High Court of Punjab and HaryanaCWP/17888/2010dismissed

Atma Ram v. State Of Punjab And ORS.

2016-08-31Ms. Justice Navita Singh,Mr. Justice Jasgurpreet Singh Puri11 pages

!"# $#%&'&()*+*'",-

. "/!!/ $#!$ "01*+02'

)

1#'#(") 01&4'0!50!(-1$3%!"#6&"0 701&!8&3&""!9 94&""!9-$3%!"#' 1"0#:#"&"&(#1 01&!8#'00!1$6!8-$$&"&(!9

#"&"&(#1"/!!/ '&(%#$#!$ 0!$:*1%0!'#$!9(+6&"0 "0#1%;'0!1#1'-<5(!/#(&"!!1+!($!6!(!1+-9!($/#!'*1&(+= <&+0! <&'6!'<5'!9#$##$ = $!"#$>=?>?*" .,<&+0!'?

<&'6!'%/:1&'#$&(@0!'1!?? '&"*!"#$!"3&99!+#!"0&($!-&'"1&%" !"0&($!&''0!1#6!'7="0&#<&+0! ;7 <&'6!' !99&(+(6#'"#1( '&$# !"0&($!;*(&!(&1!$0#1#!

"#1-"/!!/:*1%0!'#$7="0/1# '0!1#*" "0#'!&$=<&+0!!($ <&'6!'<51#+&'"#1#$'!9#$##$!($"0*'

0#<#%!/#6(#1&(:''#''&( ""!99!($/#!'*1&(+ <&+0!><&'6!'*"

=<&+0! <&'6!'(&"!!1+!($!6!(!1+0!$ &9#$ .

??=&("0&'*1":*""&(+"%0!99#(+#("& &%!"&(' 1!%A*&'&"&( "0# 9!($ 1"0#%0#/#!"!"0&($!;*(&!(&!$ 0!"6!'$#%&$#$(

?&( !3*1 "0#:#"&"&(#1'"0#1#&(-&#-(&"!!1+!($!6!( !1+!($( =

-2#""#1'!"#("::#!9=. ??

6!'!996#$ <5"0&'*1"'#""&(+!'&$#"0#8*$+/#("/!$#<5"0#9#!1(#$&(+9#*$+# $!"#$

?6#3#1-"0#!::#99!"#8*$+/#("$!"#$ =

6!''#"

!'&$#<5"0#:#B*1"!($ 1#'00#!1&(+<5"0&'*1"6!'1$#1#$<5"0# :#B*1" #"&"&(#1"/!!/0!$ &9#$"0#:1#'#(":#"&"&(&("0&'*1"

(

6&"0!:1!5#1"$#%9!1#:''#''&(<5!"0&($!/:13#/#(" 1*'" &('01""0#1*'" <&+0!'><&'6!'9!($&(@0!"!.?-40!'1! ?? !"!"0&($!;*(&!(&1!$&99#+!9!($%('#A*#("1#'"1!"&(

:''#''&("0&/%%1$&(+""0#:#"&"&(#1-"/!!/-&("0#5#!1

"0#1*'"0!$"1&#$""!4#"0#:''#''&(*($#1"0#+!1< "0#!6!1$ :!''#$0#:#"&"&(#10!$(#11(#*'!$3&%# "0#%*('#9 &9#$!'*&"

1 $#%9!1!"&( !($ :#1/!(#(" &(8*(%"&( 60&%0 6!' $&'/&''#$ ( >,

0#1#!

"#1- 1/ "0# 5#!1

>- "0# :#"&"&(#1 0!$ /!$# %11#':($#(%#6&"0+3#1(/#("!*"01&"&#'!($"0#1#6!'!$&1#%"&(" /!4#! !%" &($&(+1#:1""&'&("0#9&+0" "0#!<3# !%"'-"0#:#"&"&(#1 '*+0""0#1#9&# !'#!19&#1'"!"#$ 0#1*'"0!' &9#$61&""#('"!"#/#("$!"#$

""0&':#"&"&( "&''"!"#$"0!""0#:#"&"&( &9#$<5(&"!!1+ .

= 6!'

&9#$(

?!+!&('"60&%02=. ??

6!' &9#$!($&"

1#/!&(#$:#($&(+ 1 &(!90#!1&(+(:!1!, "0#61&""#('"!"#/#("-&"

6!''"!"#$"0!""0#9!($ "0#:#"&"&(#1!($"0#1%;'0!1#1'/#!'*1&(+

, <&+0!' <&'6!'6!'!%A*&1#$0#1*'"0!$"!4#("0#'!/#'"!($<# 1# "0#&3&9*1"60&%0 &(!995(#3&$#(%#$&'/&''#$"0#'*&" &9#$<5"0# :#"&"&(#1"/!!/(/#1&"' 2#!1(#$ *('#9 1 "0# :#"&"&(#1 &( '*::1" "0# 61&"

:#"&"&(3#0#/#("95%("#($#$"0!""0#1*'"0!$("!%A*&1#$"0#'*<8#%" 9!($<#9(+&(+""0#:#"&"&(#1!($'"&990!$/!$##(%1!%0/#("("0# 9!($<#9(+&(+""0#:#"&"&(#10#%*('#9"0#(%("#($#$"0!""0#/!:' !'6#99!'8!/!<!($&1#%1$'%9#!195'06"0!""0#9!($:*1%0!'#$<5"0# :#"&"&(#16!'("!%A*&1#$<5"0#1*'"!($"0#9!($ !99&(+&(@0!"!

40!'1!?? (#!'"#1('&$# !"0&($!;*(&!(&1!$6!'

!%A*&1#$!($"0#6(#1'0!$"!4#(%/:#('!"&( 1"0#'!&$!1#!60#1#!'

"0#:#"&"&(#1C'9!($ !99'("0#6#'"#1('&$# "0#'!&$1!$'""0# :#"&"&(#1!::1!%0&(+"0#&3&9*1"<5 &9&(+!%&3&9'*&"!($<"!&(&(+ 8*$+/#("!+!&('"0&/-9#!1(#$%*('#9'*</&""#$"0!""0#'*&"6!' &9#$ *($#1!61(+!$3&%#-&#-&3&9*&"= $!"#$==

$#%&$#$( >,

!($!"!(51!"#!%%1$&(+""0#%*('#9"0*+0"0#'!&$8*$+/#(" !($ $#%1## 6!' (" %0!99#(+#$ <5 "0# :#"&"&(#1- &" 6*9$ /!4# ( $&

#1#(%#!'"0#%&3&9%*1"&"'#9 <'#13#$"0!""0#/!""#16!''"&99:#($&(+ &("0#&+0*1"&(1#9!"&(""0#!%A*&'&"&(!($"0!"&'605"0#:#"&"&(#1 "/!!/6!':1/:"#$" &9#"0&'61&":#"&"&("0*+0&("0#5#!1

- '&(%#"0#'*&"6!'$&'/&''#$&("0#5#!1

2#!1(#$*('#9 1"0# :#"&"&(#1"0#(%("#($#$"0!""0#%;'0!1#1' "0#:#"&"&(#1-(!/#95-(&"!

!1+!($!6!(!1+!1#!91#!$5<# 1#"0&'*1"&(2=. ??

!($"0#:#"&"&(#1-<#&(+!%;'0!1#1'-6*9$!9'<##("&"9#$""0#1#9&#

= !9(+6&"0"0#/::1!%0&(+"0&'*1"9!"#6*9$/!4#($&

#1#(%#&( "0!"#3#("*!9&"5#"0#1# 1#:1!5#$ 1!996&(+"0#61&":#"&"&( #1%("1!-9#!1(#$%*('#9 1"0#1*'"3#0#/#("95::'#$ "0#61&":#"&"&(!($&(3&"&(+*1!""#("&(""0#61&""#('"!"#/#(" &9#$<5 "0#1*'"-%*('#9 1"0#1*'"!1+*#$"0!""0#1*'"&(%9#!1"#1/''"!"#$&( "0#61&""#('"!"#/#("!<*""0#!%A*&'&"&( '*<8#%"9!($ "0#:#"&"&(#1 &(!%%1$!(%#6&"09!6!($"0#:''#''&(6!'!9'"!4#((>>? ?!

"#1 "0#!6!1$6!':!''#$( , ?

0#:#"&"&(&'9&!<9#"<#$&'/&''#$ !'&"6!' &9#$&("0#5#!1

6&"0*":*""&(+"%0!99#(+#"0#!%A*&'&"&( :1%##$&(+'&("0&':#"&"&((!':!%&*':9#!"0!""0#1*'"0!$/!$# #(%1!%0/#("("0#'*<8#%"9!($%%1$&(+""0#%*('#9 1"0#1*'"- "0#:#"&"&(#1&'<96&(+0"!($%9$60&%06*9$<#%9#!1 1/"0# 8*$+/#(" "0# %&3&9 %*1" &( "0!" "0# :#"&"&(#1 0!$ %0!99#(+#$ "0# !%A*&'&"&(:1%##$&(+'!($!9'%9!&/#$"<#&(:''#''&(<# 1#"0#%&3&9 %*1" 0*' "0&':#"&"&( &'!+!&(("0#'!/#&''*#'0&':#"&"&(&' "0#1# 1#%9#!195("/!&("!&(!<9#!'"0#8*$+/#("1#%1$#$<5"0#%&3&9 %*1"%!(("<#&+(1#$!($<&($'"0#:#"&"&(#1""#("&(6!'!9'&(3&"#$ ""0#1$#1$!"#$#<1*!15 -

(>.,=

&(2 =. ??

0#%*('#9 1"0#1*'""0#1# 1#:1!5#$ 1$&'/&''!9

"0#61&":#"&"&( " "0# *"'#"- &" &' (#%#''!15 " '"!"# "0# !%"' !<*" "0&'

9&"&+!"&( 0#1*'"0!$:*<9&'0#$("& &%!"&(*($#1#%"&(,. "0# *(8!<6(/:13#/#("1*'"-??

&('01""0#??

%" (= ?

= !($'*<'#A*#("("& &%!"&(*($#1#%"&(= (.,?

0#!6!1$6!'

> $#%9!1#$( , ?

0#%;'0!1#1' :#"&"&(#1"/!!/-(!/#95- (&"!!1+!($!6!(!1+0!$ &9#$ .

=%0!99#(+&(+ !%A*&'&"&(-60&%06!'!996#$(

?$/&""#$95-:#"&"&(#1"/!

!/0!$(":*""%0!99#(+#"0#!%A*&'&"&(!""0!""&/#*"0# &9#$%&3&9 '*&"&("0#5#!1

%0!99#(+&(+!%A*&'&"&(#"%&/&9!195'/#"0#1 :#"&"&('%0!99#(+&(+!%A*&'&"&(6#1#!9'!996#$("0#'!&$$!"#<5"0# 9#!1(#$&(+9#*$+# "0&'*1" 0#1*'"0!$ &9#$2<# 1#"0&'

*1"60&%06!'$#%&$#$*9"&/!"#95( =

0#:#B*1"(

,'#"!'&$#"0#'!&$!::#99!"#8*$+/#("!($1#/&""#$!99"0#/!""#1'" "0&'*1" 1 1#'0%('&$#1!"&( 6 &( ' !1 !' :1#'#("

- ?=,

>!($

!1#%(%#1(#$-"0#'!/#6#1# ("9&'"#$<# 1#"0&'*1"<# 1#"0#8*$+/#("6!'$#9&3#1#$( =

:#10!:'$*#""0#9'' 1#%1$' "0#'#%!'#' 0#1# 1#-!':#1"0# 1$#1'/!$#<5"0#(C<9#0&# *'"&%# "0&'*1"-"0#'#/!""#1'0!3# <##(:9!%#$ 10#!1&(+6&"02' ?=,

>0!'<##( &9#$ (,

>!($&'!9'9&'"#$ 10#!1&(+ 6-%/&(+""0#:1#'#("61&":#"&"&(-&"&'(#%#''!15 1*'

"A*"#"0#:1!5#1'&("0#:1#'#("61&":#"&"&("0!"6!' &9#$(

996&(+!1#"0#:1!5#1');

D! !61&"&("0#(!"*1# !($!/*'$#%9!1&(+"0#*(!*"01&E#$ 1#"#("&( :''#''&( 9!($/#!'*1&(+ &+0!'>&'6!'

%/:1&'#$&(@0!"!.?-@0!'1!?? '&"*!"#!"!"0&($! *(&!(!!$-!"!0&($!<5"0#1#':($#(" ;1*'""<# &99#+!9-*(!*"01&E#$!($3&9!"&3# 1"&%9#'=!($,

; "0#

('"&"*"&( ($&!)

! "

# $ % $

& ' #

$ $ ( ! ) #

#* ! " $

#! +,,( ,,-.

/ & ,0!

+1,1 ,,-.

/ & 20! #

) #

#*3 #1*'!9 "0#!<3#:1!5#1''06'"0!""0#:#"&"&(#1&''##4&(+ $#%9!1!"&(!<*""0#!99#+#$*(!*"01&E#$:''#''&(71#"#("&( "0#9!($ /#!'*1&(+ <&+0!'><&'6!'&(40!'1!?? !($%('#A*#("1$#1

1#'"1!"&(("0#61&":#"&"&(-&"&''"!"#$"0!""0#:''#''&(6!'"!4#( &99#+!995&("0#5#!1

"&'%9#!1"0!""0#1#&'(%0!99#(+#""0# !%A*&'&"&(:1%##$&(+'&("0&':#"&"&(-!'%!(<#'##( 1/"0#:1!5#1'

!<3# ("0#61&""#('"!"#/#("-"0#1#&'!':#%& &%'"!"#/#("&(1#:95( /#1&"'&(:!1! -60&%0&'A*"#$<#96);

$2$

+,! 4 -5+ 6

& ' 2 #

7 4 --8 !

$ 4 ) #' 3 0#:#"&"&(#1<#&(+"0#%;'0!1#16&"0(&"!!1+!($!("0#1- %!((""15"%("#($"0!"0&'9!($6!'("!%A*&1#$<#&(+("0#6#'"#1(

'&$#0#:#"&"&(#1-"0#1# 1#-%9#!1954(#6!<*""0#'"!($"!4#(<5"0# 1*'"("0#!%A*&'&"&( 0&'9!($!($"0!"&'605-"0#:#"&"&(#1 &9#$&3&9 *&"= $!"#$==

0#%&3&9'*&"6!' 1$#%9!1!"&(!($:#1/!(#("

&(8*(%"&(('"#!$ '"!"&(+"0# !%"'-#3&$#(%#!($ &($&(+#"%&("0!"'*&"- &"6*9$<#!::1:1&!"# 1*'"A*"#"0#1#9#3!(":!1!+1!:0' 1/"0#%&3&9 %*1"8*$+/#("-60&%06*9$+&3#%9#!1!('6#1""0#%("#("&('1!&'#$<5 2#!1(#$*('#9 1"0#:#"&"&(#1 #-"0#1# 1#-A*"#"0# 996&(+ :!1!+1!:0' 1/"0#'!&$%&3&9%*1"8*$+/#(");

!" #$ % & $ '

(

)* +* , ''-

* . * & & &

& #

( )* +* , ''- * * *

/ 0% 1

& &

!" # $% & '

., 23#22 4 4 4&5 "++'6) 1

% & $ * & / % % & $ * -* +* , ''-, ""6 7 $ & $ %

., $ -* +* , ""6, ''-$ ) * +* , "'$ 45 "++ '6) !)

-* +* & % 8 4

- * -* -* +* , ''-, ""6/ 0

!"#$%& '

( ) *+* **, + )

-# ./ 0 1 -0& 2

./ 3 / 45 -" 6 ./ ' ' 2

7 8"9

// 1

) )

/ ) / )

( )

6))

)

( )

4:) 4/ 0 0;

**<,='

; $

4:) 4/ 0 $

0; **<,='

$; =+<<* ) %-

)6 )

4:) 4/ 0

( 5

) / 7 8>'

? / (

6 ) /

(

) ( '

/=2/ *2( /

;<<+ '

(

/=2/ *2( /

;<<+ '

6 / ) / '

/ )

5 )

6 ;

7 " &' "0*' %15'"!9 %9#!1 1/ "0# !<3# 8*$+/#(" "0!" "0# :#"&"&(#1"/!!/0!$':#%& &%!9951!&'#$"0#&''*#'!<*""0#9%!"&(

"0#9!($<#9(+&(+"0&/!($ *1"0#1"0!"0&'9!($6!'("!%A*&1#$!($"0!" 0#6!'&(:''#''&( 0&'9!($!($"0!"6&"0*"/!4&(+!(5!%A*&'&"&(- "0#1*'" 6!' !""#/:"&(+ "<"!&( "0#:''#''&( "0#'*<8#%"9!($ #"&"&(#1"/!!/"#($#1#$0&'#3&$#(%#<# 1#"0#"1&!9%*1"!($"0# 1*'"!9'#B!/&(#$&"'6&"(#''"1#<*""0##3&$#(%# #!9''*+0"!

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

#1#(" 1/"0#(#"0!"6!'!%A*&1#$-60&%0&'1#:#!"#$95 1!&'#$&("0&'61&":#"&"&(-6!'!9'1!&'#$<50&/<# 1#"0#%&3&9%*1"( :!1!> "0#8*$+/#("!<3#-"0#%&3&9%*1"%9#!1950#9$"0!""0#:9!&("&

:#"&"&(#1"!/!/ !&9#$":&(:&("!'"60&%0:1"&(*" <&+0!

<&'6!'%/:1&'#$&(40!'1!?? &'&(0&':''#''&((*1:&(&(- "0#%&3&9%*1"0!$$#%&$#$"0#$&':*"#$A*#'"&(' !%"'!'"60&%0 :1"&(6!'!%A*&1#$!($60&%0:1"&(6!'("!%A*&1#$-<51#%1$&(+ #3&$#(%#!($"0#%*1"0#9$"0!""0#:#"&"&(#10!$ !&9#$":13#0&'%!'# #!1#!

1!&$-6#%!(!"!99#($#!3*1"+<#0&($"0#%&3&9%*1"8*$+/#(" !($ &(""0#'!&$ $&':*"#$ A*#'"&(' !%"3#1!+!&(&( "0#:1#'#("

8*1&'$&%"&( "&'&("#1#'"&(+"("#"0!""0#:#"&"&(#1(#3#1%0!99#(+#$"0# '!&$8*$+/#(" "0#%&3&9%*1"!($!996#$&""1#/!&(<&($&(+(0&/ #3#(!'($!"##1#!9956($#1!'"066#6&99<#!<9#""&(4#16&"0 "0#'!&$8*$+/#(" "0#%&3&9%*1"!'%("#($#$<# 1#*'<59#!1(#$ *('#9 1"0#:#"&"&(#1

#-"0#1# 1#- &($"0!""0#:#"&"&(#1 &9#$"0#:1#'#(":#"&"&( !

"#10!3&(+9'"<# 1#"0#%&3&9%*1"!($'*%0!/*9"&:9&%&"5 9&+&+!"&( %!(("<#:#1/&""#$ ("0#1#'*9"-6# &($(/#1&"&("0#:1#'#("61&"

:#"&"&(#-"0#1# 1#-/!4#"0# 996&(+1$#1);

&'$&'/&''#$

&& 1$#1!'"%'"' .0 .

0 $ + ,+- 1 0#"0#1':#!4&(+71#!'(#$

#' 0#"0#11#:1"!<9#