High Court of Punjab and HaryanaCWP/11224/2013dismissed

Naresh Kumar & ORS v. State Of Haryana And ORS

2017-10-04Mr. Justice A.B. Chaudhari13 pages

! "# $%&'( )* $ +,!,%&(

& -.

///. !

" # " !

" $% &&''(')()* ')&+ # !

" ! , - !

" $% '+((' ')&+ - $ !

" $% '++). ')&+&&/++ ')&( '&'0. ')&* - !

" $% &&+(0 ')&( , !

- !

" 1 !

" $% '&*) ')&. !

" $% &/2(+ ')&/ #3-# !

" $% '*'2& ')&+ 45 !

" !4# !

" $% &*.&* ')&* !

" $% /.)+ ')&/'&)*/'&'0( ')&* 4- 5 !

" $% &)'0*&((22 ')&* 1 !

" $% ')+.''&'(' ')&*

- !

" -- !

$% '&)2. ')&* !

" $%6&/()& &*.206')&.&..&'6')&/')&') ')2&*6')&* , - , //. 0 3 -- $% &&''( ')()*'*'2&'+((''++). ')&+$% &&+(0&&/++'/&&&

')&( $% &/()& '&*) &*.20 ')&. $% /.)+ &..&'&/2(+ ')&/ $% &*.&*&)'0*&((22')&') ')+.'')2&*'&)*/'&)2.'&'(''&'0('&'0. ')&* #!

$%6&&''(6')&+ -

# - "-''/

9 " #

# ++ 8

!"$ 8-:%-;

-": -"-- #

--5 !#

'&&&')&'< = 6(&>3 # "

&.)'')&' $%6&&&'26'))/ -

- ? 5 )/)*')).

< = 6.

6+*>!#" !" ! 8# #

5? #

5!5 5

-? 5 8"

- !

-! # "-- "< > -

8 1! 4"@ 62/6'))2 -

)&)2'))2< = 6+2>@6 '0)+*6'0)((6'))2#-8 5 " #" --5 -- 85 )*&''))2#"#!" '()0')&& 9 #

8 5 ! - --"

# 88 "- --"" #"#" "#

')).

" # "

8- -

')&+ 3

- 1! 4" $%6'(06'))/ -

" )2)&'))/< = 62>

8 " "

#"- 8 -8 =$ &').'))/ < = 6&)> 5 -5 "

$ -" "

- 8 ! 5

-8-

8"" 35 8 $ -

#5 # "

# -8-

8 5!8- # #"8" 8"

5 " 3" -! "

! )/)''))(< = 6&>#&()) #! #"#

8-- '4

- 9 - " A " <9A> 8 "

" -"

4 -"

" 1 "

8- , 5 A -$ 8-# --!! &))*'))(< = 6'>

'.)-$ 8-- 5# &0/+3 $ 8-<-

A ->#

8-- 5"

" 8

- 9A8 "

"-"

4 "

-!-3 #-" 5 8 --"

"- -

8 !# $ 8-4- 8 8--

9 " # -"

+& < = 6(> 8 #"# -"-- # # $

A 4

- 9A4 , 5 3 "8 !

'+&''))( < = 6.>#8 &# # "# .

- 9A" --!

#" B3 3, ! 9"

, ! !55

$ 8-9 6 5 4-85;4@# 1

<>! 9 -" A "

- # "

"C D19EF$F $D39A9$ 3D;A ;93D3 G 3 3D91H39 @D$H93GA;$D : : 5 4-8 5 8 $ 8- 9 - " A " "

'(6@ '))+ #'&:&':)( : --

8 - .:+2*9A! # "

!-5 $ 8- 9 - " A " :6 $

49A" -

:6 $

( 4 8I 39A#8 '2)/')).< = 6&> 8-5 9 -" A " "

'))+ #" 8 --" 8 - )()&'))( < = 6'> 4! 8 "

- !

'&&''))(#"8 5 " .

9A< = 6.>3 #

8 6 5 "

? -" -58- 3 #"--58 -- $ 8-8 $ "

# 5 8 - - '*)2'))."

8# #

" '))+ "

#! " 8 , ! "

9A#

8-" " # #

5 - J 85!

4 5 3"

5 #"

-#"#

5- 8--5-- "

-$ $ "

" # &*&''))( - &2)&./0*/:6 8 " 8 D="? $

D? 8 $

D? "

&22' 3" '*)2')). "

8"--5 8 1! 4"/)%1)2345)"-!+)! < >#"# # )2)&'))/8 -5 #

? " - #"8 58 -- "

"--5 -5 "

8 -8 =$ #8"

&').'))/3 $

#" # - 5! ! 55 " 9A8 5 -- #5 " B<>% -5- # - " " 9 -" A " <>% ""

"!- , !

- 5 5 " 9 - " A " ! #

5 "

" 9 -" " "

'))+ <>% "-- 8"

D="?

9 8- <!>% = "

!- - -"

:" " 9 -" A " 8- I %-"5 " <> # - # ""

" -5-

!- 8- # -5 "

" " #! <> #- #"-= - 8#"

"85 5 8"

? "

#5 " "6 -- -- <> # - 8- "-- "

D="?

# # $ ;

$ - 5 A" - 1"

,- -" 55 <!> # - #

= "

" -5 - " 9A3 #- 5

-? " @ "8 5 1! 4" "

#!!! )*)0'))(0) 869"

<- A -> -""- 59 !4

- 9A# 5

8" ? )()0'))(3 "#"

5 !" -"

3 " # ""

5- -- # -

# " #" ""

8 A " 3

# "--5 8 @ 5- 5 # - * # # - - ""

5 -, ! !" -5

89-

1! 4" 6)%.)7-!+)! < > 5 8 -5 -- #! # # 89A8 #

-"A " 8 -! 8 869"

-"3 -

#-- #8 5

-- #85 #

"-8 8 #5!"

!" 3

/)%1)2 345)"-! +)! < > # "" 5- 5 3 ! 5 " 1! 4" B&/$

5 #

- 8- "

- # - #

! -"

" 8 -

-"8-

" D! 9A # 8 -"

-- #

"# !- " 55 8

-- # #!

-" " 5 -5#

? 85 5

#"#

! ? # -! -- # 5 ! 3 5 8-I

" # ! )*)0'))(#" # 5 -"

" # 3 # -- #

! " /)*2))")2)%< > &.)'')&'

< = 6()> #"

$ 8-:%- ;

<- A ->!! '.)*'))(#"# 0( $ 8-:

%-;

-5! 3-"

" %5 -" 3 " " ! #

)2)0'))( -"@" -

-" #

8 8

8 -F# # 5 8 -"

3 !" # # 5 9A8-3 #"--5 # #"#-- # 5 ! #

9A #"

!8 6)%.)7-!+)! < > %- "5 '&&&')&'< = 6 (&> "

8 # $ 8- # # " %-;

- -

5 3-"

" %5 -"1 ; - 5 8 8 #- 8

9A#8--5" "

9!# @ 5 -" #

- 1 - #

5 &.

6 # #- 8"

8 ')&'')&' ;""

85 8"

$%6'++).6')&+ -

$%6')()'6')&+ -

8- 5 -- - -"

5? #

' !8-"

%-;

## 5-"- - #-"

,-1

1 "

G 5 "

"- "

5- ')&'')&' 5

!"## #8 -" <3-"

" > +))(')&( < = 6&&> --

1 -#- # #! ! # #- " 8 -" " 4

" -3 "--5 8 ! +))(')&(8-5$%600'(6 ')&( --55 # " " ! '.)*'))(9 #""

8 %-;

'))(# 9A8 # ,-1 "#

/)*2))")2)%-!)%$ 6*)!6-!+)! !< > 8 " 5 !"" G 5,-1 "

"- "

- - -

!"# - 3!##- &/)+')&/ 3 -- 5 6)% .)7-!+)! < >

! )*)0'))(#"

869"

"# 5 -"

-- "

# 5

! '.)*'))(#"

%-;

9 " !

)/)''))(&))*'))(#"#

8 8 " " 8 1, 1 "

-!-

" - #" " "- " /)*2) )")2)% < > 3 8 '2)/')). A "-

"--5

8 #" -

#" 8 -8 -8 1! 4" 8 =$ )2)&'))/ &').'))/"

"8 ! - 85 -

8 "

- -# #- - 8- 5 '))'85$%6''(..6')&' -

$%6'.2.*6')&' -

#" # )(&&'))( < = 62> &/)&')&. < = 6&)> " !- <

"# - $%6&*.206')&.>9 "- -8 5

8 !"

8"--55 "5 '))/ ""

" -5-

"#"# 8')&'-"- 8 -" /)*2) )")2)%-! +)! < > - -#--"5-" = $

% %&

% ' (

% ) * + #(

,%'

- .

- / )* ! #

# 5 --"3"- # -- -

- 3" "

'&&&')&' "

8- -

" " # -

" " 3 5 # 8A "855!" ;! ! '&&&')&'

""# $

" 5!5

#- 8

8A "# !? 8 3 "

# 5"--5

8 " #"-8 -8 1! 4" -- = $ -

" ""

5-5 #

8 )(&)')&* //.

! "