Karan v. State Of Haryana

-1-

 
        

  





     

 





 !"
     

  

####
 
$
%&'

(
)"*



 $
$ '

"+ ,(
))-(


./' &'
"
&0
####

 

!  "#$%&  

'
!
1 ,
*




&
"
'
"
"

"
2 3 
!

"
4
'

5!,
$ &

(
6 *,

7 "56$8(
6"(

+,,
'
"
"

"
  
!

"
4

'
)""  ,

6 "&(
6"(
*"
+''
'
4 ,
!!,



'
! (
+'
+
9 *,

'
1

'
" (
'


4
"1"
"
'
!! ,
'1(
'

,
4
"1"

/'
 

'
!



'



 1
&'
'

"
&*



1 '

'
+ 
+:&

"*

!
*',
4 &
&


; 7 )3
"
'

'
+ 
&&
1
 '

,


'

:
,&
+ '

*:
"
+',
*,,&(

+' 
, 
 
1
1
4'"(
* :
'
*',
"
!!,"
4 :



'

-2- 
"



'
 "
 (
'
 &
4 
 1



+''

 &
4
 1
 
'
+"+
+ '
'
! ,
"
!"
'
+"+
"
!

'
! ,

'
' "
"
'
 '
+
4 
!

'
! ,

'
' "

*:
"
'
:
+ '
*',
,&
+ '
!'(
, !

!
.",,0(
!



+''
'
+
+
)/$(

"
 "
"
" 1 

1  ,
"

!




&
 "
 (5

'
*',

/'
! 
4&

9 *,
!!,"

4 ,
"
 



'
6 *,

. 
"
  

',"0
) (
 2
.
'
< '
)

 2=0
4

'+*(
'
 1
+ 
"1"
*"
"
"

"
2 3 

"
'
!! ,
'1
+ ,
"1"

   > "
 ,

'
! 
'

& "
'


'
!
 (

+ 
;

*"!
?
''

"

"'
5
 94
+'
+
'
(
+'

!
'
!


 (
+
'

*&
! ,

'
'

"

/'
,,&


&  '
!
! 

'

'
+ 1!

 &

'1

8

 '
 41

"
'


+  "

 

"
'
'

,, 
'

, "
4
! "

3 3 
"
'

3
+ 
"


'


4
@ 1"

'
 

8
'


 '
4
41

"
'

'
 ,

,:,


:
1

8

,
 41

"
'

'
1 '



 &
1
8 
+,,

* ,
 

"
'


'
"
4 '
'

*
, "
""
"
'

(
'





:
 

'
1 ' , 
'

,
4
!, "
4
'
, "
 ,

'

! 

'
9 "&1 

'




"""

  
,"

'#$()*+#$, +-.) / $#$0 1#020 ,$,1 34 2-5$(6!  
"""

2 A 
,"

'2#*+#$, /

-3- 3#$ 1#020 ,$,1 34 $#7$-$6 "
AA
"""

 3 
,"

'+0)-2 1#020 ,$,1 34 $#7$-$6
/'

(

'


4
! "
'

'
1!

&"
"
4
 "
"

4
, "

& , 
4 ,
 (
, "
 ,

'

(

 
1
) 8
7'

&+

,(
'


 41

"
'

'
"
!

"
4
'
7 "5 
"

,"
"

"


+ '
, +

8

 '
41

"
'



,
*,*"

 
 '
 
"
'

(
'
"

"*
'


4 ,


> "
 ,



4

'
 "
!
'

41

"
'




4 ,

,,
'
 "
 
  /'

'


' "
'
, "
 ,

'
!


"
! "
'
"

8
'
!
 
'
! 
'



4
 1"

'
B8

$*

!
'
!

(

+ 
;

*"!
?
''

"

"'
5
 94
+'
+
  &
! ,
"



*
'

4

4

"

'
! 

/'
! 
'


4
 "

 
"
'
'

,, 
'


4
! "

'
!
 
"
'



1 

3
!


+ 
"
'
 ,
'





"



"


!!

 '


+ ,"

:
 4

 ,
1
4
'
 ,

, ""


 '
!!

 '


'
!
 (

+

9 *,

'
1

'
" "
'
4 ,
!!,



&*"
4

'
!*

 


'
)

 2  


'
)

 2

!"

"
'4,+

-4-

   

              

         

                       

 


 !"

#$                       

      %
       

            &              &    '

        

  

       (   )                             *+
7
!"&
 '(

+ ,"
4
!


1 :




'
9 "&1 
+''
'

*
4
,"
!
4
'
, "
 ,



/'
,* 
! 

9 "&1
!

"



!

"

'2#*+#$, / 3#$ 1#020 ,$,1 34 $#7$-$6 
!"

"
'4,+

-5- ,
          *-.*"-"-        /           - *-*"-"-      0

 

     

   1234*

  #*- *"-"-5 -" "  #      5 #  .-6    2 
 

 76-! 82
8$ 
5 9  : ;   *       123     < & 5     &   *=0 >=

    &     *0-    ; 5                         


                     0 >=

*? *- *"-"-   -%--
/   0  > =

      =  ;   

          @ 5  & =  ;     4*=3-. 7 6       5   ;5  @&  > @  !

 $      

  ;  5   & 5          & 5           

-6-

        * ;5       &     ;  5                     A @& >@        &      *9              )  &    

   '    

#*- *"-"-* B'''''''''' <       5 " 0"---                )        

               )&         &    '

    

  

          )* B'''''''' 3      2 ?                     

-7- )       ;   5   & 5   123*

 5                 % ,9            "-* -*"-"- ,       )   +*2          503   : 5   5 &   @    5  /                        '           *2           )  0 3   :5   0*+ B''''''''

                      123                   ; 5      ;5 **   A @& > @       0 > =

  -                  


*2  

-8-          ,0+    

 * B''''''''' 0       *-.*"-"-    /      - *-*"-"-   0

              )   E       E: /  E2 F /  *+ )
! ,

'
4* "
 
+ ,"
'+
'

*
+'

'
,,&


&  
'
.- :

?
- 0+ '

'
& *



!!
4,+

'
' "
4 :

'


'
1!,   (


'
+ 
, "

4 ,

)
"


7'

'

+ 
!, "

& 
4 ,


 
. ! 0
,
+'
'
,,&


+ '

'
! 

'
'

"
, "
'
9 

'
' "

'
" "
"

4,"

"
+"
 :
+ 
*"
1

'
,*  ! 

'
 "
9 "&1

!"

"
'4,+

,
                      .*- *"-"

0'
" 

       5 "    G G !

 
 

$ 0 "- . !   ,  0+$       
  /   G G  3  &  -"*-"*"-"

  

-90 5G3  & 

      * 1              3 )1234*"

# "7*-.*"-"-  5"-  -" # 2 
   5 !"$ !$5   5 9!
 0$ 0

 !   ,5  H 59 0+$     0  4      5*:     

 "7*-.*"-"-        * B''''''''' ?

 5                 52   5    )        &                 * 0        

  " *-*"-"-       

-*- *"-"

   '- *-6*"-"

      



  ' *= 

           &       *0  

-10- 

    

 9  * B'''''''' @         )        ' * 5 "    0

       

 
              '       5 " !

$    0                      * 9        '                             

  )  *9 

   

                 3376""-"- D  *5 =   "*-.*"-"-  33 6""-"-  5 )*5 =   -"*-*"-"-* :                 '

         '

  

                &  * /

   

           *2          )     

-11-   '       5  =5 7!

$!$ 0 

 * 9                             * 0 F           .*- *"-"

 
 /  GG 3  &      -"*-"*"-"

     0  5 G3  &    *

               E              E

 G /  EG /  * B''''''''
8
'
!
 (
'
7 "5
'



*
""

'
 '

'
! 
'


4

 "

 
"
'
'

,, 
'

, "
4
,"
"
'
1 
 "

'
!
 

;

*"!
"

"'
"

 
+ 
1!

'

""

/'


'

'
1 '

'
! 

,
 &
1
8 "
* ,

"
'

'


 '
!


:
 

'
 "
1 '

'


'
"
'
4 '





"

'

*
""
'

,

4
""

D
! 1!

(

 
4


"
'


+ ,"
4

4 "
1!



, &"

4 ,

E '
! 
'
 '


+''
'
! 

*,*"(
 
 



'

'

-12- ! 

, "

4 ,

'
 "
 
"

!
'
9 "&1

'
=4,

!1



#+8+-$% 991$% :; 34 
,"
       

              "&

<! 
'


4
',"
'



'
1 

'
 

F  
+''



4
""
!1 ,

""

+' '
'
4 ,


4
&  "

 "

 
4
9 "
1,

'
4 

 " 
'
 '
 

/'
,* 
! 

'
 "
9 "&1

!"

"
'4,+
,0      =                      )*2          

           

         )    *+
!&

*+
'
4* "
 "
 1

(
'
!
*

,,+"
"
'
1!

&"
"
"

"
2 3 
!

"
4
'

5!,
$ &

(
6 *,
6 
7 "(
6"56$8(
6"

+,,
'
"
"

"
  
!

"
4
'
)""  ,

6 "&(
6"(

 "
"


" "


4
, "

4 ,
 49 
'
 '&
4 ,5 
4"

'

 

'
"
 ,


$ &

58,,
$ &



"
 '
 49 
'1

4&
F "


 '
  +*(
 '&


"
4*
'

,,
4
 "

 ,
@!

!

'
1 

'
 
"
'
/ ,

+ ,"

-13- !"
"!" ,

'
4*


1 "

'
!
 
+''


,

'
!

!

"9 "

&
'
!
*
! 


'
1 
*
! 
'


4
"""(
'
!"&
1,,  !!,

(

 (
'

,,


"
"!"


"

 

& 

19,18(1# =! 

"!
E' '
! :&5 "
%5;
E' '
!

4, %5;