Cholamandalam General Ins.Co.Ltd. v. Jasbir Singh & ORS.
! "#$# %& ' ( ) %* ) % + (%$,+ %" )- %./ *0 000000-- ((
1$0 $2#+3#%4' %* ' + 000000 $- %* % & 5/ 30 33 3
!" #
%&'
()& !" #
)) *% + !" #
,- + !" # ! 3 0 /
)
2' &!
!!
'' 0! -#' 3 ##'! +)'1 ('/0) ,)!%
% 4% ('/0)4 &%'
$!
)'/')'
' #)'1 0 5 6 ) 2 ' 8
01 3 3 /'$ $#
3 ,/' -'2%
)) 2 '2 ,)!% !1 0 &%') !'"'2 ! 1 +#) . 9 :
; 01' -'2%
'))' '! / 0 <3
1 &% % #%!
"'))2 ='
0 ,)!%> %' 0
5 ! 1 ##) 0#
2' # )) 9 % ##0 1 ##) 0$$!
10)'
) '1 ) 2'" 0 '?0' 0'!
$#0 / %
? ' $#0 )$ $10 /'! $#0 1!'/) 0)'2 '2 % % > ')'
> ') !1 0 &% $!
+'"') > ') !1 0 (% $!
, %) > ') ,)!% (#'
)'!
!
) %" '!
/ %
? '
')'2 )$ $10 1'!
# $'!
/!
/#0 ##'! 3 @ '#
''
& $$!'2 "%'#)
!
&' 1 !'2 $#01 ' 6##'!
< 1
)!'2
' $1!
$ )) &'2 '0
!"#
$
"#& !$ %
$ "#& ' ( ) (
"#& +,)
) "# &
$ '2 ' # '!'
)!'2 # ! &!!
' #)'1 > &" )'/')'
' $!
33 3 / 3/3
3
:!
# 0)
# ! '#
'' 0! -#' 3 A%'#) # '?0!6#)'1 1 % 5< 6
01 %$ ')!
' (%$
) / )) &!
/ '! ; # # 0) ! 20 )' # !
'' )) &! (%$
!'1')
) * %" %!
# 0)
'
0!
&% ) # !
# )"
' !0#!
0! ',
$ %
% $$
- ! . /
% %, %
0$ )$
* ( - ./
1 %$(
$$
)
* ( ,2 $$
&+3 ) $
*% * ( 4-5
$ * $$6
& 3
<
$ %
) * 6$
$$
5 % - *2 7)(2 0$ * ( ) ( %
$$
$ )
7$
$ 21
$ $ 6$ % 4 - 5
6 ( 6 ** 21 ( )
2 $$
& +23) 6$
+
, $$
) *
&+3)
)0
) .3 ( 8$ $$
( ) * *, 9 ( 0 *
(
* * *
1 % * ( *( 21
& +3
) *
) *
% *
% & +3$ 6
%
1 $$
* ) * $
&+3$ :$ ( ) * 2
$$
;+<) ,2 $$
) %
&+6 6+&=23)
$ $
%
2
>
0) / " ") !0) # '!!
1') # !
%)!
')!
' )% 02% !
'1 ##'! '2 5 6
1 % )#'#' 6 ." C ' ! #01 # / '" )!
0/' #)'1 * /# ) )'
'1 ) '1 1 ) !'!
) )) )$"'2 1 !
%' 1 %) 5 6 !') &2 )/ 060 '))!
)/ 0 * &)))!
'#'
) )& %)!
%' + 0 ')!
% B' 2) !#
#)'1 %' '" B22 !
%'2% ' (%' + 0 %$ 1 %'=!
#' /'2 1 )'/) ' /# ' ) !'"!
1''101 &2 1 )" B# 1 !0# 0! ?13.
The claim petitions are drafted by the Advocates and it is standard practice to state the maximum earnings and amount of compensation in the pleadings. The Court/Tribunal should appreciate the evidence led on oath, rather than strictly adhering to the pleadings. The present claim petition was dismissed solely on the stated earning of Rs.6,000/- in the pleadings, completely discarding the evidence presented. This indicates a manifest failure to apply judicial mind. Therefore, the present appeal is allowed. The appellant/claimant is granted
compensation under Section 163-A by taking his income to be Rs.3,000/- per month. > 0% ' ' )& /# # 2 )'/) 2!'2 #)'1 + 0 1 /!
1''101 &2
)'#/) 0 '))!
1' '))!
)/ 0 1 / *
# ('/0) )'2 %'
'#'
) !
1 %) 5 6 3 * "'& / " !'#0' &)) !
$'!'2 ('/0) %' + 0 $'! 2 0!
'$ 1 %/ %)!
< + D0)
) /'2 !" '!
1' ! !'1'! T% *0# %/ !'#!
!'/0 #0 #%!0)!
$ %&'
()& !" # &'%'
' !
! ! #'
# %' ! "'& ! !!
; <
; %' + 0
!'2
)'#' '$ ) !
!' !
$ 3 3
' E%% '26 ! F
.
E%% /) F
.