High Court of Punjab and HaryanaCRM-M/6713/2018allowed

Sukhvir Singh v. State Of Punjab

2018-05-02Mr. Justice Avneesh Jhingan13 pages

! "

# " "

"%&'(

)

+ ,* -./01 2/

))) %$$%1 3%1'-'

$ -4 )))%'6%$

+ ,* 9%%6 2/ :

55-

)))669& $ 3%1'-'

$ -4

;%'6%$

1%'%$( 1) $%161%%$ 2/< 0& $%< 6%$$%1)

))

< 0& $%<

669& $ $) ') .

9$ < " < -4 5) ))) = $/%'% $> '%'

*< &9-55% $2%$/%1 /% 12< 0%> &$ &88

12-8%$'

'%< '89 &1&-8'$ &%'<

>/%$/%1

&$< ?

< -9= &869%

11%'$2 &%1 % &/ '%< $)

6%$$ 9% @?

1) ))< '%%.2 &&%'' 9 6%$$%1< &2 $1

99%2%

&88''

%&%'

6-'/

&$< ?

< >/%1%

669& $

'%%.2 '-'6%' '%$%&% 861'8%$

$%1 /% &0&$% &88''

%&% 6-'/ &$

02 '%$%&% -%12 121-'

861'8%$

=% 1'<

% ') <

9' 86'% -6 /8< % -9$ =8%$ >/&/ /% -%12 121-'

861'8%$

-1$/%1 6%1

8$/')

66%

8$$% 1%2-9 /% 12 0%

1%1 $%

@) ) /%1% $%1<

669& $ '%%.2 '-'6%' '%$%&% + * 9%)

) /% &88

12-8%$ % 1) $%161%%$ 2/< 9% 1% &-'%9

66% 12 6%$$%1

))

< 9% 1% &-'%9

66% 12

669& $ &18

66% 9< $/-2/ &'%$ 8%8'

'/> '2% 5$/

&&-'%

$8% $/%1

11%'$ + >/99= -1%9% $% '%'<

1'%'

-$ ) @ $% ) < 1%2'$%1%

9&% $ $ < "'$1&$ 7/ < >/%1%

1'% -$ 12 $2 ) ?

$% ) ) < 1%2'$%1%

9&% $ $ $=< '/ /1< 1*<

$%1 $/%=

'$ $% 1%6'% $/ &%1'

11%'$2 $/%8<

$%1

%1 % $/%8 $/%=

12/$ 1&/%

&%1A $%< />%0%1< %0% '-&%$ &869 &%

&$<

6%1 $ 4-28%$

'$$-$ %&/ -61%8% -1$<

!! "#$!"% 0') &&%'(# & + * ?) @) $/ 9% 1% &-'%9 '6%&& 99= 6$ 99>2

6/'

4-28%$( ) C% '/ > % $> %&''< 1%%11% 1%%11 1%1< >/%1% D'-5'$ $ &869 &%D 1%E-1%8%$ %85%

&$ /%9 '-&%$) 5/ / .

"-5%= +'-61 *<

$> !-2% 5%&/ &-99% -$ $ 9%0 2/F'

+'-61 *< ''-% -'<

99>'

( D))))C/ &%1 &&%1% 1%E-1% &0%=

5-$ &/&%

&&-'% ') /%

&&-'% +'-'6%&$* $9

= /% 5%&8%'

&/&%

&%1 &&%1%< %0% $/-2/ $/%1% '6%&& 18) /% -'% >1 D12/$D

1%9%0 &%'

%&' 9%0 2/ '%%8'

= %%&$0% %86/ ''

&% &%1 &/&% 20% 81% =

12/$ D'-'6%&$D

'$ 2% 20% '-&/

&/&%

%0$ &'%E-%&%'

99> $1 '21%''2 $)D >%0%1< >/9% -22 >/%$/%1 '$ $% 1%E-1%8%$'

8%$ &$'

'%< 2 '89 1$= $-1% %0%&%

'6%&$ 5%$>%%

!'%6/ %1 %B +'-61 *< &/'% 99> 0%>'

%&/% $$%1 '%< >/%1% /%9 1&/2 &%1F'

18 $ '-'6%&$ %%&$ D =- >'/ =- = 1&/%

&%1

$%D '-5'$ $ &869 &% 1%E-1%8%$

&$) %0%1$/%9%''< & $% ' -'% %G61%'' D'-5'$ $ &869 &%D 99>2 >1'

( D ) /% -'% %G61%'' D'-5'$ $ &869 &%D % &.21- 1&/2 &%1

- % $%161%$ $ &% '$$-$ %&/ 9%0 2/ '%) 9%

4-28%$ $ '9 $

$%161%$2

'$ $-$1= 610'< 86-$%

%1%$ 8% 2 5'%10 $')D $ %'$

1%%G$1 &$% 6/ !'%6/ %1 %B %'

$&% $ 9%0 2/

/ .

"-5%= < !'%6/ %1 %B 99>% 212 &$-8 >

9%0 2/F'

'%) ?) 0%> 1%22 '&-''< >%

18 6 54%&$ >/&/ 12/$ +* &$< =

%21< &%11% '-'6%&$< 0B) &/%&.

8'-'% 6>%1<

0 &%$ 6%1''

88'%

99%2 $'

$2 '$2 9'% '%'

%1&%8%$

2%&%'< >-9 86%1 $0% 1$ %86>%1% &%1

661'% 6%1' $%% 1&/% 12/$ 1&/%

&%1

$%) C% /%'$ $ /92 '

592 $

-$/1'% &%1 '-5'%&$ +*

&$ &&%1%< $1=

1%E-1%'

'$1&$ &869 &%)

9-1% &869= 610' >-9 1%%1 1%&0%1= 99&$

1$&9% '-'6%&$

0$ &0&$ 8% 1%&1% 9= ''

1%&0%1= 99&$

1$&9% 6%1'

&&-'% -12 '-&/ 1&/) /%1% $%1< '-'6%&$ = = &/'% %G%1&'% 12/$ 610% /8 610')

5'%10%

))) $ -$= &-1$'

2%$

$%$ H%2'9 $-1% 1%-99=

$$%2 >/9% '&6% 610' &'$1-%) D/% .%= 6%2 %0%1= '

'61$ ><

8-'

86%$'< $%$ .%1 %G61%''% $'%9< .%

>/9%)D

) C%

6 &&%6$ D'-5'$ $ &869 &%D 1%E-1%8%$

&$ $1-&%

$ !'%6/ %1 %B

/ .

"-5%= %$/%1 51% -$ 22% '-5'%&$ +*

1 &' &%

&$-8 > 9%0 2/F'

'%) %%9%''

E-%'$ >/%$/%1 61&%-1% 61%'&15% 99>%

1%E-1%8%$

8%$<

$$%1 $1 9) $ >-9 %$/%1 6''59% 1 % '59% = >

5'9-$% 18-9

5%/ 9)

)C%

9' %%9 $/-2/

20%'

6$ %86>%1% &%1 .% '-&/ 6%1' +'-'6%&$* %$/%1 % 1%'$ &%1 1%1 86 1$

-$/%$&$=< $1 '6 1%&=

&1%$>1$/%''

%$1% 61&%%2'< 1'$ '$ &%<

%% 0-1 '/-9 61-&% '-'6%&$ % 1%'$ $%< %4='

81% &%&% &88 &86 1%

= $/%1 &%1) $ >-9 9=

9%2$8 &= 1&/ 61&%%2'< = 0%19= '$1%2$/% 61'%&-$

>%99) ) &&129=< >%

'>%1 1%%1%&% %1

1%'

) /%

66% 9'

'/ 99< >< &%

66161 %&/ '6'

9)I

! "

# ) 1)

< 9% 1% &-'%9

669& $

66% 9< -1$/%1 1%9% -6

$/%1 4-28%$ -61%8%

! # $ % #&'

()& $ & ()" *

+, J )

$ 61'%&-$

>/&/ -

&&%6$ &% $> -1$'

5%9> '&%

+ &&-'%*

661'% 12/$ 1&/% %$/%1

&%1 %'6$% $%992 /8

5-$ 9%2 12/$

9 /8

1%9 $ 1&/<

+ &&-'%* &'%$ >1$2 1&/% 69&% & 9'

+1 2 1$=*< $> -1$'

5%9> 8%

&&9-' 1%E-1%8%$'

'$ -99= &869%

/%&%

9 &0&$% %&% 6-'/ &$) ) C%

21%% 2 $> -1$'

5%9>

'< -1 6<

1&/

1%&0%1= %

99%2% &$1 J/ 'I %'

$'= $1= 1%E-1%8%$'

/%9

34 ='/ / -5/ !

+'-61 *) /'

>% = 99>2 '')

1'$<

8$$% &$ %8%122 1%&1

61-&%

&%1K %&<

8$$% &$ -%

1%8%$% 1'$ '< 1&/

1%&0%1= &$1 J/ 'I %

&%1K /1<

8$$% &$ % 69&% & 9'

2 1$=< 1%&0%1% &$1 J/ 'I /8<

&%1

1 $/%= &-9

< $/%1%1%< $/%= >%1% %86>%1% .% 1&/

1%&0%1=

&$1 J/ 'I

610%

&$ %G&%6$ %$/%1

&%1K -1$/< 1%1 .% 1&/

1%&0%1= &$1

1$&9%'

5= '-'6%&$< 1&/

1%&0%1=

&18$= 1%E-1%8%$'

&$) $ '< $/%1%1%< $1= 61'%&-$ 610% 1&/

1%&0%1= %

&%1)

/-2/< 61'%&-$ %G 8%

0% 69&% & 9'

+ C C* 2 69&% 1$= % $/%8 %6'% 1&/A1%&0%1= %

&%1)

1%8%$% ''< >%

&'%1% 6 61'%&-$

610% 1&/

1%&0%1= &$1 +/ '* %

&&1 &% 61&%-1% 61%'&15%

&$) &% &869 &% $1= 61&%-1% 61%'&15%

&$ 61'%&-$

< '%< >% - 61'%&-$ 9% 610% &869 &%

1%E-1% ><

%$$9% &9 8 $'

5%%$ '%%.

&E-$$ 9)

) 92/$ 1%22 '&-''<

66% '-&&%%'

99>%) 86-2% 4-28%$ '%$

'%) '

&'%E-%&% $/%1%<

$F'

&0&$ '%$

&E-$$% &/ 12%'

E-%'$)

- .(

1# 2# 3

4 5

6$/ 3

4 7

- 5 8

97 :6

;

# '-661$ /%1

12-8%$'< '/%

9' 1%%1'

%4 'F +'-61 *< +'6%&& 99= 6/'

< ?

*< '-58$ 9= 6%1' 1&/% ' 1%E-1%'

/%A'/% 61-&%

&%1

$%< %&%''

11%'$2A%$ 2 &%1 'K '-'6%&$ &'%$'

%$ 2 &%1 /8'%9 1&/2 /%1A/8)

/% -1$/%1 '-58$'

%0%

&$- 99= 1%E-1%'

%1 %

61-&$ '-'6%&$

&%1

>-9 9= -6 '-'6%&$ =2 ')

) H% 1% $ &-'%9

9' '%

12-8%$ 1%&0%1= 99&$

1$&9% >-9 '-'6%&$ 9= &0&$

&&-'% %0%$- 99= 1%&1% 9= ''

1%&0%1= -12 1&/< $/%1 &1151 $0% %0%&%< >/%1% 61%'%$ '%<

9% '$

66% 9<

669& $

91% = '$ '

&0&$%< 1-'

21-'

20%

66% 9K

1%2 1'

6%$$%1 '%%.'

9 -12 $1 9< $1 >-9 -9=

%0%&%

&E-$ &0&$ /8)

1%2 1'

6%$$%1< '/% '-58$'

$/%1%

$/%1 1%2'$%1%

'$ /8 $ 1= <

99%22 $/%1% &88''

%&% 6-'/ &$)

99=< '/% '-58$'

1-2 8% &% 5%2 $ -4 5< >-9 %''$ $2 9 $1

'-'6%2 '%$%&%

669& $< &0&$%)

02 &'%1% 10 &$%$'< 6-16'% 9

669& $

669& $ '%%.2 '-'6%' '%$%&%< $/-2/ 9% 1% $ &-'%9 = &11%&$ '-58$$2

%0%&% >/&/

'% &0&$

= 6%1'< />%0%1< >/

9% '$ 6-16'% 9A'-'6%' '%$%&%< $ 21%< $/-2/ &$ --5$%9=

'$ $-$% 0%1= 8-&/ %%% $1=

&-15 8% &% -'% $G& 1-2'

5%&82 '&%$=< 6''59= 9% 2 $/%1 &18%'

9'<

6-'/8%$'

610% &$< 1-'

%&%'<

9' 0%1= '$12%$< />%0%1<

5'%10% -61%8% !

%4 'F +'-61 * + $8% $8%*< &869 &% $1= 610''

'-&/

&$< %'-1% 8'-'%<

5'9-$%9= %''%$ 1$ 61'%&-$2

2%&%')

?) 2 1%6% $< --5$%9=<

6%1 '

1%2'$%1% % &/ $/%'% $> '%'

+>/99= '%6 $%9=*<

&&-'%

'/> '2% &'%$ 8%8'

%%&$ $/%= >'/ 61-&% %$/%1

&%1

= 1&/% %$ 2 &%1 /8'%9) #%$<

--5$%9=< '29%

&&-'% % &/

91% = %$ % 69&% 1$%'

&&%1% + % &/ '%*

'-&/ $/%= >-9

66%

= '

661%/% $/%= >-9 %'& 6%< = 69&% & 9'

61%'%$< &$% %$ % $/%8)

&$%G$< >-9 %&%''

1= 1%%1 &$'

% &/ '%6 $%9= %0% 6-16'% 9A'-'6%' '%$%&%<

'%6 1%1 02 ''% % &/ '%)

))*+,-)./,0 '%< 6%$$%1 '$ $% &82 $ >/% /% '%%

69&% 1$= &''$2 %

$> % '$ 59%'< '$66% /8

%E-1%

5-$ 1$&-9 1'<

$/%1% $%1 18% /8 >'/ 1&/ /8< /% &-9

9' 6$ 2%$ 1&/ &-&$%

&%1) /%1% $%1< 6%$$%1 02

21%%

1&/ <

&'%$ 8%8 02 '/> '2%

1&/ &-&$%< 8'

$G& 6>%1

'$ $% -

69=$/%% $1-'%1 6&.%$ 6%$$%1)

) 6 -1$< 1'$9=< 6%$$%1

91% = 02 %$ % $/1%% 69&%8%< $/%1% >-9 ' /8 61-&%

$%)

%&9=< >/%$/%1 &'%$ 8%8 '2% -1%''

&$- 99= 09-$ 19=< >-9 %% '%% $1 -1$<

$/%1 %0%&%K

$/%1%1%< .%%62 0%> $ 4-28%$ '$$-$ %&/ "%

+'-61 *< %%&$ J

9' 8 !"

- .( $

# '%E-%$9=< 6%$$%1 < )%) -./01 2/< '/ 1%9% '% 9 -6 /8 -1'/2

%E- 9

'-1%$= 5'

$' &$ 9% 1% $1 -1$)

)+/,-)./,0 )),1//) )./,+ )

9'<

6%1 61'%&-$< >/% "

$/%1 69&% & 9'

>%1% $1 0%992

610 0%/&9% $/1-2/ 099 2% 7-9

5-$

(

6)8)< $1992 -$=<

669& $ '$ $% '%% &82

8$1&=&9% $/%1 '%<

'%%2 69&% 1$=< /% 2$ 6%169%G%

$1% $-1 8$1&=&9%

1-K 61&%''< 8$1&=&9% 2$ '>$&/% < 69&% 1$= $/%1% $%1 02

661%/%% /8) /% '$ $% '&9'% %$$=

$9 /8 /% '-'6%&$% /% 11=2 &$1

>'/% 1&/ /8< $/-2/ /%

9%2 12/$ 2%$ 1&/ &-&$%

&%1

$%) /%

669& $ '$ $% 0%<

9'< 1%6'% &%&% <

&'%$ '$ $%8%$ '2% /8 %%&$<

$%1 >/&/ /% 1&/%<

J$G& $2 $%1 9I >%2/2

'$ $% 1%&0%1% %1 6&.%$ + < $')

) 2 < 1%%1%&% >/ /%9 "%

(

)>#('#()

() )( ('

# ?

# )># <

@ - A

- - %

# GGGG

) %1% 1$2 1%1 $/%'%

'%'< &'%1%

66161 5'%10% 50-'9=

-99=

90% &$ 1-2 8% &% $ &-15%K >/%$/%1

&$- 99=

$/'% -922 9% 1-2'

5%2

661%/%%< '8%

9= 6%$$= $/%0%'

+ 6''59= $/%1'*

5%2 '/>

661%/%%< $-1 99= %%'

'%% 1%-99=

-1$'< 610''

&$<

-1$/%1 $%161%$% -61%8% -1$<

-99= &869% >$/< '-&/ 610''

5%2 0%1= '$12%$K

$/%1%1%< '869=

&&%6$2 >1

69&% &

5'9-$%9= $1-% 0%1'

= 1$&-9 &&-11%&%< >$/-$

= &1151 $<

8-$'

'-&/ 69&% & 9'

L $1-'$>1$/=

$%99 9%< >/&/ -1$- $%9=

'%) /'

5'%10 $ % -% 1%'6%&$ '-&/ 69&% &%1'

& 9'<

9%0%9'< $/%1 -$= 6%1%&$9= /%'$9=

92%$9=)

+%&%< 5'%10 $'

$/%1 H1'/6'

'%<

'-'6%&$ '/-9 .%

$%< %4='

81% &%&% %=%'

&88

= $/%1 6%1'*)

)

0&2 12A$ 2 C/%$/%1 '6% .2A1% '% #%'

C/%$/%1 %61$ #%'