Besco Limited v. State Of Haryana & ORS





  
   




 

!"

#$%& '( )(* #(+ ,( '

-&  .

/ $.

 #
.

 / $.

 #
#0   ( .(021&3.(45*- .(#,,4(-,3

&23(,-( .64.73 3(+3 ((-&!8 .(0%6#,76 .( 5,&3 &23 ((-&9  ,-(3:(6&%-(70,( ;!<8;

=3 < ;

=38< ;

=3 < ;

=3>< ;

=3!

< ;

=3 ?< ;

=&.*68>;?< ;8= *&  )667.6-*(3 ,6 ,(*,(3 ( :(  , @  6 && && !8 !> ?3 , 24& , :( 5*(&  , *(3 ,6677 , A*  6& 2&  && !8

!

 *& *&( # 9  , $& A* 3 ! >9 <( ,( B, /=3 66:&@+&&!

!!*&*&(#?,  ,-(,,667&,&A*-(&7 ,7(*&,,-(&(,-(,@7(&-(%( ,7  6& *  !C 8!> 3 @* , -(5 *6&  @  *-  ,(*,(,6&%*(7!06?.(6:(6(A*(&(, -*(-  6 7,:+ &3 ,((3 , 6& %*(7 9? 06 C .(6  *7,  @ A*(& ( 7 *-   &*(6 ( 2& , %-*7&,:(-

,&,(-&,:(;%,,:( - , @ 6& ( *%  :(&  !

!8 
  -&*,,-(%,76&*D-(&,+(!> ? (26&+-(&:+(
-&*,,-(, 4+2-(7*-&*(6*&*(7,-(&

?+(
6-&*,,6&-((%7-(" %(:&*(+7(@667:,; E8 %((2(&@& #((&,27(:

%(&8 %(,(-&,2 6-(&*&6+*-6 D*( ;! $(& *6 ( , -( ((   2 , 5*&7%(&(&1!989 

!!6&B#*6#7, ,() #(+ ,(/&&& >!!

!83&,&( :*&@+,*(,%(2,((*&( A* & &( , &(@6+  (67 , 6& ( -(-(3 :,,*666,((,2(%-6+,--6@6
3,*3 &&,,6%,-(@D%&,67,,& 5*&7%
6-&*,,&(&(*@5%(#-6 $2@(,/@6#*-(%*(3:,(*A*( -(&,@7(& , 2 ,  , *(  #*6 #7,/  <*-(= @(2&*&( F"

 1,6 ,( %+  @ + 6676+  (67 , 6&G-(-(+.G,4$7(.G,*-#-7 & 127 .66 (% A*
 @*   %-(2 *- , # 2(%  @ &( & D& %6( (%  66 ,( %6(6+ -6& 6&:(  , @ & @23  : 66+ &6 & (** , , (H%%,--&2*55(;,6(&&5* *&,,*7(**(1(,*7#,&@677.G ,4$7 ,%%,&726+,

8   (-  :,, @5 *&( # ";  :( (2&3%(,-@6,,(%+,2@2(6 ,(64(**(:,,:(6*;(6&(%A* I(,4$7:-(*&6-,2 :2(,7&,(H%%,,( %6(6+-6&%+,2@(*#D( :*&(4&+,(**(G@*6&7,(:( :,,*7,&&*@%@5*&(#"; @*,( -(-( &(2&  @ (6& *&( , -6+ && ?, @(3

C3,*,((@67&(;(, & D& , @  2(% -6+ ( , # 2(%H&66&D-,(**(:,, & 6& :2( :66  %+ @ , 2(%H &(6,6&&@*6&7.G,4$73 , &6  *, @  ,( *&& @* &(27 6&:(:*6&%*&6A*6+@(6:1 6,,%,-(,26 6&@5*&(#";

@*;*,+%7, @-(:,.G,4$7:,&7,6* &(:@+*(89,(&(+&(6+3: ,6&,26&:(&&6@5*&(# ";

@*@6%4*&6-(+3,4 A*6+ & *, A*6 @  ,2 @ 7(&  ,(%6(6+-6&:( DDD DDD I( , ( (;&3 , H-*@6 -*(-H  , A* @7  6*(+ - :(& , (7*6& &*(6  , #  *-,6& :2(3 , &6  @2(%6+(,(6&(+- 6&(-(-((%A*,(6&:(6*&7 , -( 6+  , -6  ;*@%  @5 *&(#";

&6(&6676&*66&#%6(6+3(  , 3 , 6%  -(+  %& *3 :*6& 6 (A*( (&( , (-& ( A*6+ &(&  &-*,(H%2,((*&(A* & &(, &(@6+  (67 ,6&(-(-( J6*&7  , -(K :,, *666 , ((  ,

9 2(%6+,--6@6,(H%%,66 @  6@(+  2 (, 6%  , (7(& @* 6+ , @*6&7G(**(,66@&(&(D%-:,,:(  D  , %  *  # 9  , D(,(7(&,66@%-6&:,-(&,( %,&66,*;A*:,(7(&,D7(**( ,66@%&L $(& *6 ( , (-& ,  @5 ( , &-6,-(:(-,67,,(&5*&7%
2:,,&6A*(-,% &&&&@+2 ,,*(#*6#7,/ <*-(=3,-(:(-&-&,%(%  

          !"#