Madan Vaid v. Shimla Chandigarh Dicese Society

-1IN THE HIGH COURT OF PUNJAB & HARYANA AT CHANDIGARH Date of Decision: 13.03.2024 Madan Vaid & anr.

..... Appellants

Versus

Shimla Chandigarh Dicese Society Catholic Churche & anr.

..... Respondents CORAM: HON'BLE MRS. JUSTICE


Present:

Ms. Ekta Thakur, Advocate, and
 

       
       

  ! 


, J.

"   in he sent a l    

 #$#% ##& ' 
   ! "'   ! 

 (          

   '    "'    '   '

  )
  * +    

  ),- +    .%/


 *       #0.# ##0  *     - 1   !1 #/

/%2%

   ! - 

   

  $! 

        3      ! -     .2  ! 

                   

-2-           4 



"  

$5 



    

  -  

 6/ ##7  " 

   86

 /$ #%.# ##0   6.######7      -'  '  .'       '      !1 #/

/%2% 9   .

 '

   '      .



 :  #5#  ##% 6         -   '4    '       

 

            ;          '        '  ;                  "'        ./#0 ##%<

. 3   * 0.# ##0   - 1 !1 #/

/%2%  

 ! - .2! 

         =;

 3     '  

         *                  = ;

-3- / 3   

        '      =;6

$ 6   .  

    

                   /     

       "           '        

 



           !        >       '                :    ?     @   .$#) + 
 *  .522) A   A+ >          

   !             

 "                                        '   "  1B'     !       

  
  

 #.#

6) !  + 5#&  <

  

              

  

     

 

 

     !"

#



    

       

!" #       

-4-  

 

   

        

        

$  !"      %

#&      

     '

 !"  !!(      

 


)

  *  

 + $  !"   ,
!")

   

     

 '( -   

        



     

        

    .    

      

          '(       

  /  '(        0

              

   /     

     0

/   '1( &              /    '(        2        

               

    



  

  

 



          '!( #    /  '(          

 

-5-



       

  

         2     

 

     



   

        

 '3( 4  



 

    /   '(



    .     

    



     

   

 

, 5     

 

   

  

   

   61#+  

  

                  2   

    !"     

      '(   

           

  $ /  '(    0  8&

      

  '93""""""( :     

       0

   

    '93"""""( ;$ /  '1(                   



      

 

  

 



      

   

                $ /    '!(             

-6-

    

          

     

 



       

   

    

                 

 $ /  '3(  



        

         !"          

       

              

 

  /  '3(          

            

 

   !"    61# # 1          !        ,
!  5                     

 '(     

!"     



          0    

  61#' 

           

(   

     # 

  

 '( #     !"

    

              0                 

               

-7-   !"         

  

  !"   

 

   '1( 4  



 

    /    '(                   

          

    !"  

         

 

    /  / '

(  / 

               /     

 '

     /  ( 

 /   2 

         0         :

'

(

         /    2  

 /    

  /  + $ /   '(       !         !"      

   

      <= #   

 .  

   61# #$ /   '( '1(       

   

 '      66(            

    !"       

    

       

-8-      !"        .   



     

     ! *

  !!   



      %$  !! 

 ,
!!  7  

 

/                

   





      # 

 

+ 3 $  

     

    

     

 

    '(

'(          



        

      

  

                     

  



     

     

       



    %&$  !6            

                   

   

             $  !>

        #               !6    !>               

   

 

   

  !"  



      

         !6 !> # 

    

   

  

    

-9- 6 $      % 

  !6 !>    

            

  

         .          2 

 

       

 >             !"    

     .   

     ?        !"    

  

    !"      

 

  

 .



         @           !"

  

 



               !"

 /  



  $            

               A &       

     

              

 

 



       !" #-

    '

  1   (             

         !"      #  -



     

-10-   93"""B/ 

   C6D     

     1   

    

  

 $  

       

   0 1        -  

      

      

   .   1 +    '         :  ?   @  .$#) +   "   !             

      60####7     C%D                    

 ! !" #


$   %

1. Whether speaking/reasoned: Yes/No

2. Whether reportable:

Yes/No