High Court of Punjab and HaryanaCWP/16737/2011allowed

Om Parkash v. P.S.E.B. Patiala And ORS

2015-12-14Mr. Justice Arun Palli13 pages

!"##$

% #

!

&! '( &#) &(

)

!

"#" "$%

&" ' #$ %$ $#%& ' ' %++# $, #- #+ %% %+++ . (/

0'1

'

34' !!!5

(' %+,&

(' . (' 6 .(

%

*

" '1 '

' '1

$

' %

( ' ' "

' '( " '' "

" ' '1 "'1 '6 ( 6

"

(/

0'1 3 45 ( 3.( %

5

%9-)- $#%% :"

6 ;( / < ; 4'6 %+9& ( " = ; 4'6 ''

" $###

2'/

""#$ %&

'( ) * #+,

%%+

< '( & - 3.( %> %5

''

* ?&

''

( ('35 ' 35 (" ( ( '1

....

-

"'1

('''

@('> ." '

. ''

' ' "'> ' (' & 35A

(" '( - "'1 "'

." '

. "'1 ''

' 3(5 "'> ' (' 2 '( &

)

< ( (" " ( " "'> ' + %9 "'1 "'1 3 '5 "' ('

(

"

' ("

'' "'1 "'1 4'( %++#

(

?$

(/

0'1

( ''

"35 "'1 "' (' 5 B " +>%9 '

5 B (' "

5B (' %9

) " (

"

. (' "A

( '( 35

" %# #9 %++) '' ?35 B (' " (' "

/ ( >' ''1 ' ( "'> '

( " $, #-

''

(

*

< 4 (" "( '1 ' 4 "'

." '

' ' '(

(' ( '6 ( ' ( '' "

( "'

." ( (" '1

(' , (/

0'1

'

34' !!!5

(' %+,&

( "'

." 1 '' ' @( 1 ' " '( "

(" "'

." ( ''

(' " ( '6 ( 6

('

" (' '"

' + %9 '( "

&

B ' ( '

'"

!

"

(" ' ( '( 3%5 3+5 4'( % (' '' "'> ' + %9 "'1

( @(' ( '( 3-5 "'1 "'

."

''

' "'> ' (' 2 ( '( 3&5

( ''1 4(

' '

1 " ( ( '( - & (' !

6 1

(''1 4'( ' (

6 ' + %9 ( 6

( 1 ( '( 35

35 4'(

! ''1 4'( "'1 '

1 ' + %9

' 6 "( 1 '

('1 " "'1 '(

( ( '( "'

." ( '( & - 4'( % '1 4 3 ' 25

"(' ('

1 '

' "'

."

'

( ('1 ." ( (' 1" ' 1

." 1

"' (' " '

0(''1 "'1 '( "

B 1 ''

" '( " ('

-

" $, #-

+ ' 1 ' .(

3' '1 .( $

%9-)- $#%%5

'1 '' ? (/

0'1 ' "35 "'1 "' :>:

),*>C > 4 %$% + %% ++

''

'' 5 > ( " ( (' " > (' "

/ ( > 1 ''1 ' ( "'> '

5 > > (' %9

5>

' '

' > .

5 35 ( . ('

5

''

'

''

"

% % +9

( /( ( 4

" @( ( 1 '

)

%+->C > 4 %+,, " "

''

" (

*

( "

. 1 "35

''

C ( "'1 (''

C ( . 1'

% , $###

C "'1

''

. '1 ( '(> 35 4'(

1

1 "'1 (' + %9

, '

''

@( " (' ' ( "'1

> ' ( > ' '

' > .

( '( ) $, #- %++# " "

" ''

" ( " '( ( "''1

( 1 ' " (

( '( 35 %++#

'"

$, #- "'1 (' ) > (' %9

"''1 ( '( 35 (' '

(

' ( $, #- " '

" 3( ( '( 35 ('5 ''

. '( %++#

''

( '( 35 '( % $, #-

'

( '( 35 '(

"''1 ( '( 35 '( % 4('

'1 ( '( 35 '(

,

8.

(' ' 1 ('1 ' ) ( " "( 2'/

%99+% $#%% / < ; 4'6 %+-* $##- (('1 ( '' <;4

(' , %+,&

(' 5 = ; 4'6 54' > 5B : 5 ( 3 !!5

"''1 :"

6 ;( %9-)- $#%% / < ; 4'6

#9 #$ %+9&

" = ; 4'6 #$ #$ %+,$ $###

( ( ''

(' "

) ( 4' > B :

( 3 !!5 "

! "' ""

" ) ( "

" 6 ( "'

." "

! '1 ( "'

." 1 '1 ( (

'' " " ( '( 35 '( % $, #-

''1 " (" /

+

!

""

'' %++#

$, #- $###

! ''1 ( :"

6 ;( )# #+ '1 $, #- $###

( 1 '' 4'(

#% #% %++9

%#

! ' ' '( ('

4'(

$, #- "'

." 1 "'1 >

( "1 '' "'> ' + %9 "'1 ( (/

( '( - & 4'( %

C( '' < ; 4'6 ( $, %++, 3.( *

%99+% $#%%5

"'1 "

<;4 =;4 "' &#

1 '" ' @( ''1 ( '( - '

B (

'

%%

2 '( 1 ' ' (" ' '1 D ' '' (' ('

( 6

" $##, :"

6 ;( $##+ 2'/

'

1

:"

6 ;( ' $$-# $#%# 2'/

' $$&- $#%#

/ "(

'

( 6 :"

6 ;( 4( $#%% "' %+,,

''1 '

( " " (

! '

" (

''

( (

( '

1" ''

'

B 1 " ( "

' "'1 ' "(

B ( ' (

' ('1 "(' ''1 "

' ( 1 = ; 4'6 < ; 4'6

%$

4@('1 ''

.( + %9-)- $#%% ' .( , %99+% $#%% #+ $#%# @(

'

''

@('

' "

" "

1

( " ( 4> ' (' ( ' " ''

' ' "' -E (" " (

"

) " "

( "

#% #% $##+ %9-)- $#%% "

#% %# $##+ %99+% $#%%

''

* ( ''

(''1 B (" ' (('1 '1 '" (' $, #-

'

"

''

), " '

.( 9

478 %9-)- $#%% .( &

%99+% $#%%

''

()%)*+), &

* --"./!

0.)