High Court of Punjab and HaryanaCRR/435/2016allowed

Amaninder Singh Sekhon v. State Of Punjab

2016-05-23Mr. Justice Dr. Shekher Dhawan7 pages

!"##$%&%'(

)!'%'*#+,%'-.,#/.'

#"%"%'#+ 1#+&2& ,"!"# 2'3!4 #&5'*#'"

+#&#'"(0 +,#*%6,+*7$!"#8%". +,,+!+6*7$!"#+".#5#"%"%'#+ +9,!$.*#7!6**:6 2'3!4 +4%'* !%,.!+)!6*7$!"#+ ".#$)5:!%'!'" ;;;

.#%'&"!'"+#7%&%'5#"%"%'%&*%+#$"#*!-!%'&"".#+*#+*!"#*

65!&&#*4=".#:#!+'#***%"%'!:,#&&%'&2*-#6 !+%*/"%'

"#+)&8.%$.".#5+#&#'"5#"%"%'#+.!&4##'&2))'#*"!$#"+%!:!&!' !**%"%'!:!$$2&#*%'$!&# *!"#* >

2'*#+&#$"%'& <6 6 6 >6 ?6> 6>!'* 0 6+#-%&"#+#*!" :%$#,"!"%'6 %"= !+%*/" 4+%#'!++!"%'!$"&82:*4#'#$#&&!+=

*!"#*<2'*#+&#$"%'&?666

+#!*8%".,#$"%' 8!&-"+#-%&"#+#*!"".#%'&"!'$#$)5:!%'!'" !+*#7,%'-.!'*!-!%'&"!+)!'3%",%'-.&'3!%4,%'-.8%".".# !::#-!"%'&".!".#.!*-%7#'!4:8"".#$)5:!%'!'",2$.!::#-#* !$$2&#* !+)!'3%" ,%'-. !55+!$.#* ".# 5+#&#'" 5#"%"%'#+6 8. %& ! 5+!$"%$%'- *7$!"# " %:# !' !55:%$!"%' &##/%'- $'$#&&%' !'"%$%5!"+=4!%:%'".#!+#'"%$#* .#8!&&%-'#*4= &2$.5#+&'!&!+)!'3%",%'-.!'*".#5+#&#'"5#"%"%'#+5+#5!+#*!'

00 !%*!7%"%'"#+)&".#%*#'"%"=*%&$:&#*4=!+)!'3%",%'-.'< !'*8.%$.8!&!55#'*#*!:'-8%".".#4!%:!55:%$!"%'%:#*2'*#+,#$"%' ?+ ,2$.!55:%$!"%'8!&*%&)%&&#*'<<4=".#$2+" :#!+'#* **%"%'!: ,#&&%'& 2*-#6 !+%*/" 5' *%&)%&&!: ".# !'"%$%5!"+=4!%:!55:%$!"%'!+)!'3%",%'-.8!&!++#&"#*'

< .#+#!"#+6!+)!'3%",%'-.8!&!:&&.8'!&!++#&"#*'< <'

".#4!&%&5+*2$"%'8!++!'"&%' *!"#* <2'*#+ &#$"%' !'*%'8.%$..#!$#*"+%!:2'*#+".#'!)#!+)!'3%" ,%'-.!'*#!+'#*!$@2%""!:7%*#32*-#)#'"*!"#*> 65!&&#*4=".# +%!:2+","!"#5+##++#*!'!55#!:!-!%'&"".#32*-#)#'"!$@2%""!:

5''"%$#.!7%'-4##'%&&2#*"!+)!'3%",%'-.!'*%'52+&2!'$#"!' %'@2%+=)!+/#*4=".#".#',#&&%'&2*-#6 !+%*/"%""+!'&5%+#*".!"%'!$"

!+)!'3%",%'-.8!&+2'92)!+&'%8!'.!'*6+#&%*#'"!:4%+ !&"%6 !+%*/" .%& :#* " ".# +#-%&"+!"%' 5+#&#'" *!"#*

2'*#+&#$"%'& <66 6 >6 ?6> 6>!'* 0 6+#-%&"#+#*!" :%$#,"!"%'6%"= !+%*/" 2+%'- ".# $2+&# %'7#&"%-!"%' !'* )2:"%5:# %'@2%+%#& .!7%'-4##'.#:*65+#&#'"5#"%"%'#+8!&2'*%''$#'"!'*8!&5:!$#*%' $:2)''%'".#$.!::!'5+#&#'"#*'> '!55:%$!"%'2'*#+,#$"%' <+ 8!&)7#*4=".# 5+&#$2"%'!'*8.%$..!&4##'!$$#5"#*:#!*%'-"".#5!&&%'-".# %)52-'#*+*#+

#+2&!:".#%)52-'#*+*#+82:*+#7#!:".!"".#5+#&#'" 5#"%"%'#+.!&4##'&2))'#*"!$#"+%!:!&!'!**%"%'!:!$$2&#*25' ".#*#5&%"%'!'*&"!"#)#'"&+#$+*#* A0

,!+3!:!!'* A0

00 !&5!:,%'-.!'*':='".#4!&%&".!"!'!%*!7%".!*4##'%:#*4=".# 5+#&#'"5#"%"%'#+%'".#$!5!$%"=!'*7$!"#!:'-8%".!'!55:%$!"%' 2'*#+,#$"%'?+ &##/%'-$'$#&&%'5+#0!++#&"4!%:%*#'"%=%'- ".#!$$2&#*".#+#%'!&!+)!'3%",%'-.!'*!&'!)#*%'".# 2'&#:+".#5!+"%#&.!7#4##'.#!+*!":#'-".

"#$ % & % %

% '

(#$

& %

"#) % %

& % %

"*#$

"# ! "#

+ "#,

"#%

.##B"#'"58#+8%".".#2+""&2))'5#+&'&".#+ ".!'".#!$$2&#*2'*#+,#$"%' <".#*#+%)%'!: +$#*2+#"

00 &"!'*"+%!:%'!5#'*%'-$!&#.!&$)#25+$'&%*#+!"%'4#+#".# 'C4:#,25+#)#2+"%'!'2)4#+*#$%&%'&'

6%"8!&4&#+7#*!&2'*#+( /0 % 1

2 %

' %

2 '

% %

& '

"# $ %&6%".!*4##'.#:*!&::8&( /0

%% %

)

445 *6(78"9:;# !6!

2 %

' '

()

*#&# $ +6".#'C4:#,25+#)#2+".#:*".!"".#58#+2'*#+ ,#$"%' <".#*#+%)%'!: +$#*2+#%&!*%&$+#"%'!+=!'*!'

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

%'-$.!+-#642"&.+"&!"%&!$"%'"!' #B"#'"".!"".##7%*#'$#6%-#&2'+#42""#*682:*:#!*"$'7%$"%''".# !4&#'$#&2$.&!"%&!$"%'6".#2+"&.2:*+#+!%'+)#B#+$%&%'-58#+ 2'*#+,#$"%' <".#*#+%)%'!: +$#*2+# ' ".# $'&%*#+#* 7%#8 ".%& 2+"6 ".# %)52-'#* +*#+ &2))'%'-".#5+#&#'"5#"%"%'#+!&!'!**%"%'!:!$$2&#*$!''"&2&"!%'%' ".#:%-."".#&#"":#*5+%'$%5:#&!'*5!+!)#"#+&:!%**8'4=".#'C4:# 5#B 2+" + #B#+$%&# 58#+& 2'*#+ ,#$"%' < + !'* !& $+=&"!:%E#*.#+#%'!

.#$2+"4#:8.!&$)5:#"#:=7#+:/#*".#!&5#$"".!"".# 5#"%"%'#+%'".#$!5!$%"=!'*7$!"#.!*%:#*!'!%*!7%"!&5#+ %*#'"%"= *%&$:&#* 4= !+)!'3%" ,%'-. !'* 8. 8!& '!)#* 4= ".# $)5:!%'!'"!+*#7,%'-.!&&2$.%'".# ")!=4#'"#*".!"

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

,!+3!:!!'* A0

!&5!:,%'-..!7#4##'5#+2&#*.!7%'-4##'5:!$#*'+#$+*!'*!55#'*#* !& ''#B2+#& !'* !:'- 8%". ".#%'&"!'" 5#"%"%' !'* ".#%+ *#5&%"%'82:*$:#!+:=&.8".!"".#+#%&'+##+#'$#"!'=$'&5%+!$= .!"$.#*4=".#5+#&#'"5#"%"%'#+8%".".#)!%'!$$2&#*+2'92)!+!:%!& !+)!'3%",%'-..#*#5&%"%'".#&#"88%"'#&&#&%&)#+#:=!$"2!:!& +#-!+*&!'!%*!7%".!7%'-4##'"#'*#+#*4=".#5+#&#'"5#"%"%'#+!:'- 8%".!'!55:%$!"%'2'*#+,#$"%'?+ !+)!'3%",%'-.68. ".#+8%&#%&+2'92)!+%' *!"#*<

0>0 "4#&"".#5+#&#'"5#"%"%'#+.!&7#+%%#*".#!%*!7%"".# *#5'#'"68.$:!%)#*.%)&#:"4#!+)!'3%",%'-. '".#!$"&!'* $%+$2)&"!'$#&".#5+#&#'"$!&#68.#+#%''#7%*#'$#.!&4##':#*4#+# ".# $2+" " &.8 !'= 5+%+ $''#$"%'D$'$#+' + $'&5%+!$= ".# 5#"%"%'#+8%".".#)!%'!$$2&#*6".#&!)#82:*4#$'&"+2#*!&!$'*2$" '".#5!+"".#5#"%"%'#+8.%$.8!&4'!%*#!'*"8!+*&*%&$.!+-# .%&5+#&&%'!:*2"%#&!&!'*7$!"# '*#+&2$.$%+$2)&"!'$#&6' #'$#82:*4#)!*#2"!-!%'&"".#5#"%"%'#+ #:%!'$#%'&2$.+#-!+* )!=4#)!*#"".#*#$%&%'".#'C4:#,25+#)#2+"%'' ! ,* -

$ *

#". / %"0 !'*".#&!)#.!7%'- 4##'::8#*4=".%&2+"%'.

()#"0 $ ## '7%#8".#!47#6".#5+#&#'" 5#"%"%'%& !::8#*.# %)52-'#*+*#+*!"#* <

65!&&#*4=".#:#!+'#***%"%'!:,#&&%'& 2*-#6 !+%*/"@2!".#5+#&#'"5#"%"%'#+6%&@2!&.#*

:2$/= A.#".#+"4#+##++#*" #5+"#+F#&