High Court of Punjab and HaryanaCRR/4433/2016dismissed

Ganesh Kumar Bansal v. State Of Punjab

2017-03-06Mr. Justice Dr. Shekher Dhawan9 pages

#$%$ & $ '$ $$

$ &$

&( & )*+),-.

*,/0%**1,#*2(

*0* 1(( "045

*67 ( $+8 9%:

# 1

# & 1

& &1$ $+8 9%:

# 1

# & 1

& &1$ $+8 9%:

# 1

# & 1

& &1$ $+8 9%:

# 1

# & 1

& &1$ " ( " ( " ( " (+ /1&72-$7 )( (, 6

;<;<;< ;<;<;< ;<;<;< ;<;<;<

# & 1

& &1$-#

# & 1

& &1$-#

# & 1

& &1$-#

# & 1

& &1$-#

*((

*6 ((*7 )( 7=*((,

7 7( 7> 6** 75@(, 7$77(1 *** #07= -:07,( *2,),66)(

75@(,

1 )(.(, ") 70

A= ,* 7*),= )* ! - 07 )(*--.->-.-8%(, 7"

71 )(*7 72(,1 )((, "

( 06( $)(- ?>>- =*( 7 ( ") 1(( 3=)

%0 0-:07,,*5

7 )

10) ((() (,((, 6 2*2A= 6*($***((( -!) 7$))0(*(, )

10= -:07,((,

(6((

2 *(7* *06 0( $ =(*- 0(8*, =*( (,

7 (, )8))0* 7- , = = 7 7

(6 7 2(, (,

( 7 * =7= )( 507= (7*)(

(07*((, ) 10= -:07,

7)0* 66 =(, 6 *05(* (,( (, 6 ( 7 7 )(0( 6* )0(2070((50* 6) **2 :

)0* ,*

7() ( B) 6(* 6(7( *05(( 7 5@ 16 )

*(=(

1 ( )( 7(,(7=,*5

)7 7,7=(, 6 ( (

( * * =0 7 (,( (, 2 == 7*) 6) * (, 507= ( ( ( (( * **0 7 (,

7) 7))0(*0),7*) 6) *(, (( * (=(:07,&*()(2,),2 )

7(, )

70= (, ) @ * 8C 7 C8 (,( (,

*5 =,** 770( ( (* 7* (,((, *87

7-@-2*((, ,7*(, )*(,

& )(-

(, 1 ) * "045 7 ( 5@ (, 6

7)0* =0 *(,(*6 * (( 72@(,=*7

2(,70 ) 7)0(-(, (2075 6 *0 7(,(*0), )( ,* 5

7 =7 (, 7 )( (()( ) 6* )0( '

((, )( (* 7*(,((, ( 507= (=0 *2 (0(D 7(, * 6* 77-* *0),- (, 2* E0 *( 2=0= ))0= ( (,

@ 2=0 ** , = 5

)0* ( * *05(( 7(,(07 ))0*() *)(5 )*(0 7(,( ,*5

@*8666(

7)0* (, 6 ,*5

, 7(

=(,7(, 6 7=* )7,

6 0*

*)6 7 5( )* 62 07 )(*.7>(, ") 70 ) ( B 75@(, 95 106 0(F1(( %,

1(( %,

*,1=,G-$ ?..1> *,1=,G-$ ?..1> *,1=,G-$ ?..1> *,1=,G-$ ?..1> (2*, 7*2*+ F 7 1 )((, 2, 6 =(, )*

(, 6* )0(-(, 6* )0(,*=((7 *)5

),= =*( (, ))0* 7 7 *(( 5@ 2,(

7 , 66* * ( 6

(, =0( (,

))0* ( ) * ( (, ( *(= (,

70(@(, 0(()*7 )7(, )*

7(, 7)0 (**05(( 7(, 2(,7(, *05***(, ))0* 77(, 6* )0( (,(5 , #07= ,*(6**(, ( 7

(, 1 )(.1 )(>(,

F(, #07= )*7 *(,((, *(*0) (=07 6)

7==*((, ))0* 7-, *,7*),=

))0* 77 )7,* ***7=G-*

4 75@1 )(.

-(, (, ,7-(,

#07= * (, 6 (,( (, * =07 6 *0=(,((, ))0* 7,*)(( 7

2,),+8 5* B)0*

@(5 5@(, 0(-, *, 2(=),= =*((, ))0* 7-*6 7 7 )(> 7=(, (26 **(= 40B(6*(-*(, @,

=((5 -(2075 ) (,(((, 5 ==7(, (*(= (, (

(0(,-

)(@7 )((,

7 2,),(,

"* )0( 66* * ( 770) ( ( 5

()00*@407= *@2 =,((5 ((), ( (, 655 7 (, ))0* ( * ( 5=(@(, #07= ((,(*(= (, (( )*7 @7 (72 =,* *(

2, (, )(*- 6

7 207 5 )6(5

2(, (, ) (, ))0* 7 (

*(77( *(7407= (2,),*(5 @ 66 75 )7=7= =7=(, =0( (, 2* (, ))0* 7*( B)(@(5 66 ((, *(= 7 )7=(, (( 1 )(.

1 )(>(,

$((,(*(= (, 0(* ( ( *

2, (, * *0) ( =07 ) )((, ))0* 72, (**0 (

7,*) )( 1(= *0*6)=*((,

))0* 7- (, (( * (, = *0*6)-)((A (, 6) 6,*=0(( ))0*(, ( %0(((, (*(= **(=*0*6)2,), 7*(, 0(( (,A (,( (, * =07 6 *0= (,( (,

))0* 7,*)(( 7 (, (*(6 ((, 0((*@(,((, **0) (=07 6)

7==*((, ))0*

(, )(*(, 6 ()* -(2075 66*( ( (A ( (,( H("

(( .5@2@ 605) ( *( ) ( 5 7 (,* 0( 7 2,

7 )(*,75

*0=,(( =*( ))* =*((,

6 (6 7(, -(, 5**(, E0@ 6( 7( 7 *05(( 7 5@ (, 16 )

*(=(

1 " (6 2*6 7 7*6(@8 *67 ( H( "

(( . 10), 6 (( 2* 7*6* 75@& *% ),(,*0( 7 2=5* (*2 )7 7+ FH ,

6 0* 7 (, 6( (, 16 )

*(=(

2,), B6)(@ )7* )** =)(*5@(, *67 (* C7 )(- *0), )(*- 6 ) - 0( ( )**)=D5 (,(**-(,

)) 70(,(@(, 1((

(*70(@ 507( =*( ! =*((, *67 (* 77

*(=( (, * 7(A ) **@ )( =*( (, ))7) 2(, 2 H - -7 )((, *67 (* 7()( ))7=@7 *0 (,((, 5**(, 6( (, 1 *( 6* (A =*((! 7 70

*(=((, *

( -)( ))7) 2(,225 (A =*(2,@ 07(5

,*27*6* (, "05) ( *(:(=(

17I8 $ #$ !# 1

17I8 $

3 # &

,* 0( ,* 6 0* 7 (, 60= 7 7 7( > 7 )=(, 66)( 75@(, 6 )(.(, ") 70 *

A=7*),=

=(* =*( (, 6 ( 6 7 )8))0* ,

70@() 7(, 2=( *+

=(*=*())0* 7 *,/0 %*- $***(( ( !) 7 $))0(*- 7106 ( 7 (1(*,/00(*, 2 (,( ( (,

( ( (, @ 2 2A= *0), )6)( * (, ) 10= - :07,

@,7=( )*, 7(, 5*( *066 07 , 7) B6 * *5@ (=0

@ 77 ( )*, (, 5* 07 (, ) )( 7* @ = 7(,((, 2 )*, 7(,

5**%07= ($( ( (( * E0@) * 07(,(2, **0=%07= (*07 7 (, 7*- $0(,(@ ,7 *(0)( 7 (, (,( (, 6 7= 5*H( - )()(@71 = 5 )*, 07 (,*, 77 =0(5 *6 ( (,* ( * %0( (, ))0* 72=@( 6 ( =(, (( *& )(( 7=(

)*, 7(, 5*(, ( * @*,7= 507= (( ( (( *5@),==(, 507= ( @ =0 *0), (( 7( 7 C .

C (=() B6 * *-(, @),= 7(, =0 J )*(J?)* (( 7( 7 C)

B6 * *-(, @),= 7(, =0 J)*(J.)*

(, (( @)( 72*J.->C-I8 50(2*( 7(J.->C-I8 1@-(, (( (, =0 JI8 2* ),= 7 ( J-I8

$(, =0 J-I82*),= 7(J--I8

507= (( (*)( 7, 7) -(,

=0 J>---??I82*),= 7(J>-->-??I8 5@= @ @)(( 7*= **0), (( *7=(( 7 0(* )*, 7(,

*0@ >

*= 76( 7 5@ (, 0( ( 7 ) (,

66)(7*),= 75@(, 6 ,*5

)0), (, 2=( *+ F( * * (( 7 66*( 2 (,(

*0*6)* 0=,( ),= =*())0*

(, )* ,7(, *E0( 6) 7 50A@

7 (, 606*

0 5 7)0 (* *,2= )** = * 2(, 60(@ 5@ (, ))0* 7 6(@ ( (,0=,@5 ((

7 *(2,

))0* 7 6(@ ,7 )

7 *0), 507= ( ( ( (( ***0),(, & )(( 50(**(,

*7 )7(,((, 7)0 (*(

(, ) 10= -:07,((, :)

*0@ )*, ( H(,0( 8( (= (,

)(*(, )* )( 7(, 5

*7 6( $ B0 8C *05(( 7 5@ 1 - ( *

( ( (

(,((, 5

*7 )(*@*0),

> 7)0 (* *,2= 5(( ) *8)70)( 6())0* 72, 5@(, @ = 7@(6 2(,(, 507= (( (=0 *7),= 7(, 7=(* * 2 * 27* ( ( 7 =0 !

B6 (( (, 0( J ) 2* )

( 7(J)*-(, (( 0( J--I82*),= 7(J--I8 (, (( 0(((=J>---??I82*),= (J>-->-??I8 (, (( 0(J.

)*2*)

( 7(J.)*),==(, (( J.--C-CI8(J.--C-CI8 (, (( -(,

0(J)*2*),= 7(J?)* (, - (, =0 J?-I8 2* )

( 7 ( J-?-I8 **7)0 ( )7( )((,((, 60),* )((

-, 7 75@ 10= *-

,7* 77 7* 7) *I(, ( *)) 7) ,*)((

)( *6@ (, 7 7 * 7 5@ (, 1( /

*0* 0(,(@-*0* )( 707*(, 606* * (, 6 (( 7 7 (, 00(,D 75(( = @I(6 = 0(* 5

*7 (( *6) 2*7 5@6 (0))0* 2(, (, (, 10= * &

2 7 & 47 /0 G

(, )*7 7 2 (,* 0(- (, 60= 7 ,* 5

6** 7 *()(@ ( * (, 6 ( * =

= )* 62 1 )(.(,

") 70 7*7725@(, $6 B0( *, *, *, *, 1=,9* 1=,9* 1=,9* 1=,9*)* *06

)* ( )* (,

* 40*7)(*7 0(

((7***

# & 1

& &1$

# & 1

& &1$

# & 1

& &1$

# & 1

& &1$ ),-. ),-. ),-. ),-. # &

# &

1 1 1 1

( +

( + H, *6 A=I * 7K '

*I H, 6(5 K '