Randhir Singh v. State Of Haryana And Others
!" "#$%$&' ( )'* +), -
! "
# $
- . %
& ' (
" ) * +,-.++/%,
(( ! ( ( "" 0 " +% +/%1 )
* +,-.++/%, "
! ( !
!
! ""( 2
" ! (2 "" .3-4 & )
! 5 ( )! (
( ! ( )( 5 ( )+//3 &( ! 5 " ! " "
( ! " " ( !
" 5 ( ( !
" 5 ( 2( "
!
+ &"(
" !
! ( ( ( !
" +3 %3-1 /% +//%
! +3 %3-1 !
" " %.-7%.37,+,7,+.,/8& )
6
,/8! ,/+ & )
6 ! %.-7%.37,/+& )( 9
0! : ( /- %3-1 6 ! ( ) ( ( )( !!
( ) ! 5
' ) /+ +//% !4
!
" "
#
"
$
% & ,
! (
"( !
(
;
( ( (< 5( ;( (< ! 5 ( " ( (
& "= " 9 %3 +/%/ ( # > : 0! 2 (
! ! ( : !
!
? 4 '
$
%
( $
)
& .
6 " ' ) ( "! " 4 " !
" " !( '
6 ! (
" ( 5! ! ( ?! ""
> # "
! 6 &
@
&"( A ( ++ +//+ ( ) * 18-@+//+ )" ! ( # > A (+% +//+ A (++ +//+ " !
/+ +//%B ' )C
! ( !
/+ +//%( " +3 %3-1 /% +//%
( :
# > # > : 0!( "
"$ "
"
"
+3 %3-1 /% +//% &! ! ! !
" ) * 18-@+//+!
! A "
A0 " '
%3 +/%/ B ? 4,C " 5 B ? 4.C! !
5 "
A0 5
( !
( ! ( 8 1 ! 8 , '( ) "
% % (
) 5 ! " !! !
"
!
!
( A0 " ! ( 9%3 +/%/
? 4+ " ( 8 1 8 ,
( !( # > : 0! 6 8 , 8 1 ! ) ' ' )' 6 6 >
$' > 0 &%338 )%-/+ ""B "C B%33@C3 )),@ D& 9 &+//. )%//1 0 D& B+//1C- ))8.8 ! ! 5 ! " ( !
" ( " ( !
!( " "
-
6 5 "
!
" 5( !
" (
"
( ( " ( "" ( ( A&" ! ( "
"
"
!( !
!
"
""
! $ "
( ( ! ! !!
" " 6 ' " (
" ('
"
6 "
8 ,8 1 ) 8 , ' " ! "
! $ "
"
(
!
"
! 8 1 !
"
%/
:
6 " ( 9
0!: ( /- %3-1 !(
( " " (" " ! "
"
!! ! "
( ! ( "
( !
! ! ! ( : ( " !
( ! ' "
!!
! " 5(( 5 ( !
+3 %3-1 /% +//% (
! " "
%%
6 '( )
"
% % ( "( 8 % , 8 1 ) ! ! 4 *
$+,- ,. $/ $-0 $11,$- * ,- 2*3,4$1,20 3
$1
+
7
$11,$- * 0#2-7*2,0,. # *- ,- 896:$7
;
9 :
9 : 7
'
9 :$
%
7
'
;
%
;'
9 :
<=
7
9 :
<=
/
7
9 :+
9 :9 :
9:$
7
"
98:- ' 96: 7
;
7
%
%
& $11,$- * ,-2*- +$+*3*-+ >96: 7
!
'
9:
7
)
9:
98: 96: 7
" 7
;
9>: 7
;
'
98: ' 9>: "
5
9?: ' 98:
9<: ' 9>:
;
7
! 7
< $
7
!
9
2 5 8:
!
"
$"
% 9
!
:
(
" @ %+
&) * %,+@+/%, ,/ +/%1 "
'
""= !! ( ( ? 4 ;# 2 5 67
2 5 8
2 5 >9 :
7
2 9 : 2 5 >
7
2 9 :2 5 >
2 9 :
2 5 <
7
%
(
" & %,
&0")$ D& &%3-. ),-/ )! ! ( 4 A
%
% %
%
%
"
>)?
+ C
& %.
&C B C )( "
,/+& ) ! ! !! ( (
!
"
! "
&! 4
%
, D
%
%
!
!
%
+
!
!
+
+
!
%
!
@ %1
" ! "
!
! ""
""
! "
(
" ( !
' #"! 5
%@
6
) %3--
)
" (( " ( (
( ( (( !
!
! "
!
! "
" ( ! (
" ( ( ( ! " (
( ?
! ! " ""
! ( !
"( ?
(
?" ! %8
&
"
?! ( ""
" ( !
)
) 0 !
6 ' ( " " ) " ! "!
! "( ( !
" !
%-
! (
"! " " ( "(
( !( ! ( "
! ,%%B+CBC )& 0! ! "
"! "
"
! " 5 ! ( "?
( "
! !
"
! ( !
( ( " &
" !
( ) ) ! " ! 5 ( ) !!" ' %3
6 ) ! 5 ( "
6 ( ( (
( ! ( "
( 0& "!" "
( !
( 9
)) * %-.8+//3 2 B
9/-
+/%. ( ! 5
" ")( ! )'
( " '
" +/
) !
! "
!
( ! ( 6 ( !
( " "
( ( 2 " " +! C E 7
+%
( !"
! >? 5 ( ( (!( !
"
"( " " ! " ! ! ! " ( !
"
! "
! ( ) & " " 5 & $ "
" ( " ( !
! ( ! " " ( ! "
$ "
( E 0
( "( ) "" ) ' ( " ! ! ' ! " !
6 "
( "" ! ( 5
!
! ;! <""
! ( (
"
! ! """! "
& " ! " ( (( (
( " ! ! " "
"
( ' ( " 8 ,8 1 ( ? ( "( !
( ( ! ( ! ! ( " ( (
! ( ) #
6) " !
%33.B+C 9@-%B )C ) " !"
'( ++
&!
( ! "
! " !(
+,
&" !
( ( ' !(
4B%C ) * %,88+/%1 - B C
0! E " 4 - 1 +8 /8 +/%@FB+C) * +@.,1+/%. B
+ %- /1 +/%1FB,C) * .+,3+/%% "0
%@ /1 +/%+F B.C E
* %1-/ +/%% 3 ,
0! E " 4 - -
307 %/ /+ +/%+FB1C ) * @%,%+/%+
"
%+ /3 +/%,FB@C ) * 1++-+/%% !
+ " +1 /, +/%,FB8C)
/ * @@@,+/%+
/% %+ +/%1FB-C) * ..@1+/%1 2
- 1 /+ /, +/%@) * 3%,3+/%1 0 $ B 2
%.
/% +/%@ & " "(!
" !
" +.
&" & ! " ( !
"
! ( (
('
" "
%.-7%.3 +/, ! %.3 ,/8!
"" " G ,/+ & )H "( !
( ! " (" "
50( +/%.B,C ) .1% ( ( = ; < ( ( !( !
& %% & ( !4 66
"
(
!
+
F 7
"
%
+
%
+
) 7
& +1
9$"
) 9+% +/%@ " "' E
* 1%.+/%.!" %,
+/%. E B) C* ,+8@@+/%. (0( ! '
#
"( /- +/%.( ) & " ! ( &""
"( "
" "
#
"( +/%+
+@
"
+8
( " " ( ! " " ( ( >?4 ) #" & # "
6 ( ! 5 "
+-
&! !
( ! " A&* +. : ( +, +//+ ! ,/8 .3-4 1/@
& ) ! "9+- +//,: ( ++
+//, ! ( 9
A6
) ""
' : ( %1 +//.
! : ( /1
+//.* "( %@ +//1 #"!
* "( %8 +//1 E ( 2 " )
"( %8 +//3 : 5 ! +.
+/%/( #
"( %/ +/%/ " 17%+ %% +/%+ " = +,%. !('
"
!
" 6 "
+3
(" ( !" " " (
5 !(
( ! (
# 0 ) B
#E4-1 +//1B%C )618@ ! ( "
" ( ( ? !
!
( " ( " ! !( "
& # 0 ' )E
* %@@/+/%%
* "( %8 +/%% "" ( !
B ! 5
87%,
) %3--! ! ( * "
# 0 !
,/
BC
+83,,- & )! ! "
6 ! !
" ! ! ( !
" !( ( * ! ( ! " ) 8 % 1 '() "
% % 9
"!
!" " 2 5
! !
9
!
!
" 5
" (
! ( !! !
!( (
0 ! !
! ( !
"
" ,%
2 ( ! " " !
! 5 ! ! ! ,%%BC) "
? "
! " ! ! " " ( !
" ! ! %3-1 ""
!
( " 6 !" +3 %3-1 /% +//%! (
( ! ( 2 ( ( ! " ! ""
"
" ( ( ! ( 5 5 " ( ""! !4 - !
8G 8==>88 6= 8==> 98AG:
6< 6= 8==?6A 8==< ''
9>HA:
>
65 8==<8> < 8=6= 96A?G:
0
+I8>6?& ,+
,%% B+C BC " ! (
"
(!( ! ( !
! !! "! "
"
!
! " "
"
( !
'
" !( "
"
)D& 0 B%338C. )),-1 5 " (
& "
' '"*
&:)E
B+//1C8 ))8@.6 * )
) E
( B+//@C+ ))+11( !
! ( ?" (
,,
& "!" ( .3-4
! ( "
& ! ! (( ' ! ! 5 !" "
( " ( !
! ( ( ( * ( "
!!
) ( ! 5 5(
5 * 5!
?"
"
"
('
! ! '
,.
&" (!(" " "
( ( 0
" "
( E ( ( " 2(
,1
A &"
( !" ,@
( " !
0 - ( "' 7 I ( I