High Court of Punjab and HaryanaCWP/12622/2025dismissed

Pinki v. Haryana Public Service Comission And Others

2025-07-15Mr. Justice Vinod S. Bhardwaj10 pages

#$%$!&'

()( (

' *+ ( , -

!" #"

$%&'#(

%)# * $ & '%&'#(

% )#

# $+ & !+ %&'#(

% )# "*#& , -

,( .

(

**$ (

# $$#+& * -& )# ./0( # $$ 0. 1(* # 1.2 #34

#(#&

! - & ( #

! " 5

**#*

*$ (

$& # %

# $ "$!

$ - &'

$ & -#) "#&&

32433436 71. 28% * & /- " *#& - ./$ ( ' ( #55 #% +"/- " **$ (

#,*

# ! (# &

# #) " ( & &

. )# " *# #) *.

- ( # #) ! (.$ . & 9. '

$ 7&5

' &8 7:#.*8

3 ! (.$ . & ;

5 <$) * 5 % - % *..

# &' 5 #=,343=*./$ "&#243343=%

&0( & 3 &#.$ ** !#/"

$)#)

#(# &

#).$) $$ "9. &.(

# $9.

$ ) (

#*( /& )# "*# #)*.

- ( ##)! (.$ . &9. '

$ 7&5

' &8 7:#.*8 .& &' 5 #=,343= *./$ "& # 243343=/- "! (.$ . &;

5<$) * 5 % - %

& "

& ((#& !$- ./5

& " **$ (

# )# (# &

$9.

$ ) (

#*( /&)# " &*# 1 ( ".>

! " !# $# % & '$ ( & ) & ( ) * # & ' + = &(#.$)#

#./5

#% / !).$$-9.

$ ) &% **$ &)# ** & "<

1 5

# (#&.( &/- " - ./$ (' (#55 #78.& #$$ #44?

#+ &($ &*#' # $$-9.

$ ) & ".$ #) "( ! %/- "*#& 78%./0( #).$) $$5 #) $$# " $ ! / $ - ( ./9. $-% " *

# $# ** & )# 9.

$ ) & " ./0( #+$&! #+'% &. ! " (.

- ' ) (

##) **$ (

#)#5 #& 5

#@$ ! / $ -% "( & &

.+ 0( &/- "*#& )# ")#$$#+ ! #>A

= , $#

& - *% &

& . # /0 1

2334 34435 2!16

&13! 7! ! '$ 8

0#9&1:

3;435 52 6!1 <

&1! # " !# $# % &

'$ ( & ) & ( ) =&

1 !

(

9 + 6 + *( ) ( $$-*#' &&

% "'

- #/0( # # " 0( # #) " ( & &

.% " (#.$& ./5 *

# # "(#5* .

"# - ? ..

" #%

# ./5

$& *

# !

" 1* ( ( ) (

*#& /- " 9.

$ ) &" ("("#$ ") $&#)&'$#*5 #&.( # #

#% ")#% " (#.$& # / "$& $ ! /$ #+'% " &*

#+ & 5 &' & " 5*.!&0( # #&&

&32433436 "#*

'* "#) & ".>

# 1

# $ % & ' ( ''#)* ) +, ,,- .+ ( / ( 0 1 # 2

3 .& 454

(6 1 ,- 0-00+./ (7 (00 1

!1 !

# !9

' + B !! '& "#)% "

+ *

/) $& C &(#.$)#

(& ")#$$#+ !

!.5 > 7 8

#+#& ("("#$ ") $&#) &#

# $& &# "$

&9.

$ -* 5 &+

**# ! (.$ . 1 # )) ( ' & **# 5 $

&3233434"'& &D.

$ - $- (.5! (.$ . 1 # )) (

&* 0 "

& %

&)#5B4?342 #3243343=% #

$ ! * #&#)6- % E5# "% &33& - ")#% " 1* (#.!"

' / (# && 9.

$ )- ! 1* ( 5 #) 9. 5 *( /& " &' 5 ( &' 5 5 &

&#$-) '- #)$'

1* (% )

#@($ 5 ((* &%" #

$1* (+#.$&

5#. #C- %E5# "% &3?& -./5

1* (( ) (

./5

&/-

# #5 / !&#./ &#.*( &F 7 8 "*#& 78"

'# *#(.& -1* #* ## '

# # & 5 +" " " * ( ( $ 1* (

? *#& /- " *

# ! (.$ . (" #

&*0"

& %(""

$ % ( 9.

$ ) " *( /& 1* ( " *#& #55 # ". $$!& # "

' / $- 0( *

#@ ($ 5 /- "#$& !

" 1* ( # 9. '

$ #

#) ! (.$ . (" & 1 #

)) ( *( /& "&' 5 2 &(#.$ ** !#/"

$)#) "*#& - ./$ (' (#55 #7" ) G@8% ** !*..

(# (%./5

"( ).$$-1 5 &

#@ 9.

$ ) (

# " ( ) (

./5

& .**# "#) #55 # (#($.&&

" 1* ( !

& /- " *

&*0"

& % ( &% # "$'

) $& 9. & .& 5 #) " &' 5 ). " ./5

" ( '#$' !& *.

#9. '

$(#)1* (% "5

+ )& # +##(( # # 1* /#&- $- ) ( ' ! ( ) (

)#5

"1* /#&-(#) 5 !

"( & &

& &# *# "9. 1* (%+ " ( & &

.0( &*$ ($ (# 5 $ + *

#% 5$-'8&9-0900/

) # ) %$

! # " 5&' 5 %+" ("+

' 5 ,/00/ "$'

"#) & ".> ->-?

!1 1&###

# @

( & (

&# (!-& &

B &!- (!

&# 1& ( (!&# -#(

&$#

& # - -&&1 *# - & (! & # )&$# 1&# ( ( &&

1& #

&$#&& # &)

& 35AA2 $ 05 & $# (! & # 1 &(

-& &&(!( 1 ) !& &

% & '$ & 1 &$# &(9 &

&&# (

&# ) 1 & & (9 (! # ## # #* 7B& &

&#& & &&

-&&( B ! ( & & # ! ( # & # =& # #

) )

# # -&&

& # ! B 1 ! #

-& & (!

& 1& #

& # !-& # & # (! & # #

"&1 & & & ( * #-&&1&$# ( (! & # -&

& ) # (& =& #

& * ) & (!

& # ( & #

$#=&$#1*# -&$# ((! & # -& - * *1 &

& & $#

% & & '$ 1 -& &

)&# ) 8 $#&

C # 1& - ##& !

& #

& $#

0#&# #

-1& (! & $# & ( -& -&# )&(!( &(

C$# B&# 1 &

&# &(

(!&$#

&&! ( &(

# 1# & &

&# -&##* &# & 1& - &

1-& & (# $#D + & 1

& # ( &&$#

&# .# ! & 1& # & ( -& /B !( ! & $#-& C #

& # .#

&& & &* - && ! # &

8 &.# & & #

$#1 &$#( &# .# 1& # (!&$#

-& ( 1 # & & # ( !

,B&# 1 & &( &(( & &

& &&# !( (! ( # (!&$# @

! (!& &# :. +

2 E &(#.$ ** !#/"

$)#) "*#& - ./$ (' (#55 #78). "./5

1* #* # + #/

&*( ) ( $$-

#@( +$$ + )#5&

" & & # *# " 9. 1* ( " $'

) $& *( ) & " &' 5 ). " (# &

&& # $

#5 $- ' & )#5 " 1* ( ( ) (

./5

& /- *

#)#5 &*0"

& % &<" $1.4

* ! #2E & (

#@1* ( &D.

$ - $- (.5 ! (.$ . 1 # )) (* )#5B4?342 #3243343=% # " ( ) (

#* !#E)#5 " 5#!

#)$( "1* ( * #& 44343 #3243343= 4 "

' "$ &(#.$)# "*( '* &"

' !# "#.!"&#(.5 **&&+ " "* + *

" *

# "

*$ (& (# & /$ $ ( # " 1* ( & D.

$ - $- (.5! (.$ . 1 # )) ( + " &*0"

& % &%(# & !

"*# "9. * ( ( $1* ( ! (.$ . (" & 1 # 9. &/-

"&' 5 3 *( ) ( 9.- + &&& # $ & (#.$ )# *

& !+" " &*0"

& %(""

$ % ).( #& &5 .) ( .#5$- & $ + ./5

& *#

&*0"

& % &#*

&#$$- & $ &"

& /! $ ()# " &*.*##$- = ' "#.!"

5* "

/5 & #&5#

E *

# &' &) 5!

& ! ".

/$'

#)&)# " ) $&% 5#) "(# &&#* #

(#55( $5 !#)& ( # /9.

&+ " ! (.$ . $ (" " #5

$#(#&

# & (

&* 0 "

& % & + !

!& & .) ( . !% !5

# !% # $ !% # - # " ( ) (

( '

- $

# ! (.$ . " *

#@ #$%

/ % '#$'& (#55( $ ( '

#/"

$)#) && $%+" ("&## 5#. ## 9.

! (.$ . $ (" .(" 1* ( 5$- )$(

**$ (

##) ! (.$ . $#+$&!)#5 !*.*# &( # / (# .& $'

! (.$ . $ ("1* ( 6 ;. "5#% " #. "

*' #.$-#/'& "0.&!5

) 7.* 8

" - ./$ (' (#55 #78 &#.!"

1* #* ## +##(( # # "( & &

+"# 9.

$ ) & "1 5

#/.

+)#.& $ ! /$ "1* *# (#($.&&

#& &# 5 "$ ! / $ -( #)1* ( )# "*# $#+$$

/$ "& $ +

+" & *.

(#( ! "9. '

$(#) ( & &

@$ ! / $ -% "#* ##) 5*$#-#(#5* .

"# -

$& # !

+ !"

&*)( #' "( & &

@#+ # ? ;# " #! ' /#' !& "0.&!5 * &/- " #.

) . 1(&## ) &

" - $$!

$ -% 5*#* -% *' - # / ( # #) *#& 78 "#$& ! " *

# $ ! /$ )# " *# #) *.

- ( ##)! (.$ . &9. '

$ 7&5

' &8:#.* B #!#.& 5 &#.

)# - )(/- " #.

"* ( C

"* + *

# ((#& !$-& 5 & 123 .

(

4!4

E&&#*C ,C@ E&&# ( ,C@