← Library
High Court of Punjab and HaryanaCRR/4450/2016allowed

Kailash Katyal v. State Of Haryana And ANR

2026-04-23Mr. Justice Yashvir Singh Rathor15 pages





       

 

 

!!"##$%&

' 

      

"(!)%*"%&(

  

!!"##$%& ' 

     

"(!)%*"%&(  

   

     

   

 





  

 

   ! " 

  







 %&'% +,

- +





 '

   

)

* + ,$ + '

* -

' $ '

,..%"%

* /  - 0'1$ 2

 

 

&

,..%"%

 

& 

,..%%

* '

-

,

'

* 2

+ $ '

,..%%

 

&

,..%"%



& 

 

&

"

,..%%

 '

  

.

 #







(

   

 

  



&,..%"%

(

%- -



 "4

 +

$ 1  

+

4 , /, 



(

 



 



-  



&,..%%

(





+





 

 "4

 +

$ 1  $ 

+

4 , /,













+

$ 5 + .

(

 



!6.

&7"

 7"

+



6/,

/  +

$ 1  $

(



 

+

$

& $







8' +9

1  

+ & :

  ;

 "4



<





=



 



=

(







 

.

"$$>%

* 

+ $ - $ -

$ 5 +

(

 

  

  

. 1 $ 

 

* +- /

? &



( 

 

- $ -

$ 5 $ +

$ +- /

?

 

 * .

( (<

 

2





7"$



 

/

(

 '*$ 



(

"

/*$

    



* $



  











 

   $



(   

  2 





- $ -

:- -

%

;$ 5 $ +

$ +- /

? .







 

<



  0

 

*  

@ 

/0)1 (2)1& 3+)45  

A  -  * 

+ $

*>

+ A 2 / 

  

.

"





 

-   

(

 /

,   



 .

"$$>%

 

-  /

% - -

*@  

 %& 

 

 

(



+

 , /,  



% - 





- -

$ 5 $ +

+ .

 





<

 &

  "

,

+

$



 

+

4 , /,







+

$ 5 + .



  B +

$ 1  $

 

 "4





 

%- -



 











+

$ 5 + .

 

=



B +

 ( 



- -



*@



   

 $



$

  ! 

$



(

,..%"% 



(

&,..%% '

( 

(

  B  





- -



 

(  



 (



 

 B   A

 







!6.

<





 

+



6/,

 









 B  

 







!6.

 

 (

$ 

(

 B   A

 







 





(

<

A





 B   A

 



*@ <





 



-  



 $

*>

+ A 2 / $  (





 





 

+



6/,

,

 +











+

4 , /, 

  





 

<  C  







 







!6.

  

 

 7

 $  +  

 











!6.

 (



 (







*@

  

 

$

 B   A

 



 $

,





(



  

 



,

$

,

 



 

 

 

4 B   A

 

 





( 







 







+

$ 5 + .







 



 B   A

 



    



 



(

 <

 +

 

/ 



  

  :;

+,, 4$ $1*""!

6%72 '(

&$&"

)0 8%9$:

$%* )&2"1( :;

+,, $ 2$1$;

$# $%* )&2"1( '(

&$&"

)0 $1<$%$ $%* $%)&2"1

 



 



 

 6/,

# 

=







A

8(

 6/,



+

 6/,

%  ( )

"=&6)%  ,  +   

$ 

(



$

 





 

A  



 (

E

"=&6)%  , :"&;"%& )0 &26%7 )

(



$ !



F

+   





$

 

<





 





 

 



G #



)

 

 



 

!



( 



 

 6/,$ 

(

:;

:;



(



 6/,$

(

>



:;



:;

 





$

 

<





 



:;

 

 



 







 6/,



 

 



 

 '

  



 6/,





 



 6/,$

(



I



 ?

E  

 J E6

E





6  /  ,

DA

 

E 

E



$

<$



  



EE 

<

 

(





<

  = <



 





 

E@ E 





(







  = <



 





  E@ 

E 

A

E E

E #

 

? 



<$



   

"

 (





 H



EE E E







D 















E

E   + 





   

($

 

  #



  

 

  $ 

 <

 





+ $





E

E

 E





 



$



<







<   = <

  # (











(







 

  #





:;

+,, 7 $;"(2

8;$1 @(

&$&"

)0 22$&&6(7$12 

:;

 +,, 4

22""%$ @(

'69$<

8;$1 +$2$9$%$ 2 9( +  ,

A

 

(

 



 

+



6/, ) G" '(







 



 





$  

 



 

,



 

+

 6/,





 

=





 



(

 





 

I

7

:;

 +,,  ';$#"%*8 $# @(

&$&"

)0

 2 9( +  ,

A



+



 ) G #

,

<

 

 

+

 6/,$







A

  

   









(



 



(

 (







 * 







A



 





$  

+

 6/,

( 



+

 6/,



 $

(







 



(

 

  

 (





  

+

 6/,I 4

'



 









=

(

 



 

 

(<  $



!6.

<





  ,

 $

*@   :' A /%;

A  - $  

*>

+ A 2 / 



* *

+ 

-  



 >

 

C

 

 /

,    *(

<



  

.

"

"



 

.

"$$>%



-  ?

%- -

 %&

*@ 

(

 :' A /%;

 

)%

       

  

     !" #"$    %  #  & '

()

  *                         !             '

    +   %  # " 

 '

, # !

-$  

! "   + !

  & "" &      

!

   % & !   !  %     

  

 % ./01/  $+&      2    #        #            

 &  +   +      * 34, 

!   

%  #  & "" (2   %#25   5 $ !  '67 &  

       %#2

  !    

   

%'6 %'6 !   %#2 %5& '

.888894+

     

      *    )              5

 

!           

  %' "2       

 !    :  &     #     #          2  +&     #    5 &   +('

)

 +   '" ! &1'

)888894  +   ;&< 

 

 $ :!

= 

 

-  ,

:-

$ 5 +

;



  

 * 

+ 



.

"$$>%

- 

*@ (



  

 0



* +- /

?  :? ,;$ 

  

. 1





 

 

* . 1

< -  ,





 2



* +- /

* ?



  



 





  

 

(



 



 # < 

 

+



6/,

(

$



=

(



$ 

 





(

<

A





 *





 

+



6/,$

(

  



 



 >

 



 









 < 











(

 2 

% 

- -



+

$ 5 + .$

 

,..%%$ 





A <  

 



%- -

 

% +

$ 5 + .









 









 

+

 6/,$ 



 









% +

$ 5 + .

,..%% 2   +









- -

<   C  

+

4 , /, 





= +

$ 5 + .



(

. 

 

 "4 =

- -

(

(

 "

 (





2 9( +  ,

$1*""!

6%72A( =$("

:

 ;

2$1$;

$#A( =$("

:

 ;

  



 (



 (

  



 

<  C 



- -





$##)B"*

 

 ?

 =

- -

(

("& $(6*"

(

*6(;6(("*  / 

 

 :

;$



 7  



 

  (   

/  '

  5 /

 < #<

 

< >   

5 >&



.

(

5 >&