High Court of Punjab and HaryanaCWP/15867/2019dismissed

Bara Singh v. State Of Punjab And Others

2019-08-17Mr. Justice B.S. Walia5 pages

!"!#$%$&'

()$&*+ ,! $ $&!( -!(%.% ) !.&/0&" +!(% , !%1&"!& % !(!' &203!4(.% $#!)3$ (!%!& ' 4%3$%+((5"6# !( +!1! $ $&!( 777 (8!( $& +! 9($ 1! $ $& .&"!( ( $#3!

&% $ . $& &"$ $% ( +! $%%.&#! 9($ 5 ("!( ( "$(!# $& !%1!#$338 $& +!& .(! 4&";.% ( ;"$8$&* 9("&&!<.(! : " !"=

&"((!$&% !;!& +!1! $ $&!(9$ +.330#>9*!% $&% !"9("#;1!&% $&?

A!(&!"#.&%!3#& !&"% + +!3!(&!"A0.( .( 5 $3 B+!(!$& !((!!((!" %C +!A0.( .( 2D51%%!"&9("+3"$&* + +!1! $ $&!(%%!(6$#!%+"0!!& !(;$& !"08(!%1&"!& % &"=$& 6$3 $& +! 1(6$%$& )!# $& @ +! &".% ($3 $%1. !% # 5 ?9!6!(5$&% !"*(& $&*(!$&% !;!& 9$ +.330#>9*!%5 +! 3!(&!"A0.( .( 9("!"#;1!&% $&?

:@&38A$>!9$%!5 %$;$3(38 %$ . !" !;138!!% 9!(! *(& !" ?

:@ 08 +! A0.( .(

0. %$;$3(38 %$ . !" !;138!!% $&6>!" +! /.($%"$# $& +$% .( 08 98

5 =

&"A%&"

5 9+$#+ 9!(! "$%1%!" 08 +$% .( 6$"! ("!( " !"

?5 08 *(& $&* (! (!&#+;!& #;1!&% $& 5

E F A!(&!"#.&%!3#& !&"% + $& +!#$(#.;% &#!%5 +!1! $ $&!(9%3% !& $ 3!" ;"$$# $&9("&"(*(& (!3$!%1(8!"(5%+" 0!!&*(& !" %$;$3(38%$ . !"1!(%&%%(!!((!" 06! = +6! #&%$"!(!" +! %.0;$%%$& 3!(&!" #.&%!3 ( +! 1! $ $&!(50. ;($" + +!9($ 1! $ $&$%3$03! 0!"$%;$%%!"& +! %+( *(.&" "!38 &" 3#+!% +! 1! $ $&!( $% & !& $ 3!" (!3$! ;!(!38 & %+9$&* + %$;$3(38 %$ . !" 1!(%&% % +! 1! $ $&!( 9!(! *(& !"#;1!&% $&5

:@&##.& +!1! $ $&!(0!$&*$& +! 1%$ $& !&#! %$ !( &" +6$&* 11(#+!" +! $*+ .( &38 !( (!3$! 9% *(& !" %$;$3(38 %$ . !" 1!(%&% +! 1! $ $&!( ;$& $&!"% $#%$3!&#!(1!($"#3%! 8!(%(; +!" ! 1%%$&* +! 9(" &" #;! +! .( &38 !( +!( %$;$3(38 %$ . !"1!(%&%+"0!!&*(& !" +!0!&!$ &" + 6$"!("!(" !"

?&%;!9+ %$;$3(#$(#.;% &#!%5$&A

5 +!#3$;1. ( +08 +!11!33& % +!(!$&08989($ 1! $ $&$3!"$& +!8!(

59%(!/!# !"& +!*(.&"$&("$& !"!38&"3#+!% 11!33& % +!(!$&+"/$&!" +!(&%1( !1( ;!& %$#>! -!($$!(% &"$389*!0%$%$& +!8!( @ +!$(%!(6$#!%9!(!"$%1!&%!"9$ + *$&% 9+$#+ +!8 ($%!" $&".% ($3 "$%1. ! 9+$#+ 9% &%9!(!" $& +!$( 6.( !%.3 & 385 +!89!(!(!$&% !"&"$!(!& " !%$& +!8!( @ +!$(%!(6$#!%9!(!(!*.3($G!"9! ?

=.&"!( 6!(&;!& 3$#8 +!8 #& $&.!" %!(6! & (!*.3( 0%$% &" 3 !( $3!" 9($ 1! $ $&#3$;$&* + +!89!(!!& $ 3!" %!!>(!*.3($G $&&#;13! $& ?

"8%%!(6$#!%1!(3" 6!(&;!& 13$#8" !"

+! 9($ 1! $ $&9%"$%1%!"9$ +"$(!# $& +!. +($ 8 !<;$&! &" "!#$"! +!$( #3$; +! #;1! !& . +($ 8 (!/!# !" +! #3$; 6$"! ("!(" !"

?+!11!33& % +!&$3!"& +!(9($ 1! $ $&$& +!

E=F 8!(

9+$#+9%"$%;$%%!"08 +!3!(&!")$&*3!."*!& +!*(.&" "!38 &" 3#+!% & 11!35 +! ("!( +! 3!(&!" )$&*3! ."*! 9% .1+!3" !3!6& !< (# +! "!#$%$& +! $6$%$& !&#+ $& A

$ 3!" % C

25$%(!1(".#!"%.&"!('@

! " ##

! $

## & !

( ' ) "

*% + ,-

./ % ' 0! " 12 3! ( 3

$ ' 0! 4 2

.5 - 6

! $ 0! " # " " $ & !

' 7 * /

% "

2 8 & !

' 7

9 !

E?F . :!

! " " " ! $ ! " "

! $ 6 !

; ! $" ' & "

$" %< ? & ).>+0$( )$&*+2% #%! B).1(D +! $6$%$& !&#+ "!&$!" (!3$!& &38&##.& "!386!( 8!(%$&*$ $&* +!"$%1. !

0. 3% & +! *(.&" + $& +! #&&!# !" #%! & 9+$#+ (!3$&#! 9% 13#!"5 +!1! $ $&!(%+"11(#+!" +! .( $& +!8!(

9+$3! +! 11!33& %$&).>+0$()$&*+2%#%!+"(!;$&!"!&#!%$ !(%& +!$&% & #%!5 +!1! $ $&!("$"& #+33!&*!9("&&!<.(!:" !"=

(1!($"#3%! 8!(%&"%3!1 6!(+$%($*+ &"$ $%&389+!& ("!(9%1%%!"$& +!#%!%$;$3(38%$ . !"1!(%&%$&

&" =

&"A%&"

? + +! 1! $ $&!( #+%! $&6>! +! /.($%"$# $& +$% .( #+33!&*! 9(" " !" =

6$"! 9($ 1! $ $& " !"

$! !( .( +!(31%!#3%! $6!8!(% $%5 +.%5#(8% 3#3!( + +!1! $ $&!(339!"*(%% *(9 .&"!( +$% !! 08 #H.$!%#!&#$&* $& +! 9(" " !" =

08 & #+33!&*$&* +!%;!(1!($"#3%! 8!(% $%&38&#;$&* >&9%$;$3(38%$ . !"1!(%&%+6$&*0!!&*(& !" +!(!3$! + +! 1! $ $&!($&6>!" +!/.($%"$# $& +$% .( 5 + $6!8!(% !( +! *(& (!3$! +! +!( %$;$3(38 %$ . !" 1!(%&% +! 1%$ $& +! 1! $ $&!($% + !&#!%$ !(

EF & +!3$*+ +!1%$ $&%& !"06!5&#%!9+ %!6!( $%;"!. 9((& $&*$& !(!(!&#!9$ + +!9("1%%!"08 +!3!(&!" A0.( .( ( +! (!%&% % *$6!& 06!5 +! 9($ 1! $ $& $% 0!(! ;!($ &"$%##("$&*38"$%;$%%!"$&! B)AD

(/!%+>>+.(& +! +!(%1!>$&*:(!%&!" ' !%:

+! +!((!1( 03! ' !%: