← Library
High Court of Punjab and HaryanaCWP/15240/2019allowed

M/S Asf Insignia Sez Pvt. Ltd. v. State Of Haryana And Others

2023-02-10Ms. Justice Jaishree Thakur12 pages



     



  

 

  !"

#"

   !$ ""

%&'  %"& 

(  

   !   "

 

 ) *++ ,, +(     -, ,&.   +$/+0,,(     "

! 

"+( 3( +/ 4$ 451 +6 $  7 *3 + $0 0$/ $$ +0($.( +4  /+ / ++4  8$ /4 *+(  *   #0  $ +(4  0  +90(00( $.

"6 $4 .:;"6<+=,(   1+ , 7+4 0+( 2 *   #0, $ 4 4+$*++4 90(00($.,+(   0(+>++($* *+4*, (.+0($. +   + *+

22 0$   $   "6,  +  4,  (  +  0(  $.  0$  *   ,?,,?@A2*+4* (64$5 +4 ,3(+ +0($. $ /.+ +43+ ,(+4 / *90(0 (.0 0($.,+ +((4/40($.+44/$ /. +4  +( +(  2"6* +4  (./4 4$+4$+(++4+44 $44. 0 . 7(+04+4 +*  +0( $.3 / *$ +4/.+,+( 3 ( +/ 47 *$  +( + 0 . +(    .

4 & ,+( 3(  ) *++ ,4 $ 4(( * /+4+( 3$4$/0++4.0($. + * +4 .+(      0(,3+ ( $/2 : =(+ 0( $.

           4  *$  +  (    1  +    4 00$  $ +0($.( + $    600      00$     B



 7  +   (  7$(+$3++ 4(,3+ $ +$4 7$(+03++  0  "+00$  4/4 +0+$+  3++3$44 +0($.+$4 +/ +*

2 2 @  ,   -, ,&. ,4 $ 4 (( * /+4+(  23$4$/0++(  + 4$0  +( ( /$+0($.+/ (/.(  

2"6#   +(  , + ( $ 0($.$ +( +   0( *$+ @B A@+( $$ $ 0($. ++(   +$  +++$ 4+( 3++  +* +$*++(4 *+ +43((4/4 04.,+( + 44 +(+ (4  0 (   1 +4+( 0($.*+0*  04$5+# *0 ,3+$.+( 4+((4 0 $ +0($.

64$5+#*0 $  ;

 

  

 

 

    

 

  

 

    

                    

  

   

  

 





  

 

  

 



       

                

  !      "

  



 #

2@2  +0($.+ / $  +( + 0/$+0($.(/.+407C$0 *  +4 , 4./+4++( ++4$ ((++&*+6$$ 45+6 $   7 * /$$  (  6+(+  0(, ?BB,   $0 +*/43+$.,3+($/24$

+ . $0 9$,/.,, /+4,, $,+ 4(,D    3++. *$($(+ (4  0 ,+ $0 +44/90(0(.0  0($.

"+ ($$  ;



     

 

  $     %

     

 



        

           

 &     

 





  &     '     

     (

 )            * + # ?

$0  93++3( 3$4 $+$((+( $ +0($.40 600$  



, 9$ 2 @,0 46+ ., $ 600(0 + 46+ .2$02  4600 , $  *0 

2A2 (0 ,;

 

"

" (



  

 ,-$ .%

   ,-!/         *+$

   E<(  2$+3 *4.7+ 0($.+$4 +/ +* 38$7$+  $ 0($.

  +     ,  +  4    3++  3  $/C   (.0     0(  $. +  /  9$    

  /3  + (        "6  #     *  $(     0 "+ 4*. 0 "+ 4*. /4:;""

<= ((4  0 :; <=($$ ((4* /.

 0           

AA5,   

1   

 0     &.       @B5B2@F2 ,   

B,$ +4 (   + %  +4 3++0($.+/ +*(+ , 3$4/ 0+44,+03$4/90( 0(.0 0($.

(+( +  0(,

?BB  3++  (  +    $.  +44  /  +*    (     .  $0 9$+($(. *$+($(+ (4  0   0 

:=+&. 

,  A,  3++  90(  44              00/4 ((.$0 4+,3+ +  0 0+ 0($.,+0344*44.+*  3/ *  "+ ( +* *0($. 4 3++44 3+ +(4  0  "+ +(    44.

252 0  *+0($.* +4 44*44.   *+0(48$+ */ 0  00  /.+  0 4, $ /4

# $ 4(( * /+4+(  + +0 4.*$++ ( $ +0($.  * +($4 &+*$+ @B+  0(    (0  $     +  0(  $.    $  *$     $0+$   A443$ $   @B+((4 $ 03+ +0( $  A+  @B A+  0( ($+$  ;

  

 

  

   0

 

 

1  1 

  /        

23         

          "

    

  

 

      45      

  

  



               

                       

    

 

 



     5 6 7

 

8



212 

    

       



         

      

   



      

 



     9    



  "

 

    



  '     

 

 

  



                        



  

     



 



         

  



  

4 

           

 

  

  

              

           5 6

 

       

  9

    

     "

 

        

 

  

2?2 '                 

      

       

   

    

      :         

  

        

   

    2       

       



      &   

         ;

 

  1    

  



 

 

   



 



       <   

        

      

         

 



 



       =  

  

 



          



    



        4 

     

 



        



 

  





G!      /  

'9        





2B2

       

 # !

     



  !   

  :> 

      5 6       2       9       

  

      



 '        

  

                             4 

5  

 

 

  %    

      

 

" %      

         

   





        

        

     # &3,+*$0 3$4 /4/4+(   +*$ ++ ( $ +  0(4 +*0($. + $0 $*+/*3++3 3+ +

"+.7 *0($.  ( +* +4/. +( +

2 2   0( +&.   ,+,+*$0  $ $ /4  +3,+43 +*3444 + 

     (4 5A+6 $   45A+6 $  + / 4/$( /.+6 $ 4F ++$(06$ "  #  $  %&'() *+,, - 3+ +/ +4+ .944 .43+/ $   AC$*0 $  ;92 $  9;2 /       % ? 

      ? !      



   @     

 

   

                            

  1   

     

 /   $  9;2             A  "? ?       

   

         

 /   # $+  4/0C$*0  /.$&*+ 6$ . ,

$   #  $  + /0& 1!'(+,,2# /3!3++7 +  /.+ $(06$ "  #  4  ) * "+&*+ 6$4+ 5  $  6,7&1!! +,,2# .

11 ++4+0($.443+$$+.43 /

2

2   045A+6 $    

 C$*0 $  ;66  .   

   



29 $       

            $   9;2    

/  %    

   

      

  

        

  %   

     

       

29 $ #

 +( 3+$ .$+.43,0($.+ / 440(   13+4* *+4(4 $  3++* *0($. $+(44. 90($   :

=+  0(  

+    + $0 90(,+* *0($. ($(* 3+$ .$+.43 ,+, 3$4/445A+6 $  

6 8$ 4.  *++ +(  

 5 +* *0($. +44*44.  *+0( 00  +0/$ /.+ 46+ ., $ 600(0 ,&.  .+ ( 43 ,+,+( + ,3++ 0 . (   14 +0($. $ + (  ,3$4/ 4$ +04 *3+ H1I

2 2 ( $00+,+03(44+0$  $  J(  443 +/0 #  "

$   10!!%   C     J++(7 *  ' J++(/4

'