Udai Bhan Yadav v. State Of Haryana And ORS
!"# $% #&'('$) *++ ,!'
-!) !,!.
+++#"'"'$)#/ 0#/(1(
2"!"# $% !/3!)!
!), $"-#/(
++++#(4$),#)"( 5 6 +
2 2 2 2
! "
$ $ $
% &
' *+ +, -++.
/0 1*2 ) *+ +3 -++.
(
( 5 *- 6
8&& /
''
"
/ 9 :2+ - 7
''
*
6 &
< #
# %.,5
%5 )
&
< #
) ' ' #
;
&
'8 #
6 '8'
#
;
& += += %..3 > ?
(
(#
-++3 '
(
(#
'#
:
' 4 '8 '
+, +, -++.
'
?
=
4 ) !
@ A)) ?
# !'
@ *+ +, -++.
' ' # ) +% +. -++.
) ' -++.
; )
' @ !'
"
0 (
'8'
' ?
(
%+
B %B
?
0
'
' ' -* %% -++.
/0 1=2
4
' (
6
?
?'
'
,
4 !
@ A)) ?
'' 7
!
@ "
4 -, % -++.
/0 152
6
?
?
#
*+ %- -++.
/0 1B2
4
6
?
-% +% -+%+ /0 1,2
4
# ' +3 +* -+%+ /0 1.2
4
#
'
# )
) +% +. -++.
4
+3 +* -+%+ /0 1.2
(
.
C
''
?'
(# 4 '8'
4
'
#
'
' ?
D8
(
(
%+
0
%+ C )
'
#
' ' #
' ' #
)
6
?
'
?
( '
?'
' '
7 E
! "#$ $$ % & $ '(
6(
# ' !
E
()
*+,
!
$- % $
& $''(
(
) '
?
%% C '
(
4
' '8'
?'
' 85 *-
4
'
) %- C ' )
'
(
?
# 4 '
' 4
(
( C '
' 6( ": ' &
$-% $
!.,/
'' /# $/ ( %* C
6(
2
( #
''
) '8
#
& +. +- -++B
0
#
?
' '
?'
%= &
7 E -% +, -+%5 6( ( '8 !
E
-, +- -+%, !
E
7
7 -% +, -+%5 ( E 7
?
)
6 %5 &
( (
%B 4
?'
' ( %, &
5 *-8
5 *-8E 6
8&&
''
8 8+ + -# /19# %$/ "-# :/!)"
$% /#"'/'):
4#)('$)( '( !( %$99$;( 8 /
(
'
'
*+
'
#
'
-5 / 2 /2
&
/&2
''
#
/ &)
& && '
( #8)
( )#8)
/
2/ &)
&&& '
/ 2 &)
& && '
( #8)
( )#
6
'
( )#8 (
'
(
#
6
/-2 >
)
(# /%2/
( )#
)
(# / /
1
( )#8)
)
(# 6
( )# (
(
''
#
( )# )#8)
)#8 (
6
)) )
( )# 1) )#8)
)#8 (
6
$"#
44$')"'):
!1"-$/'"3 /#"!')( !) !<($91"# /':-"
"$ /#"'/# !)3 $.#/)=#)"
#=49$3## /#%#//#, "$ -!.# $) $/ !%"#/ -# -!( !""!')#, "-# !:# $% %'%"3 3#!/( $/ %'%"3%'.# 3#!/( ') "-# &!(# $% '.'9 2#/.'&#> $/ %'%"3 #':-"
3#!/( ') "-# &!(# $% ?1,'&'!9 (#/.'&#> !( "-# &!(# =!3 <# ;'"-$1"
!((':)'):
!)3 /#!($)+
&$//#(4$),'):
/':-"
'( !9($ !.!'9!<9# "$ (1&- !
:$.#/)=#)"
#=49$3## "$ /#"'/# $) $/ !%"#/ -# -!( !""!')#, "-# !:# $% %'%"3 3#!/(> %'%"3%'.# 3#!/( $/ %'%"3#':-"
3#!/(> !( "-# &!(# =!3 <#+@ F5 *-8E /%2
#
' # :
#
''
# )
"
?
4
''
#
'
) A '
4
''
#
4
)
#
''
#
'' #
0'
G %3
'
' 5 *-8
& 85 *-8E
'
4
%.
E) ' )
8 B %B
B %B /-2
8 FB %B/-2 &
& ' %.,.
A
'
'
#8
' (
5+H
(
)
B %.7 6
*+++18
"
#8
''
#8 6
*,518
6 85 *- B %B
?
(
%+ 1
''
( '
?
85 *-8E
1
'
? -%
(
( '
%+
1
( '
( 1 %+
--
E
5 *-
B %B
'
'
))
))
(
*
( ' %+
( ' ?'
5 *-8E
?
4
>
'' #
''
?
(
4
-* "
)
: 4
'8 '
' 4 '8'
6
?
4
' '8'
( 4 #
'
4 &
# '
'' #
( ?
( '8'
( '
( '
+. +- -++B '8 ))
'
''
''
:
# 0
-= <
'
85 *- 4
-5 C
' 6(
/#
'
'
7 E
(
'6 ' 6(
8 = 5 *- E
"
< < %1- /-,28,.8-I&& -. %.3*
8 J/
#
' #
#
''
# )
"
?
4
''
#
'
) A '
4
''
#
4
)
#
''
#
'' #
0'
J '
?
#
J '
J &
( '
' 5 *-8E ' ?
'
-3 * %.3.
) *% * %.3.
/'#
0 8-2 !'
) '
74 # '
'' )
'
G -B
6(
!
E
*+,
/# !
E ?
?
/# ' 6(
*+,
/#
8 F5 E)
' ?
'
''
?
'
'
) '
& 0 8%
J
(
C
7 ( ;
' '
) *% % %..* 7 ))
'
*% % %..*J ; '
) '
' '' )
'
'
(
( A
< ( ; ' 7
"
7
%..*/%2
5%.
8 J '
?
#
J '
J &
( '
' 5 *- ' ?
'
-3 - %.3.
) *% * %.3.
/'#
0 8-2 !'
) '
74 # '
'' )
'
I
'
* 4
' ' 5 *- E
J
0 J
6
0 *+
'
* < '
# ' J -,
'
'
? '
'6
)
'
-3 C '
6( ": ' &
.,/
/#
5 *-
( '
( (
' '
'
": ' &
C '
'
%B 6(
.,/
/#
8 F16. As noticed above, the respondent has not chosen to seek the benefit of pension in terms of Rule 6.16 (2) of the PCS Rules Vol. I in the first writ petition No.2890/97, which was dismissed by the Division Bench with costs for the aforesaid reasons. In the said writ petition, second prayer made by the writ petitioner (respondent herein) was to issue a writ of
mandamus directing the respondents-authorities (appellants herein) to take back the writ petitioner into service in order to complete 20 years qualifying service for the purpose of pension, gratuity, etc. This prayer of the writ petitioner would clearly indicate that his claim for the grant of pension in the case of voluntary retirement is squarely covered by Section 5.32-B of the PCS Rules and not under Rule 6.16(1) of the Rules as held by the High Court. Undisputedly, the respondent has not completed 20 years qualifying service before he sought voluntary retirement on 09.02.1997 and his request was accepted by the competent authority on 19.06.1996 with immediate effect.
-.
&
).,/
/#
(
7>8-3.+8%..,
?
'
( (
' 5+++18
( ; )
(
7>8=B%.8%...
(
''
%5% 77 < -3.+8%..,
!
E
0
'( ": ' &
?'
": ' &
''
( < -3.+8%..,
''
%5% 77 *+
# ))
.,/
/# *% ;(
%5 6(
.,/
/# ": ' &
)
?
''
5 *-8E
1
1
( (
"
& +. +- -++B
))
'
''
) )
6(
/#2
*+,
/#
( ": ' &
.,/
/#2 *- & 6 6(
/#2
*+,
/#
&
'8 +. +- -++B
)) '8'
' 0
#
'
''
5 *-
7
** I
#
'' '
6
?
' '
6 #
?
( '
#
'
)
''
!'
'' #
?
''
:
'( '8 '6 E
)
' ?
'
6
?
'8
*= '
) ' ' '
7 E
/#
!
*+,
/# /! ' #
5 *-
B %B 6
*5 C '
'''
(
)
' '#
*B <
(
*,
*3
''
'
#
'
!)1!/3 *>
2 2 2