High Court of Punjab and HaryanaFAO/2994/2006allowed

Santosh Kumar And ORS. v. Sukhdev Singh @ Sukha And ORS.

2018-07-30Mr. Justice Tejinder Singh Dhindsa5 pages

!"#$# %&'()(*+ $-./0 1# -1$ 2233 41$/$ ,/5-67,#%8-9,/5- -1$ $2 %6%

1$% & 1( 86#$- %"- :67 "

! 1 $( 1($-;

%# 3;

1:67 "

;# $(, %< , :67 "

! 11$2 %6% % ('( === -#$ #$ "3 $> 3 $5#%8 %- %"0% !

# %( 1#!3<# 0 <?% #"6

2 # %/%61,"

# %* !

- 1 4-#"3 "

;

$ !#36 ?! 1 - 1 ""#6% 3 #0$ 1#?/% 3:.

1% 3 -1#% ?1!116 "3 #0#%8

/% ! $(3 "$ % !6

- !1#@./0 -

#% 0 17-#"3

523 " %('(A(3 ;1 -;#6 ;: ; $ %$:6 /886;#6 ;60 -1 ! $$ /2 %?- 3! ! -"3 $;

%('(A ;-#3 $21 "6#%8 % ?#"<"3: B/ 3#$7-#"3?

1#%8 18#$

# %% ('')+?#%861#7%?<,/5-67,#%8-#% 1 $- %83#8% 0 %%1:$ 1/"5 #%$ -?#"<"3 %6 % !;-#"-$71 #%@/1#$;1$/!!16?<1#@./0

%6;- $/""/0?6 0("

?A< 1$ ! 8

#0 ! $; 15#%8 $315#% 7 (#8-,"- 3 %68

#%8

$(**:)'AC210 % $$ 1<!1 0 -6/"

# %2 :,

( ;

$!/1 -1 7116

-;#6 ;: ; $ %$:6 /8-

86 ;#6 ;6 0 -1 ;1

33< 62%6% % - 1%#%8$ ! -"3 #02 # %;

$" % 6?< - ;%1C61#71 3$

-#%$/1 %"" 02 %<?<!#3#%8$2

;1#

2 % -23 6#%8$ ! -2 #$: -! 33 ;#%8#$$/$;1 !1 06?< 3&

! "#

$ $

$ %&''

() *+ (

)

+ ,

. / , + +

&''

#+ + +

%&'' '

" +

#/ / , %&'3

. 34 $18 16$$$/ (*!#%6#%8$;11 /1%6#%!

7 /1 ! "3 %6# ;

$-36

- !1#@./0

523 " %

!#%@/1#$$/!!16#% #%7 37#%8 - !!%6#%87-#"3 #%D/$ %6 % -1 $- %6%83#8% 61#7#%8 !1$2 %6%

% (*,/5-67,#%8-( $18 16$D/ /0 !" 02%$

# %:1#?/% $$$$6 -3<#%" 0 ! $6 ? $(AC210 % -( 8 ! $6-

1$(66/"

# % !*C'16- $?%0 !1 0 16$3#7#%8 %621$ % 3E2%$$ !

' $6( 1#?/% 3?<

5#%8#% 1"5 %#%8

$/21 %%/

%'*(A(:-

-3<$ 1< $(AC21

!$/21 %%/

$/0 ! $(AC210 %

-1 1(< 6 2 #%8 /%#D/0 - 6 3 8< 0/3 #23#1 !**- $?% ?#!/1"

6#% ; " 02 %% $( -21# 6

$6; /36 710 #%6#%$17#": 0/3 #23#1 !- 223#6

#10% ?<

5#%80 % ? $(AC 0/3 #23#1 !)- ?% 223#6(-

$/0 ! $(:C- 166 16$ !/%1 3E2%$$: $(AC! 13 $$ !$

$(A:C % !

3 $$ !" %$ 1 #/0( -/$:

3" 02%$

166#%!

7 /1 !

"3 $#$ $(A:A:C 3 %8;# -#% 1$ 9)(AF!1 0

!#3#%8 ! - "3 #0 2 # % #33 "

/ 3 1 3#G

# %( H# ?#3# < 2 <

- $?%!

%6@ #% 3< %6$71 33</2 % 1$2 %6% $#(( - ;%1:61#71 3$ -#%$/1 %"" 02 %<( ,#%" - %3<#$$/#%7 376#% -#%$

3#$;# 18 16 D/ /0 !" 02%$

# %:- 7- 16" /%$3! 1

3$ ! 1 -" % #%81$2 %6% % ('%$/1 %" 02 %<( % - " %$#616 7#; ! -#$ /1 : - !

# % 166 ?< - 1#?/% 3 1D/#1$ ? 1 $$$$6 $/#

?3<%- %"6( - $8 %/%" % 1 71

$ 1<$

$6 ! 1 - ! 1"-:A- 6?% 66/"6 %1" 16 $E( IC 1!3"

#%8 -

3 $ 1< ? $(*:+C 21 0 % -( ,/"- $

3$ 1!3"

6"1

#%66/"

# %$#% -%

/1 !" % 1#?/ # %

16$ 1 7#6% /%6 "( -"

11<- 0$ 1<;

$$- ;% ?

$(+C %6;-#"-- $?%1 /%66 !! ? $(AC210 % -(-#$

- $$$$6?< 3( % " %$#6167#; ! -#$ /1 $" 00#

11 1#%

5#%8 $(*:+C $ - 0 % -3< #%" 0( - 66/"

# %$ 0

16$ 023 <>$ " % 1#?/ # %C 1 7#6% /%6 "(; /36 - 7 ?

" %$ 1/6 ?2 %62 1"3 ! -$ 1< ! -023 <(-#$; /36 $2"# 33<?$ ;-% -D/$ 1#$$;# -18 16 $$$$0% !

" 02/ " 02%$

/%61 ?%!#"# $"-0 !38#$3

# %( "" 16#%83<:# #$6#1"

! 12/12 $$ !

" 02/ #%8" 02%$

-3<$ 1< ! $6; /36?

$(*:+C( -1#?/% $1#8- !/33<

8 ! $61#@ ./0

1$ $ %

$6 %$17#"1" 16

66/"6( .2#%8 #% 7#; - %/0?1 ! 62%6% $C"3 $ 1#?/% 3 /8- ?- 70 6 *C -66/"

# %!1 0 -3<#%" 0 ! $6 0 / -#$21$ % 3C3#7#%8E2%$$(-$ 0#$$ 6#1"

6( -1#?/% $!/1 -1116#%?#!/1"

#%8 -#%" 0 ! $6#((;-#3-#$#%$17#" 1 #10% %63#5;#$- 7#%8

223#6 0/3 #23#1 ! -#%" 0 ! $6 8 !

$/21 %%/

0/3 #23#1 !)2 $ 1 #10% (,/"-" %"2 #$ 3#%

3621#%"#23 !" 02/ #%8" 02%$

# %/%61 - 14-#"3 "

($21 8 ! $6#((A< 1$ %6?<52#%8#%7#; 21#%"#233 #66 ;%#%

:0/3 #23#1 !** /8-

- 7?% 223#6( #$$ 6#1"

6(-

-1!1/8 3#% 16#%8 $/0 ! $(AC#% 33/%61 -" %7% # % 6$#((3 $$ !" %$ 1 #/0:!/%1 3E2%$$ %63 $$ !$

"($/0 ! $():C #$: $ $/"-: 166 /%61 - " %7% # % 3 - 6$ ?< ! 33 ;#%8 -6#"

/03 #66 ;%?<,/210 /1 #%"

$ !

! "

% #

& '

&( -12 1 %;-#"- -#02/8%6 16; /36 1D/#10 6#!#"

# %#$

$% 81 %<#%"1 $#% #%" 0 16$!/ /121 $2"

$(.2#%8#%7#;

$ %

210 %% @ ?#(($17#%8 315/%61 -6/"

# %2 :

! %6;

1$ ! 8 $ %

#%"1 $#%#%" 0 !*AF 16$!/ /121 $2"

$#$ 3$ 166( % 7#; ! - 6#$"/$$# % ? 7: - 17#$6C1 $$$$6

#$; 156 / $! 33 ;$& ,1( ( 3"/3

# % *( %" 01 /%66 !!

*:C210 % ( *AF #%"1 $ #% #%" 0 16$ !/ /1 21 $2"

*:J*AFK*':+C '( *C - 66/"

# %$ 16$21$ % 3E2%$$ ! *':+LK'AC *':+'AK*:'AC ( 02%$

223<#%80/3 #23#1 !** *:'AE*K*::C *::E**K*'::C A( %7% # % 6$ ):C (

*'::J):K $(*:':C - ! 1"

3"/3

617#$6C%- %"6 " 02%$

# %

? 22 1 # %6#%D/ 3$- 1$ 0 %8$ -"3 $C 3 %8;# #% 1$ 9F!1 0

!!#3#%8 ! -#%$

3 "

/ 3#G

-1 !( 22 3#$ 33 ;6#% ! 1$ #6 10$(

%6#%8 223#"

# %$ #! %<:$- 33 3$ $

%66#$2 $6 !(

3/"5< I- -1$2 5#%8C1 $ %6& $C I- -1 2 1

?3& $C