (# " (# ! A " "

5 )

"&)"(#

#":) 44 #

, " " " #

(# " " /1/ 1 0

)

" -.

# "" >/44

" ) "

10 "

##"

" # , " 44

)

" "

(# " (#

5 )

"&)"(# "

(# "

(# # " (# "

#) ##%

" -.

) " 121/ 1 0" " J %

)

" ?7 " -.

# #

" #

"" 1 "

1/# "

(# "

(# " "J%

(# " J&)"(# ) #

" "121/ 1 0 " ) "

" -.

7 ) "

# D #4 / # A -

""" # ) "

J5 )

&)"(# # " /1874 # # "

" 1>74 1 "

"" "J%

(# #" " #

## " 5 )

&)"(# " /1874 # "

" #

# -.

"" D # 4 / # A -

. "

?7 # "" " 44 " # #

"" "1/# "" >/ 44

J5 )

" &)" (#

" /1874 # ")#

?# ?7 " "

" >/44 "

" /1874 # " :) "

J5 )

"&)"(# "

" " " #

# ## " )

" " "J%

(# -#.

7 ) "

# K #4 B -

. # 7 #

B -

. " 0 B -

. #

J 5 )

" &)" (# " /18=/074 ) "

" " " ## " ")#

" " ""

# -@.

)

J (# "

(# ) #" ?7 " ) " " "

# % "

J (# "

(# ##

8 #

8" &$ ''(( '((* )*+," 8 >

# 5 "

&$ '01' '01()*+,"

8 > " 8

1 )(( * 2

! 2 C2$ 8 = C2$