← Library
High Court of Punjab and HaryanaCRR/3891/2016allowed

Rekha Devi v. Sunil And ORS

2018-09-25Mr. Justice Harsimran Singh Sethi14 pages





      

 



 !

"#$% &'

  (

)





+

   

 

(

, )- '

%.+

'!

 / '

+ 

%.+

% 

+

  0

! - *%..0%2 3

  

  4'!

 &

 1 ++

+$$!

+ #3/*+







%'

&'  + %

++

+

+#3.++

 

/*+1%5' 6

% 78

$+

+ 9* + 

:;$;;$8(1

+

(

+' %#3  * 6'

'

+

< * '

# + +

#

=*   # % '

78

"

#1

+



+

< * %+* 16'

'!

+

!!

!+ + 1

+

< * 

=* 8

++

 +

*

 9% '

+

< * 6

=* 8

*!!

1*"

% '

!! +

+  +

*



+6'

'6 *+

'

+

# 

$>'

% '!

 +*!

5  '



'+

# 

#:%6' 

+

*1'

#  +

"

=   4'/*+



%8



%'

&'  + %#3 "!*1 +

++

+$'+

# =* 

"

1+

*

6'

+6

 1+# .++

 

/*+1%5' 6

%

!! 

6

!

+*!

* /* /*



+(

' + * :

?

 ! "# $% +

14' + /86

*!'+ +

+

+

# =* 

'+

*

.11 +

!

'

#  + 9 )- '

%

 '!

' %

+

'

+1 + '+

# 

+=* 

*+# @* +

#3

+*

@* 38

++

 

  # 

'  

+  1 

+ 

 +

    #  ' 

+%  ' % 

@* 3 *+  # 

+*

+ 

!

+*!

=*+1"

 ++#3  &'(')*#

+'$',),-.-,/ 01 ")'

* +'2 &$"$

,/")3*4*)5 *),

&5 6'5 5,)01 07 $ (

%/ '

+ 

%

 !!

#'

 '

+

% *#"

1 '!



#

 + * '/* /*



+(

' + * :

'

 "

3 +

!

+ 

1 + # !

+*!

=*+1"

  ++#3 *!" $ 8*)'"(*& *9$ )*2 &$"$

,/*5 :* &*5 $ & ;,&

5*$< 0=. ";& ( ,"& *$ $!1   4'



 36 !

*+#'

+ 1 =* 



' 6

+6'

@* 3

*1'

#

+*

'

#

+ 

+

#  'A : 4'=* 3'

#+

! 

:. /* /*



+(

' + .

% ?

6 %= 

+*  "+ '* +>'  " =* 3

+#

3

+!

=* 

'+

""



%

 "

&

@* 3%

& ' +

"

3#

3#*

 + 

+ 1 '!

%



+

+ 1  

 :,.    '  /*   /*

    

+  (

' + .

 ! +*

* +, ? 

                       

   

   

              

  

       

 



        

          

      

         

  

              

               "

      

             "

 #$          

            %          

          &

         

        

  '

* '/* /*



+(

' + * % :%!  +  !

+*

#  6+ +

1 !

* '/* /*



+(

' +  * : ,! +*

* +, ?!

     "%$ 

           

  &

 

 (



 )*                   

     

  

     #  +  (       &

      

        (                           

   

            

           





    

    

     ,$  

          

$            

 &





  (        %      

  

 

 -

    -    

   

     -     -   

   

     

  

 -         (    

    

 .

&

   

     $ 

/

   

   (  &





   (        

    

       

   0    

   



      

   

  

 

               

      

      

            

          (          (        



         1               2

  

        3%  ,    (       &

      

        (              

          "

       

         43

 /       

      3  5"

3  61"



          

      &

    /            



    

  

 %

,  6+            

            



         %   ,      "

               "

                   '

 * ':* "

& 

1

# + +#3

&

+

+

*"

"3 '"

*

@*  

%  #B

#

6' '+

# 

 "



! 3

 

++B

+

#

6' '# 

1  #3

!

"*

 3 !

4'**

!*

#

 # % "+



6 #

*1'

 " +*3

++

5

+%6'

'6 + 1 '=* 

' +  4'

*1 + 1* ':* !

1+

D ' + =* 



' 6



1 

1 '

1#

+ $ 8*)'"(*&

*&(*+$

,/ *5 :*&*5 $ < 0=. !1 4'

*

! @* 3

+ 6

+ 1'

#

+

:

 6% '! * 

% '# 

*+#3 '1

5 

+



'+

#  '    '  !

 

 #  :%  6'

'  

*



6 *+

' 3 1#3 3 %6 +

#  '

$5



6

'  4'5  '

%

 +*!

#3 '!

%

'#  '6

1

+

'$6' 



"    '  

' 

  =#  

+  "

'

" 

 03

   4' 1

'#  '

+

3 !

'+

#  6 '

*



8



13% '

*





"

" '

+"

"3  =# 

03

   .# 

*+#3 '1

5 

+





+

*"

%6'

+"

#  +

* + 

$

'E +

.

8 !*# +

*"

%!!

+#3 !*# 

+

1 '



+* 3

+! *"!



'+

8 '>&*( *:2$ (  (* (4&*(*)5*),

& 00<0=

<&#=1?- '

1

3# '+

# 



 

"

+ '5 

+

'1

 +"

#* + 

$ E +

.

4' ! *"!



'+

+' 3

 

!

36'

+ !* '! *"!

 "  ' 6 =*+1"

 ++ 

*@'

)5&*2$

< *3*$

*)= 0 <A=

<&#=7 ?

+*&;*# ')B *)5*),

&2 &$"$

,/0.?0

&0  4'

 &'(')*#

+'$',),!!.,/ 0 # 5('

@*) *2$

,/*&:*)*5 6'5 5,)!00 0'

'+



'  !*!

   

1 



 +

    #  '%  !

 

 5  

#1   '

*



%

! +

#

+  +

+  =*+1"

"  6  '

 #

& &'(')*# 

+'$',)  ,  1-A  ,/   0-  # *(*))*2 &$"$

,/*&:*)**)5,

&$5 6'5 5,)A 01.

 + #

=*+1"

*+  3

 !

"

$ 8*)'"(*& *9 )*$6*$ <$";&*= '

#

+

%6' '!

+* 1+

"!

+ + 

:,. '/* /*



+(

' +  .

 +6 '* :* '

# +

+8 $ 8*)'

"(*& *9 )*$6*$ <$";&*= ' *!" '

1

3'+



#

"

*

@*  

%  #

+

3 #

% ' +

#

+

# 

 "

 

++

! 3



+

3 #

"

*

@*  

'+

# 

 "

 

++% ' +

#

# 

1  #3 '*

 !

*

.* 3 9

 % '=*+1"

 ++ $ 8*)'

"(*& *9 )*$6*$ <$";&*=

# +*!

%! "

 3

1

'

'!

! * 8 $ 8*)'"(*&

*9 )*$6*$ <$";&*=% ' *!" F "

*%

!

+



"#   @* 3 F!

+   

%  /*   /*

  5

+ 

+  ' + >  ""

%6' + 16 " =* 3* +/*  /*

.

%

'+

* +, ,#(        77 "

               )##885)

        ((  !

  

 

   

           

   /

      5""

 $  

 

 

    (  ( 



         ( 

  

        !            

                 5"  )# ,,    ( 077&

 (      "

  

 

     

    )# , +     

  

    



  

                ,19"    '       5""

 0)##885)  

         

        

  

 

 :          

  

 

      

          :            

   

           



           

   

     

  

   

 



  +     

   

     .

  &

 

                 

  

   $ 

  /



    

      

          

                 

  

'

$

'  =*+1"

 !

1 

1  +

%  *!" 4"C*&,$$*')@"#*(,$$*')+$

,/D $

)B*#& ;,&

5*$ 0<-=  <&'(')*#=!.7'

'+?"      

   0

  



     



  

 

              

       

  )#,        



  

                  )#'

 '!

%

#6'

+ 



6 '

'4'5  '

6'

''

#

*+ #3 '1

5 

+



!*# +

*"



1 '!



#:%"

& 1' ""

=

'+

*

.

'#  '!

6

1

+ ""+

3

'#  6 ! :+ '

#  '%

# 1

+%

* 36' '

#

'

+

6 '#

6'

'+

#  ''

# 

+ '

*



 : .

"6'

" 

"*! # '  *!"  =*+1"

 ++ *&*B '<"+ )'# =

&,"B  B*# "*&5'*)E,

&E (  *3)' '2 &$"$

,/

*&&*5 $

*)5*),

& 07<=  <&'(')*#=0 A0 8 ( 15'

%

@*

# '=* 3

+4'/* /*

+% 

+ ' +

%

"

*

'+

# 







*#"

+#3 '

+ *# * 

+  '  =*   6

 + 

'  +

  5

+   +

14'' +

 %*

1

+;

!!

3

+'6

++

#  +

"

= .11 +#3 +%

!! 6

!+# '

/*+1%6'

'6

+ "

"

6

'

+ "

+ #3 '2 1' 8 #

&1 +%

 H(6

!+# *!" 4'!



+

# ' *!"

 6'

# '



!  '=* 3

+>' + 16

*% ' *!" '+

* +, ?6  ;

                     

   3  5"77"

 

  

   

        

     

    <

  )# &

       

                  





       



        

    

  

$

           

 

   

    

  

   

                      !"#$ >' 

 =*+1"

+ '=*+1"

 ++

$ 8*)'"(*& *9 )*$6*$ <$";&*=%

* ''+

* +, ?#6$     

 

 

  

    

 2

        

      

   

        77"

             

                    !!"#$ // // // #2$       

   

 

 

            

   

             

        

!

         

  %  &  " $    '                     !(!"#$  4'/*+



8



'.++

 

/*+1%5' 6

%'

  3

!!

!

+ #   '"  4'  #  ' 

   3 

 

  6 ' 

9 

*



*+

*+

# 1

+% !

36'

'#  '6

1

+6  + 8

6 &



%

!



" 1

+"

'  ' + +

 +

3

1 

 11

+ + '  ' +

1 

1 

'# 



  

 + *#

# 

'"

1 +



+

#  '

++ '"

*

% ' "!*1 +

+4'"

 "

++#

&

'//5

'

+

@* 3

+ 3

'#

'

6 '+

# 

"

#

'

*

8

'

 

%

 '"



'+

+

+ 1

+

+

4' +*#+

! '"

 " '  !

 +

!3 +  4'

!

+  6+

#   < 

=

;

(4 & 1 0?     >' ! & 1;

+ I

>' '!

#