High Court of Punjab and HaryanaCWP/11433/2013allowed

Subhash Chander v. Financial Commissioner & Secy. To Hry. And ORS.

2018-10-30Mr. Justice Darshan Singh10 pages

!" "

#" $%&&" '("'! " )*! " +* ,-.!/ " *" "

01'%-.1-("'

2 &" &3 " " & & "3- "- , % 3 & *!

%%,3"!" '-

4 52 *""/32 %!" !"

*"& )/ - ("'( !

*" '"

2 %%3 ,"* "3!! 6

.7 "4 % " *", %! & *" "% "3 "&! 3 *" "3"!3 && " %%3%%%& %!& "3

8%- 9 &"% #%%3 ) %* " 2 *""3 &"! "% /"' "3- "&% *"!3 ! !3 *", ! :

! %3 !!!

;

.7 "4 *! ;=

' .!!% 0 !3-> % & "

? &, %- !*"&% *"!3 !* " &* 3! "3 !! 6

%%8*'@

2 *"" , %"/3 2 %!" ,"/!, "34 %%33" ""3 %"&&! '"<<;4<<9 A&"

%%& %! & "3

>49 /%%3 ) %* "-"> %" %,2 #3%B " - .&%//3! &"! &!)*";

" -<<< !3 *"3 %' ""3 %"

"*"-"&%,"3"!

3 *"! "$"? "&)*"!! "-

"3"! !" 96= 9 = 6=

4B ?! !" ! "/ ""

*.- <

2 .!!% 0 !3-> %'"!"!!

<! "3! !-&3 "'- "

"&3 "&% "3,&! !!%'- & %!!, ,"!3 , "3%," %!-!%"! - "3!! "!!% *," "'3!' *","%%!! "3 /3 ' *%! '!! "&*" %"*"*"! !" 6 " " "% " " *"" /4 !," " !" %!! !3

2 %"!.!!% 0 !3 %! " %!!!

'/!3 !, "- %!

""!''" &3 !&! ,"3

%3 " &%/2 ! &,"& !!

!/! "' "3 %! "&!3 ! . ":

"! ' %, "3" ! & *"2 %!", !"3" ! & , /"*"! " & ""3"?, 3 *" " 3 *" ," *"!

" & "3"3 "' 2 %%3! 3 ! & ! %3 !' ! ! %%!!

"3/3 2 %"!.!!% 0 !3! "!" ! "3 ,"3"! '"

#3%"*"!%%

< /3%3"! "

"" "- %%-% %' 3"&3 , ! 3 ! &"% %%! ' /333'2 *"/ "/ ""

*., %!&*' % "& /!""! & / ", ,' ! /! %!!" ',"3&

,'" "'"3"3 ! & /!2 *"' "', 7

%% !3 *",*"/", '

!'"3"3 ! &C/ &*% ! %!' %% "' "'" " "

3 ","!%8**"*,"8' ' %% %!! " *," "' %! "!! " %%! +!" 6-

! )3".-<

)3"3.

"' *," /" '"", " 7 ! & *!% !* !*"*"'""

!"3" 3" ! % " ! 2 " ! 3 "&33' !% !3 *"!

" %!%! "&"&% "33 *" ! " ; 2 %%3! ""3 %" ," "%! *"! 0 "'-<<;.

"%* '" "& "3!!

"'" "! "3 "&%- *", "/!, !*"&% "34 !""

%6 ("' /% "/ &.**%) %-< 6 " "5) %@ 6 /&"-

.74 & %%3 ! ;=

2 *" %!"*%'

"34 6 $"

"'-

.74 7*%3 "&% !!!! "3 !% !3 *"

<.:

",**! !

!&:

"'"%'3 & %%3 "*" , "&% , "3"! ? 83" ! *" **" ! "' %3 * 9 2 *%! "" %& !*"&%:

"' ":

%"! "3"&% "3 ! *! * %, !*"&% !

;

"&%*"!3 & % %'" " " 6 2 *"%&"' & & *" ! "3!' "&"! 3/ % " *" /33 3'%%":

! &=&"%2 '!!'

"&%! !*"&%*"!3"! & %%3

2 *" ',' **%49

9 *%! ""! ! & .7 4; 4 7 " %! , * 2 ! & " .%%& .

"' *"!3 , ' "

/%- 1 %- > % ? , ,

% *'

/! &3 "%%& !* ! %!/%% !&"/="/ / ' %" !! &"-<<;.74;2 /%-1 % 7! &3 9 &"- <<; ":

3 %8 )& .33",%-"!3"?-1 %!> %,!" 3

#%%3("-> %! &3 %%&

%!&'&!*""

%.749 *"*% "

%%& %!!%"! !" ("'%3D!

(%!3.-<6 " "5. <6 @!*" & ("'+%E

! "." &-<69 "3"!3%%& %!!%"!#%%3) %* "- 2 %1 %-"> %- ", :

""&!%% %"2 "

9 ! .749 !!9 &"-<<; 3! ' .%%& .

"'- 1 % > %- 5"!3 %%&*"*% 2 %!".3""-1 %! 3/ ' 41/"& &"- %%& "' **"/!$"&+ !@" %%&.7 46!! &"-<<;, %3!' .%%& .

"'-1 %.74 %" "& 1/"& * '&&"-> %!!

"! &"-

, !" /, *!3!*"&%:

"' !") % 6 ) % < 6-3" '*! *", , !

"" "&3/"&"/ &"-

3 3 ;

'"(,/"- *'& *"/% *!%/ &,!"!"%! < ? / "!%"! % " *"! /% 3 " 3 **"48 ?'!! *"*% "%%&

%!,&!' 2 %!".3""-1 %*"

.7492 *",2 %!" 2 %!" .3"" " , *" %%& "', ,

"/%1 %- *"F *""

"! "/ ,3 " %%&, !' %%& "'2 *" ! "% *%' %%& *" %!

!%"! - ,"*! "3 *"',

/"/

%, !%! "3" "&% 3 &2 *" %!/""!%'%3 *"! &*"!

/ ! & %!!

6 ! *," "' "&% "3 2 ! &,"8* !"8!

"3 /3! "

'"3 "! /%% %3 !' ""!! ' "% "! //*"!

*" * 3 "' "2 !*"& *"!3 &*"/ * !&%

% " "! %!%3!"'*" 2 *% %% 3 38 ?"'3*" ! " % & %%, !"/ *"&! !*"&% *"!3 %! G , %%',"3'3 *",! "3!'3/3 & ! "

"3 ,!!!&"2 - ,/"-! & "% 8*%!*"/! %% , *% %!!- !*"& 3 %%,!

- % * " &"% " , , *"! "&%!*!*"*!"

*"%B!- !! %%3 "!" %"! .!!% 0 !3 ! "33 7 !

% !3 *"""'! !; ""'

*"*"& %! /! "% "'%!3 *"//!=!!%/!"3 "3 &' **%'3"%/&"%"3 *" 3'- '&"%' %!!?

%3%* %! %!%!%% /'" ! %%&- *"*"/ ;; . <6 ! *"

2 %!" !"3"!1"%," ."' 6-

< 6; 0 "'-<<9- %! / " :

! %%& "'

/%-1 %, !! ! &" "3" % !!!%%%!, ,, A "! *" ?

" '/% "

%-!" /!7" " 3 ""! "% " *"/7 ""'""&%"%" "%/ "&%!!&*"!32 &

&* "3 &* 3! "34 & %' *" / , )& "- ," ! " &-&"!" #%%3>,","3%'%%!

*"D"-'3," ."' "& &- %!,

" "%!, " %!%!

%% /'" " %%&2 ! &"%! "34 " " C:

"')*"; <<<

#3%B " -.&%/! %"%3 %%&

>49 %! #%%3)%* "" "& "3!82

"& "3 !&:

"'! "&%"!% "" 2 *" "3 33/7!, & &* "3, !%!! "3 "&% "/"- "34 ! '" " !! "'" "! "3 "&% , "!%'%3&2 /!,%%"& & "%* !!! % 2 "&% " "3 "/3 " &*% "

< %%3! "!" ! "3 *"2 *", %%& "'?

"*" ! *" *," "'7 !' %%-! %%, *"!, % %!' %% "!*"'?

",'& % "- 3 4 * %!8!, " ' !*"

"&! "!

*"*"%' %%& "'2 "33 *"* 3,"3%%&&!

*" "& %%& "'-&%'- BB> 8-( - -1 %2 "3 !%% "% %%& "' /3!! "

" !C/%"- %!,

" "%! *," "', *", "3"3 "'( "&! %%&", "3"3 "' %!! *"*"' " "&8 3!"/3:

"' **3 '" <<;4<<9?

*" %!*"/ "3 "&%"% /!%%!' *" -, %! !*"& % *"/ "3 !*"&% *"!3 & %%3!&"%! "%3* &? //"'" ! *"

/3 !% , "%' %**3 "3 ' "*! !*"& & &"% ""! %' ! " *" " ""& ! &8 & *3!!*"/ & *!""&!

2 "! **"' ", ,! *%*" "8

$" """!!/- *%%,! ! &* 3! "34 !! 6 /&"-

.7 4% *"!3, ": % "" :

!!!%%3%-"""'! "%.%% *"' % !3 3" ' "%! *", ,& "& ! "* " !

*' "!" %3, *"*%& ! %,%% ""' H"*" &%%"%E*'%' ""3

%= "& = ",*8?*"&' 3 " * %! *%'!

*!' "&% " !*"&%*"!3- &* "', %!%8 *! *"I"!3%'!"! ! ! ",%3%*""

%!'*3 *83"!"/'! *"'&!$" "'

< , *' "3"' ", ":

*% %

"*"

!"#"$"#% &