High Court of Punjab and HaryanaCWP/18369/2010allowed

Neena Sood v. Maharishi Dayanand University Rohtak

2016-12-06Mr. Justice A.B. Chaudhari10 pages

"# $

%"&'('")'$ *"$+,$$ "

%" -"'(.'/)'$*""#, $0

)"#$.

+,$$ "#1#2-'#+ (*$+""'$ 3 !!

6 78+"9.$+'#9 +/$+'$#+#,#### ('9(-# $'/%'"1#'"'

("- " // 3! !!4 (#$"'$

00! 7 *" $+ :## %'. ;;

#-/$'

$/. $+ < +'

//" 5"#*$+,8"#)#$$+=- " -/ *$+ " '

> "'/ -/# *" 5'= '$ #> +'# 2-'#+ +" '9) "#-/$6%6("*5'= $# $#,-$ $+#-9#2- $","# $'$ $+#' ""8'#"$"'$ !!

0!?78+// ($ ',$$+*'$* (","$'$ ; !

0!7#-9=$$ 9.:+"'" '=#$"$'

:## #-(4 $7<$+#-9#2- $ ""4

0!?7$+"'# (() 9.$+<+'

//"*$+ "#, $0- )"#$.8'#$+'$ ) +'#9 ,"-$+'$$+

,$$ "+''$-'//.',,'" %'. ;;)"//!! ($ =,'"$= $ $+#'5'=$8'# $$+'$$+"8'#'(','*$" // !!

$+"8'# ""*$+,$$ "># //+"#-/$ @7+'9 /'"'#,"',,'"'

%'. ;;

$+"*"+"

/(9/$.$#/*8'#-9$*-/+*'$*+"'"/"8"$,$$ 8'# $ ')'/'9/'

$+# ,'##9.$+#-"$+''/# $9 ,"- 9. $+,$$ "$8'# $+-# /-$+'$$+"8'# "" $ #-9#$'

$'$$+'$#+',,'" ,"/ ;;'(' #$ //!! $+"*" $+'9# *$+""'

$+*'$8+$+"$+'

'$ '$-'//.',,'" ,"/ ;;$+"#-/$*%'. ;;

'#"" $+ $'9-/'$ "(#$"8'#*'1 +-#$+#-9#2- $%##-$$+ '

'$8'# $+9'##**'1"",",'"9.:-#+-,$'$+ $+ '/ (/"1 $#$9 $$+'$$+#,-$#$=# ?.'"#/'$"*"=$+ '$*,'## (-$ '- $*$+*'$$+'$$+,$$ "+'=("'$$ '

'''

*"=$+"+''"##'","# $'$ $+.'"!

?9.

8'. * 0='/ *"= ( +" '=## 8++ 8-/ 9 /'" *"=

0 :++'#-(+$')"*'$ /$$"8++8'#$9() 9.

$+ (#$"'" '- $*8++#++'#/#$-$ $+(" "

$#$+-#$9 $$+'$$+- )"#$. $#8 )"*- $+'$$+ "$*'$##-8'#9(-#'

/. )8*$+*'$$+'$#++'##-(+$ *"='$ ? .'"# /'$" $+ =,-( "" +'# 9 ,'##

3 !!

8++8-/9 ("'# $#$'#$+""8++ +'#9 ,'## #,$*$+*'$$+'$$+"8'#' 2-".","$

; !

;9.$+#$"$-(4 $7 +"*')-"4

6!7$#

'/#$9 $$+'$8+/,'## ($+#-9#2- $""'$ !!

0!?7$+<+'

//"*$+"#, $0- )"#$. $ ##-'

.#-+ $$$+,$$ "$+'$$+ 2-".","$#+-/9 #'"'

"""'# #'# $'9)'

"A$$+"(+$* $+,$$ "$/'=$+(" +"*')-" - #/*"$+,$$ "+'#"(+$/."/-, $+," ,/ */'88+++'#9 /'8 9.$+,5-"$

!"#$#-9=$$+'$9*"$+# 8'#$9 '$/'#$$+'-$+"$.#+-/+')##-'#+8'-# $ () ($+,$$ "'

,,"$- $.$","# $'#$8+.$+* (#

$+ 2-".","$8"/'9/$9#'" ,'"$*"=$+#$+"'""$' ##-# 8++- $$+# -"$*/#$+=,-( ""# $A-#$*+=#$=,"$'

$'#,$ 8++#$9 $#$+'$$+,$$ "'# $+'$'1 '=##

$+.'" ;9.8'.*""#, $+#'-"#+#,-$ +''"# '$$+'$, $*$='#$8+$+"$+'

'$8++'*'/"

9 ,/' =,'"$= $ $+* '/5'= '$ *$+'

$'1

'=## $$+""#, -"#'*$",'## (5'=#

:,$=9" $+ #-,,/= $'". 5'= '$ -/ 9 ,"=$$ $ $ - + ,$$ " */ B 03C! * ;; 8++ $ 8'# #,*'//.'//($+'$#++'9 "//*"$+.'" ;0;'$ "//= $00@0! #++'($=,'"$= $ ,',"

*5'= '$ *"=$+/+

)"#$.:++'',, $+ ==- '$ '$ ;

C ;;4

0!78+"9.+"/(9/$.

+' 9 2-#$ 9. $+ "#, $0- )"#$. $+ #'= "'# '#

# - "

!"# $ %& '

& ( )*"$+

, -.

/+ 0& 1

, 2 3 + 3

%& '

& 1 143

5 33

1 2 , +

1+3+ 6+ 2 .,

,1 %&

+%&

87+9 :

8; - 3

++9

%& ' %& & < +-#$#',,'" $$+'$8'.9'1 $+.'" ;;#+8'# '/"'.9*"$+#-"$#1 (,"$$ $+#$" ($+*'=##

$+-"#8+++'#9 -9$9.$+=,-( "" $+ ("- $+'$ $+ ( +'# 9 #+8 $+'$ #+ 8'# ' #$- $ * $+ "#, $- )"#$. $+#'.'" 8++#+) $-'//.($"0',,'"

!C C ;;,$$ "8'#("'

$' $"="" $+ #'=$"=#'#,'## B ! ;* ;;'$!?

! ;;+ $"="$ 8'#$+'$$+"#, $#8"$ $ -$#-,,/.$+ ,$$ ",#$'//$-"#'

$+"'*$" )8*$+ $"=""'#,"

$+==- '$ '$! C ;;4

0C7#+8'#'//8$ $ - $+-"#+#'/$$""'#'#- "

8; -

3 ++9 : :%#$0 #=:':

& ( : > )*"$7;+

, -.

/+ 0& 1

+7, ; -

3 %&

& ,

5 +

2 2 41? ?

++ ; -

3 %&

& 143 + 2 )

0'=#:

&2%& & @ - ++, "# $ ; - 2 ?757 #=:':

&< +8"$,$$ 8'#$+"'*$"#,#*'/ (8$+9- + *8"$,$$ #'

$+/''#8'#B ?C * ;;$$/'# ! " # $ %

3 ;;

$8'#+/$+'$#-+#$- $#8" $$/*"$+9 *$*$+'=##

$+""#, -"#+"/)'

$,'"'#*$+#'"""'#'# - " A / + +

3 3 1/++6

2 3 31 3 1 2 5

3 2 , ; -

3 /

2 +, 2 3 ; -

3 / ; 7 + -.,

+ 1 3+ B

, 233 3+ , 3 / /3 / ; 7 +-.,

+/ +3 3,

, 2 143 3+ , /

2 ; -

3 ++ / +1

++,

2 6

3 2 3+ 1 12

2 ; 7 + -.,

+ ,1 8+, -.,

2 ++ /+1+

; - B +-.,

8> 9 7

B 3 1++ /

++//

C , 2

; -

3 3+

2 +.,

/ 3 1 + < ,'"$*"=$+'9)*'$$+,$$ "+'#'/#,/'

6 ##-9.$+

)"#$.8++8-/#+8$+'$#+ +' $'//.$'1 '=## $+.'" ; "-#'/*$+#'=8-/ ( $#+8$+'$+""(#$"'$ -=9"#= $ '#00@!

#++'9 ')#$" /)'"-#-= $#9. 3 ? ;

5-" 0! # '

$$. '" ##- !

3 ; *" $+ ""#, -"#A $"' (*$+'//-= $#8-/( $ #+8$+'$9'##*$+""$+'$,$$ "8'# $'#$- $ $+.'"

;;'

+' $9"-(+$ ""$+ ##'". *"='$ #'(' #$$+ "" '$+"$+

)"#$.9 ("#, $ $+'9)#'/$('$

+''##$'//$+"" - #/ *" $+ ,$$ " +'# "*"" $ $+ *'$ $+'$

'- $*($$ ("0',,'" $+-"# ;;#++'',,'" $+ #-,,/= $'".5'= '$ %'. ;;

+""#-/$+'9 #+8 '#

#-/$@'$"/(9/$.4 @7+"'*$"$# $#,-$$+'$) ("8'###-$+"

? ;;!4

667'

5'= '$

"$*'$ ! ;;4

6?7+#-9#2- $-= $#'" '/# $#,-$'

$99.$+- )"#$.'##-+ 8)"$+ $")"#.'"#=' /. '- $*$+*'$ $+'$$8%#8++8"##- +"*')-"'(' #$:"'/3 ?

'(' #$$+#'="(#$"'$ 00! $+$+%#8"*)

'$ ! ;;

67 %'"":"3 ?

8+"'#$+" -=9"#33!+=,/. '=/.:-#+&-='"8+

+',",'"$+%8'#'/#,"'(' #$,'"$= $'//. ,"/= '". 2-". -$9. "*##"& :%'+'/8'"$+"8'#'

'=## 9. $+ =,/. $+'$ % 8$+ :"'/ 33! +' 9

,",'"9.+='

++',-$+##( '$-"# $+9'1#*$+% 4

6;7 $'//.)

$+#$"$'

:## -( $7:+"'" '=+'() ')"#* ('(' #$$+,$$ "

$+("- $+'$$+#'#"'/ -=9"#+''/#9 ##-$$+"$8 '

'$# '=/.#+-+-A''

%# 1+' '

$+"*"$+ %-/ $+')9 ##-$$+,$$ "$$+'$, $*$=

$+"$+,$$ " "+"*'$+"+',"-$+"( '/%8++ 8'# *$+"'# #*"$+')"#* ("" #-/$'

$/.$+ *"#$=,-( ""'$ 3 !!

+'9 ,'### $$+"#

#,-$$+'$ $+#-9#2- $","# $'$ $+='$$"8'#"0/1 $'

$+#-9#2- $ 2-".","$'= *')-" ; !

;$# '/#$9 $$+'$ $+# 2-". :+" 'A#+%'/+$"'+' ',,'"'

'=$$$+'$++',",'"$+%9'" (:"'/ 3 ? $+ 9'## * $+ "#-/$0#+$ 8++ +'# 9 /'" )

$*'$ '$ ! ;;

:=/'"/. &-/,: (+/"1 * $+ ( " ( // +' '/# ',,'" '

() ' #$'$= $

! !

;$+'$++'+1$+%9'" (33!'

,-$+# $'/'$$+9'1*$+%8+++'9 ##-$#+-+-A'+ =,/.8+8'##=##*"=#"):-"#+/"1 +##$'$= $ +''=$$$+'$%9'" (33!8'#,",'"9.+='

++' ,-$+# $'/'$$+9'1*$+% $+"##05'= '$ ++'

'=$$ $+'$ + $ 1 8 $+ ,$$ " ,"# '//. "$/. '

"$/. $#'/#$9*-"$+" $$+'$'#,"

6!!8++ #2-)'/ $$

0!,"-9.$+- )"#$.8++#'"#-/$0 #+$$+ '=*$+,$$ "*(-"#'(' #$$+"//3 ! !!'

$+ $'/='"1# +"%8++'",$'#;

**" $#-9A$# '"'#,"$+"#-/$#+$$#$9 $$+'$$+,$$ "+','## +"#'(" " )# 8++8'# *$+"/)'

$"'# #$ 8(+8$+$+ 2-".**"'/#$+'$*$+("+'9 ,",'" *"'--/ $/.$+,$$ "8-/ $+') /.,$*"")# '

8-/+'),"*""' #$)# *'*"'-8'#9 ('""-$+ #'"'# (# $#-**"*"='

. *"=$. $+, *$+# -"$ + 2-".**"+' $$+'$,'(!*$+"(#$"

+'#9 $"

**'

#-/$'$ 8$+$+"#-/$9"'

+$+,'(+'# 9 " #$"-$'

$+,$$ "8'# $,"# $$+"*"$+#'= -/ $9',$+""+' $)"9 ,","/.=' $' $ 8'#'/# $$+'$#++'$'1 '=## $+-"#- "$+ ""#*$+#-"$$#*-"$+" $$+'$$+"( '/("+'#'/# 9 ,"- #-/$'

$/.$+9 *$*-9$8'#$($$+,$$ "

$+-#8+/,'## ($+=,-( ""8$+-$##- ('

. $'# #-+$+#*'$#+') $9 1,$ #"'$ - #/*"$+,$$ "+'#9 '$,' #$#-9=$$+'$$+ ,'"$= $'/," (#'(' #$$+ "

/"1+'#9 $'$'

$+ 2-".","$'$ C !

; $+'#9 $$+'$%

9'" (33!4

67'

$+"#-/$0#+$

0!!8" ',$'#

5-"#'

0C $+#' 2-". 2-".," (# ) $+#' 2-".**"'=$$+ /-# $+'$='"1#*$+% $'// 8$+ $+ $". "#-/$0#+$ '(' #$ // 3! !! * $+ ,$$ "'

$+"*"%-/ $+')9 ##-$+"'(' #$ #"'/3 ?8+ $+'#9 ##-'(' #$33! - #/*"$+,$$ "'/#, $-$$+'$*"=$+"##0 5'= '$ * B0! '=/. :-"'A +'

:-," $ $ $+ ,'"$= $'/," (#8+++'9 $'$8+,#$+'$$+ -"#8'#'#$'

$-"###-+$+/'##*'$ ("-, ( * //#8'#"#")*"**" $D #6:$'$#/1* - A'9*

'A'#+$'

$+'$'- $$+"+'9 '+-((',9$8 // #!! $!!!

*" +''/#9 ='$5+9$0 9.

$+ #' 8$ ## 8++ # $+ ,+$,. * $+ "#-/$ #+$ * 5'= '$ %'. ;; '

'# ," $ $+" # (', 9$8 $8 "//

-=9"# &, ( )8$+'9)#-## $+#-"$#*$+ , $+'$$+* ($+'$$+""* ;;8'# $,"# $8++/ $+<+'

//"$,'##$+=,-( ""#8$+-$'

.A-#$*'$

'# $ + ,$$ " +' '/"'. ',,"'+ $+# -"$ #1 ( ,"$$ '(' #$$+#2-'/*'$ +"(#$"'$ -=9"/'"/.

#+8#$+'$$+,$$ "8'#'#$- $'

$+"*"$-/ $+')9

+/$+'$,$$ "8'# $'#$- $ $+.'" ;;8++#$+9'# "'# *" #'" ( $+ % '

$+ (" ##- # $ #-9#2- $-= $# /.#-9#$'

$'$$+'$$+,$$ "8'# *$+

#$- $#*$+"#, $- )"#$.'

#-** $='$"'/+'#9 ,/' ""8+.$+"#'(', $+"// -=9"#8++8'# *$+ "'# #8++/'$$+,'## (*$+=,-( ""'(' :-** $='$"'/'/#'= "" )'"-# 2-"#$ #+8$+'$$+"8'##=""8+++'9 $"

-$8++$+ ,$$ "># //-=9"-/ $9$'// #-+"-=#$'

#'// $+# *'$# +') $ 9 $'1 $ #"'$ 8+/ ,'## ( $+ =,-( "" " (/.$+#-"$#*$+, $+'$$+=,-( ""# $A-#$*'9/'

$+#'=#/'9/$92-'#++#-"$#

$*/$+'$$#',,","'$$"=$$+='$$"*"*"#+ #"'$ '$ $+##$'(1, ( )8$+*'$$+'$$+,$$ "+''/"'.,'##-$ $+.'" ;;

'#$8-/()'*"#+/'#*/*$$+/$('$ *"#+ "- * /$('$ '(' 8-/ ')"#/. '**$ $+ /* * $+ ,$$ " " (/.$+,"# $8"$,$$ #'//8 % &

#6 ')

B+$+"#,'1 (6"'# # B+$+" ,"$'9/ #