High Court of Punjab and HaryanaCRM-M/6758/2018allowed

Gagan @ Balwinder Singh And ORS v. State Of Punjab And ANR

2018-08-14Mr. Justice Anupinder Singh Grewal7 pages

"#$%$ & '

+ +,

!"#$%"&'((" (&$ )*+$, ()) !"#$%"'"

+,-

.*/ &( '((" * #(" -./ "% & 0" "% 0(1($) "# *&$,%() %"2*$&(3"% "45 $ 6/67/687 3( * #("5/-8-.$ 8-9"%& ($$)0" :%" &";& 0;<:)$"#"! ("5/="%& 0<$")(# $("

&()>$ ((# $'*&$)$ $ $)) #"2*($) '"# (3 $((3 &%"1"&,$("%#"1'"1($(! $,>&'$( ( " $ 8965/68.&'$(> (# "$''$ ,%"&)$ ($)0"*? ))$2$ $3($%"3(3&($1 #" @$"&3*("%&#"1'"1( #"1')($#&"% '""%* (#($) $3($ 0)$ $'*&$)$ $ /.65/68.&$ ,#(! >&((&$,"(# &$&'$(&$!) &

('*$1(#$,)A>(&"*$A* *(%)*##"#(""'*$ ""%&$##* &$!, #)$ $'"#)$(1 "%% &*)(1$$(1",+#(!$ 3"$)"%$)3$)A1(" #"#()&"#($)#"%)(#$>(2*( ")A"*&$'"') " "&$!"%(3&>(&$#&"&+*"'"#&((3&"'"'A(3& ")(%$ )(,A$ "&(3&#* "&1,A&)3$)A1& #(!() ('*$&#"%)(#,>>"'$(&$!(3)"!" %"&"#($)" "#($)&$1"A"&"#(A$*#&#$,")* % "1(3(!"&'$(")&( ('*,A#"1'"1("% #"*#"1(3 >(&#$()3$)#"2*#$>))">! & #(1($) ('* ""#$()A(#&1)!

"")A>"'$( "& ('*(1"%&(#"'#"2*#$ %%#&#(1($) $# "#$&(%%#$ #"2*#!*'"&"#(A$ )$3&%"&)$>'#(,'*(&1!'*(&1$ &B1'*(&1(#)* (3 $&'$)A%"#(1($)$# ">!1""%&"&#(!() ('*"(C #"%)(# "% >" '$( $%"1 &1)! (" #(1($) $'# &%"&)3$)A1')$A1'("")!&#"%)(#,>>" '$(@>(&&$ $D"%*(3&$&$ !(1'$#"% ('* 2*$"#(A$)$3(1((1(E *())&#"( $("")!& #"%)(#,>>"( ,A'*(3("&%"!

)$>(2*( "3(! *3$ "&>(&"%&'$(" ('*

#"3(E(3&('(#(')")A& ($)3$) A1$)"'"!( %" #"3(E(3 & #"1'"1( ,> >" ( "% $ #(1($) ('*

#("5/600($B''"!(("(&(3$ &(#("" ")A'"!( %"#"1'"* (3 *(3&($),*'1(#"1'"* (3 !$$''))$"!(("$)$3">!,A(!A$*$ #"'

#("5/600#$",&")'"("A@>&(&#"3((" "$#"1'"1(,>&'$(&$!@#$()A@",#"%( &( #(")$")A"&"%%#'#(, * & ($$)0" &$$)"1""%%#'#(, "*( 0 !"&"%%# B((3(& 0> (1("$$ %"1(1"(11$D(3& B((3"%%#",)(3&"(3$ !>1" $)(("%'""% "%"%%#$,(3#"3( (!(>"%#&")"3(#$)$ !$#1 &(#($$ 2*(& %")""D(3,A" #("5/6 00"#"3(&#"1'"1(,>&'$(" ('**" 1$($(&$#(A"%&'"# *'#(, %"#(1($)($)@&($) 0"*#$",'1( "$!),A" &#"''#(, * &$ '"# *#& %"(!"D(3 #("-./00,A&(3& 0"* * $ ",! $,"! & >(& "% ")A '$( " & #(1($) ('*>"*) "$)>$A,*%%(#("1($$#(1($)($)

(!(>"%&'$)$"*,)%%#@&(#" *#>"*) &$!)% 2*$&"#(A$)$3&%"&"%# #"11( ,A'" (!") (3"!$#"$ 1(($("%"$#2*((3"%%(#($)'">" >&()B#((3"%%(#'">#$",'1( ",#"1'"1( (D>( ! & "%# (!")(3 ")A >" '(!$ '" ,* %)#(3 '$!(A"%#&$$#"(!")(3#$*(3(("$))""%)(% "#$*(3(("$))""%'"'A,AB (3(11(&$"%)" "% )(%@ #$" , '1( " , #"1'"1( B#' & $,"!C 1(" 3$!"%%#&(!A$"&$$))"&"%%# &"*) ,'1( ",#"1'"1( ,A&0"* (#&'""%"% "%%#,%"&0"*$3$(>"*) (!")

&#" *#"%&'$(" ('*&%"(%&0"* ""'1(&$1",#"1'"1( &&'$(>"*) "')$A(#D*'"&0"*"*& $#2*($)"%$##* ,A*,!(3&$ 1(($(""%#(1($)+*(# ((!(&("%$ 1(($(""%#(1($)+*(#"%"# &#((E")$$ $ "'&(#D (3 ",')$A *'"0"* "*,!

";,) & *'1 0"* &$ $1')A #)$(%( & )3$) '"((""#"3(E(3#"1'"1((3(&#$"%

!"$ &$",! $ *

! "

%&'

(

)*+ ,

(

!("

( - "

(

.- -

(

(-(

(

( *

(

- -

(

( -

(

# "

(

+ ,

&'#$ ""%$))($A""%&B#'(" !($3 $,"!#(!(>"%&'""% * (#($) $3($ 0)$ $'*&$)$ $ /.65/68.1$ ('**$#"%&" $ 8965/68.'$ ,A&(0"*&0"*%)&$"*%*)'*'" >"*) ,! ,AD'(3&'"# (3$)(! >()),(&( "%+*(#(%&)1$#& ,>&'$(($##' ##" (3)A&''(("($))"> "45 $ 6/67/6873( * #("5/-8-.$ 8-9"%& 0:)$ "#"! ("5/="%& 0<$")(# $(" &()>$ ((#

$'*&$)$$ $))#"2*($)'"# (3$((3&%"1 "& ,$("%#"1'"1($(! $,>&'$($&,A2*$& 2*$ &''((" . +,/

&&'$D(3?$" F"

&& '"$,) F"