Anil Kumar v. Superintending Canal Officer And Others
!
" !
!#$% (%)*+*&,
--
,*.
/01#2
------ %$*$*&,%2 3%2+0+ 405%2*,$%,(*,6 #,#.
''*)%27
%2&8%502 #,#.
*2).%7
%2&8%502 &$9%2+ ------
%+5&,(%,$+ : ;
4 4
2%+%,$ 2- -;- #<#<7 (=&)#$% 5%$*$*&,%2- 2- *21#.<*$ 4*,69 !*>#,#7 4%,*&2 ! 0,<#?- - - 4
; - 2#@%2 *,+$#,$ )*=*.
'*.%( 0,(%2 2$*).%+
A
&,+$*$0$*&, ,(*#7 *,$%2 #.*#7 *++0#,)% ,#$02% )%2$*&2#2* +%$$*,6 #+*(%
5#++%( !*=*+*&,#.
#,#.
''*)%27 ?&9#2 *, +9&2$ :!: - -
7 5#++%( 405%2*,$%,(*,6 #,#.
''*)%27
%2&8%502 *2).%7
%2&8%502 *, +9&2$ :4:-
2*%'.@7 3*+9#.
/01#2 #552&#)9%( )#,#.
#0$9&2*$*%+ >*$9 5.%# ?%*,6 *22*6#$%( : !:
)&,,%)$%( >*$9 &0$.%$
40C9)9#*, *,&2 =*..#6% 4#2(#2502#7 %9+*.
?&9#27 !*+$2*)$
#8*.C#7 9&>%=%27 +#1% (%1&.*+9%( 5&*,$ :
5&*,$ : !:7
#))&2(*,6.@7 52#@%2 1#(% >#$%2)&02+%-
+055&2$ )&,$%,$*&,7 2%.*#,)% 5.#)%( 05&,
A7 5#++%( !%50$@ &..%)$&27 ?&9#27 >9%2%?@ 9% 9#( '*B%( $02, >#$%2 >#2#?#,(* C9#.-
- #55%#2+ ).#*1 &?<%)$%( &>,%2+ $92&069 >9&+% ?%*,6 ).#*1%(D 5.%# : !:
20,,*,6 +5&$ ,&2 +*6, (%1&.*+9%( C9#.
%=%, '*%.( +$#''
9#( 2%)&11%,(%( >#$%2)&02+%-
5&, )&,+*(%2#$*&, 1#$$%2 >%..
2%)&2(+7 ! 9*1+%.'
*,+5%)$%( +5&$ -
'&0,( C9#.
5&*,$ : :
5&*,$ : :
$&0)9*,6 -
'02$9%2 &?+%2=%( +*,)% /9#.
5&*,$ :! .&> .%=%.
7 $9%2%'&2%7 5&++*?.% *22*6#$% -
- !02*,6 )&02+% 9%#2*,6 5%$*$*&,7 )&,+%,+0+ #22*=%( &$9%2 #(<&*,*,6 &>,%2+ >#$%2)&02+%7 )#2=%( (02*,6 )&,+&.*(#$*&, &5%2#$*&, =*..#6%
7 7
7 7
20,,*,6 +5&$-
'02$9%2 #62%%( 5%2 &.( +*$% 5.#, #$$#)9%( )#+%7 : :
+9&>, (%1&.*+9%( +&1% .%,6$9 #..
5#2$*%+ #62%%( +#1%7 #))&2(*,6.@7 !7 =*(%
05&, )&,+*(%2*,6 )&,+%,+0+ #22*=%( 5#2$*%+ #55%#2*,6 ?%'&2%
9*1D &2(%2%( :!:
: :
5%2 10$0#.
)&,+%,$-
-
%%.*,6 #662*%=%( #6#*,+$
52%'%22%( #55%#.
?%'&2% 47 (*+1*++%(7 =*(% - -
- - #'&2%1%,$*&,%( )*2)01+$#,)%+7 '*.%( *,+$#,$ )*=*.
?%'&2% &02$ +%%C*,6 2%.*%'+7 ,&$*)%( 9%2%*,#?&=%- - ;%#2,%( +0?1*$+ &>,%2
+#,)$*&,%( ,&2 #,@ 20,,*,6 $92&069 .#,(-
'02$9%2 +0?1*$$%( E0%+$*&, >2&,6.@ &2(%2%( ?% 2%+$&2%( ?#+*+ 10$0#.
)&,+%,$ !7 ,&$*)% &2 +011&,+ %=%2 *++0%( 5%$*$*&,%2-
'02$9%2 ).#*1%( 7 :! 20,,*,6 +5&$7 .*,%(
7
7 7
#))&2(*,6.@7 52#@%2 +%$$*,6 #+*(%
A 1#(%-
%#2(- A- + 2%6#2(+ '*2+$ )&,$%,$*&, 9% &>,%2
&?+%2=%( =%2,#)0.#2 )&5@ @%#2
2%)&2(%( &>,%2+9*5 &6#
#1 +&, #2(#++
+9#2%
&,@ >*'% &6#
#1
+9#2%-
2%1#2C+ )&.01, 7 %,$2@ 10$#$*&,
*,(*)#$*,6
%B$%,$ /#,#.
+9&>, 9#=% %B)9#,6%( &,% 3*+9,0 /01#2 +&, 0.+*
#1 ,*.
/01#2 5%$*$*&,%2- A- !02*,6 )&02+% 9%#2*,6 5%$*$*&,7 +5%)*'*) E0%2@ 2#*+%( >9%$9%2 C9%>#$ 7 *,).0(%+
5#2$*$*&,%( #1&,6+$ )&+9#2%2+7 9&>%=%27 2%+5&,+% ,%6#$*=%-
A-
#.+& (*+50$%( ,#$02%
#.+& #(<&*,*,6 #2% 2%)&2(%( :%92*:
*-%- )#,#.
*22*6#$*&,-
A- 9#$ #5#2$7 #.+& ?&2,% =%2,#)0.#2 )&5@ @%#2
7
7 7 6#*2 101C*, C9#. (%5*)$%( $9%2%*,-
9%, %,$2*%+ 2%6#2(+ %B*+$%,)%
#2% )&,+*(%2%( 2%.#$*&, +*$% 5.#, 7 ).%#2.@ 2%'.%)$+ %B*+$%,)% >#$%2)&02+%- % 1#@7 )#,#.
#0$9&2*$*%+ ?%.&> 9#=% &2(%2%(
52*1#2*.@ ?#+*+ )&,+%,+0+ #22*=%( &>,%2+ #(<&*,*,6 .#,(+-
1@ )&,+*(%2%( =*%>7 %=%, *'
&?$#*,%(
%B)9#,6%7
*,'#)$ 5#2$ C9%>#$ )&,+*+$*,6 +%=%2#.
&$9%2 C9#+2# ,01?%2+7 %=%,$0#.*$@7 &,.@ ?%)&1%+ )&+9#2%2 C9%>#$ )&,)%(%(.@ #?+%,)% 5#2$*$*&,7 )#,,&$ ).#*1 %B).0+*=% &>,%2+9*5
02$9%27 '&2$9)&1*,6 %B).0+*=% 5&++%++*&,
- ;%#2,%( '#*.%( +9&> >9#$ 52%<0(*)% )#0+%( >*$9 52&=*+*&,*,6 C*.# .*,%
1@ )&,+*(%2%( =*%>7 1#@ +%%C 5#2$*$*&,
*'
+& #(=*+%( +& ).#*1 2%)%*=%( 9*1 %B)9#,6% .#,(- - =*%> #?&=% (*+)0++*&,7 '*,( 1%2*$ +#1% #))&2(*,6.@ (*+1*++%(- %,(*,6 #55.*)#$*&, +7 *'
#,@7 +9#..
#.+& +$#,( ).&+%(-
4
!
--
+<C+ 9%$9%2 +5%#C*,62%#+&,%( "%+
& 9%$9%2 2%5&2$#?.% "%+
&