Paramjit Singh v. State Of Punjab
!"#$%&%'
!"!(") !"#%&%'
* *+,-. -"/01*++- %%% .-.-!"
(
.*.
!3(",*4 %%%
5!"
".
# 67 %
2 8
" #
$ % & 2 89%
'
!
(# !
)
+
,-
. $ !$
'
/ ,) !
$ #
$
$$ .0 1 # !
# !
0 #2 #3+
0
!! !
$ #.!
0 $' 0 &/#
0/# .50
"#
/#!
$678
)
/ )9: : :: 4 ! 7 $ !
#!$$$ # $
& #0
, $
#$' ! # '.
"#
/#
. .
0
' 7
## ;!!
0
,$
! $ # 0$ '
!
& .'
#$'
. $ #$' !
00 ! !!
$
/ ): :
4 ! 7 .
# 0+00 !
'
' !
! !
2 .
.
(
##
!$
$
$ .
$$ #
' ! $ 0
$
/ ,) !
$ #
$
. . 0
0#
7 $$ ' #
67
$ #
& .' 2 $
/ /
! $ 2
#
# 0 <<$ !,$
! $.
:)= . .0
" ' 7 ;$ "$
$
:1
! $ # $
1
. $'.
$$
. !! $
0 $' 1
! $.
1
#
# 8 4:,:: 1
#
# 8 4: :,,9 !=/;$
1
#
# 8 4 ":,9 !=/0;$
! .'> $ #
1
0
0 .
$ >
#
# $
$
0$
!
0 !! > !! !
$#
& .'2 1
7; $$
#
#$' ! $6 0 ! $$
$ #
! / ';!!
$ 3#
!
#
> 0 !
,
$
00
= . 1
!! ! !! ! $07.!
$
' 0&/#%
0 &/#%
.50 %
0/# $
1% $ 0.
' $1
.
$ 1
. $$ 1' 7; 1 '
0.
!
1 '
0. !! !
!7;7 .' $ ! !! $ !7;.
$$ !
.' .
7.$
?
01 ' !
'
$ .
'
!
>
$
'
#
> !
$ .
0
!!
# '
#
. $$'.
# ! '
#
>
! '
#
0.% 0 $ /. /#?
@ $
67 .
#
!
'
# $$.
#
> $ !
$
.
(
0
$ !
#
=$ #
0 3+
B=3+ = )3+ =3+ B = 3+ B=2 .
0
!
#
0
!
. +0 2 #3+
. .$$ 0
#
!
. #
!
$$ 0 7!
$ # # #
!
.
1 !
0 .
#
!
.
1 #
# # $ 1 .#.
$$ #
!
0
!
# 0 0
.
#
!
0'
0
'
/ $
'
! $ =
$ .
$$
0#
) 0
$ '# ! $$ .#
: 9!".0 *55;-)*.-!"("
).-!"&' %%% 3!
.*<-"/ 3( .0
*" *;;!= .0
0*" = -.-"/ >5
..!.*< 50!.!/ *50 !3.0
.*" * * = ;; * - 5(.
0*" = -.-"/ !3 .0
*55;-)*".3!
)!+5* !"!3.0 *+ % 0 *55;-)*.-!"0* 4
"+!
!".0 / !(" .0*.
.0 5
)(.-!" 0* *;;
/ .0 -/"*.(
!3 .0
*55;-)*".!" !+ !3.0 !)(+ ".
*" -"!
.!
.0 *+ 9 .0 *55;-)*". =*".
.! >*+-"
0*" = -.-"/ >5
.3!
)!+5* !"!3.0 - 5(.
-/"*.(
!3*55;-)*".=-.00- .*" * -/"*.(
% 0 ;
)!("
;3!
*55;-)*".?*55 ;;*".0*
/( .0*. ( -"/ .0 -"
.-/*.-!" !3 .0 )*
-/"*.(
!3)!*))(
=
.*< " -" .0 .9 0!=
9 "!. .0*. !3 *55;-)*".*))(
3!
.0
!"
.0*.0- -/"*.(
!
"!..*;;@%0( -.0*
" )!".
.0*. "!= .0 *55;-)*". =*".
.!
>*+-"
*"@ 0*" = -.-"/ >5
. -" *"
+-
-!"3!
.0*.5( 5!
4 / *".
3!
.*<-"/ 3( .0
-".0-
/* % . .0 !(.
.9 -. - -+5!
.*". .! !4
.0*. .0
*;;
/*.-!"
-"4 30* 4
".0*.*))(
* *+,-.
-"/0*;!"/=-.0)!*))(
4 -"/=!
<-"/-"" -*"
9 -; 5!.-" * -!( )*5*)-.-
+4 AA;
!-;
.*"<
4@3!
/-"/)
.*-" !)(+ ".
-".0-
/* % .0* 4
"* /( *;
!.0*..0 -/"*.(
!3)! *))(
=
/!. !4.*-"
*" =
". 3!
)!+5* !".!.0
-) )- 7*4!
*.!
@% ..0 !(.
.9-.-
..;
5 -")-5;
!3;*=.0*.*))(
)*""!.
< *"@ -
).-!"3 !+.0 . 3!
-"
.-/*.-!" */ ")@ .! ! .0 -"
.-/*.-!" -" * 5* .-)(;* =*@ ! (-.
.!.0 *))(
%.-33!
-"
.-/*.-"/ */ ")@ .! )!;;
). .0 4
. 5- ) !3
( -"/-"
.-/*.-!"9-"!
.!)!""
)..0
*))(
=-.0.0 *;;
/ !33 *" .0
*3.
;
()0 -" .0 )!( . -" !
.! 5 .0
)0* /
*/*-"
..0 *))(
%0
)!
!3.0 .
-*;
)!( . 0!= .0*. )-+ " -/"*.(
!3 *55;-)*".?*55 ;;*". =
"!. .*< " -" .0 )!( ( -"/ -"
.-/*.-!"% ! 3!
.0*. +*""
9 *))(
)!(; "!.0* !(/0. -
).-!"
9* *4!
!4
3!
.*<-"/!30- -/"*.(
* = ;;%
( *;!3
)!
=!(; 0!=.0*.
5!
.!3
-)
)- 7*4!
*.!
@9=0-)00* ;-
"!.4
";
-".! 4@.0 5
)(.-!"90!=
9*..0 3*/
" !3.0 .
-*;=* *;;!= .!4 ;
-".!
*" .0*..!!!".0 *55;-)*.-!"!3)!*))(
!3.0
*55;-)*".!";@%
( *;!3
5!
.=!(; 0!=.0*.
* +-..
= -.-"/!3*55;-)*".?*))(
-""/;- 0!"
.!)<
/-
*" +
/-
=
.*< " *
* <.!*" .0*.* +-..
= -.-"/ =
*;
!)!+5*
=-.0B(
.-!"
= -.-"/CD.!C*
= ;;% !.0 / !(" !5;
0* "!;
/ .! .*" % 5* .3 !+.0*.
)!
=!(; 0!=.0*. (33-)- ".
!55!
.("-.-
=
*;
!/ *".
.!.0 .!;
.0 * = ;;% 0 *55;-)*". *55 ;;*". =* *. ;-4
.@ -" )*
0 =*".
.!
)!".
. .0 *-
-) )- 7*4!
*.!
@
5!
.% 0
0* 4
" "!.0-"/ 5;
* 3* *
". *55;-)*.-!" - )!")
* .! =0@ .0
*55;-)*".*55 ;;*". - "!.)0!!
.!;
* *"@ ()0
90!=
9.0 / !(" !5;
*4!(..0
-"
.-/*.-"/*/ ")@0* -"/"!..*< ".0 )-+
-/"*.(
90* "!;
/*;4*
%0 )*
;*= !
;-
(5!"4@.0 ;
)!("
;3!
*55 ;;*"..-.;
*
9 -" .0 )- )(+ .*")
=!(; "!. 4
*55;-)*4;
%0 *55;-)*.-!"4 -"/4
3.!3*"@+
-.
.*"
- +-
%E
$!
#
$'
# 1 ' $ .
$$
$
$
$$'. $. #
$ 7$
' $ .
$$ !# ! $$ .0
'
!6/A. .#
!
3#$ 1
#
0
#
.
0
.
(
$ 0$ 7.$ $ #
#
$ .' 0 #!$
$'
#
$!
$
& #0
) )
' ! !"#"
!#$
$
%&
>
!
:!("
;3!
5 .-.-!"
0*
;- (5!"*
) ".
,( /+ ".5*
4@.0 !"64;
(5
+ .-"
-+-"*;55 *;!%!3'F* -"/!(.!3 7
: F ;%G!%!3DG.-.;
* : -/% (<0,
. -"/0
. %G 2 0 .*.
!3 ..*
0 *"
!.0
E )- !"%%'9=0
-".0 !"64;
(5
+ .0* 0 ; * ("
# :%%%%%".0 5
".*55 *;9= *
)!")
!";@ =-.0.0
, ).-!"!3*55;-)*.-!"3-;
4@.0 *55 ;;*".
("
).-!"&' %%%4 3!
-!"( / -"
.0 ) -+-"*; *55 *; 3-;
4@ 0-+ */*-"
. .0
)!" -).-!" !
9 =0 .0
.0
-!" ( /
)!++-..
-" "!. >
)- -"/ 5!=
("
).-!"&' %%%.!5
+-..0 *55 ;;*"..!;
* -.-!"*; - * B(
.-!" .! 4 *"
=
% .0
.0 -/0 !( . )!++-..
-" "!.
>
)- -"/ 5!=
("
).-!" %%% * .!
)(
!3,( .-) H % 0*5.
III !3 .0 !
!3 -+-"*;
!) (
9'D& *;
=-.0:55 *;
E%
).-!"&' %%% +5!=
.0 55 ;;*.
!( . .! .*<
3( .0
!
-
).-..!4 .*< "%
).-!"&' * 3!;;!= # :&'%55 ;;*.
)!( .+*@.*< 3( .0
!
).-..!4 .*< "%J FG " *;-"/ =-.0 *"@ *55 *; ("
.0-
)0*5.
9 .0 55 ;;*.
!( .9 -3 -. .0-"<
* -.-!"*; .! 4 "
)
@9 0*;;
)!
-.
!"
*" +*@ -.0
.*< ()0
-.
;39!
-
).-..!4 .*< "4@* */- *.
9!
=0 ".0 55 ;;*.
.- * -/0 !( .9 4@ * !( . !3
-!" !
* */- *.
%FG80 ".0 * -.-!"*; -
.*< " 4@ .0 !( . !3
-!" !
.0
*/- *.
9-.!
0 0*;;)
.-3@ ()0
.!.0 55 ;;*.
.9*" ()0!( . 0*;;
.0
(5!"5 !)
.! - 5!
!3.0 *55 *;%F&G
0 *))(
!
0- 5;
0*;;0* -/0.
.!4 5
".=0 ".0 * -.-!"*; -
.*< "%FG0 .*<-"/!3 ("
.0-
).-!" 0*;; 4 (4, )..! .0 5 ! - -!"
!3 0*5.
II9* -3-.=
*"-"B(- @%E &%0 < @=!
-"
).-!"&'FG*
:-3-..0-"<
* -.-!"*; .! 4 "
)
@E% 0 =!
:"
)
@E (
-"
).-!" &'FG - .! + *"
)
@3!
)- -"/.0 *55 *;%0 *55 *;0*
"3-;
4@.0 *))(
9=0!0* 4
")!" -).
% 0 5!=
!3 55 ;;*.
!( . *
)!".*-"
-"
).-!" &% " *" *55 *; 3 !+ * )!" -).-!"9 *"
55 ;;*.
.)*" >
)-
5!=
("
).-!"
&F4G9=0-)0- .!.0 3!;;!=-"/ ).# F4G-"*"*55 *;3 !+*)!" -).-!"F-G
3-" -"/ *"
".
*" *)B(-. !
- )0* / .0
*))(
9!
!
0-+.!4
.
4@*!( .!3 )!+5 ".,( -).-!" (4!
-"*.
.! ()055 ;;*.
!( .!
)!++-..
3!
.
-*;9!
F--G*;.
3-" -"/9 +*-".*-"-"/ .0
".
9 !
F---G =-.0 !
=-.0!(.
*;.
-"/.0 3-" -"/9*;.
"*.(
!
>.
".9!
.0 "*.(
*" >.
".9!3.0
".
94(."!. !* .!
"0*") *+ K %!=
.!.*< * -.-!"*; ("
).-!"
&'- 9.0( 9=-.0*"!4, )..!*55 !5 -*.
;@ )-
.0 *55 *;4@.0 55 ;;*.
..!
)(
!3 ,( .-) %0 )!5 *" *+4-.!3
).-!"&' %%% 0* )!+ (53!
)!"
*.-!"4 3!
.0- .-"
*,
=* * -
*2 % .*.
!38
. "/*;*"
"!.0
9 '$ D%( .-) - *@*.(;;*09
*<-"/3!
")00 ; .0*.*=- - )
.-!"-
)!"3
!".0 55 ;;*.
*" .0 * -.-!"*;
+*@4 "
)
@3!
* * .@!3
!"
% 0 ; .0*.* -.-!"*; +( .4 "
)
@
) "!. 4 )*(
-. =!(; 4 -+5!
-4;
.! 5 !"!(")
,( /+ ". 4(. 4 )*(
.0
=!(; 4 3*-;(
!3 ,( .-) =-.0!(. -.% !;;!=-"/ =* ;*- !=" -"
* */ *50!
%*" '# :%LLLLLLLLLLLL% -") *=-
)
.-!"- )!"3
!"*55 ;;*.
)!( 9.0
;-+-.
!3 .0*. )!( M ,( -).-!" +( !4 -!( ;@4 -).*.
4@.0 >-/ ")@!3.0
-.(*.-!"*" 3*- 5;*@*" /!!
*55
.!4 !";@ *3 /(-
%0
- 9"! !(4.9
!+ *"*;!/@4 .=
".0 5!=
.!!
*
-*; *" .0 5!=
.! .*< * -.-!"*;
% 0 3!
+
- *" >.
+ *55 !5 -*.
;@.*< "-3* -.-!"*; =-;;
"!. (33-) %!.0*).-!"
(4 (+ 3*-;(
!3 ,( .-) * * )!" -.-!" 5
)
".% 0
.0
+4;*") *" -.- 0* ;@5 !5
.!
)!"
( !"
).-!" =-.0 .0 *- !3 !4
*.-!"
+* 4@ .0- !( . -" .0
-".
.*.-!" !3 .0 !.0
).-!"% '% -.-!"*; +*@4 "
)
@3!
* .@!3
!"
=0-)0-.- 0* ;@5 !5
.!
)!"
( !"
).-!" =-.0 .0 *- !3 !4
*.-!"
+* .! !=0*..0 ;
/- ;*.(
0*
*-"
3 !+ !-"/9"*+ ;@9.!)!".
!;
)
.-!" !3 .0 *55 ;;*.
)!( . .! )
.*-"
.*.
)- )(+ .*")
%.+*@90!=
94 *- .0*.* -.-!"*; +( .4 "
)
@"!.
)*(
-.=!(; 4 -+5!
-4;
.!5 !"!(")
,( /+ ".4(.4 )*(
=!(; 4 3*-;(
!3 ,( .-) =-.0!(. -.% 0 5!=
+( . 4
>
)-
5* -"/;@*" !";@-" (-.*4;
)*
% ()0 *).-!" - ,( .-3- 9 .0
- "!
-).-!"!".0 <-" !3 =0-)0+*@
) %.+*@4 3!
+*;!
(4 .*".-*;%.
+( .9!3)!(
9"!.4
) -" ()0*=*@ .! )*(
5
,( -) .!.0 *))(
* 3!
>*+5;
-. 0!(; "!.4
) * * - /(-
3!
*
-*;!
.!)0*"/ "*.(
!3.0 )*
*/*-"
.0-+%0 !
+( ."!.!
-"* -;@4
+* -3 .0 5
)(.-!" 0* 0* * 3*-
!55!
.("-.@*" 0* "!.* *-;
!3-.(";
B(-
+ ".
!3,( .-) -).*.
!.0
=-
LL LLLLLLLL%E $%0- .*/*-"-" *+40*(*" "!.0
2 %
.*.
!3*0* 0.
*9FG D$'0* "!.
.0 5!=
("
).-!"&' %%%!3.0 55 ;;*.
!( .% !;;!=-"/=* .*.
-"* */ *50!
%*"
# :%0
- * *-;*4;
*
@=- - )
.-!"-"
.0 +*..
!3!4.*-"-"/* -.-!"*; -"
+ !3
).-!"&'!3.0 !
!3 -+-"*;
!) (
% 5;*-" ;!!< *. .0 .*.(.!
@ ! - -!"
F
).-!" &'G =!(;
*; .0
*+ LLLLLLLL%=!
!3)*(.-!"
0!=
9!(/0..!4 -".
! () 3!
/(- *") .! =-.#.0*. .0- * -.-!"*; )*""!.
*" !(/0."!..!4
) -" ()0*=*@ .!)*(
*"@5
,( -) .!.0 *))(
%.-
"!.* - /(-
3!
*
-*;!
.!)0*"/
"*.(
!3.0 )*
*/*-"
..0 *))(
%0-
!( .-".0 )*
!3 *,
=* * -
* %
.*.
!38%%-""!(")
.*-".
+ !4
.0*..0 !
+( ."!.!
-"* -;@4 +* -3 .0 5
)(.-!"0* 0* *3*- !55!
.("-.@*"
0* "!.* *-;
!3-.%0- .=* )*" -
"!(/0 .!
)!
0!=
9 .0*. -. - .0
)!") 5.!3,( .-) =0-)0!(/0..!5
*-;*"
-" .0
".9 .0 *+ -).*.
>
)-
!3 5!=
* )!"3
4@.0 !
9.0
!(/0.
"!..!4 *"@0
-.*.-!"-".0*.
/* %E %
!+.0 ;*=;*- !="4@.0- .* "!.
*4!
9 -.- );
.0*. .0
*
"! 3 ..
!".0
5!=
("
).-!"&' %%%!3.0 55 ;;*.
!( .% ;; 5!=
*
)!"3
!" .0 !( . .!
)(
!3,( .-) %0 (;.-+*.
!4, ).!3,( -)-*;
* +-"- *.-!" - .!
)(
!3 ,( .-) % !(
>- 3!
-"/,( .-) .!.0 5 !5;
%%%%E " .0 *3!
*- ,( /+ ".9 .0 !"64;
(5
+
!( . =0-;
- )(
-"/ .=! / !("
, ).-"/ .0
*55;-)*.-!"("
).-!"&' %%%4@.0 .!3
-!"
*" -/0!( .0 ; .0*."
-.0
3-;-"/!3 *"*55;-)*.-!"3!
* -.-!"*; *.*4 ;*.
.*/ - */ !(" .!
, )..0 *+ "!
;*@-"
)- -!"!3.0 *55 *;- */ !(" .! - +-
*+
-3.0 5 !5!
* -.-!"*; "*4;
.!
)(
!3,( .-) -"*)0- -"/.0 !4, ).!3 ,( -)-*;* +-"- *.-!"%E
$!
#
!
$
#
$$'. #
!
0 (
0#
)
' $ .
$$ 0# $ !
!$
/ ,)
7
$'$
/ $0
0 $!0
$
$ !
+0#
!6/A
$
0
'
&
$'
# $ . ' #
!
#$
$!
7! 0
> #
$
0
!
! 0
$ .
$$ .
. ! & #0 !
2 C$ /
'
()*+ ,0
$'
!$# $ #
& 0 !
$
$$ . $ .
$$
& !& $ 0
!& 7
. +0 2 # 3+
1
#
$$' .
#
!
+
0
! $ > 0 $$ .
'# # '
0 >
# !
$ $
. !
!
!
' $ # !
0 #
!
& .$$
#$'
$$ .
0#
)
' $ .
$$ 0# $ !
!$
/ ,)
> $ .
$$ .$$# '
2 #3+
!
1# # ! #
!
+
0 0
0 .
#
. 0' 1 . 0
#
$$ 1
'
0 . . $$
$
0 . +
0 .
, #
.
.$$
2 #3+
. . +
$' > $ .
$$ .$$ 00 !
!!
#
2 # 3+
$ ' .$$ #
'
0 * )09'
F 2 8G