High Court of Punjab and HaryanaRFA/420/2025disposed of

Sunil Kumar And Others v. State Of Haryana And Others

2026-02-04Mr. Justice Harkesh Manuja4 pages

,*(

(60$0)%

C !" !" !" !" #$ #$ #$ #$ --(..,)* --(..,)* --(..,)* --(..,)*$ ($-)4()* ($-)4()* ($-)4()* ($-)4()* $ % % % % '($()*% '

$ '

&! &! &! &! " " " " ,)4((-',<,$++,+,'145 6,*( *+(,--(..,)*$ /+0),$+,0)1 1,'2,) ), 3'/+0,),1456,*( '0*,7 0)8+ ,0)01456,*( '($-)4()*$9 BBBB 1 1 1 1 ',.

',.

',. " " " " ::

::;

', ,2(' 7,4( 0) *+0$ ,--.06,*0) 0 0$ ' $((<0)8 -('70$$0) * .

(,4 ,440*0),. (504 4()6( /2 -.,60)8 ) '(6'4 $7( '(.(5,)* 4637()* $ 5 50= -+*6-0($ * *+((80$*('7,0)*,0)(4/2*+(

06( ;637;!1+ +*,< ,)4,--.06,*0) >0*+'(-'*4,*(4

: ,$ ))(?3'($;

,)4; - ) )*06(1 '(-.2 ) /(+,.

'($-)4()* $9 ,)4 +,$ / (()

0.(41*+($,7(0 $*,<())'(6'4 ,5 50)8+(,'4.(,')(43)$(. *+(-,'*0($@*+(,3*+()*060*2 4637()*$$38 8+**/(-'436(4)*/(0)80) 40$-3*(,**+(+,)4$ '($-)4 4()* $9 @ *,< <0)8 0)* ,663)* *+( 0)40)8$ '

'(6'4(4 /2 *+( .(,')(4 ( ('( )6( 3'* >+('(0) *+( 6.,07 *+( ,--(..,)*$; ., ,)4>)('$ +,$ /(() 4()0(4 /( (0)8 /,''(4/2.070*, ,*0)1*+(4637()*$$38+**/ (-'436(4,'(5('2736+'(D30 0'(4

'*+(67-.(*( (,)4(

(6*05(,4A3406,*0) *+ +(,--(,.

$0)+,)4*>3.4+ +(.- *+(3'**4(6 604(*+('08+*$ *+(-,'*0($0), ,)(

(6*05(7,))('@*+('>0$(,.

.$1

*+(4637()*$ 38+**/(-'436(4,'( '7*+ +('(6'4$ *+('($-)4()* $ ).2 >+06+*+(2$3-- -'($$(4/( '(*+(.(,')(4( ('( ()6(3'*66'40)8.2*+(-', ,2(' 0$,..>(4,)4*+ +($,7(,'(*,<())'(6'4,$, ,440*0),.(504()6( :

;

)- -3'$3,)6(**+()*06(1'(-.2* *+(,--.06,*0) '6)4),*0) ) 4(.,20) 0.0)8*+ +(-'($()*,--(,.+,$/(() 0.(4 4)/(+,.

*+('($-)4()* $9 1*+($,7(0$ $*,<())'(6'4@>+('(0)0*0$-'

',2(4*+,**+(-'($()*,--.06,*0) )0$ *7,0)*,0),/.( .0,/.(*/(40$7 70$$(4,$*+(,--(,.0)+,)40$) + +,5( +(,'4 .(,')(4 63)$(. *+( -,'*0($ ,)4 8)( *+'38+ 6)*()*$ *+(, ,--.06,*0) $ , 7,**(' ,6*1 ) *+( '( ( ('()6( -(*0*0) $ -'( (''(4 ,* 0)$*,)6( ,-- -(..,)*$;.,)4>)('$1 -'(503$.2 ,) ,>,'4 -,$$(4 /2 *+( .(,') )(4 ( ('()6(3'

'*>,$6+,..()8(4/( '(*+0$ 3'*/2>,2

0(0).(,4 46,$(+('(0)/(,'0)8;:C9;

,$>(..,$0)*+('6))(6 6*(4 6,$($/2>,2

'($-(6*05($,$*+(6,$(7 7,2/(@+>(5('1*+($($> >('( >0*+4',>)/2*+ +(,--(..,)* $;.,)4>)('

$504 4('4('4,*(4 F

C 0).

(,4 6,$( ,)4 0) *+(' 6,$($ ,$ *+( 6,$( 7,2 / /(1 >0*+ .0/('*2 * 75( (50 0(> --.06,*0) /( ( '( *+( .(,')(4 ( ('()6( 3'* +('(, *('1 *+( '( ('( )6( -(*0*0) $-'( ( (''(4/2 *+( ,--(..,)* $;.,)4> >)('

$+,5( ,8,0) /(()40$70$ $$(4 /(0)8/,''(4/2 2.070*,*0)>0*+3*,--'(60,*0)8 8*+('(6(0-*E'(6'4$7,0)*,0)(4 4/2 *+(

06( ;637;!1+*,<,/3* 0.0) )8 /A(6*0)$/2*+(,--(..,)*

.,)4>)('

$3) )4(' (6*0) F *+(!,)46D3 30$0*0)6*1 F:'(6(0-*4, ,*(4 :

:1,$'

'( (''(4*0)*+(07-38)(4,>,'

'4,$>(..,$,--.06,*0),)4'(- -'* 4,*(4

>,$-.,6(4)'(6'4/2*+('

'($-)4()*$)*+(*+('+,)41 4637()*$*,<() ))'(6'40)*+( '7 ,440 0*0),.(504()6(,$))(?3'($ ;

,)4 ; +,5( ) )(0*+(' /(() '( (''(4 * )' 4( (,.* >0*+ /2 *+( .(,')(4 ( ('( )6( 3'* ) $36+ 60'637$*,)6($1 *+('( /(0 0)8 ) 4(.,2 ) *+( -,'* ,--.06,)*$;,--(.

..,)*$E.,)4>)('$>+0.(-'( (''0 0)8/A(6*0)$3)4(' (6*0) F *+(!,)46D30$ $0*0)6*1 F:1>+06+,$-(' ))(?3'(;

>('(>0*+0)*07(1

-'($()*,--(,.- -'( (''(4,**+(0)$*,)6( ,--.0 06,)*$;,--(..,)*$>,$)**/(+ +(.4 /(0)8 /,''(4 /2 2 .070*,*0)1 ($-(60,..2 >+() *+ +(2 >('( 40.08()*.2 -3'$30)8 *+ +(0' '(7(40($ ) , ,6*1 0* 0$ *+( .(,')(4 ( ('()6( ( 3'* >+06+1 ) ,663)* 5('$08+*1 ,0.(4 4 * *,<( 0)* 6)$04(',*0) * *+( 6''(6* '(6'4$ '(6(0-*$ '( ('()6(-(*0*0 ) $;/A(6*0)$ 0.(43)4(' (6*0 0) F *+(!,)46D30$0*0) 6*1

F: ,)4 *+3 $1 *+( 4(.,2 >,$ )* * / /( ,**'0/3*(4 * *+( ,--.06,) )*$;

,--(..,)*$E.,)4 >)('$/2-3**0)8*+(7*,)240 0$,45,)*,8(3$-$0*0) '(5('1)(504()6(>,$.(4/2 2*+('($-)4()*$$,$*($*,/.

.0$+ *+,*,)2)*06( 3)4(' (6*0)

*+(!,) )46D30$0*0)6*1 F:>,$( (5(' $('5(4 3-) *+( ( ,--(..,)*$;.,)4>)('$ ' ,)2 2 6-2 *+( ,>,'4 -,$$(4 3) )4(' (6*0)

*+('

'( >,$ '>,'4(4 * *+(7 5() ) (504()6( >,$ /'38+* ) '(6'4/2*+('($ $-)4()*$*$+>*+,**+(,73 3)* 67-()$,*0),$$($$(43) )4(' *+(,>,'4-,$$( (4/2*+(!>,$40$/3'$(4* *+(,--(..,)*$;.,)4>)('$/(

'( 0.0)8 '

'( ('()6( -(*0*0) $ )6(4( 4.21 *+( *+(' $070.,'.2 $0*3, ,*(4 .,)4>)('$-('* *,0)0)8**+($,7(,6D30$0*0)- -'6((40)8$+,5(,.'(,42/(()+ +(.4 ()*0*.(4 '*+( ()+,)6(4,73)* 67-()$,* *0)-('*,0)0)8**+(,6D30'(4., ,)4

,..0)8 0) *+( $, ,7( '(5()3( ($*,*(1 0( #0..,8( ( ,'+0 +,'1 0$*'06* +*,<1 1 0) 50(> A3487( ()*E'4(' 4,*(4

-,$ $$(4 /2 *+0$ 3'* 0) , /3)6+ + ,--(,.$1.(,46,$ $( >+06+>,$ ;

;

1*0*.(4H,.+,)4*+('$#('

,.+,)4*+('$#('

'$3$ '$3$ '$3$ '$3$ *,*( ,'2,), *,*( ,'2,), *,*( ,'2,), *,*( ,'2,), ,,)4*+('$G ,,)4*+('$G ,,)4*+('$G ,,)4*+('$G,$(4*+('(3-), ,)4,--.20)8*+(-'0)60-.( -,'

'0*21 /($04($ 8',)* A3$* ,)4 ,0' 67-()$,*0)1 1 *+( .,)4>)('$E,--.06,)*$ /( (0)8 $070.,'.2$0*3,*( (4,'(+(.4()*0*.(4 '8',)* $0 070.,',73)* 67-()$,*0) ) 50(> *+( 40$63$$0) 7,4( +('(0),/5( ,$ >(.. ,$ '7 6)*()*$ *+(, ,--.06,*0) $1*+(-',2('0$,.. >(4,)44(.,20) 0.0)8*+(-'($ $()* ,--(,.

$1,$7( ()*0)(4,/5(10$+('(/26)4 )(4>(5('1*+(,--.06,)*$$+ +,.. /(()*0*.(4 '0) )*('($* '*+(-('04 4(.,20) ) 0.0)8*+(,--(,.,$>(..@,$0) -'($()* 6,$(1 ,4 470**(4.21 *+( ,--.06,)*$;,--(..

,)*$ >('( )* '($-)$0/.( ' , ,)2 4(.,2 ,)4 >('

'( (5() 6)*0)33$.2 -3'$30) )8 *+(0' 6.,07 *+'38+ 40

'()* -'6((40)8$

I J 2 >,2 -'($()* ,--(,.

$1 6+,.

..()8( +,$ /(() .,04 * *+( > >,'4 4,*(4 C F

-,$$(4/2*+(.(,')(444.

0$*'06*348(1+*,< +('(0), *( '* /('( (''(4,$*+ +(K( ('()6(3'*L I J * *+(5('23*$(*1.(,')(463)$(.

. '*+(,--(..,)*$$3/70*$*+,* -'($()*,--(,.0 0$$D3,'(.265('(4/2*+(A348 87()*4,*(4

-,$$(4 /2 *+0$3'*0),/ /3)6+ ,--(,.$1.(,46,$( > >+06+>,$ ;

;

1*0* *.(4 H,.+,)4*+( H,.+,)4*+( H,.+,)4*+( H,.+,)4*+( +('$#('$3$ *,* +('$#('$3$ *,* +('$#('$3$ *,* +('$#('$3$ *,*( ,'2,),,)4 ,'2,),,)4 ,'2,),,)4 ,'2,),,)4 4 *+('$G 4 *+('$G 4 *+('$G 4 *+('$G I9J !(, ,')(463)$(. '*+('($-)4()* *$,'()*0),-$0*0)*6)*'5 5('* *+(,/5( ,6*3, ,.-$0*0) IJ * *(' 80)8 *+'38+ *+( A3487()* * '( (''(4 * ,/5( ,$ >(.. ,$ -'($()*6,$(1*+0 0$3'*,8'(($>0*+*+(,$$('*0 )7,4(/2*+(.(,')(463)$(.

*+(,--(..,)*$ I J ) )$(D3()*.21*+(-'($()*,--(,.

$ ,'(40$-$(4 0)*+($,7(*('

'7$ ,$,.+L$6,$( ,.+L$6,$( ,.+L$6,$( ,.+L$6,$( ( $3-', ICJ ..

-()40)8,--.06,*0) $10 ,)21$ $+,..,.$$*,)440$-$(4 (/'

(/'

(/'3,'2 3,'2 3,'2 3,'2

1111

*0< " " " "

C M+ M+ +(*+('$-(,<0)8E'(,$)(4

($ +(*+(''(-'*,/.(

($ $E $E