High Court of Punjab and HaryanaCWP/11182/2013dismissed

Lakhmir Singh v. The Presiding Officer And ORS

2023-07-26Mr. Justice Harsh Bunger13 pages

!"# #&'('$) *+* ,!-./'0 1')2.

3** #"'"'$)#0 4#0(5( .# 0#('6')2

%%'&#07 )65("0'!8 ,!9$50 $50"7 )'$) #00'"$0:7 .!)6'2!0.

$".#0(

3** #(;$)6#)"(

< , *

1 1

0#(#)"

0* 1*=*

6>$&!"# ;#"'"'$)#0* 0* .!)6!)6##;

1')2.7

6>$&!"# 0#(;$)6#)"

$* ?* * * 1

* #"'"'$)#0

,!-./'0 1')2. .!( %'8#6 ".'( ;#"'"'$) 5)6#0

0"'&8#( + $)("'"5"'$) )6'!7 (##-')2 !

@0'"

(#""')2 !('6# '/;52)#6 !@!06 6!"#6 **7 ;598'(.#6 6!"#6 **

))#A50# ;!((#6 ,6* )65("0'!8 0'95)!8 &5/,!9$50 $50"7

.!)6'2!0.B @.#0#9:

0#%#0#)&# ')65("0'!8 6'(;5"# 0!'(#6 ;#"'"'$)#0 0#2!06')2 "#0/')!"'$) .'( (#0>'&#(7 .!( 9##) !)(@#0#6 !2!')("

.'/*

0'#%8:7 ;#"'"'$)#0

,!-./'0 1')2. 0!'(#6 !) ')65("0'!8 6'(;5"# (#0>')2 #/!)6 $"'&# 6!"#6 *** .# (!'6 6'(;5"# @!( 0#%#00#6 !6C56'&!"'$) 8#!0)#6 )65("0'!8 0'95)!8&5/ ,!9$50 $50"7 .!)6'2!0.

.#0#')!%"#0 0#%#00#6 D".# 0'95)!8< 5)6#0 (#&"'$) & )65("0'!8 '(;5"#(

&"7 E+

.#0#')!%"#0

0#%#00#6 DE+

&"<*

#/!)6 )$"'&# @!( 2$"

"0#!"#6 ("!"#/#)"

&8!'/* *

( ;#0 ;#"'"'$)#07 .# @!( !;;$')"#6 !&.')#

;#0!"$0 6!'8:

@!2# 9!('( ')

!)5!0:7 EE $6#0) $$6 )6'!

,"6*

.#0#')!%"#0 0#%#00#6 D0#(;$)6#)"!)!2#/#)"<* #"'"'$)#0 &8!'/#6 .!># @$0-#6 &$)"')5$5(8:

5;"$ ?** .'( (#0>'&#( @#0# "#0/')!"#6 ** ') !) '88#2!8 !09'"0!0:

/!))#0 !6$;"')2 5)%!'0 8!9$50 ;0!&"'&#*

#"'"'$)#0 &8!'/#6 C5)'$0 .'/ .!6 9##) 0#"!')#6 ') (#0>'&# #>#) )#@ !;;$')"/#)"( .!6 9##) /!6# /!)!2#/#)"

".#0#%$0# .'( (#0>'&#( @#0# "#0/')!"#6 ') >'$8!"'$) 1#&"'$)( ?7 ? ? E+

&"*

&&$06')28:7 ;#"'"'$)#0 ;0!:#6 0#')("!"#/#)"

') (#0>'&# @'".

%588 9!&- @!2#( &$)"')5'":

(#0>'&#*

* .# !%$0#("!"#6 &8!'/ ;#"'"'$)#0@$0-/!) @!( $;;$(#6 0#(;$)6#)"!)!2#/#)"

(59/'""')2 '"( 0#;8:*

.# 0#(;$)6#)"!)!2#/#)"

("!"#6 '"

#)2!2#6 ') /!)5%!&"50')2 90#!6 .!( (5%%'&'#)"

)5/9#0 0#258!0 #/;8$:##(7 .$@#>#0 /##"

&!(5!8 >!0:')2 6#/!)6 /!0-#"7 0#(;$)6#)" /!)!2#/#)"

$&&!('$)!88:

#/;8$:( 8!9$50 /##"

0#F5'0#/#)"

/!0-#"*

@!( %50".#0 ("!"#6 ;#"'"'$)#0@$0-/!)

,!-./'0 1')2. @!( )#>#0 #)2!2#6 6!'8:

@!2# 9!('( '"

@!( 6#)'#6 .# @$0-#6 :#!0( &$)"')5$5(8:* "

@!( (59/'""#6 ;#"'"'$)#0 @!( #)2!2#6 &!(5!8 8!9$50#0 !"

"'/# 0#F5'0#/#)"*

) **7 )$ &!(5!8 @$0- @!( !>!'8!98#7 .#)&# .# &$586 9# ;0$>'6#6 @$0- ".#0#!%"#0 .# )#>#0 0#;$0"#6 @$0-*

@!( !8($ ("!"#6

;#"'"'$)#0 .!6 0#)6#0#6 &$)"')5$5( (#0>'&# $)# :#!0 5)6#0 1#&"'$) ?

E+

&"7 ".#0#%$0#7 ".#0# @!( )$ F5#("'$) &$/;8'!)&# 1#&"'$) ? E+

&"*

".#0 !>#0/#)"( !88#2!"'$)( /!6# ;#"'"'$)#0 @#0# 6#)'#6 ;0!:#0 @!( /!6# 6'(/'((!8 &8!'/ ;#"'"'$)#0*

?* 0$/ ;8#!6')2( ;!0"'#(7 8#!0)#6 ,!9$50 $50"

%0!/#6 %$88$@')2 '((5#(

! "

# $

! "

# %

& '

* ) $06#0 ;0$># .'( &!(# &8!'/7 ;#"'"'$)#0 @$0-/!) ,!-./'0 1')2.7 #A!/')#6 .'/(#8%

* .# ;#"'"'$)#0@$0-/!) !8($ #A!/')#6 1.* 150C'"

1.!0!/!7 )%$0&#/#)"

%%'&#0

7 1.* 150')6#0 =5/!07 7

%%'&# /;8$:##( 1"!"# )(50!)&# $0;$0!"'$)7 .!)6'2!0.

1.* =

!C!C7

&&$5)"( !)!2#0 !)!2#/#)"

*.#0#!%"#07 ;#"'"'$)#0$0-/!) &8$(#6 .'( #>'6#)&#*

) $".#0 .!)67 0#(;$)6#)"( !8($ #A!/')#6 1.* *=*

!C!C7

&&$5)"( !)!2#0 * .#0#!%"#07 0#(;$)6#)"( #>'6#)&# @!( &8$(#6*

%"#0 &$)('6#0')2 &!(# 0#(;#&"'># ;!0"'#( !8($ /!"#0'!8 #>'6#)&# 0#&$06B ,#!0)#6 9#8$@7 >'6# '/;52)#6 !@!06 6!"#6 **

))#A50# 7 6#&'6#6

0#%#0#)&# !2!')("

;#"'"'$)#0@$0-/!)* E*

#')2 !220'#>#6 !2!')("

'/;52)#6 !@!06 6!"#6 ** 7 ;#"'"'$)#0 .!( %'8#6 ')("!)"

@0'"

;#"'"'$) 9#%$0# ".'( $50"* * .!># .#!06 8#!0)#6 &$5)(#8( 0#(;#&"'># ;!0"'#( ;#05(#6 ;!;#09$$- @'".

".#'0 !98# !(('("!)&#*

* ) ')("!)"

&!(#7 '"

;8#!6#6 &!(# ;#"'"'$)#0 .# @!( !;;$')"#6 ') 0#(;$)6#)"!)!2#/#)"

!&.')#

;#0!"$0 ')

!)5!0:7 EE .# &$)"')5$5(8:

@$0-#6 "'88 ?**7 @.#) (566#)8:

.'( (#0>'&#( @#0# "#0/')!"#6 ') !) '88#2!8 !09'"0!0:

/!))#0 @'".$5"

%$88$@')2 /!)6!"$0:

;0$>'('$)( E+

&"*

) $".#0 .!)67 '"

@!( ("!)6 0#(;$)6#)"!)!2#/#)"

;#"'"'$)#0 @!( #)2!2#6 !

&!(5!8 8!9$50#0 ;#"'"'$)#0 .!6 0#)6#0#6 &$)"')5$5( (#0>'&# ') "#0/( 1#&"'$) ?

E+

&"7 ".#0#%$0#7 ;#"'"'$)#0 #)"'"8#6 ;0$"#&"'$)

1#&"'$) ? E+

&"* .5(7 ') $06#0 (##- 0#8'#% ') "#0/( 1#&"'$) ? E+

&"7 ;#"'"'$)#0 @!( 0#F5'0#6 ;0$># .# @$0-#6 6!:( ') /$)".( ;0#&#6')2 6!"# .'( !88#2#6 "#0/')!"'$) 0#(;$)6#)" !)!2#/#)"*

12.

It is well settled law that the onus to prove existence of relationship of employer and employee between the parties is upon the workman. In Workmen of

Nilgiri Coop. Mkt. Society Ltd. v. State of Tamil Nadu and Ors., (2004) 3 SCC 514, Hon'ble Supreme Court held as under:- G%(

) "" " *"

" + "

" " * * *"

) - .

0 *"*2 1* "

. 3

4 5

6($ 7).

$6, 8 9

;1 * "

" " "

"* * *

" " " "

;

) 0" < =*"

> 7* .*

6(@ 7).

;

." "

) ." "

" ." * " ;

B* "

" " " "* B* 9

.* + " !*

* * * "C'

!8($ @#88 (#""8#6 8!@ $)5( ;0$># @$0-/!) .!( 0#)6#0#6 &$)"')5$5( (#0>'&# ') "#0/( 1#&"'$) ?

E+

'*#*

@$0-/!) .!( @$0-#6 5)6#0 !)!2#/#)"

6!:( ') /$)".( ;0#&#6')2 6!"# "#0/')!"'$) !8($ @$0-/!)*

%50".#0 @#88 (#""8#6 /#0# !%%'6!>'"( $0 (#8%(#0>')2 ("!"#/#)"( /!6# &8!'/!)"

@$0-/!) @'88 (5%%'&# ') /!""#0 6'(&.!02# 9506#) ;8!&#6 8!@ @$0-/!) ;0$># .# .!6 @$0-#6 6!:( ') !

2'>#) :#!0* ) ".'( 0#2!067 0#%#0#)&# &!) 9# /!6# &!(# #*" ."

0 - AA%D%E .

0* <

< F AA@D,E 0..

(@A

$/')2 &!(# ') .!)67 >'6# '/;52)#6 !@!06 6!"#6 **

))#A50# 7 ,6* 9#8$@ .!( 0#"50)#6 %$88$@')2 %')6')2( CC0 .

2 %

0" AA, " .* <8 ?!!

" /* AAA

AA ""

& "* " * %A .* "

" G

AA * @$ AA < AAA

1 A, *

" * %A " )< F

B* #

"" #

9 * * * 0

* <"

)

" 3+

$ /* AAA

" %A "

* &

,,( " * *

.9AG6AG,

* %

AA 3+ # " &

$ % .

F " # .

" "

& " *

" # "

) * "* .* " "

$ " /* AAA

" %A " " G

F 3+

$ 3+

% " " * %A "* " G

F* B* ""

" 0 @ > )< F

B* "

* !*

* *

)* -

$ $

- *

* ! ! "

& %

) * -

F""" =

> '

;#05(!8 !9$># #A"0!&"#6 %')6')2( @$586 /!-# '"

#>'6#)"

;#"'"'$)#0@$0-/!) %!'8#6 6'(&.!02# $)5( ;8!&#6 5;$) .'/ ;0$>')2 #/;8$:###/;8$:#0 0#8!"'$)(.';

)$0 '"

@!( ;0$>#6 ;#"'"'$)#0@$0-/!) .!6 &$/;8#"#6 6!:( @$05)6#0 !)!2#/#)"

') "#0/( (#&"'$) ?

E+

&"7 ($ !""0!&"

;0$>'('$)( (#&"'$) ? E+

&"* $ !;;$')"/#)"

8#""#0 $0 ;0$$% 0#&#';"

(!8!0:

$0 @!2#( $0 !):

0#&$06 #)2!2#/#)"

0#(;$)6#)"!)!2#/#)"

') :#!0 $0 !):

$06#0 ') 0#2!06 @!( ;0$65&#6* "

@!( 0!".#0 !6/'""#6 ;#"'"'$)#0@$0-/!) #("!98'(./#)"

@.'&.

#)2!2#6 .'( (#0>'&#(7 .!6 &#!(#6 #A'("

.5(7 $)&# ;#"'"'$)#0@$0-/!) .!6 %!'8#6 ;0$># #/;8$:###/;8$:#0 0#8!"'$)(.';

$0 .# .!6 &$/;8#"#6 6!:( @$05)6#0 !)!2#/#)"7 )$ 0#8'#% &$586 .!># 9##) 20!)"#6 .'/* ?*

( 0#2!06( >'$8!"'$) 1#&"'$) ? 1#&"'$) ? E+

&$)&#0)#67 ;#"'"'$)#0 .!6 %!'8#6 (59("!)"'!"# (!'6 ;8#!

9#%$0# 9#8$@ @#88 9#%$0# ".'( $50"* *

( 0#2!06( ;8#!

;#"'"'$)#0 !6>#0(# ')%#0#)&# 9# 60!@) !2!')("

0#(;$)6#)"!)!2#/#)"

;0$65&')2 0#8#>!)"

0#&$067 '"

$9(#0>#6 60!@')2 !6>#0(# ')%#0#)&# $;"'$)!8

$98'2!"$0:

(!/# @'".') 6$/!') )65("0'!8 0'95)!8* 50".#07 60!@')2 !6>#0(# ')%#0#)&# 6#;#)6( %!&"( &'0&5/("!)&#( #!&.

&!(# !6>#0(# ')%#0#)&# &!))$"

9# 60!@) $)8:

9#&!5(# '"

8!@%58 6$ ($*

) ')("!)"

&!(#7 9#8$@ .!( 60!@) !):

!6>#0(# ')%#0#)&#*

50".#0/$0#7 !;!0"

%0$/ 9!0# ;8#!

)$);0$65&"'$) 0#8#>!)"

0#&$06 0#(;$)6#)"!)!2#/#)"B ".#0# )$ ;8#!

;#"'"'$)#0 0#(;$)6#)"!)!2#/#)"

.!( (5;;0#((#6 0#8#>!)"

0#&$06*

) !9(#)&# (5&.

;8#!

(5;;0#(('$)7 )$ !6>#0(# ')%#0#)&# &!) 9# 60!@) !2!')("

0#(;$)6#)"!)!2#/#)"*

) ".'( 0#2!067 0#%#0#)&# &!) 9# /!6# C562/#)"

$)<98#

;#A $50"

!7 @.#0#') '"

.!( 9##) .#86 5)6#0 @

I * * " "

!* * "* * " * " *"" * *

7 !* "" 9

.* * F .*

* * * * "

+ " *"

50".#0/$0#7 ;!0!/#"#0( #A#0&'(# C50'(6'&"'$) '2.

$50"

5)6#0

0"'&8# $)("'"5"'$) )6'!

') &!(#( ')>$8>')2 &.!88#)2# !@!06 ;!((#6 ,!9$50 $50"

)65("0'!8 $06#0( ;!((#6 $".#0 C56'&'!8 B* !* 9$6'#( !0# @#88 6#%')#6*

@0'"

&!) 9# '((5#6 &$00#&"')2 #00$0( C50'(6'&"'$) &$//'""#6 ')%#0'$0 $50"( $0 0'95)!8(*

@0'"

&!) !8($ 9# '((5#6 @.#0# ') #A#0&'(# C50'(6'&"'$) &$)%#00#6 '"7 $50"

$0 !&"( '88#2!88:

$0 '/;0$;#08:

'*#* '"

6#&'6#( !

F5#("'$) @'".$5"

2'>')2 !) $;;$0"5)'":

9# .#!06 ;!0":

!%%#&"#6 $06#0 $0 @.#0# ;0$&#650# !6$;"#6 '"

$;;$(#6 ;0')&';8#( )!"50!8 C5("'&#* $@#>#07 '"

/5("

9# 0#/#/9#0#6 C50'(6'&"'$) '2.

$50"

'((5# !

@0'"

(5;#0>'($0:

C50'(6'&"'$) !;;#88!"# $)#* .'( )#&#((!0'8:

/#!)( %')6')2 %!&"

0#!&.#6 ')%#0'$0 $50"

$0 0'95)!87 !

0#(58"

!;;0#&'!"'$) #>'6#)&#7 &!))$"

9# 0#$;#)#6 $0 F5#("'$)#6 ') @0'"

;0$&##6')2( #A&#;"

@.#) C562/#)"7 $06#0 $0 !@!06 (5%%#0( %0$/ !) #00$0 8!@ !;;!0#)"

%!&# 0#&$06* .'( !9("0!&"

("!"#/#)"

8!@7 95"

>#A#6 F5#("'$) @.!"

!) #00$0 8!@ !;;!0#)"

%!&# 0#&$06 ') @.!"

&'0&5/("!)&#( !

%')6')2 %!&"

0#&$06#6 !) ')%#0'$0 $50"

$0 $0 !

B* !* !5".$0'":

&!) 9# &$00#&"#6*

0$!68:

(;#!-')27 !) #00$0 8!@ $)# @.'&.

&!) 9# 6'(&$>#0#6 !

9!0# 0#!6')2 C562/#)"7 $06#0 $0 !@!06 5)6#0 &.!88#)2# !8$)2 @'".

6$&5/#)"( @.'&.

.!># 9##) 0#8'#6 5;$) ')%#0'$0 $50"7 $0 B* !* !5".$0'":*

) #00$07 6'(&$>#0:

@.'&.

;$(('98# $)8:

!%"#0 !

6#"!'8#6 (&05"'):

#>'6#)&# ;0$65&#6 ;!0"'#(

8#)2".:

6#9!"# !"

9!0 &!))$"

9# 0#2!06#6 !) #00$0 8!@ ;50;$(# !

@0'"

%')6')2 %!&"

0#&$06#6 !) ')%#0'$0 $50"

$0 &!) 9# &$00#&"#6 $)8:

'% '"

(.$@) ') 0#&$06')2 (!'6 %')6')2 $50"

$0 .!6 #00$)#$5(8:

0#%5(#6 !6/'"

!6/'(('98# /!"#0'!8 #>'6#)&# $0 .!6 #00$)#$5(8:

!6/'""#6 ')!6/'(('98# #>'6#)&# (!/# .!( ')%85#)&#6 '/;52)#6 %')6')2* 1'/'8!08:7 !

%')6')2 %!&"

9!(#6 )$ #>'6#)&# @$586 9# 0#2!06#6 !) #00$0 8!@ @.'&.

&!) 9# &$00#&"#6 !

@0'"

* $@#>#07 (5%%'&'#)&:

$0 !6#F5!&:

#>'6#)&# 0#8'#6 5;$) ')%#0'$0 $50"

$0 $0 B* !* !5".$0'":

&!))$"

9# 2$)# ')"$ '2.

$50"

@.'8# &$)('6#0')2 ;0!:#0 '((5# !

@0'"

* ,'-#@'(#7 /#0#7 ;$(('9'8'":

%$0/')2 !

6'%%#0#)"

$;')'$) 0# !;;0#&'!"'$) #>'6#)&# ;!0"'#( (5%%'&'#)"

'((5# !

@0'"

"#$%%& ' # $ #% ()!

*+% ,,-

$ ++#.+ & '#$ / +' +&#% ()!, *+% )-0 #

1 #" " #1 23 ##% ()!4 *+% !, - %567&#% )!!!

90 )!!! ,#% #

2:$ #% ( ;0< #% 0 4 !

* $)('6#0')2 "$"!8'":

&'0&5/("!)&#( ') 8'2."

8#2!8 ;$('"'$) ')6'&!"#6 !9$>#7 ".#0# )$ (&$;# ')"#0%#0#)&# ') %')6')2( 0#"50)#6 9#8$@ ') #A#0&'(# @0'"

C50'(6'&"'$) ".'(

$50"*

.#0#%$0#7

')("!)"

@0'"

;#"'"'$) %!'8( (!/# !&&$06')28:

6'(/'((#6 E*

;#)6')2 !;;8'&!"'$) (7 '% !):7 (.!88 ("!)6 &8$(#6*

*+* (C-( .#".#0 (;#!-')2 0#!($)#6 $06#0 #(

$ .#".#0 0#;$0"!98#