High Court of Punjab and HaryanaCRR/792/2015allowed

Sunny @ Ajay Sharma & ORS v. State Of Haryana & ANR

2017-03-01Mr. Justice Dr. Shekher Dhawan9 pages

!""#$%$&'( )*&&+ &,$!-. +)/ 01 !/"0% "!$!$&"0% 3"0%*% )! !" 0+ & &!/"0 "%4&,"&!%

0"%"&!'2

0 )$&5/6,7# !"0!/"4"!$!$&"0%

0) 8%/$6,,96 0+ &

0 8"%/ 54 96,7# !"0!/"#149 $& &! :::

/"$&%! &!0"7$%$&4"!$!$&$%,$0"#!", 5 $&%!!/"0,"0, !", 64 %%",;+9" 0&",,,$!$& 9)"%%$&%*,5"6<*0*8%/"!0 $& !"01%=/$#/ & 449$# !$&*&,"0)"#!$&(0 17",;+!/"

40%"#*!$& / % ;""& 99=", &, !/" 4"!$!$&"0% /"0"$& / 7" ;""& %*11&",! #"!0$ 9 % ,,$!$& 9 ##*%",$&# %" >, !", >>?0"5$%!"0",*&,"0)"#!$&%(6?>6?6((6(?626 @ ! 9$#")! !$&6 "/= 6$%!0$#!<*0*8%/"!0 0$" #!%"1 & !$&501!/"49" ,$&5%&0"#0, 0"!/ !!/"

# 1"!;"0"5$%!"0",&!/"#149 $&!)*&&+%&/ 0 !/)$&5/ 0"%$,"&!3$99 5"/ 5 9$&0"9 !$&! &##*00"&#"!/ !!849 #"& >>? &,$&=/$#/$!= % 99"5",!/ !/$%;0!/"0 *0 7/ ,;""& %! ;;",;+&"&$9 *&! &,/ ,;""& %% *9!",;+ &*1;"0!/"0 4"0%&%$&#9*,$&5!/"40"%"&!4"!$!$&"0%149 $& &!/ , %%"0!",!/ !/" &,/$%;0!/"0="0"%!*,"&!%399"5"6 "/= &!/" !"*9 , +$">>?#149 $& &! 9&5=$!/#"0! $&!/"0%="0"%! &,$&5$&!/"

22 7"0 &, /!/"#99"5" &,*4&/" 0$&5 &$%"A% 7"% 7"B/"&!$#", !/ ! &$9 *&! / 7$&5 8&$" $& /$% / &, 9&5 =$!/ #"0! $& !/"0%

$&#9*,$&5 !/" 40"%"&! 4"!$!$&"0% / , %*00*&,", /$% ;0!/"0 /" #149 $& &! 9&5 =$!/ /$% #14 &$&% / 7$&5 40#"",", ! % 7" /$% ;0!/"06&$9 *&!5 7" %! ;;9==$!/!/"8&$"&!/"#/"%! *0 7 =/$9" !/"0% $&9$#!", 9"5 &, $%! ;9=% *0 7 $% %! !", ! / 7" %*##*1;",!/$%$&.*0$"%&!/"% 1"7"0+, + !$7" !!0$;*!",;+!/"

#149 $& &!= %!/ !!/"0"= % 50*4 #!$&;"!=""&%!*,"&!%7$99 5" / 5 9 &,7$99 5") 0% &,$!$%& ##*&!"&1$!+ 1&5%!!/"%"!= 50*4 #!$&%!/ !!/" ##*%",/ ,# *%",!/"," !/ *0 7 &7"%!$5 !$&/ 7$&5;""&# 00$",*!6!/"$& 9#/ 99 &= % 40"%"&!",&9+ 5 $&%!&$9 *&! &,!/"4"!$!$&"0%/"0"$&="0","#9 0", $&&#"&! 449$# !$& *&,"0 )"#!$& ( 0 = % 17", ;+ !/"

40%"#*!$&*4&0"#0,$&5%! !"1"&! C2)*&&+$";0!/"0 ,"#" %", *0 7;"0"!/"0$ 9*0!)*#/ 449$# !$&/ %;""& 99=", $&!"01%!/"$14*5&",0,"0, !", *&%"90!/"4 0!$"%/ 7";""&/" 0, !9"&5!/ )"#!$&(!/","0$1$& 9 0#",*0"0" ,% %*&,"0'2

! "

!! !

#%%&'$$() *+,

!!!

3 /""D!"&!4="0=$!/!/"*0!!%*11&4"0%&%!/"0 !/ &!/" ##*%",*&,"0)"#!$&(!/","0$1$& 9 0#",*0"! %! &,!0$ 9$& 4"&,$&5# %"/ %#1"*40#&%$,"0 !$&;"0"!/" &E;9")*40"1"*0!$& &*1;"0,"#$%$&%&

6$!= %;%"07", %*&,"0' 45

7 # !

! !

" !

9 8 !

#%%&'$$() *+,

. 2 !

6 12

1 43 &

"# $ %&6$!/ ,;""&/"9, %99=%'

! !

! "

7 #

3 & '

()

*#&# $ +6!/"&E;9")*40"1"*0!/"9,!/ !!/"4="0*&,"0 )"#!$&(!/","0$1$& 9 0#",*0"$% ,$%#0"!$& 0+ &, & "D!0 20,$& 0+4="0/"% 1"$%!;""D"0#$%",%4 0$&59+ &,&9+$& !/%"# %"%=/"0"!/"#$0#*1%! &#"%!/"# %"%= 00 &!)*#/4="0$% &!!;""D"0#$%",;"# *%"!/" 5$%!0 !"0!/")"%%$&%*,5"$%!/"

4$&$&!/ !%1"!/"4"0%&F%1 + 9%;"5*$9!+#11$!!$&5!/ ! "&#" &9+=/"0"%!0&5 &,#5"&!"7$,"&#"##*0% 5 $&%!!/"4"0%& 01!/""7$,"&#"9",;"0"!/"*0!!/ !%*#/4="0%/*9,;""D"0#$%", &,&!$& # %* 9 &,# 7 9$"01 &&"0!= % 9%;%"07",!/ !!/*5/ &9+ 40$1 #$"# %"$%!;""%! ;9$%/",01!/""7$,"&#"9",;"0"!/"

#*0!&!&"#"%% 0$9+!"%!",&!/" &7$9#0%%2"D 1$& !$&6$!=*9, 0"G*$0"1*#/%!0&5"0"7$,"&#"!/ &1"0"40; ;$9$!+/$%#149$#$!+/" !"%!!/ !/ %!;" 449$",$%&"=/$#/$%10"!/ &40$1 #$"# %" % "D"0#$%", !!/"!$1"0 1$&5#/ 05"6;*!%/0!% !$% #!$&! & "D!"&!!/ !!/""7$,"&#"6$5"%*&0";*!!",6=*9,9" ,!#&7$#!$&&!/" ;%"&#"%*#/% !$% #!$&6!/"*0!%/*9,0"0 $&01"D"0#$%$&54="0 *&,"0)"#!$&(!/","0$1$& 9 0#",*0" &!/" #!%!/"40"%"&!# %"!/"%! !"1"&! C2)*&&+ 0"#0,",& / %;""&49 #",&0"#0, !&&"D*0"2 ! =*9,;"*%"*9!0"40,*#"!/"% 1"'2 *;;$(.8 <

>-?# - $(,

::3

1 !

1 7 @-07 ! @ #

,@#

?1 #

: @ 7 -1

:@7

< " 5 !

1 !

< " , A

< "

B6 !

8 !

- -

7 @-07 !@ #

#%%&'$$() *+,

C #

?1#

:@7-1

DDD7 E!E - -"

- 8 !

8 >-?

# <

= -!

>-?# -"

5 !

= 7 : %!

" :

E 7

7 %

" : <

" :8 1 %!

< & =

" : A8 1 : 0& %"7

" :

7 " - E 8 ;;$(. ( -,8 ! !

0 !

< "< "

88 8 1 !

8 1

1 !

, A ! -"

! -!

$(( , 8! !

B6 ((F) ,

7 # #!"

A -

22 4"0*% 9!/"%! !"1"&! C2=*9,0"7" 9!/ !/"/ % 0"$!"0 !",/$%$&$!$ 97"0%$&0"9 !$&5!!/"##*00"&#"!/ !!849 #"& >>? $&4*0%* &#"! =/$#/!/" / , ;""& 0"5$%!"0", % 4"0 ,"4%$!$& C2 9"5 &, $%! ;9=% 0" !!0$;*!", ! !/" 40"%"&! 4"!$!$&"0% &,&!/"4"0%&,"#" %", *0 7 &!/"$14*5&",0,"0, !", 64 %%",;+!/"9" 0&", ,,$!$& 9)"%%$&%*,5"6<*0*8%/"!0 6!/",$%#*%%$&=/$9" ##"4!$&5 & 449$# !$&*&,"0)"#!$&(0 $%!!/"99=$&5""#!'2 ' -"

!! !

! !

! 5

7 -07 ! #

7?1#

:007-1

" !!

7 # #

7 -07 !#

, # ?1 7 =

? " ? E! -17 !-1

!! 8 !!

($$()3 & !/" #&%$,"0", 7$"= !/$% *0!6 !/" $14*5&", 0,"0 %*11&$&5!/"40"%"&!4"!$!$&"0% % ,,$!$& 9 ##*%",# &&!%*%! $&$& !/"9$5/!!/"%"!!9",40$&#$49"% &,4 0 1"!"0%9 $,,=&;+!/"&E;9" 4"D *0! $& "D"0#$%" 4="0% *&,"0 )"#!$& ( 0 &, % #0+%! 9$H",$&!/".*,5"1"&!%&!$#",/"0"$& ;7"

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

07"0!",!/ !$&!/" %! 0!"1 "40!!/0""$&.*0$"% / 7";""&%/=&$"&"%! ;=*&, &,!=!/"0%$149"$&.*0$"%$" & ;0 %$&&!/""9;= &, 9 #"0 !$&,*"!4""9$&5!/"& $9 0" 0$1 #$"6!/"$&.*0$"%0"9"#!",$&!/" %! 0!"1 "40! 0"&!#00;0 !

!/"7"0%$&!/"#149 $& &!!/ ! *0 7 ,"#" %",= %;" !"&*4 &, 5$7"&$%! &,9"5;9=%;+>!4"0%&% &0,"0*&,"0)"#!$&(0 $%&!!;"4 %%",&9+ ;"# *%"!/"$0%!$&01 &!0&"!/"=$!&"%%"%%""8%!$149$# !"!/"0 4"0%& %)*$#$"&! &,#5"&!0" %&% 0"0"G*$0",!;"4 %%",;+!/" #*0! % % ! % !$%+ !/" $&50",$"&!% !/" 407$%$& 0 !/"

0"1"&!$&",4*04%"!/"#*0!= %0"G*$0",! 449+%!0$&5"&!!"%!% &, &"!/"%"!"%!% %9 $,,=&$&'

,*# %" %*40 = %!/ !"7"& !/*5/6&9+ 40$1 #$"# %"$%!;""%! ;9$%/",01!/""7$,"&#"9", ;"0"!/"#*0!;*!$!=*9,0"G*$0"1*#/%!0&5"0"7$,"&#"!/ &1"0" 40; ;$9$!+#149$#$!+%*#/4"0%&%%*5/!!;"%*11&", %

22 ,,$!$& 9 ##*%", /$%*0!=*9,/ 7"&/"%$! !$&$&/9,$&5!/ !!/" $14*5&",0,"0, !", 64 %%",;+!/"9" 0&",,,$!$& 9)"%%$&% *,5"6<*0*8%/"!0 ##"4!$&5 & 449$# !$& *&,"0)"#!$& ( 0 %*11&$&5!/"4"!$!$&"0%/"0"$& % ,,$!$& 9 ##*%",6/ %;""&4 %%",$& 0*!$&" &, 1"#/ &$# 9 %/$& &, $& *!!"0,$%0"5 0, !/"%"!!9", 4%$!$&9 =$&0"%4"#!!/"%#4" &, 1;$!4="0%*&,"0)"#!$& (0

0!/"0" %&%0"#0,", ;7"6!/"40"%"&!0"7$%$&4"!$!$&$% 99=", /"$14*5&",0,"0, !", 64 %%", ;+!/"9" 0&", ,,$!$& 9)"%%$&%*,5"6<*0*8%/"!0 6$%%"! %$,"&%"G*"&!$ 99+!/" 0,"00 1$&5#/ 05"% 5 $&%!!/"40"%"&!4"!$!$&"0% % 9%!/"#/ 05"%/""! ;!/, !",? 6 0"G* %/", !!"0$%0"1$!!",; #8!!/"0$ 9 *0!!0"#&%$,"0!/"$%%*"$&!/"9$5/!!/"4 0 1"!"0%9 $,,=&0 "D"0#$%"4="0*&,"0)"#!$&(0 ;+!/"&E;9"4"D*0!$& '

,*# %" %*40 0"%/0,"0;"4 %%",=$!/$& 4"0$, !/0""1&!/%01!/", !"4 %%$&5!/$%0,"0 !"0/" 0$&5!/"4 0!$"% #&#"0&", !$%#9 0$$",!/ !!/",$0"#!$&%#&! $&",$&!/"40"%"&!0,"0 !0"#&%$,"0!/"1 !!"01 +&!;"#&%!0*",!/ !!/$%*0!/ %$& &+ 1 &&"0"D40"%%", &4$&$&=$!/0"5 0,!!/"4"!$!$&"0%$&!/$%4"!$!$&! ;"%*11&", % ,,$!$& 9 ##*%",)*#/ %4"#!$%!;"," 9!;+!/"0$ 9 *0! !!/"%! 5"4 %%$&5!/"0,"0 0"%/ &,&1"0$!%

"!$!$&$%,$%4%", ##0,$&59+

9*#8+ C/"!/"0%4" 8$&5F0" %&",'

"% C/"!/"0 "40! ;9"'