← Library
High Court of Punjab and HaryanaCWP/17840/2010disposed of

Rajesh Chauhan v. State Of Haryana & ORS.

2015-01-20Mr. Justice Ramendra Jain5 pages

       

 !"

#$% &%'()(*+  ,   

    

     

 

 !+ - .!//  .

0%)%*$+ !01!#2(34/%*(0&5'#$%6($7 !0!#*&%%8/(*974&5'#$% 0$7%8%$($(*%0 !0#9#*&%%8/#):4&&2&5'#$%%*%0#24#0;#*#  #<%)7 (*&#24 7%8%$($(*%0 (2%&$7%80%)%*$8%$($(*6($7#90(%5#*'%$7#$ 8%0)*)4676%0%26%0(*=%0($46%0%

%0%&#88(*$=%*$467%0%#)$7% '2#(= $7%8%$($(*%06#)*$'*)(&%0%& )&:0(*9$7%8%*&%*'; $7%80%)%*$8%$($(*4$7%8%$($(*%0 6#)

%0%&#88(*$=%*$4$7%'2#(=()>%(*90%)$0('$%&$*$(*#2>%*% ($)

0=$7%&#$%8%0)*)26%0(*=%0($6%0%#88(*$%& .%#0*%&':*)%2 0$7%8%$($(*%0):>=($$%&$7#$(*8:0):#*'% $#&5%0$()%=%*$()):%&*  

? (22(*9:8 ?8)$) 0$ 0# %#'7%0)4$7%8%$($(*%04>%(*9%2(9(>2%4#882(%& 0$7%)#=% $%0$7% 80'%)) )%2%'$(*4$7%0%):2$6#)&%'2#0%&7%*#=% $7%8%$($(*%06#) #$/0 (* !"'#$%90;)$7%'#*&(&#$%4676#)26%0(* =%0($ #$ /0 ,46#) ()):%& #88(*$=%*$ 2%$$%0* , 4$7% 8%$($(*%0 (2%&$7%60($8%$($(*)8%'( ('#22;0#()(*9$7%# 0%)#(&()):%(*$7% 8%$($(*7%'*$%*$(*0#()%&>;$7%8%$($(*%0(*8#0#90#87?(5"#22%9(*9 $7#$8%0)*)4676%0%26%0(*=%0($4*#=%2;4!#*<1:=#0#*&#0&%%8 1:=#0  7#&  >%%*  

%0%&  #88(*$=%*$  6($7  )#=%  @:#2( ('#$(*4  #)  $7%

 8%$($(*%08))%))%)4(%4 (*%0$) 0= %27(*(5%0)($;46#) *$0%82(%&$)8%'( ('#22;7%*$7()6#)>0:97$$$7%*$('% $7%':0$4 0%8%#$%&#&<:0*=%*$)6%0%):97$>;2%#0*%&':*)%2 0$7%/$#$%#*&

(*&(*9*0%82;4$7%8%$($(*%06#)

%0%&#88(*$=%*$5(&%0&%0&#$%& ? A/$#$%=%*$$$7#$%

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

:0$7%0):>=($$%&$7#$)%*(0($;#*&$7%0>%*% ($))7#22>%#5#(2#>2%$$7% %=82;%%)  67  #0%  #88(*$%&  #9#(*)$  $7%  ):>)$#*$(5%  8)$)  7% #88(*$=%*$ $7%8%$($(*%0#)6%22#)$7%0'#*&(&#$%)()*$%=80#0; >#)()7%;6(22>%'* (0=%&*2;#9#(*)$$7%):>)$#*$(5%8)$)467('7)7#22 >%*$7%>#)() $7%(0)%*(0($;% :0$7%0):>=($$%&$7#$$7%06()%4$7% #88(*$=%*$)$$7%8)$ 0$#*&0# $%#'7%0#0%:*&%0'7#22%*9% >% 0%$7()':0$ %#0&2%#0*%&':*)%2 0$7%8#0$(%)#*&8%0:)%&$7%8#8%0 >3 *0%)8*)%$$7%#&5%0$()%=%*$()):%&*  

? (22(*9 :8 ?8)$) 0$#*&0# $%#'7%04$7%8%$($(*%04>%(*9#&%90%%72&%0 (*(*%0$)4#882(%& 0$7%)#=%7%@:#2( ('#$(*)0%@:(0%&#)8%0$7% #&5%0$()%=%*$6#)!#$0(':2#$(*6($7$6;%#0) (82=#(*0$ 0# C#=(*#$(*  '*&:'$%&  >;  #0;#*#  *&:)$0(#2  0#(*(*9  %8#0$=%*$  0 %@:(5#2%*$@:#2( ('#$(*0%'9*()%&>;#0;#*#&:'#$(* %8#0$=%*$7% '2#(= $7%8%$($(*%06#)$7#$&%90%%(*(*%0$)()7(97%0@:#2( ('#$(* $7#*&(82=#(*0$ 0# $C#=(*#$(*47%*'%47%6#) :22;%2(9(>2% $%0 '=82%$(*    $7%  80'%))    )%2%'$(*4  $7%  0%):2$  6#)  &%'2#0%&  7%

A 8%$($(*%06#)82#'%&#$/0 (*$7%=%0($2()$ $7%'#*&(&#$%) >%2*9(*9$ !"'#$%90;7%'#*&(&#$%#$/0,(*$7%=%0($ 2()$ !"'#$%90;6#)

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

/%2%'$(*==())(*7#)=#&%$7% )%2%'$(*#*&*#=% $7%'#*&(&#$%)6%0%0%'==%*&%&(* 5#0(:) ()$0('$) 0#88(*$=%*$#)$7%8)$) 0$ 0# %#'7%0)  ()   ()$0('$  #&0%  /=%  '#*&(&#$%)  67  7#5% 8#))%& (*%0$)#*&$7%;7#5%>%%*)%2%'$%&#*& #88(*$%&  (*  $7%  )#=%  >#$'7  (*  67('7  $7%  8%$($(*%0  6#) )%2%'$%&  %6  *#=%)  67('7  #0%  (*  $7%  3*62%&9%    $7% 8%$($(*%0#0%!#*<1:=#040$ 0# $%#'7%045$/0 /%'/'724 #>%7>#28:0()#0"4#*$7%0'#*&(&#$%)*#=%2; #0&%%81:=#080%)%*$2;8)$%&(*5$(97/'72417%0(4

()$0('$7#<<#0677#)8#))%&$7%)#=%@:#2( ('#$(* 0=$7% )#=%*(5%0)($;#*&)%2%'$%&#*&#88(*$%&(*$7%)#=%>#$'7 /4  #'$(*    $7%  0%)8*&%*$)  ()  *  $7%  #'%    ($ &()'0(=(*#$0;E *$7%60($$%* )$#$%=%*$  (2%&>;1#=2%)7 /7#0=#4 ()$0('$ &:'#$(*

('%041#0*#2*>%7#2 $7%0%)8*&%*$)4*)8%'( ('0%82;

6#)9(5%*$$7%# 0%)#(&8#0#90#877%*$7%# 0%)#(&8(*$6#)0#()%& >;2%#0*%&':*)%2 0$7%8%$($(*%04* $7()':0$8#))%&$7%

 

226(*90&%0+ D:*)%2 0$7%8%$($(*%07#)467(2%0% %00(*9$8#0#?):>F 8#0#  (5"4  ):>=($$%&  $7#$  $7%  '#*&(&#$%)4  67  7#&  8#))%&

(*%0$)46%0%)%2%'$%&#2*96($7$7%8%$($(*%0 %6 $7%=#0%!#*<1:=#040$#*&0# $%#'7%045$ /0  /%'  /'724  #>%7>#28:0  ()#0"  #*&  #0&%%8  1:=#04 5$(97/'72417%0(4 ()$0('$7#<<#04677#&8#))%&$7% )#=%@:#2( ('#$(*) 0=$7%)#=%*(5%0)($;#)$7%8%$($(*%04 $7%;)$#*&)%2%'$%&#*&#88(*$%& 8%0:)#2 $7%0%82;)76)$7#$*0%)8*)%7#)>%%*

(2%&>;$7%0%)8*&%*$)$$7%)#(&):>F8#0#(5" 8#0#? :*)%2 0$7%0%)8*&%*$)80#;) 0#*#&<:0*=%*$$ (2%# )8%'( ('#

(&#5($(*$7()0%9#0& %%& :2>%&*%6($7(*#8%0(& :06%%3) .()$ :0$7%0'*)(&%0#$(**G  E 7%0%# $%042%#0*%&':*)%2 0$7%/$#$%):97$#&<:0*=%*$) $(22 A$ (2%0%82;(*$%0=) $7%# 0%)#(&0&%0* A4$7() ':0$0%'0&%&$7%)$#$%=%*$ 2%#0*%&':*)%2 0$7%8%$($(*%0$7#$$7% 8%$($(*%07#)>%%*

%0%&#88(*$=%*$#)0$#*&0# $%#'7%07%0&%0 &#$%& ? A

%0(*9 #88(*$=%*$$$7%8%$($(*%0#)0$#*&0# %#'7%06#)):>)%@:%*$2;82#'%&*0%'0& 7%'2#(=*6()$7#$$7%8%$($(*%04>%(*9=0%=%0($0(:) #*& :22;%2(9(>2%$>%#88(*$%&#)0$#*&0# $%#'7%04&%)%05%&$>% 

%0%&#88(*$=%*$>% 0%$7%8%0)*)26%0(*=%0($6%0%#88(*$%&0

0=$7%)#=%&#$%$()*$(*&()8:$%$7#$'#*&(&#$%#$/0,(*$7% '#$%90;     !"4  $  67('7  $7%  8%$($(*%0  >%2*9)4  6#)  

%0%& #88(*$=%*$ * , #*&7%<(*%&7())%05('%):>)%@:%*$2;7% 8%$($(*%06#)#$/0 (*$7%=%0($2()$7%)$#*&$#3%*>;$7% 8%$($(*%00%9#0&(*97()%2(9(>(2($;#*&#2)$7#$$7%0'#*&(&#$%)8))%))(*9 )#=%@:#2( ('#$(*6%0%9(5%*#88(*$=%*$(*$7%)#=%80'%)) )%2%'$(* 6#)*$)8%'( ('#22;0%82(%&$>;$7%/$#$%40#$7%04 (*&(*9($&(

(':2$$7% 8%$($(*%06#)#2)

%0%&#88(*$=%*$!%#*(*9$7%0%>;40%<%'$(* $7%

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

$7%==())(*#)8%0=%0($(*$7%)%2%'$2()$ 0$7%0%#)*)=%*$(*%&#>5%4$7%60($8%$($(*()#226%& 7%0%)8*&%*$)#0%&(0%'$%&$90#*$*$(*#2>%*% ($)$$7%8%$($(*%0 0= $7%&#$%'#*&(&#$%#$/0,(*$7%=%0($2()$<(*%&)%05('%476%5%04 $7%=*%$#0;>%*% ($))7#22>%8#;#>2% 0=$7%&#$%$7%8%$($(*%0<(*%& )%05('% #<%)7 (*&#2"

:&9%   , =3