High Court of Punjab and HaryanaCRM-M/25367/2019dismissed

Sairun Nisha And ANR v. Ut Chandigarh And ORS

2024-04-05Mrs. Justice Manisha Batra9 pages

IN THE HIGH COURT FOR THE STATES OF PUNJAB AND

HARYANA AT CHANDIGARH

#$ $!

% ! &!" '

( ) $ *!$ $!

+ ,

-#./01

2' (31 ,#3 -, /,(,

,#3 -, /,(,)

! !" # $%&

' (# )* + $, , -.

&- % # $-/ $,% * 01

1 #!(#" 1

2 # 1 )* ! ! 3 1 !" 1 + & + 1 # 4 + 1! ) 3 1 3 3 1 - - &- / #1 # 6# 1# 1" 3 1 # 3" # 73

3 1 8 1 3 # 1# & .- 9'

3 !" 3" (# 63 + 541 3 #!7 1 #" # 1 3"

: # #; 1

# 1 3 # < + 1

1 3 #1 1 3# ! ' !"

1 1 1" 13 1# . 9' 3 1 !" #! 3 1

1 3 1 !# 1

1 ! 1" 1 !"

3 #1" ! # # 11 1 &.

-& &- / 1 ! 3

1 " ' # )* 3

3 # + &41 ! = ! !

7 1 " ## 1

# >5

3 " 3 # 11 1

# (# )* # ! # !" # "

! " 1

14 + 5 3 1 (#1 " 11 1 ! "

3 1 # " 11 # 1 #

# , 6# ' # 7# !# + 5 3 " 7 1"

#! 3 1 3 3 * # #!1 3 - -.

&- > 11

! # ?# )1"

# !# + 5 ! * # # ! # 1 !1

!" 1 # : )* ' ! # 3# ! !

3 # ! 3

9 # # "

# # 1

(# 11 # ! # $-/ $,% *

3 1 6 #!1 ! 1 8 # 3 ! =1 1 " ! =1

# (# )* (# 1 ! 1 #

* # 3 # ! # 1

# 3 ! ! ' 1! #@ 3 # $%&

# 7# #1 6@! #1 # 3 6

3 3 = 3 # $%&

# = "; 3 ! ! 6

3 # " # 7# !# # 1' " # 1"

! " " # # 3 ! = !#

6@! #1

3 # 1 # 1 !" 3" # #1! = 3 # $%&

!# "

# # 7# ! #1

3 # ! 3 1 1 3 # # # "AB 3 1 ) *1 1 " ' # " 1 # " 1' # #C

=== === === === AB 3 # 1 )* 1 # 1 11 " 1' # #C === === === === AB 3 1 )* 1 !# " 1!! ! 3 # 7# # # # #C === === === === AB 3 1 1" 3 1 4 3 1#"

# 3 # 1 3' # 3 3 1 # #

# ! 1 !

#$$

$ 3 6@! #1 ! 3 6

# (# 1 1 )* = 7# 1 3 1 # 1# # 5&- * 3 3 # 3 #" 1 !# ! = 3 # # 3 ;C AB # 7# AB !# "

! 1 %& '() (%% *()"

" (%% % $

, - 3 3 ! 3 # $%&

! = " 3 1" !

# 3 1" !" #

# ! # .

% %

/ % 0$$ ) 12"

3,, 3 =

# 3 = 7# # $%&

# 3# " 1!' # (#" 3 (# ! 3 ! # 3# ! # #

* 3 3 = 3 # $%&

(# = # * 4 / 5+") %

% $$3 3

-3 = # 7# # $%&

# 3 ! = " #" 3 # " 3 # = 7# !"

" 3 1! (# = 3

3 !" 7# # 6

# 3 1 * 6 )

/ % $ ( ( ) ,, 6D! #1 E# = # ## # !"

# # ! 1 1 # # (#

# = 1 3 3 1!" !" #1

!# 1 1 # # ! 3 # # ! # # (# 1 3 ! ! #! 1 3 (#1

* 3 # $%&

! " (# ! 3 ;! 63 3 1 3 # 4(#" 1 # (# 14 # : 6

# (# 1 4 1 = 7# 4 # * =1 3 # )* " ;! 6

# ' " = 3 ' #

(# (# ! =1 ' 3 )* 1 1 " (# " 6

# 3 3 3 1 )* 1

1! (# = 3 # $%&

! 1 ! 1 !" 6D! #1

4 +7 !

% 0$

8 3$ 4 "

)/" %

/ 0$$

) 9- 3 6D! #1 ! = 3 # $%&

(# = # * 7# # $%&

# 3 ! = " #" 3 # " 3 # = 7# !" " 3

* !" # 3' ! # 3 * 3 #1 !" 1 # 3 # (# 1 3 1 41!# ! ! (# 8 " 3 3 ! #1 * 1 (# )* (# 1 ! 1 # + &41 1 ! (# # 4 + 5 ! !" 1 # ! # 3" (# 1 3"

1 1 3 3 #" ! 1" 1 !" 1 8 ! ! 11 # ! # $-/ $,% *

! 1 #

* 3# ! 1# " ! #

3 #1

# # 3 (# )* 3 (# 1 1

" 1

! # # 3 3 3 1

* 3 ! 1 ! 1 !

1 "

05.04.2024 (MANISHA BATRA)

JUDGE Whether speaking/reasoned Yes/No Whether reportable Yes/No