High Court of Punjab and HaryanaCRA-D/484/2019dismissed

Simarjit Singh @ Tinku v. State Of Punjab

2023-02-06Mr. Justice Sureshwar Thakur,Mr. Justice Kuldeep Tiwari25 pages

!"#$%#&'$()* * +

) ,- * ..

./ 0

,- * .0 - / ! "#$ % & '& !( )* +'&,-./.0123% % &'&4( )* +'&,-5.10123% %&4(%- ( 6"% - / 1* 2%

''&+'8+* *88 6 !8 10%1.%0123('+('#"&!4!' *& ** &!#% 0% '')" &* '&*+ 9** ( !& ' ) &* + *)&*&( ( + * 10%1.%0123( "#' &&&

!(8&(&* %:: 0:%1:%0125(!& *& :1090129.;09:. + ,( &* & 6&'( -&&* 8&(<'"#('#')"*)&* +'++*&'" *&:10 <&'*&:.( (012+ ,( (')" < * $ %%#(&#2(3#4 .#&"$(

#4$3 **

(# (#%!25"

:10 <&'*& :.+ , %%+&+ %21(1119 %%+58' 012+ , %%+;# %=(1119 %%+=8'

''*< **#%

:% '*&#+ +8'8>?% 2@+ ' *8& ' 8& > A2@ >'&+ + ' B*8&B@( <'&*' < * "# %9% %%( 6& &!'

> A2:@>'&++ 'B)&!&++&*B@% # +*( ' 8 >?% 2@ + ' *8& & * ' $ C '8& +") 8#&)&' "# &!"<4%#'" & &0122%'). !' 0%#. !' ( ( + '8( 8# #! !'4' 8&<! "00#(<'

<8& &86&&!' &49&!'( D"&&4'9" &'&(A %2(6&'(" .#"*4%88 &#+8&!(8#&< &86&&!' &4* '*'*+8# !' !&)"&!8# !' '% # !' 4' 8& ' (

+ 8#(-&6&!'(! "0#%#& < # 8# !' +8 ' 8&8&'+!&)&!'"&! )# &8!++* *88&"<'8(<&'' &)&+*"+'&!( (' "*4'&<'% <(&*23%:%0125(8# !' 4' ' " 8&&! +8 ' &<B ' <' 4 8# &< " <'"+8# !'8#&8('& ' ' 4<<'&'%8+#*+& ' 8# !'4' 8&'"4& "#8# &<&86&&!' &4( (' & +' " #%<*8&!&+8&*( (# ')88%*&"4%E '"&+'")8(' < !& !&'9** &86&&!' &4%

.% + !&& + ' ( ' )&!& ++&* *88* '&)&!& *'&!+'** % 0.%1:%0125(*&+*&+8&('9** &86&&!' &4< %&!&('++ &*8>?% 3@(0.%1:%0125(<'&('*+ '& *&8 &* '+*9** &'( (&*'+('!*) ' " #+'&<&+ 4' 8&(<'&*'<"& &(&&! &%' *) " #<4&&)& *)#88 >?% 21@( ('*)#<<& "#"&&!'(

&!'( (!& &!'( &"'& (6&'%' " # <& &+& "#F6<&!' *'&!'%' " # <+88?8&&%'8 #(&%%0.%1:%0125( ')&!&++&**&) '*&+8&(<'( '*9** &'< %"G#( 05%1:%0125( ' 9** &86& &!' &4 ++ ' &*8>?% 25@( (&*'+(' '&*#'&& * !*) '8*#*"&! %

10, .30/(<'&*'< +&!' " #%' *) 8*#*<4&&)& *)#88 >?% 2/@%'8 #(&%%05%1:%0125('*9** &'++ &*8>?% 2;@( '(' '&*#''+9** &86& &!' &4( (!*) ' >& '&@(<'&*'< + &!!&!'&(<'&' " #<"& %'*) < &D )& 88 >?% 23@% ' !' & < *) %'8+<&( *&252,% %,%(< *) %+*8&+'&)&!&(' &( *&2;:,% %,%(<+& "+'** G!&%

& &!'*?*&)#&""#'*+&(' G !& *88& ' * ' * + & )& *88& 13%13%0125%

& &!&8+*&*("''9** <

6 *'!' +*88&&+++*&'" *& :10(012( (.;0+ ,%'*&(& )&*( ?8& 8# 2. <&% ' 8 + "' ' 9** ( *&:2:,% %,%(<* (<'&( '# &** ! +&8&*&<'& #&! '!&) !&'8% 5% ' &,(+*8&+&(* ' ) &* + *)&*&( ( + * 10%1.%0123( <'"#("''9** ')"*)&* +'*'! +8 !&'8 *&:10 <&'*&:.( (012+ ,% ;% ' *+'9** &86&&!'

&4 ! ' ' & * & " *&*8& )& *( ('*&'"")'&4& *'&+*&*8*(**&)#"&''!&+' 9** % '+( ' 9** ) " *G& "#? &!'&8'"+&+ "%'+'! ' '! *)&('<')"++* '&*+ '9** ( *!#) (G& "#<% ' &,'*)&* '9** 8# '"&+*6* 8&% '8("#+&!*& * &*&&'&8&+*8&' 8&> A2@(

*'&!'> A0@( (4'<& > A:@('! '

*'* &*&+'*&H* ** &!#( ' *'! ' <&!+) &*+*)&*&G 9** (&"&!&"&'#+<% /% ' * &! "'+ + ' * 9** &'! '''" &' * # ' "& + &* 8 + * 9** &86& &!' &4% ' " # < ! *) "#&86&&!' &4'& &*8 "#'&8% +'! ')' &*8+ '9** (! #8 "#'&8(& 8&&"&' #+<(&*&8&&!8&< &*) &* '+(<'&*'* **'&8<&''*88&&+' *&8%)'<&('*)#(++* "G &* 8+'9** (&+ (<'&*'*&# 8"&''&!&% 3%

*(' *'& ' *)&(++* '&*+"''9** ( '&*&) &*8(') &* + *)&*&% ' * &* ' 8 + *8& ' 8& > A2@( *' &!' > A0@( ( 4'<& > A:@(& )' 8&)"'& *88&&+'*&8(<'8+'4

8> A21@()'&))8+"''9** %

'("#+&!'*&) &*8+"''

7 9** <'*)#88+ " #>?% 21@( '! '' * ' & ''< &6#84'+* *4%F#('! ''&&4 &'*'&+*&*8* +#"&' ) "#' *&( ('&)&#&!&#&'6 !8+ *)&*&(* "#' &,(<'&*'8#< #&+*% 21% ' * & " *&*8& )& *( '+(<')?8&'&4&'*'&+*&*8*( <'&*'')"&) ") "#'*&(**&)# "&!'8'!&+'9** %'8,(&& 6 !8 &

! "# $%&'()*)&&+$'& <+&)* &&*&( <'&*'&+* &!+& &!+*)&*&(&*" *&*8& )& *( &*& <'+ ?* ' $

# '*'+") !&&( ?8&'*&*8&)& *( "#'*&% .- .

. . 8 .

22% '*&'?8& ')&!&++&*+ '* A2:(<' <&'! *&+* &+8&0.%1:%0125(<'('** &86& &!' &4< %-&!&!&('** &86& &!' &4++ &*8>?% 3@( 0.%1:%0125(<'&('*+ ')8 '&<&+4'

8&23%1:%0125"#!&!'( '+('!<&' *9** &'*& ' " #8*#* &! &(<''# !& & "& ' " # '&% +' &* ' # ' ' * 9** 4< " ' *( <' ' " # < "& ( ('++ ! 8* '& *%*+ *' &* 8 >?% 3@( ' ' &* # ! *) ' " #+'&<&+4' 8&(<'&*'<"& &(&&! &%'&* +*)#< )& !' ( ('*) " #<4&& )& *)#88>?% 21@(<'&*'<<& "#"&&!'

&!'("& (& <&(&%%!& &!'( &"'& (6&'(<'<?8& A2.%' " #<& &+& "#F6<&!' *'&!'% 20% ')&!&++&*> A2:@+' '' 8 #('*&) '*&+8& '('* 9** &'< % 2:% -&! ' * + &!&( 05%1:%0125( ' ** &86&&!' &4++ ' &* 8 >?% 25@( <'&( ' &8&* *9** &'+*88&&+8 +4' 8&( ( &* '23%1:%0125('(<&'*88&&+'&*&(&%%* 9** &'( 8 '& <&+ 4' 8& "# !&!

' '+(*& '" #8*#* &! &+& &% +' &* ''*! *) '8*#*(<'&*'< &&+' " #%*+*' &*8>?% 25@(' ' &*#'&& * !*) '8*#*"&!

10, .30/( <'&*' < 4 & & )& *)# 88>?% 2/@% 2.% '8 #(&%%05%1:%0125('*9** &'++ &*8>?% 2;@(<'&(' 8 &*'8&+9** &86&&!'

&4 G 8 + 4' 8&( <&' *88 &&( ( "G& "&+' " # &(&

&! &% ++ !' > '&@*) ( <'&*'< + &!!&!'&( (*'(' ' &*#''+9** &86&&!' &4( (!' >& '&@*) (<'&*'<&D )& 88 >?% 23@% -8 2=% )'*+ '+' * ('*& '?8& -%8&!' &( &*++&*(,&)& &( 8&( A.% '0=%1:%0125(&*& >?% =@"&!8) "#')&!&++&*+* *&!' 88 + ' " #( -% 6& ( %%%( ,&)&

&(8&(*& +-*+'& ( <'&*'*8& '&8(-%& &!' -% &' '!% ) * ' 8?% 5%* *&!' 88' " #('+<&!")&<* "#' +-*$ C'!'+'" #<50&*'%< " # + 8 # &' +8( <&! " &&! '&(!#68 " <%-& 8 <)'" #%&!8&<"%

88&&!<"%?8&&+ " #(<+ ' &'"<+'#+& *8&!+8*)&#% 8 <& *)&#% &' &*& ) ' " 8% &*&+8'('#? '! &'"<+'#+& *8&!+8*)&#%

8 <&*)&#% &*&+ '? &' &*&<)' *' "'! '+'&'!&* ?8&&% " <&''% &*& +" 88&& ! && < + *'8&* ?8&&% F&)( ( "' 4& # < + *'8&* ?8&& '&'!&*?8&&% <+'&'!&*?8&&% '""&8' "<&6& ' < " * % ' "" &"< ' 88?8&& <<&'&<4%E

+' ' & < * ?8&&+'*'8&*?8&H( (''&'!# %** &!''&'!#(' * <! '< ++2.%=*8!'% <)('*+ '

* "*& ()+8'*'8&*?8&H( ( ''&'!#% 25% '& , ' ?8& ' 8 >?% 5@(<'+ &*'( +&&*+ '+' * <'&"#' *(<&!+&8%

<)(+8'+& ")&* "#" + *( < ( ")& * & ' 8 C$

& '

&#('&,*+#** '' * ' & '%(<'+'!''+*8+' ++&! '(&'*)#+' " #(<'&*'<

"& &("#'9** % 8 2;% &*'! ' + )&! ' 8&) "'& *88&& + ' *&8( ' *& ' ?8& *8&' 8& A2(<') * '8 >?% 2@(" <'(' <!& %' ' ' !' 4' >&* * @ < 8& ' ** &86&&!' &4+#"*4( (<" +'&< *4% <)(+'8&!('** &86&&!' &4 "&!' !'( (' '+8'8&8&'(' " '*'*%)# &8(' ' !'

"*4'8&8&'<&' '&)&+*"% <)(&*'(0125('*8 4< ' ' !' < 8&&! +8 ' 8&8& '( <'('G& "'+8'** &86& &!' &4("(' & !&)#&+*##%'( '*' ' !''<)('<)(* ! 4< #'&! " '% &#( "&! +# *+& " &))8+'** &86&&!' &4"'& ' 8&&!+' !'('! ! ' %+"' #+ !&!' ('** &86&&!' &4 !*) ' " #+' !'(<'&*'<"& &(&&! &%' +**'&*&&) !'#*?

8&&(<'&(&+* '' !'( &!

+ ' &+&8( ' 8) *8& !& ' ** &86&&!' &4(' &* (& - ( '+(*88&<&) "<'8% 2/% '*&'?8& *'&!'(* + * 4'( A0(<' '8&+ *8&' 8&> A2@(! &!' * "&!!&) "&!( ("&! +8'8&8&'"# ** &86&&!' &4("*+&*&)'*'*% ) &!'&*?8&&(' 'G"<' * '** &86&&!' &44*& '&*( ('< 8# &8&8& !&! *88& ++* % <)( &! *?

8&&( ' 8& '' * ' &(<')(<&''* 9** &'% 23% ' ? <& ?

8&> A2@ *'&!'> A0@% &&'(' *&+&*# ''** &86&&!' &4 ' (8#&8(' 4&' * %A''< *?8&&"#' +**('&!8&* " &*& '+8&8*'')*&#+'&8#% 01% '+(**&)##D&!'8+' +& ' <&( '& , +& # 8&

* &*&'&( (&*+#"** ''& 8* &"( (<'#"* &*%' 8&)!&'** &86&&!' &4("'& *88&&+'*&8( *!&*#) "#' +& 8('<)(8&)(<')("*8&! '&('*9** &'% %

02% '8&8<&(+'&(?8& "# '*&&'4 8> A21@(<' '23%1:%0125( "1/$:1%8%(<'&&!8&+8 '!','&( <''*' (6&'('<"'' ** !&!8*#*( (' * <&&!&"< '8'8*#*("('<**&'&8% & ?8&&&*'&+"*8?* ' $ C')" &!"&+# %8 ')&! ! & <&' ' +8&# + * 4'(<'<8& <&'&86&&!' &4( ** &'*%23%:%0125("/%:1

( < *8&! "*4 +8 '!' ,'& 8&%A'*' 6&'(< &86&&!' &'("'** & '*(!&!8*#*%4'<&++&86& &!'<"#8<'&&&!&"<"' ** '8*#*("('<**& '&8%8#4&!(&86&&!' 8 ''#4&!'&<&+4' 6< &( 6&'('<+&!<%F(*8 4< ' "' ** & ' * ')

6 *88& 8 +4' ' "& ' " #8<'%'+(*' '&* !* 8#8%E -&!*?8&&(' ''' 8' ** &86&&!' &4!<&'' * 8# &8% +' ''!'(' * <'&&)( #( * <4<'&8'+8&#88" <'&<''&& *(<'&*'84&*''<+8&& '8% 00% '+(+8'&8#+'4 8> A21@(& 8#) '"''9** < *#&!' * (8*#*(+4&&!'%&'* +'*&'' * <&)&'*8#+ "''9** <4& '+('(&&'* +'*&'+4&&!'('<*& "#"'' 9** (8*#*(<''#<&!' "#'4

8> A21@% 0:% A')?8& '&* +' &, <'&8! ) &*+*)&*&%A+& '' &,'&!'#*)&* '9** &86&&!'

&4+*88&&!'8 +'&<&+4' 8&('<)(< +& #8&!&'*9** &' ! &!'&&))8&'8 + * 4' 8&%

)'( ' & !' )& * )&" * ( <'&*' "&'''*9** &'' '&*&( &%%9** &86&&!'(&&! "#&!' " #% 0.% F!&)& &)& +& &!++8&!'") &&G"''9** &'*% 0=%

&#( <&''+9** &86& &!' &4(<'' "G'&(8 &* 8 >?% 3@( 0.%1:%0125( <'&( ' *+ ') 8 '&<&+4' 8&23%1:%0125"#!&!'( '+('!<&'*9** &'*& ' " #8*#*&! &(<''#"& ' " # &%*+'& &*8>?% 3@( '!*) ' " #+'&<&+4' 8&(<'&*'< "& &( & &! &% ' & * + *)#<)& !' ( (&<<& "#& <&( &%% !& &!'( &" '& ( 6&'( <' < ?8& A2.

"#'*&%'+(8+# " &+! &!'!&+'*)#* &!+' " #%'+(05%1:%0125('8 ' &*8 >?% 25@(<'&(' &* '23%1:%0125('(<&'*88 &&+'&*&(&%%*9** &'(8 '&<&+4' 8&"#!&!' '+(*& ' " #8*#*&!

7 *+*' &*8>?% 25@('!*) ' 8*#*"&! %

10, .30/% 05% # &* ")& &('8&)!&' 9** &86&&!' &4("'& *88&&+8 +'&<&+( ) +8'&8&+*8&'

8> A2@( *'&!'> A0@( (4'<& > A:@( <' '&'' !&)"&!' * '+8'8&8&'('* " '*'*% 0;%

'8( ' * + ' *&( !& ' 9** &86&&!' &4(!&!'+8' &8*' &8#+'4 8> A21@(<'' (+' &8('&8 '*9&'4&!' * 8<'( & **&* &&( 8*#*% '+('&4(&'*'&+*&*8*(<'&*') * "#'*&("# #" "() "'4' 8&<4& "#9** &86&&!'

&4% 0/% <( )'+'*9** &'(<'' '&(8 &*8 >?% 2;@(<'&('8 &*'8&8 "#' 9** &86&&!' &4G8 +4' 8&( <&'*88&&( ("&+' " #% *'

&*8('!*) >& '&@(! #

+ &!!&!'&(<'&(' " #<"& ( ('&' #*)#++* +8'&8%?**' &*8(' &)& *)&"* (**'&8<&''*88&& +'*&8% 03% <(<*& &)')& &#)+ ' * &* 8 >?% 2;@( 8 "# ' 9** &'%+'& &*8( ( ' *)# ++* '( '< ' ' # 8&&"+'&8(&'& &*"'&**&! ' (<'&*'<!

*) "#'&8%'+'* +'& &*8 &*#'&"#)&&+*&0=+ ' &)& **>'&++ I*H@% 8#( 8& + +&# & *' ' *+& 8 *&*8*()& &*&0. 0=+'*%*&0. 0=+'**&"'*&*8*(<'&*'84*+& & 8&&"% <)(?*&')&&&*&" & *&05+'*(** &!<'&*'(*+&8 "## <'&"&!&* #+ &*++&**") !& *'(&+*'*+&&8 &'&88 &*+ !&%*&0;+'*")&*&(0.

( 0= 05+'* 84 8&&"8*'+'8 +** 8 <'&"&!

,-."

"/"0 !1"## ! " "2!/"3!(( )

-+"

!60! "4"#/"0 !

" "2!/"3!7

8(()

+ !

-9"685 "# #"8 "

!3!#"8

! 842!/"3!:: $!

# *6& &!+''*&*# &* ' *+& 8 "+ &* ++&*( <'&*' & '<& & 8&&"( '<)( "*8 8&&" & )& * <' ' &+8&!&)"#** ')&!&++&*** &*)# + +*( '% ( # ' & + &+8&*") (<'&*'( &&*&)#&*#(' +* &*) %+'8< " *+& 8 "+&*(*G#('&"#)&&+*&0=+' *% :1% '*'+'") &* !)&&( '&,+& '' &*88 "#9** &'("+&*(&# 8&&"'?'' '

)&!&++&*'*<''' '& ' ! &*) '+8(<'(+'8&& 8&&"( '&"#)&&+*&0=+'*% :2% '*)#<'&*'<++* +8'9** &'&#&4 *' '+*'&< + "#&!' " #( ('< &*88&&+ 8 % :0% (8&)'"&! ) !&' 9** &'%+*( *'&!'> A0@(<'< ?8& "#'*&+'<&)'8&)( '*!&*# 8& ''9** &'' &<')<&'' * % ::% '# 8&&")& *!&'9** &'&'&8#+'4 8> A21@(<'' # '&8 '*9** &86&&!'<&'' * %

<)( #"# &* ")(&&<''* + ' *& ' '4 8 > A21@ ' 4'

8&&)&'*8#+"''9** ('(' *+'*&&'(+4&&!4' 8&(' " # < "#"''9** (8*#*( &!*'&('#<&!' "#'4 8> A21@% ' '# + C &)E ' " "# &* & 86 !8 "#8, '&,% &)*& + '#( <&' ' "&! # '

*"&))& *"&'&!'G&&&4&'*'&+ *&*8*(< '&+'" ** %' 6 !8 &*& 5;!" "

!"# ( -<-&=+)=(' B"8,'' $

! &

0 1

2 *3

4!4 5 67 84''86 !

& & !

;

2 6 <

' !

# (&'6 !8 &*& !! >?

!"#

8(%-<&'*&=-('$' B"8,' ' $ 7

+ !

;

# '*('9** &'< #*#&!' * (8*#*(!<&''* 9** &86&&!' &4( (+8&' &*8('&'*&*8&)& *(&' ! ) * !&'&8(<'&*'&*"+)&!'& &))8&4&&!4' 8&(<&'*88&&+'* 9** &86&&!' &4%*'(' '&+'** ('(&#'*&)'& !&(<'( &* ")('*&'+& % '+('8( '#&""9** &'&'&&))8<&''*9** &86& &!' &4&"#&!

' " #(& **'*&8+ *9** % <"<&''&*&** & **8+' " #('+(*G'&8'*'! < + ++* &'" *& 012 + ' ,% ,&*#('")*&'!+' *&84&!*("(&!

('** ** & +*&&'&*&** &<&'**' " #'!'"#&!'8&&% *'(*& &!'&#+'+* *&*8*(' *& ' 8&"# +& "&! '8 ' !& + 9** &'(G'*'!+8 !&'&8 *&:10 <&'*&:.+ ,%< "* ' ''&,')+8 '*'! *&:.+ ,% <)(<?8&&!('&*('!&#+' 6 !8+*)&*&(* "#' &,( *&:10 <&'*&:.+ ,(&'"*+*&+&* *'!"&!+8 *&:.+ ,% :.% '+( & ' "* + # *)&*&!

)& * )&"* **'9** &'<&'' *88&&+8 +' * (< 8&& & '6 !8+*)&*&(&8*'&&*)&*&+ 9** &'( *&:10 <&'*&:.+ ,(<'&8&&&!'&*)&*& *&012+ ,(+ &!'&!' '*9** &86&&!'& &&!

:=% )&<+'+& &*&(< +& #8& &'("&! %,-./.0123(+ "#' ** &86&&!' &4 ** &!#('8&'"# 3'9''#3% <)( ' ( "&! % ,-5.10123(

6 + "#'*9** &'&:!4"5;!55$<#3 '?''&*)&*&( *&:10 <&'*&:.+ ,( & & ( "( '& *)&*& *& 012 + , & 8&& ' % :5% '9** (&+&* #('+'<&'" 4&* #'+'*>@&8 % :;% '*#(&+#(" <&'&** *<&' <+?&#+'& +&8&&++&&!%' * "+'<&' <% .

./ 0

0 - / 15%10%010:

)& A''4&!9 $J9 A''"$J9