Gaurav Grover And ORS v. State Of Haryana And Another




   
 


    



 

!"#

$%

  

 !"#$%&'(# $#& !

 $

 &

'( ) %!

*+%,"$ '( - !)++#( '

(.)/ +%," $%(0(  $#& !

 $$
*+   $     2  "

/%  %  !,   340  ( $# *"5 *" (647%%08(4(0707%!, 606+ 693+68:+688+37:+3;4 +97:+9<<
*

% / ,! +!, 66+./+

 ,.//*= // 2 5$,%



*")2

",)$)

%%0(8(0700>?

6@(

5 = **

%2#,)$/   $% (0  %     *   ,)),%  (  =+  =   

 " $,2/ +"

//#$  % /)% # /%   %

$+= ,

$$"),)$)

( 2

" )+$  A * $="



2#$# *, " $,% =/%2 " /?,

%2 "$,

"% +

5 %// 2 5$,% 

*"))#2

  5 %   "- ,( 

 %% %%<<(8(0700% ,%$  $$2"
//5'*

B#'*

",% *

) + ,%%2"%
//5'*

B# '*

= / % ,% % $(
$ , )+/%'
+./ 

$ %%:(;(0700

(C $ / ?% $,$  "  )  "  ,)$/   )  + ,, %B$ +!A+D+!-# *%!=*,%%<8(4(0700/*=  )"

!
/-!

*,%%67(4(0700( 2

" ) + /%'
+./ ,,/%% $ $$  $    %      ,)$)

  / /#  %  =   # $

( ,, %$ 

, + !A " -# A +!)(D= "" -#

A %",, % 2%,/%$,/ )%""%% 

, /, $% **

#,, %(
%/%, /"$ +$ %,% %$ 2#/%'
+./(
 ="$"/%'
+./ %5 )%2#/%, /"$ +$ 5$ (63

% %

% = %=% )   /#5$

(<+0%9( 2$ /" #$

"340( ((=/%

= *)#)A ,% + )#2,

#

 "",#%%

%$2 "$,

"#=

 ,% "- ,(!, 607(

5//#/",

% += ,$ , 2 $,%" ,)$% *""", %
%  /%( .$ *  =""", //*%/#,)) % %",2$ ) ,2/# /% %

$+ , ", /$ , =/%2" /?,

(E2/ !$) )2", ,/% *
 



   



 B.S.Joshi and others  State of Haryana ,-*
 &./*0.* 12"//=%2#

 //,, "3.+4,*&5-, -*6&7.89,-*: 
2 %/ = $$

 /% $ , % /%/=( "+E2/!$) Gian Singh ;State of Punjab and another
 &./*0.*"%/ = 

%/ /= /%2#!$)"5 " State of Haryana ;Bhajan Lal:

&.//
&2(

:<"-%*)%  %&





 

 









 






 

 !




"


#





   


 




 
  



$


%&'





 








(





 "



 



 


 



 )*
+ ,


 
#

-

+

,


 


 


(




 
 

 
 !
(

"

 













  




 

 

 



  (


  
 -
 
"



-








 
 

(

 




 


 

(



.
-
 -


(-
 




 (










/












$




  

 




  

( $

 (-
(
  


 













.
0




1 


 


(








 .



 

(-
 *


  
 
( 

 


  

 


 
2 


 
  (
 3

 (
 

  




 



 




-


  (




  
  -
  -


-
 

-
  



.
 








  ( 



 (-
 




(




 





(
  



 




 











  (

 -


(


 

 -  


  


 





-




(

 





 .






 
 
 
 

 



# 

"


#


 
  

 
(





 










  











  -







 

 
  

 (




#










2 
 










 
 
  
 

 


 



  


 





  

 


 
#

-

  







 
 


+ ,


 

-







#




 4 $$/# */= /%2#E2/!$) $/ "-%*) %

 *+ 

$$=$  % ,)$)

+, "$,% =/%2 )/#2 "$,

"%2#//= *%,,$ * $#"$ 2#5 * =/%2 , *% "

- ,+= ,

$ ) /#2-,"/*

/, *% !, 340( 

, ,  "",!, 68:B688
( (   "", % ,)$%2/( $,/ ", % , ,) , % /*  "2$ % , % "- ,+

%) $$$   %

, % !, 340( ( ""$  /+

"

% ,  % 5/#"//

=  )2 %$) /%2#-% , /$,% %,+

(647%%08(4(0707%!, 606+693+68:+688+37:+3;4

+97:+9<<
*

% / ,! +!,60 66+./+

 , ./%// 2 5$,% 

*")5 % 5$ (<+0%92

",)$)

(

%/

1  #$ //) 2%2#) %,% " ,)$)

%  ) ,%%2",2/=(

  % //=%( 
 $#& !

 $    $% <#    /,A# C $A *B %&  B C $2/&  B