High Court of Punjab and HaryanaCWP/13970/2012dismissed

Ashutosh Gupta v. State Of Haryana & ORS

2019-02-05Mr. Justice Darshan Singh8 pages

! " # $# % &#'(# )"( #

#% ##* (+( #&, ##* (+ #"# %# -!'.* !*&#' #%,%(* (+ # #),./* (+

##"((

0"#1""(0#2 ## 3

"#, '#'(...4*)/*5%#, !6%*)/&17 #,( '1 .+ #,

1#(&1(,( #,#+8 ##49( #4 .# : #' # #,4 1..

..' 7 #, ( '* (* 7(* ( .44"#+"#114.(( +. . &#'(.;( %#+) .* 881"#7,,7# #+ #,444"#+"# ' #,0#"#++#',,7# #+1..4 9"#4..1 #(#,((,'7 " (7'!+#, #,,, #(4.'*"# 1#49( (#) . &#'+.%#+ , ( "".) .* 0;: #'

##"#.("#

4 .' #4.+..(4,#490"# (,(,7 #;: #'

#1(4 "#+"#( #471 "##,( .+7'," #'0#"(95%!6%*)/ 14# 4

#,""# '# ,( '+(.# ((

3&1(+("#..'7'##,7/ 1#/*7 (+1 ((("# (#, 7 #,("#,(( .44..,"#+"# '# ##""# '14+,# ,( '+( .#((

<*7 ((/ #(4.'*( 19 1#+("#.41: #'#"# (4".' (,."#"(7,"(,&(( 7,#".'19 #((# #1#/61 # ,," #'1#((" , (,. #,#+- .'*

#,".'41..(.

#,. =.444#+(7'(,.#(#*"# .( #(.#7 # ((.+.- (4%#+*)/0 1 (,( 7' > (4, ( (# ((

0 "# ..4( > (4, ((#((

7 ## - (4*)/0 #"".. #7'> (4,((<3 ( #(# (,. ##(4 #(#

#( #, > #(.###6, *.# "", "# 0#2 ##"#, '#'*(...4*)/ 1 (7'-%##'*&. #,,#%##' !+&#'*&.(.;( "#,, !+## &#'7 (,.#(#1,

!+## 0 # "".. # .( ,,# ( > #("#(# (,.(.".*..1( "".((> (4,((# +.- (47'

,/4.#!+## &#','"""#"##(# (, #(# (,.7',,#7 "(5 4(#*.#(#- (4*)/.( "#(4( ( "( (,.#+.( "+

(41# #(7'#- (4#(#(

# #, '..4.'*?"1"(7',,#1# .( +7 !+##"4#(#0!6%* )/ "(#(#((( .' ##"".&1+#*4 #(#"(7'#- (4*)/*"#"# ##()%

11(,(7' # 7'"4 ..14#(# @%#(.' 8('# .4 "".*"". (#% 7 .( /4( ((.'*( .',"(7'

(+ ".

A"".. =##("".*( .' ""#(7'

(+*#?

4# (( ((.'&""...1(((.' # .4""...1( )% A .

("".(#(4"".. > (4,((#((<3 "(7'.#( # - (4* )/ 1#7' "". .( 7' ".

7"(( (#(7'4 (," 4(#(# (,. #+ (".#' "#(4* 1+#* 1 .7#' !+## " ""#"# # #(#* '* (B

## ..4 > (4, ( (# ((

"( 7' .#( ((. +. - (4 %# + )/ 1#7' ".

A""..1(,( =7# #".

1""(2 ## 3

"#, '#'(.

..4*)/15%#,!6%)/& 1#4( (#) . ,(

"".) .* +(,,((

3 #,># ".'( 1..

.7 #,( '1 '

#7. 1

3(( .44"#+ "#+. . &#'(.

;( %#+) .

#: #'*1 1 ( ".

+( .# ((

.41"' : #'#"#"#"4".' (,. #,#+0".

( .4 #".'1 1#.#(( 3

..44 9 "".' : #' #"# 0 (".#'

"#(4 .,("4 " ,#(# (( A

0 ".

.( +.

8 ..44 " , (,. #, #+0.#(#. #7 +( (( (* ".(#(# (,.((,( +(> (4,((#((

44#+( 4 ,* ".

.( "". ( .#( "".. #1.

#,4 (4#" +.(' : #'"#(4(#(# (,.> #(."1# ,,# " #(#1 ##.7#'!+## ," #'" ##(#(,

, #4 , .#( . # ".

A"".. 7,," #' !+## &#'"( ##(# #, #+ ""..(# #*"#' # 1(#1. "". ..4 #(#* (+(*#(1.1

,(1(#11.7#' #(C 0,#1#(#(1# #(,.

#(#(( A8

( ##(#1 ( 0 (,. #(# + 7 7 ( #(# , !+##11".( #,%!+#,#(#(( A8

#4#(4(,. "# #,#+0#(# 7 (7'=.,,#(#".%##' !+&#'*&.((.;( "#,7'7#+4 4#..'..#(# !+#,# (, !+## &#'= ##,',". !+## &#'*"# @!+#, &#'C ( ,+"# ( 1. 4 +# #(# % !+#, 0 =. ,,#7#+(#(#(#4.',"#" 7#4#(#(##.4..'+.((+7 ( 1( ""#+. ," #'# # 44""#+. ," #', !+## &#'A!+#, &#' # %##' !+#, &#'1#*,/(

#: .' #(#6.. *#,#(# !+#,0#(# (( A8

A ?987..(: 7' "#"#"#(4 3 2#( . #"# 7,," 4( #(# ?987"(#, 7#+,(7'

# "".. # #(# ((<3 1 #" > #(.###0 .1"( 7' #"".. #7 ,..',".(17'#"(7'> ((4"# !+## #,(#(#(( A8

(1.

< ,/47#+*#"(#( 7 "+# (7+7#+ #"".. #*(# #* #(# (#+ 7 ( # 4# ( ( ,. ""# #"(0.#( #"".. #" ..'

.(!+##,'"""#"##(#(, #(# (,. 7' ,,# 7 "( ( "#(4 ( ( "(..7: +.(#(4 # #

# #,, #,' 1#?47 # # "".. #0#(# ,,#7,9?* +1 > (4, #"".. #

2#( . # "# ## 7, #"(,# (#(# , #(# (,. .(7"(7'> 44.( 7 4 # #(#". .(0> (4, #- (4(( ( 44"##(# (,.7 7 ( (( ,".'41#(# #"".. #* # #"(##> '4(4 (4 ," 4(#(#7' 444 #,,( 1 .( ,/ ' (

# : .' #(# ( ..

*#,7#(# !+#,6*# #* #4(7'

.#( . #"##(##7##'*..4.( (#,#' ( #+ (4 .#( # "".. #(#(#741 > #( .(7# ( .#" ,41,??", #(#!+## &#'".( #,"#+ #(#

< 6+(#( 7, # ##*.#( .

#"#*7 ( 7,0!+## &#' 1?"("#..'" #(# (,.( 4+#,7 #4 .(7' #.<< 6( 1"#+( ..1 @<<( 7 !+#, % ..? + !+#, %..

7?"#(7/, !+## #(#(## ,,((? ( , !+## .. 7 ( ,#,'7" (# .7,(7' !+##*(+.(' #(## 1 (..7..(: 4# ( #(# # # , ,( # ? (7'!+## 0!+##..,/# . #,#+ # 7 !+#, %* ( #..,4# (7 #7 1#"1 !+##7'# (# #: #( (#C

0 ."#+#: #..? + !+#, %..7?"#(7/, !+##6"#*47"#( (#17' "# 1 ,' (# #, ," 4( #(# 0# #* ," 4(#(#7..(: 4# ( #(### ,,(7'!+###'"#+ .1 71# (# #'#.11#: # !+##*# , *(#"#..' 0"1(#(7'.#(#- (40!+## 1"#..'"#(# #(4.'*

% (4 7.;+ .#(#- (4(( (#(#

#4 #,'..4.' 0( * '*( #(," 4(#(#0.7#'4#( "#1.1(#14("".# ,# (1 .(7 (.'> #(. 1#," 4(#(#7#,"(?"#(, !+## %61 .(*# #* (+.(#( ," 4(#(#(( A8

A ?98# # 1##(?# (##'> #( #"#+(( (# #.< 6(##4 ,7 #(#"#( 8 = ##,#* "# .( , 7. 4#'((+( 7'444,. "#+"# (7'#,471..

..' #?'#1# 7,4 4+#,,".'

6+1 7+*6 (,#1#"1 #(4.'(,(

!" #