Govind Sarda v. State Of Haryana
! "#!
$!% &!'
(
!"#$ %#& ' %% #!
! """ !#" $
% % & "
'!
))))) %#& ' %% ("
*+(! ! +, +( (-.
.!(!'/,!(!.! 012
3
#, 56/,'7!56/,7&!'% ! 7
81 #, 7 9
*+01:!.! +!.!7&50;756/, '7+.:+++<=> ?
>%,,@+ %((,
.%'
/,7:++ /!+6!-./! <> ?
>%,,@ :!+!/!.6!-.6+!/! !:!/!.'
6!-.,, &50;!6 /%+6!!! !,70 %((,7&!' 0 7:+% 66 *+ 66 ,& 756/, ( + /, :% ++/, 6!-.+.' 1 ,,. ++6,,+ + &50; % :!.%,, &50;:+,%.:!.%,.,/'%((,'., 76%, 7 ! %/! .%'/,
*+++A%! +!' +(!+ !,!, 6 ((,!.!(!'/,7:++: 6 /' + %! ! ! 4
3 5B%! # 6 + % (% B! !6 :! %/67 6' / +!,.,,',,: *+,-*,./
"
" 0
+1 ,,,2
! "
*,.3.1
"
"
(
" ! 4 (56 *+,-*,./ "
"7
"
!
".18*8 ""
"
"
(5 " "
" " ""
5 6
% !
*,./
*,./ ,3,8*,./ (
"
!
" "
! " 5
,3,8*,./
4
,8,.*,.3 5
"! *:,,
! " 7"# %# !< =#%# "
;
! < % "! & ; /7/*::7#%7*,.37,,-- ,8,.*,.3
" " #% # " ;
< "
! "
" ./,,
! " # !*,.3 *,.3 *:,.*,.3 (" ./,, """ !#%# < " !> ,8,.*,.3 "
" ! % " ! .1,/*,.3
" ! !
#%# "?
) @
% .1,/*,.3 "
2 " .-,/*,.3 ;
" ! (5 !
! "
"
.-,/*,.3
! "
"
"
"
.-,/*,.3 "
./,, " "
!.*8/ " .8,/*,.3 "
"
0 "
"" 0
"
"
"
! 5 9 .*8/
! "
.8,/*,.3
A B16 *.,/*,.3
" (
& ..17*,.3
A B.6 " "#%# <
*.,/*,.3 "
" 3,:73*, B; B
;! "
""
! !"!
! " **,/*,.3
"
" "" #%# !< ""
" "
" "
"" ! 5 ! "
./,,
! " " "
#%#
";
!< " " 5
**,/*,.3
,+,3*,.3
" " "
" "#% # !< !"
& ./+7*,.3 4
A B:6
,+,3*,.3
;
;
"
2 " !
2
! " "
"#%# "
;
!<
3
,+,1*,.3
;
;
& ..::7*,.3 ""
,+,1*,.3
(
;
;
" ! #%# !< ! #% # ?
) @
.,,:*,.3"
"
! ! "
( " "
"
"
" " "
""
,8,3*,.3" ! " A
.:,1*,.3
;
; "
;& ./+7*,.3
,+,1*,.3 D9
" "
"
;
!*,#
*,.3E ,8,:*,.3
./,:*,.3
;
; 2
B "
5 *18/
! """ !
#%# !<
! "
"
0!
"" """ ! F! "" 5 % "
"
2 " " !
"
*,.*./ *,./.3
" *+,:*,.3 #% # " ;
! <
"
& !
G"B% % >"
;;& ::7*,.3
*+,:*,.3
;
; ,+,1*,.3 .:,1*,.3
;
!
H2 C
"
2 " ,3,+*,.3
;
; "
& ::7*,.3 ,3,+*,.3
"
"
" " " *,.3 & *,.3
"2
"
"
"
;
;
"
"
;
*-..*,.3
& ::7*,.3"" "
*-..*,.3
" " "2
* */ 33, " H " C
., +/ ,:, " H" C !
"
" /,,/*,.1
" ! "
"
! ' ! < ""
" ;
"
" ;
" ;
"""
" /,,/*,.1
A B.36 ,*3*,.1
4
65 !
9 " ' % ,:,3*,.1 # ;
""
""
"
! "
"
"
"
"
! "
! #%#;< "
"
2 "
!
" ,8,3*,.1
I ;
;
,8,3*,.1 """
;
" ! ; ;
!
,1,1*,.1 "
'
"
"
,1,1*,.1 5
9
" "
! **,:*,.1 "
0 " "" "
" #% # "
;
!< J D(
* */ 33, " " 7 2
"
"" ! "
7"
#%# <""! 0"
0 !
" 7 " (> 7 % "
!
" 7 * */ 33, " " 9 " "
"., +/ ,:," 7 " 7 "
'
" ! ""
! "
2
"$ 9 7"#%# !< A
"
"
! " " *:,.*,.37-,/*,.3 /.,/*,.1E ,-,1*,.1 "" ""
" "
;
;"
,-,1*,.14
A B-6 "
"
"
**,:*,.1 " "
;
; **,:*,.1" ""
5 0 " "
* */ 33, " #% # " ;
<
A
! "
"
! " " /.,/*,.1 .+,8*,.1
;;& *,87*,.1 ! #% # !<
; ;
" ,-,1*,.1 ,-.,*,.1 " " " **,:*,.1 ,/.,*,.1""" ! 2
"
! 5 %
"
#%# !<
" !
"
"
"" 7 !"! "
"
! 5 " "
" "
" "
5 ""
""!
" #%# !<
" *+..*,.1
5 %
" "
*+..*,.14
A B.*6 ! " " " 33: ""33, "
" "
"
" " #%# < ,-,/*,.:
"8* +/ -*37"
,-,/*,.:
*3,**,.: ! ,-,1*,.1""
!
;
;
"
., +/ ,:, " 4
"
6*,.: .+
! " !
!"
"
"
"
! '4' 6 *,.:.+ .:,/*,.: 5 % " 0 " .:,/*,.: ""
" # ;
""
4#;6 (
;
4(;6 (5 !
"
! "'
" "
'""
0 "
"
*.,/*,.:
*-,/*,.:
"
!
" *.,/*,.: *-,/*,.: B 4% " 6 !
" (; (5
! " "
"
"! ,8,.*,.3
"
" ! ' 2
" 7 "
" ,-,3*,.:
;
; "
& ;;*,87*,.1 ,-,3*,.: D
!
"
! "
!
" "!
"" A "!" "" E *,,3*,.:
"
!
., +/ ,:, "
" ""
*,,3*,.: 5 %
! #%# < %
" ""
A
"
"
" = .-K /.,/*,.:
":88 " 5 ,:,1*,.: " *,,3*,.: #% # "
;
!<
""!
! *+,3*,.:
*+,3*,.: "
7> ;! B
"
"
.*8/ "
" ! #%# !< "
"
"
! (7;"
& ..17*,.3 "
"
**,:*,.:
;;+,7*,.:" #%# !< ,-,3*,.:
;
;
.+,-*,.:
"
"""
" ! !
B 2 5 ! ;
! < B
4;6& /*:87*,.1
;
" " /,,/*,.1
;
! "
B"'
! !
4
A B.:6 ""
< B
4;6 & /*:8 *,.1
""" < B
4;6 & 3,,8 *,.1 ! ! "
*+(!,6 !6,'CB62!7 ? .+7 C2+, (!'/,((,:++:! !D /'5 , %!756/,
1+6((7,%&.+%!(( > !,+/. -+6+!% '
*+ ! :! ! , +! !(! /'
4
! , /,((,7
/!+&@/,#%D/&!'&.+%! !.!(!'/,
*+,! %,!+(!+%/6 +++! 6 +01 !/ /!, +!6<=> ?
>% ,,6('C6 @7'6!7 !!+ !67+!!7+/+, ,/,!,,,. ,'% &50;
1+%!+!/%/6 +7'7+!(!. %((,'
/, +.3
D%/.:/: =>%.,,?6,(>%,, C :%, / !6 5B%!#4 +&50;+ (! '!:+=> ?
>%,, +&50;+ 6 ('6 7:++: (!%!+D%/. ++!%6/ + => ?
>%,,+ + +6(,&50;7'6!
*+,! %,+( %+%+, 4,/.7 6'
/.:!% /%/,(!D( !! %% !+ !&@/,&.+%!,% ,' 7 47 /.:!% /%%/, 1+%!+!/%/6 + + ,%+ %%/, 7 47 /.:!- % 7 479 = 6%
7 3=+ ,! '/:++, /'+ !,,!5%7!! %((, (,7,%7+ ! 6% 7 479 = % + :++, 6% : !% +5!,,!70 5%!!!0 %((,7 &!' 6 ! ,!
5B%! # 47 /. + ! !' 6% % ,% %/ ! D%/.,% .+!.D%/. 1++%/
%/6 ++6%!(+,,. !76%, 7 %/! /.+ ,! '/( /-+A%!! ! 7+!!7/ +',+ /% + 6(,/'+(!
1+%!+!/%/6 +,+%.+:+'!
6%+ !, ..+01++!6.D%/.%6/!.
+ / ,! / 7/%:+'!
9+ , %+/, !6!+%!'!+, ..+017 ,6.! !' !!.> ?
>%,, ((.+(7+,! %,+%/6 + 7
/,D%/.:!%((, /':':.6
/, + E++!.6:!
7: + + D% /. %((, :! 6%, 7 ! %/! A%,'66:% /'!! !,70 %((,7&!'7:++( +/. *+ .6
/,:!
%((:% + +!:+!. /, ,' 7 4/,+ /! :++7(7:!% /!76%, 7 %/! :!!D => ?
>%,,: %,'!6 1 +%!+!/%/6 ++!!<=> ?
>%,,@% ! !'%&@/,&.+%!,%+,,..+!D D% /, :+ (%!% ! &@/, &.+ %! ,%7D(/.: % 7 7 47 /.:! % /%%/,:+,+!6.
/.:!% / %/, %/D ! &: !7 %/A%,' + !6./.:!,% %(/, +>%66!
3
+,!
3+ ' +6&50; !.
++ /./% +/.A%:!,'% /6%%! /'=> ?
>%,, 6('C6 /%, !6,,(!. !!('! %/A%,'7+!
(:D,' % :+!,,+.! :! 7 >% 66!7 017 0 &!' &50; (%!% !.'(7!D66 !(!6.
/.:%
F( !.! ,%/67 +&50;+! /-,'(!+('6!(+ D%/.
7 479 =!( 7 47 /.,' + %!! , !(+!6.6%A%
/.7:+++ / 6 . 7 + ,+ %!! %+ /. + . ,,' / %((, /' + 6('7 :+ :++ + (!:,,' 8!.6 +! !%6 + !6' 67 (, ! .! (!'/,6 % 0%!+!7+(!7+%!+ ,! ' ! (!'/,((,, /+,+ (!6! + 6 +6 , ! !( 4
3 ! 6,+!+/%/, +.!%67:!!.!(!'/,
*+!6!+ (!'/,((, +6 6
)*!+!),-.
/%
0 %112 (-D "
E++!(-.=! G=2 E++!(!/, G=2