High Court of Punjab and HaryanaRSA/724/2005allowed

(O&M) Balbir Singh And Others v. Gurdeep Singh

2019-12-09Mr. Justice Harminder Singh Madaan12 pages

!"#$ $"$"

%% &"' ('"%#$

% )"

)'*+,"

-$('%+, "%% .

'"!$//+, "$"%

" 1+$"$% ('"% #$$!"'#$'"%# !"

#$2$"3"#$+!$4 3"45'"

66$#$+ "4""7"4+8". + )$6+ "5'"'-$""$"$$ -''$"9%$' " " #

!6$%"$"4, '!"#. :;< = >('"%#$& !"#$> +6 !",4#$$% ' '"% #$6$"%$' ?$% $ "@'$$,"$%$' $4!', '$+$%%"$$A'"!161 # , '

+. $%'%%"

. $ 6"4#$'+ 6$$6%!1. B'$6"4 %" 4"1!/6"-$'6!""'" "" ' BBA)AC'6'", 'C'6 ! !4 ' 44" "4$A'"C$$ % 6%%!1$6'"4 #$' $$"'$$'$' := 1"#$-6 #$% $!"$" "/ #$ $""+$%"+$1$,%$'# 4'$"'$% $,""1 !/,"$4 4"+6$$% 6"$' +"$"6$" 6"$4C$$'%"%"1$"4$' 4%"# .

+- . B$+%"1""

4 $'64

: " . : "+ $ $ %%"%",6%"#D%"

?$ % $ "% ","# $ #$6"46$"""#$,"4 $%

$% #$%"+ 6#'6" "4

8$$"$% 6"$'%"%"1E ))

8$$"$'$% !""'" ""' A)AE )

8$$"$$,!4$6"' !1 ,"%E )

8$$"$'$% $!, '%"%" 1 "$%'"%A'"E )

8$$"$% %%!1$6' $%"'E )

= 8$$"$'$% 4!""E )

$$%" ,"%$" 4

'"#$'"$,+$% #$ 4"")8$$'"$"D4$ )", 5 +"'#$4)8!"#"'4

$ $" $+ $ $ D4

$ )"% ('% 8+ $ 54 !'+ A "- 8+ $ ('"4 #$ 8:+ $ $##$ 8+ $ '"/ #$8 +$ 36#$8=$ !"#$8 !"#"'4

"$"#$ "' "$%"+$" A'"'. ,'"$% #$ $ #$% 6"$'%"%"1C' . 6#$,'"$% $ #$'!""'" ""' A)A+'. :

6,'"$#$% + '. 6#$,'"$ % +'. 6,'"$ #$% +'. =6$ #$$'6 4!"" ' 1+'$% 646$ ?$6,/'#4";

?$% 6##",!1$/'#4 "$$ %% !"$A'""*'#+ 5'"'-$"+6$$6# "*'# $+7?"-A'"+5'"'-$"+6$,/'#4" %$%% +$/'#4 "%!1$" A'""$'$% $ # $4 % 4'"#4" 4%"-$6. ;:;+-$. +" .

. : '6$$",', #)$6+ ?$ )$6+"5'"'-$"

.66'"$ $1$ $%""#' "%% !"$A'"+ 6$$ 6 ' $ "%<% + 6$ $ %%"$"'#$'

B$,$" "' "$%% . "' "$"%!##$"'#$$"" B$/4!"$1"

FD )-$6 . ;:;+-$. $6! $ 4('"%#$%%"$6"$ /4! B$A, '. :;< = >('"%#$&

!"#$>+'"%"4/'6$ #' . +$A'"$$ $% !6"/ %"%$' ?$% 6' '"%#"4" '$'%"%"14'"#:- 4" ?$" A'"6$ #'. :$4$ '$$%,"1 $1 $,"'$"$',"$"$ ?$" A'"!",$$% $,1)$1+ "%"$4"$% "$"1" $4 #"$4$% 6-'% 1"

= $$,'"6$"%4"

36,"+ $6D4!1$$, $$%$,"$$'4"$: 1" 7'"$"4"+6 "$$4 %!1,"' " = ?$$ D4 54 !' !$' 4+ A "-+ '% A44+)$68 ?$$'"$"D4 ('"4#$+G +6$$!"'#$$ "1 ""#$4"6 4""7"4+)$6 $43"$#$ ;6 $1"

='%14$! 8 $##$$%"#"#% !"#$2 $""$ :;1" ?$" A'"$"6$ ' $$"%6$$%+'' $-6 #$% "4 "4"$ 1"+!$$,!46"$ ' !161,"% 8$"$7"%% A'"%". /'#4$!",$%",' 1, '"/'6 +6$$6%,/'#4 +6$" 6$ $"%. %4" $ ' C$''$%""%+ !"#$ 6$%"1C$ #+6% 1$ $$

%% $ ! $%"'"4" 6$$' $' B41,6+$7"%% A'"$ """ 4#$ '$,"%64 ' ?$%%"$ # ' %!1$" A'"6%"%"%%"%"+6$""#"$ 7" %% A'" &"' " " ! - "6$ "#$% ,"%!1$ B $ 4 $ "" $ $, "'" $' #6$$%,"$'

?$% 6$ ##$4""$$$ $"'$$' 1"!-6"$'% !1$ ?$!""' 1 "#$% $$"$'%$ "'$''%$ "#$ 1!",!1$ " A'"$$%%"!% '! "1$% $6$,-1 #$!1"%"#$4"$% "$" 6#4""$ ("4)$1 3 $6$,"1"$ #"$4!1 ,"$$' # 1"'!1$4 3 $6$,-1 # $"#" B$" "

#+$6'!%4" +

; $$6' !$$$"'$',""4 6$$$6 # 1%!1$ ?$"' !1$% $! ?$% $4'!$",%""

= ?$ "" 1#'% "1" ="4! $" 4$$1$"'$',"$% $""

?$'#$"6"#"$'4$!'! 4! ,!1$A'"! 6!'$ ! -" " %'"% ?$$D4 8)"%('%+6$%",$"%"FD $ %'$':1" 8$ 54 !'+A "-+

'% A44+ )$6+ 6$ $ !"'#$ $ $' D 4"#""4

;$$$ 4 "$G $6!% %"%"1. ?$"4!4'6"#$ 4$' !" "+3""$"$ G "$#$ ?$$'"$"D48:

$ ('"4#$+G "4F "1"+6$$!"'#$ $""#$$4"6 4""7"4+ )$6$43"$#$ ; 6$1"

='%14! 8 $ $##$$$ !"#$2 "3"4 5'"6""#$$'"$ :;1" !"#$

6$6"%$$'('"%#$-6 !'%$"4$!##$$ "6$$4 8 $ '"/#$)'"#$ %$,"1 8=$ 36#$+ ""

$$6%! 7"+3F"4 ;:

$',4""7"4 ?$4"6$4 3"#$+6$6 ,#$%'$' #6$$ 4 1 8 !"#$2$"$$$+ $4$"!"$"3"#$$,!%$' %"%"1 =C$'$'%"%"1D4" 6 %'"$!1 $ 4$" "4$" !"$"$ % '"/#$"",FD :<$16" ,"%$,"14C6,% $4 $"%'"$C$$+$4$"3"#$$"' $',"$1""#$""$ :;1"C$ $1""#","$" 3%",%1," FD FD

3$'"$"$$1$#"" $" ?$ "4"6$43"#$+6$$ 6 ' %14 $ "! ?$"

%$!%' +$ ''

?$" A'"$"#$ 14$ '$ %$$!' %+$ +D ',+ "',"$-6 #"6" '#$

"' 6"

?$ % $ ! $ $ $ 6 %' 6$1""4 #$'

"$+ +$61$#% " = $ G4 %", $ 4 " % 44,! %"%"1"1"$"! 1" 6$ $ % $ !4 ," $ % 3"$%$%",!"4 6"+6$"$'6 = ?$""+ $' " 14!"" ?$'#$ $ % !# $ 4 $ !",4!1$A'"'"%"4/' !1$4!'$%! 1 ?$" A'"$ 4" -#$% '"%

?$ 6,"1 "$@' ! '"/' F,$"6+$A'"$%" "4"-+$"!"%"6$'""" $ 6 ?$% ' '"%!'$6 '!/ 6 44" 1!''$!",+ $ %", 6 %",# 4 " # ' " %$! !#" B ! !", $" $ " "*'# $+7?"-A'"+5'"'-$"# $%$$4""#"" ,"4

$ ' $ $, ! '! ! $ ,"%+$%"# # %"%" # $ "#" !1 $ " A'" $ $ '' 1 ! $ % ," % G" "*'# $+7?"-A'"+5'"'-$" $4% 14"%"$ 6$'!/%"%' $"1 $ 6 %"4, % $ ! '"#" B6!'!1>$ $ $ 4 % '" $ '$"1 " "$% +"$"6$!% "!6!"$"$% G" "*'# $+7?"-A'"+5'"'-$"6$, 1 '!1$$%"4,%'" ,"% 36,"+6$$" B$441$%% !"#A ;

=A:$! %'"%" 1!$ %% . $$4"$!4%"4!6$%"!' ",$"%! $ 1 $ %% <%% . $ %% !"#A ; A"6$"6 $%% ,6$4%"4+ $""$4"!"# 1 ?$%% : :

&"".,4!" +:+$%% 6""!-'%6$$4 36,"+

%"$A'"1%"$%% F,$"6+ $%% $! / 1!1 $$"%% 1 %% 6$"6$%% '$%% <%% . $%%"$A'"1"4-#%"1"#, $%% ,1$%"<#6 $ ##"4"$"$"" H"$ "'4+$"$#$6$$4"$ !4%"4 #$%% ?$%% !# %'"' %"%" 1 , ?$""+ $ 4 4 ?$/'#4"%!1$" A'"6 "+!'%%"%"%%" %%", """%" 666"# 1'%!1 " "*'# $+7?"-A'"+5'"'-$"

?$6"#!#'!1%$%"%%

' 1 $ /'#4 " % !1 "*'# $+7?"-A'"+5'"'-$" "$/'#4"%!1$" A'" 4#$'% """

?$%% 6"# 16$

!"#$ %&"'

!()$* "&#

'# !+,

"&#