Surender Singh Taxak v. Food Corporation Of India And ORS.
!"# #$%&%'( !)$* +,
- .)#'/#)%'0*!1!2 3#"%"%'#) 4#)&.& /)5)!"%' '/%!!'/"*#)& 3#&5'/#'"& (67 7
!
"
#
% & ()
"
"
"
"
* + ,
-
. !
" /"
! /
"
$%
89!""!'%'0*, 2
.
"
* 4
5
6
& ") #
(
% & 7$ 7) 86
"
8
" -
' 6 . 3
"
(
2
"
6 (44 .
&)
.
4+ (44-
.
.
*
2
5
6
& ")
6
" 4+ (44- &9 )
2
*4 :
(44-
3
6
3 9
*4:, ;
' 5
"
<
2 (44-
=
8 7" 7 .
8
$3 6
$ =
04--
(44- . "
8
6
"
* "
9" 4:
(44-
>
(4444? 6
" "
"
6
"
+
2
(- 4 (440
"
2
7 "8
8
"
" 6
$3 6 " " $=
04--
(44- (, 4* (440
"
=
8.
" 3
(4444?@
"
2
"
(4444?
6 "" " "
2 (, 4* (440
A2
.
<
#
% .
"
(44-
"
5
6
& ") " 8
6
"
=
" "
"
9" 8
(4444?
6
" "
"
>6 ; 6
"
2
6 "6
"
>
6 "
(4444?
"
"
" "
%
"
6
"
(4444?
'"8 : (44- ,
% " (44+ (0 4 (440 .
". "
B 4, (440 " ,* :+ ".
(4 (44-
> "
".
8 9
6
+:
:4
+ 2
8" 4 4:
(440
.
"
"
:
> " .
-
$=
04--
(44-
6 (, 4* (440 " " " 8
2
" (+ 4- (440 "
" " " 6
2 8 A$
*(:
(440
2
9 * 9"
$
*(:(
(440 2
"
(, (440
%
"
" "
9"
9" ,* :+
(4 ".
%
"
6
"
%
%
6 "
(, (440
6 "
>
,
" "
" 6
$3 6
4 4( (44
"
* 4
-
%
.
6
9" 8 .
"
"
6
"
2
5
6
& ")
6
%
D ". 8 "
,( ".
(4 6 *, :
". &"6) ,4 :+ ". *+ << ".
" A D
:4EC
%
"
"
". ""D
"
: B ".
D " "
6
6 8 86 "
"
D 3 6 "
6 ". 8
2
A
" C
" +E ".
"
(4E ". 6 4E ".
7D
".C
4
F
"
2%
"
"
"
:
( (44-
9" 5
6
& ) 5$ %
" 9
9 -
"
".
9 :4E
(4E
4E
2
(( ( (44- 9
9 0
"
"
> (* ( (44-
- 5
6
& %)
".
(4E
4E
2 6
" (+ 4- (44-
D (* ( (44- & )
(
2
* 4 6
) 8 .
"
<
G
)
6 " &< " )
" 9"
6 . G (4E ".
4E
"
" G ) D
". 86 ". "
". 6 8 8G ". 8
"
6 6 "
2 8
". &
) " 8 & )G
)
"
*
% 6
$
"6 8 6
0
"
(440 "
8
"
%
&$= 04--
(44-) (, 4* (440
". 6
"
9"
>
83 6
%
"
4:
(44- &
)
"
B (*
$
$ 0:*
<
B "
"
$ (
% " % "
8
" "
6 ""6 9 "
2
" 6
"
&
)
3
%
9" 6
6
G "
"
4 6
7
> 6
9" 3
"
8
&
)
+
=
9"
6
. %
"
" 6
" D
"
6
6
89 "8
6
%
.
6
6
"
"
.6 "
,
B ?D
:4E
6
"
6
% 6"
8
6
2 "
7
"
".
4E (4E ". 6
"9"
"
".
4 (4 6
:
=
"
:
( (44- 6 "
6
$"
5 6 (< ( (44-
6 *4 ( (44-
-
2 "
8
* + ,
7 "
A"
C 6 6
D 7
% 8 6 * + ,
6 "
8
"
&
6 4, ( (44)
B " .
"
.
0
-
6
8 6 6 6
4* 4:
(440
B
( "
9
(4
2 $
%
6 3 6 58
5
6
& %) !.6
"
" 6
5
6
!.6 B$
"6 6
"6 6
% "
"6 3 6 6 (44-
!.6 6 A H
C
(
2 "
"
".
" 8
58
(* ( (44-
9" 8
*
+
!.6 " 9" 6 <
8
. *
> 6 8
# 6 , ".
+ ". 8
6
5
* > 58
""
!.67 "6 6
B$ 8 "6 6
((
2 6
6
" ". 9"
"
" ".
". " ".
86 "
"
#6 6 6
"
"6 3 6 $
/
. "
(*
%
"
8
(
" A C
%
2
!.6
B$ &"6 6) "
" !
" F
2 F "
%
""
" $"
5
"" "
8" 8
< 6
"
9
(<
%
" "
"8
>
%
6 & $ ") $
/
(+
% 6
"6 8
9 " "
9" 8
2% (4 4 (440
(0 4 (440 6
( 4+ (440 " 4, (440
2
4 4:
(440 *4 (440
%
86
6
9"
&$= 04--
(44-) 6
&;
"
)
(,
8"
+ 86
7
9 *4:, ;
' 5 4:
4- (44-
.
%
(4 4* (440 9 9 (
6 " 3 "
8
89 9
%
9" & (, 4* (440) " "
(:
%
&9 <) 6 "
6 8"
* 4:
(44-
8"
6
& ) 6
6 " &
)
.
2 9
6
"6 8
6?6
9" 6 &)
,
6
2 8
"
" 8 "
> . 6
8
6 8
8
86 "
" (+ 4- (440 $= 04--
(44- .
(, 4* (440 "
(-
2
(< 4* (440 " 4< 4- (44 6 " "
2%
2
& (, 4* (440)
" 6 4, (440 9" 6
"
"
8" 6
$= 04--
(44- .
(, 4* (440
(0
".
8 "" 8" &86 9"
". ) "
:
". *4E
,< ".
8 +:
".
:
". 7 "
+ ". 6 &
+ ".
:)
>
" 8
*4
2
9"
6 8 4* ( (44- "6
D (< ( (44- "
6 6 " 6 *4 ( (44-
2 86
6
".
2
*
$3 6
6 "
"
* 4 5
6
& ")
8 <
9"
6 " "
*(
"
6 " 6
-
> "
2 " 8
**
8"
6
9" " 6
6
6 & %
" $
" )
" 6
" 3 "
6
8 "
9"
"
&$= 04--
(44-)
8" 6
"
A C
#$%
#
9
"
> 8"
8" "
"
.
" 6 8
6
%
"
" "!"# %*!)!'/"*#)&:8)#'/)!;.8!) %&*)!
&(44,) ( $$ +,
.
6
6
" "
0
8" "
6
"
9" "
"
6
*<
"
#
!*.9 )!<*!2!) : .'=!< #$*'%$!9 '%:#)&%">, !9!'/*!) !'/ "*#)& 00:&() %;
&I>) (0(
%
$ "
6 86 8
9"
6 8
9" 6 6 8
6
"
>
8
" " 6 "
*+
8" $%
"
9"
2 9" (- 4 (440 (< ( (44- 6 6 *4 4:
(44-
> 8" 8 .
>
7 4* ( (44-
(- 4 (440
B 6
(4
9" 8 4* ( (44- & 9"
(44-)
6 6 (- 4 (440
> 8" 8
6
$% & ) 9"
? 8
9"
*,
$" 8.
"
8"
$= 04--
(44-
"
> 9 8" 6
5
6
0
;
$%7 6 & <) 6 8
2 8" 8
".
6
*:
9 8"
"
(440
"
$= 04--
(44- 6
(440
2 86 (+ 4- (440
(
6
6 #8 6 (44
9
*-
;6
8"
6 (< 4( (440
6 9
6" " 9
0< "
8 <44
"8 8
" 9
6"
:
"
J 6 "
"
6 4< 4- (4 &
9
()
>
8"
"
(440
6
" 6 #8 6
8"
$
6 (4 ".
8
6
9
6"
2
(* ( (4*
6
"
*0
;
"
" " " ) 4%=!>>!9:"!"# .'=!<,(44* &*)
K 4G B
.
".
(( " ?"
) ?& ."*!&&$%!"#&!'/"*#)&:"!"# !*!)!&*")!!'/"*#)&, (4*) < $$ *4<G B "
6
"
6
) "!"# .'=!<:4;;*!''!,&(44) ( $$ **4 B "
" 8
) "!"# %*!)!'/"*#)&:8)#'/)!;.8!) %&*)!
&(44,) ( $$ +,G ) !*.9)!<*!2!):.'=!<#$*'%$!9'%:#)&%">, !9!'/*!)!'/"*#)& 00:&() %;
&I>) (0(G
6
"
" & 6 )
<4
"
"
* + , 0
"
" &9 )
> 8"
(+ 4- (44-
"6
" 8
(4 4* (440 &9 ()
"
3
6
"
> 8"
<
"
"
9 8"
$= 04--
(44- "
(< 4( (440 6
(* 6 (, 4* (440
>
8"
#8 6 (44
"
"
>
"
#
*%)!'=%7!9!'/"*#)&:%'!'$%!988%&&%'#)!)>!'!!'/"*#)& &%
0:- I> *(,) 8"
" 6
<(
; 9 "
6 " "
&
$
:-4
(4+ 4:
(4+ 83 6
) 6
6 (4
"
&$= <+4(
(4)
" < 4* (4
"
8
"
" "
2 ;
&; +00
(4)
" " 5
"
"
8" "
7
8 7
/ $"" $%
<*
"
"
9 0
" "
(<
".
; 8"
(( ( (44- 6
(* ( (44-
> 8" 6 6
#$% 6 ".
" "
" 8 6
(4E ".
4E
8 6 " 8 6 6
2 8
9 4 " " 58
5
6
& %) (* ( (44- 6 :4E
(4E
4E
6 6 6
$%
<<
"
"
9 8" "
"
6
$% 6
"
>
8 6
; 9 " "
7
86
" 6
" " "
(+ % 8"
"
6
;
"
& ) (4
<+
;6 8"
6 "
" 8
" &9 ) "8
8
"
> 8"
83 6
6
6 .
5
6
<,
"
"
"
) '%' '/%!!'/"*#)&:%9!2!=!'/*%,&(4<)
* $$ <+G B
"
6
3 6 "
"
) *%)!'=%7!9!'/"*#)&:%'!'$%!988%&&%'#) !)>!'!!'/"*#)& &%
0:- I> *(,) &
" 6 )G
(, ) #=)!2!&*!"*!2!'/"*#)&:!=!&"*!'%0* .)"!'/"*#)& &(4*) < $$ +<4 "
" 6
) !9/#:%'0*:*#"!"# .'=!<!'/"*#)&&#)
0-4 &*) ;
*-+G
B
" "" " "
6 .
"
"
6 8
<:
- 8" "
6
7 8 6 &$)
6
<-
%
" !&*'%;.8!): "!"# .'=!<!'/"*#)& (44< &*)
K :,,
8" - "
"
<0
% 8
8"
"
6
$= 04--
(44- (, 4* (440
6
(: 6
8
"
>
"
6 8" 6 6
". 6 8" &
)
8"
.
(0?*4 4 (440 (< 4( (440 6
6 8
6 6 8"
>
8" 6
$
:-4
(4+ 6 6
8
8
6
8 (444 (44<
> 6
7 83
"?
" 8" 6
2
6 "
6 6
"
"
+4
8 8
"
(-
" 8"
"
7
6
(4
6
" "
6 5
" ; +00
(4
K
7 "
(4
"
6
? 6
"
6
6
6
"
> 8" "
6
&(44-40 ) 8 6 "
"
(44- 6 3 6
"
"
*4 4 (440
+
& ) (* ( (4*
6
"
%
9 "
6
"
"
"
6
6
(0 4 ( (4* " &
9 (* 9 $
:-4
(4+)
6 6
# "
&# ) (0 &() "
"
"
6 6
2
8" 6
"
6
. 6
"
"
8
7
6
"
(4
5
"
8
886
" "
6
6
( 6 8 "
"
5
> 8"
"
7 ; +00
(4 " 6
8 "
(4
6 5 "
8
6
*4 +(
9
+
7
&$
:-4
(4+) 8"
"
6
$%
6
"
5
&)
2 8 9"
6 " .
> 8" 8 "
"
+(
%
&$
:-4
(4+)
9 6
"
> 6 6
F
9" & "" )
8
&
" 8 )
+*
"
5
&)
6 6 (4*
" "
"
(4
> 8" "
8
"
*
" 6
" K 6 (440 " "
6 8
>
8" 83 6
7B 7 7/6 7
"
6 (4( (4(* (4*<
&2 8 " "
"
6 $
:-4
(4+
"")
+<
8"
"
"
8
++
;
6
$% 8" "
8 6
" "
> 8" 8
$% 8 8
" 6 6 ""
6 6
" ". 9" ""
58
" !.6 B$ 6
; 8" 6 6
*( 6 $% "
"
8 !.6 6 6 3 6 $%
>
"
6 8
3 6
$% 6
+,
;6
8"
8
8" "
6 "
6
6 8"
8"
&
)
" 5
" 86 ". "
+:
8
"
6
6
"
6 "
9"
9 (
"
7
6 4:
4- (44-
&9 <) " 3
8"
**
2 8" "
9"
"
8"
%
8"
"
"
"
"
&
)
- "
6
?
9 "
2
6
$= 04--
(44- ""6 " . "
" .
8
>
#
" &
) 8"
8
7
2 " "
6
"
6
6
6
6
+-
%
"
" ) ?&%"!/#9%'#*!)8!$#."%$!9&: ?&!8!'%>!8 #!9&"!"#&7"/!'/!'"*#) &(4) $$ <:G
) ).'%8!!).!*:'%' '/%! &(44:) , $$ (4G
*< ) .&%'#&&'"#)5)%&#& 7"/:"!"# %*!) !'/"*#)& &(44<) :
$$ ,,G 8
"
%
"
"
) #8!'% !9*")!:%0*.)" #9*% &(44-) :
$$ G ) !8%9!/.85."#)$%#'$##/)!/.!"# #!$*#)	 !)#$%#"> :%0*#)#$'/!)> $*985."#)#!$*#)&&&$%!"%'!'/"*#)&, &(440) < $$ +:
"
"86
) !=#&*;.8!).5"!!'/"*#)&:"!"# !'/ "*#)&,&(44+) + $$ :(
B
6
+0
> "
"6
6
". 8
9 8
,4
#"
*+
86 "
"
*4 4 (440
6
(440
"
"
2
6
(< 4( (440 6
" "
&
") 8
"
2
"
"
6
(440
"
#8 6 (440
"
"
5 ; +00
(4 7' B8 $ 7 3 "
2 6
8
.
" 5
83
(4 "6
"
"
2 6 8
"
*, 2
" 6
" "
6
""
,
2
8
6
" "
6
"
"
8 .
%
8 6 6
"
6
"6
8
=
" "
8 8
" & (440)
,(
% "6 " 6
"
6
"6 8
*:
8
6
"
"
6
6
D
"
> .
" D 6 .
6
" "
" "
> 8
6
6
8 6
,*
% "6
"6
> 6
"
6 6
"
6
8
2 8 6
,<
> 8 6
". 8 8
6
"
"
*- ,+
2
"
"
8
" 6 6
8 "
#6
&
)
;
2 6 "
"
&
) 8
" ; !'=.&)##:"!"# &(44-) * $$ +( 7
"
"
"7
2
"
8 (+ 4- (44- 6 "6
9" 6 6 6
%
" $
" #$%
6
; 9 8
".
"
%
6
%
6 9 " "
(4E ". 4E
6
*0
> "
,,
$" "
"
" 6
% "6
"
" 8
""6 " . "
9"
> ""6
$= 04--
(44- "
9" (44-
2
&
. "?"" D)
8" " 6
.
"
3
J
9
.
8
8
6
8"
"
" 3
"
> "
" 8 "
9" 6 8
<4 9" .
,:
>
"
$= 04--
(44- & " "
) (, 4* (440
H 86
8 "
>
6
% " (44+ (4 4 (440 8
" 9"
"
"
"
(44+
2
6
" "
<
9" 6 K (440
"
"
8" 6 8 "
6
2
"
&$= 04--
(44-)
6
9" <
H 86
6 "
8
"
"
>
3 6
6 "
6
# 8
"
8 .
$= 04--
(44-
2%
= 86 "
"6 " "
<
6
#
"
6 "
"
"
6
(4444? "
6
"
6 "
& 9") "
,-
$"
".
6 9" 86 6 "
".
2 % "
" 8 8 6
".
". 8 6 6
". 8 9" 8 6 8 6
7 .
2 8 " 86 "
". 8
F 8
8 6 6
"
"
" "
>
<( 6
9
>
7 "
,0
2 8
6
6 6
". 86 +E
6
&
". 9" ) 6
6 8
"
" 6 "
" 8
"
8
2
"
6
&
)
" 9 6 "
6
9
6
" "
:4
>
8
"G 8
6 " "
2%
<* & $= 04--
(44-) 8
6
" 9
(4444?
"
7
(0 (4,