M/S Utility Powertech Ltd. v. M/S Chopra Bros (India) Pvt. Ltd. And Others
!"
"#$%$ &' ()$* +,
'- ./0 0
!"#!
$
%& '#$
$ #$
) !
( *+ 0,/ ) * % , -
& "
. ( " ( - & ( ,/ 0.
)1 % $ **2**3
( -
-
," , " , $ )142 - 5
' % ,
6 " %
, )
#
, ""
- 7 ( "
", " #!, ,6 1!2"03 - (, ,( !
8 ( # !, , 6
, $#*992# :!2" #!-/ % , - * - ( +)9+*9*9 ( " , + $- % -&" - ( -
& ($ ;"( *<299=> ,
& ) # " #
& )*9**993 "
(
&#
# (
&
, -
&
, +)9+*998- ( 1
&
#19? # 2+1 )9 @ *998 , 491A +))**998% - )9?
(, , "
&( > ; 5 # - # , 9898*9)A# ,
& -
&
- > ;# # )9? - !- B # > !, 6 C " ( 1!2" #$*$! !$ & 5&#$*3 9898*9)A
&"
( )#**#13#484. , 8#+4#48#A49. *1)9*9)1% ,
( -5 - C # # -
-5 - " ,-
$ - B
""
" - )- '
+
#
- % ) ,- - &" , -5 ( , ( ,- / #
"
, ( !
8 ( $# ,, .
-, 989))182 # # ( ,- ( $ ," - ( ,"( ( ,
&
&*998- ( , (- ( "
( "
" -"
( & "
, ( " (" , !
8 $
$,
,
< % ,"
(
& # ", " ( > !"#!
$
%& '#$
( $ # $
( '
)
, B
( , "
& ) )*9**993
&
, +)9+*998 1
& 19? , 2+1 )992*998- B +))**998 , ( 491A , )9?, "
& - ( ),
( , ( )#**#13#484.
*1)9*9)1 " , "
8#+4#48#A49. # # " 1#48#42#9+4. %
-, ( ( !"# !
$
&" )
$ , " !6$- (" (, , !
8 $ *9)2- "
- B (
5
( & - ( , ( " - ! $ # $
" , ("
, !
8 $ . B "
!" # !*9)2+ $0 488#$
%
! % &
'
!()# *9)**
)14#
*% +
( %
%
&
'
*9)8$ 0 )89= '
*)988 (*9)8
,
&
%
&
+
+" (
& , 7%/ 0#$8"& $ (2 )9 :!/ .!;/ <%/ %/ 8! ( )!$#5* !5"):!/.!;,$- $ '
*+ (*9)8#7% %5&"=) **".$9$!";'&!6"
" # ! $ '
2*24 ( *9)8 $ '
) (*9)8# 7% 9>=& ) %!)5#!5)")$: !"
<%/$%#) &;09 **&!")()$%"%#= 499A*9)3 '
*)2)4*9)3 2"&;5) $%!)$#!
(") !$:"<%/ 7%$#) (*"? &;$ , =
'
+483* (*9)* -
+ $ " -, #
&
)*9**993
&
, +)9+*998 , +))**998 (B " "
" - (, , !
8 $ *9)2# (
"" ( ,,,
( , ## "
& , " " # *9)2# # , ) & ,- ((
,
*9)1( ))
,(
, -
,
& 0"#!$ &
9
& ( $ ( @%9 ** "&!")()$%"A@%5((*$")A (
.
9 @%9 ** "&!")()$%"A , ( -. (
-. ( - (-. ) !
3D
& @%5((*$")A, , , #
( , , -. ) ( !
8# #.
' !, # - " , " , $#)142) ()142
, 0
,
(! % #-
, # - " , " , $#)142) ()142
, # .
# - # -
, # " ( , "( ""
""
- , , "
- D
" ( !
*
" (
@%5((*$")A( ( , , -. ) (!
8 - ,( -& *9)2 # #!, ,6 0
, $#*992 , , #,, , ( ( , " ;
, C , < '
) ( - ( ( !/)2+26 # *1!
,- #*992 ;
"
#0 0
(( ( B & 0 0 , " #!, ,6 ! ;
, % $, , , ,- ( -
- - , ,
""
,( ("
# ( # (-. ) !
8 $
-
, - ( , - ( ( !/*94*6 # +9 @ #*9)3 - ( *
, #, , , ""
,(" ("
" (
, , , ( !
3 $# ( , ,( -
, , - B ( -
C , C ,
- ( % -
"
(( ! '
) ,
$ , - - " -
- ,, (, , " % (
- , ( 5
& , " >" ,
< 5 ((
((
# $- (!
)1
#
-
5( 5 !, (
5 ,
-
-
" ( "
" # -
# - # " ))9+*9*9$ < .3 - * " ( -
C "- '
) ( - ( " *4))*9)1$ < .4
()$* +,
0 , = &" '
= - E '