High Court of Punjab and HaryanaCWP/14848/2012allowed

Meena Devi And ORS v. Oriental Bank Of Commerce And ORS

2017-04-07Mr. Justice Ranjit Singh14 pages

! "#$% &'(' )

* "+ %! -

%! .!

& "/00 "+ %! -

)# 12) 3))3 44

#4 )%"

"+,, 55 %(3%+*

6 , )% 7% *) "/

(+*

%! )%

8970 %(+*

%% )%

89, ""

(+*

%% 44 ,

%! & ! 6, , + 5

" :%

0$ "!

"5; ) % + & 0!% 57"

* + %+

+) ;(<<=, 0$ "!

", +5

", :,7% * + 87+:0

5 %>(6, & + ": %!!4

&!" <<=

+ %

&"!7% 0$ ";2 + .!)

* "+ %!( " "

% 0%+ %6 !$ !!

%;<( <<( ""

?7% 4(%+ % ":

& %+ ) %

+ & 0!% 57"

&") ;(<<=5

& @A %+ 5

&"!7% 0$ ";B% " * + !C@A0$7"+ ": D7

%&; "

, % , ;0 ! 6 !$ &&;%+ 5 !758

7% %+ % "

%;((

%! &

" 5 % ) % + & 0! % 57"

(%%

* ! !!7 +$7%!7

% 0 %+ %!+

%;<(<<* +

" ""

?7% 4@,

"6 ! "

&&;+ !$!

+5; ) % + & 0!% 57"

"* %'(!3

++ +( 6 !%+

" ": 3

, %,7!5 "+ % !, %)

&(6,6 &! "

7% &:7 %+ " %"

7% &, %!

& + ! " ! "+ %+ %! ?

":7% ("$ ;0 6 !0 5;% "/( %

"6 !!

"5 &

%!"* %<(

0 / ;0 ! 5* !

&": 6 , @A "

0$7"+ ": D7

%&; ! " % !$"!

! %

+( " $%

"6 !!750

, %0 " "/"

%( %+ !57%!

&":6 , "

$; $%

" , ! 5

"+ + 6

" ""

?7% 4 ! "! + % + $ !!

"+ " % !$"!

! %

+( " $%

"6 ! & & !E& :

&% $%

!%%

&": 6 , "

0$& ! & + 5 % "/ ":

057+!0 "B% >"

%;=(( ""

?7% 4<(

" " 0

;6 !" 5 ":$ & !

"/!

&&6 ":% $&;

%! "

%;@(#4

;7% 5* 0 +&

%, ! "%0

! "D7 "6 0 5;7% % ", (% $% 0$&; ": %+ % "15& 7% ++& !

7+:

+=@<< G$; "&!

+H % !$ $ % + @ ;

%! 6 + %

"" 0 / ;0 6 ,7 %+ % 7% " * 6 ;7% !750 !! " 7% %+ % +

' % :

%+ ": %

! " *7% !(6 &%

+; +* !

5% ", 0 /

;0 5 !" 5 ! ! 7% %+ % +

+ =@<< $; "&!

+ % ;7% "+% %+ 7 D7

!750 ;7% & 0 E % $% %7% %"

%;$% !! " 0

%I $; $&; "/ , ! 5

"+ + 6

" ""

?7% 4,

%!&

;6 !7%$% !

! 6 0 % % + @ ;

%! "&; " " %+ %+

%;<(<<$ !!

:,7% <<= " % !$"!

?7% 4( +

%; @( (

%! ++% !!

+ &

% && ":7$" !!7 !7

+ %

"! % ", % $% (

0 / ;0 !$ %+ %! 7"8 5

:, 7% +

%; <( << "+ %+ % ++ & !

7+:

+* %'((* + ""

?7% 4+

%;'(57

%!%

%%0

!6 0 ") ;=(<< !$ %+ %! !

7+:

%%; ":%

@A, 6 !"7% 1! %+ %!% & !!$ 5 "/1!$& ;( " !,0 * %4+7

%0+

% * %+7 % +!, &&

* ":5 "/+ !!7, 0

%6 &!

+7"+ %& 7!

>G H 3(= ::% + 5;

" % " " 0 / ": ;0 ! &":6 ,@A "

0$7"+ ":D7

%&; !$

%+ %!$ !!

:,7% "

%;<(<< " <<=(

%!, $% %% , !6%

4 %

& "/00 , ! & +6%

+ ":

%! "

";% ?

!6 , "

@A%@;

"$&

, &6 ;!5

+; "+6 && ": $ ;

& :

& !$ %7&

%!, 5

$$% !

/ "7$ !$ $&

!$ "!

%7 "! % "/ " !,0 * %4+7

%0+

% * %4+7 % +!, &&5

* ":5 "/+ !

%+7"!

%! !6 && !7"!

7&&;:"

,%7:, $&

+ ":! $%* ! "!$

" ": & ! " "+* % 7! "!

%7 "!$

" ": ;0 "

7% ": 7%!

%:70 !(

%!, 5%7:,

7% J "!,

% !!7 %

& "/ 00 * % 7! "!

%7 "!

%* "/"+ :* %" ": ;0 "

% + ?$ %; ! ! " + !$7

%+ ) % + & 0!% 57"

! , && ":

+ 5; %

& "!7% 0$ "; 2 + 5; & ":

<<=,

% 0%+ %+

%;<(<<$ !!

5;3 ":& ", , !7%

+! !&&6!#4 F)>@4E<' E<=

&"!2 + .! )

/ 37% ( +*

( 7"!

& % E )% !,/ ::

%6 &( 3% +*

, )!3 "+

% "(+*

% && " , !

" $% ;

% 0 ! *

;%+ %:%

+"@<<=

% ": 2+7"!

!( ! + %

K 0$ "!

" %+

) &": 6 , "

( !, && 5 ! $%$%

&; " ": K , "

!, && 5 +

+ 6 % 57"

& 07"

+6 % 57"

&!, &&5 $7 "

& J + 5 %%; ": 0 ? 070 "

!57%!

+ " !, &&5 "! +

&+ ! "

& << 3+E4.9, "8 (7+:

(I $; +%+ % ! ""

?7% 4 ! &!" + !$7

$7%!7 %+ %+

%;<(<<(, &

%+ + 5; ) % + & 0! % 57"

& " ) ; ( <<= 6

%E & !E & :

& % $%

"+ % @A %+ ! +

+ 6 %

& "/ 00 4 % " @ +

0$7"+ ":D7

%&;

&! !&&6!#4 FG H + @< %

& "/ 00 (% $7% (

( " "

30 )

* 6 , "

7$ +

% !70

!((>E4 G5H

+ @< %

& "/ 00 ( % $7% (

( " 3,. / ! 7$

( 6 , "

% !70 ! >=E4 GH

>+ @< %

& "/ 00 (% $7% (

( " "

( 6 , "

% !70 ! >=E4 G+H

+ @< %

& "/ 00 ( % $7% (

( " 3,"7 7$

( 6 , "

% !70

!@'@@E4 H

+ @< %

& "/ 00 (% $7% (

( " "

!, 0 7$

( 6 , "

% !70

!@'@@E4I , 6 ! "

&&;+ +" 5 %>( ", " ":

0$ "!

%!, +!7:,

!* +

" ""

?7% 4@ 5 % ?

": 7% +

%; ( , ?

": 7% + !$!

" 5; $ !! ": &&6 ":%+ %"* %'(#4 #4 3,), 9 $%(+*% & ! , !

/ ": $ %0 !! " %

! !5

6 ! & + " "15& :, 7% "+ "

%0! %+ % +

<<<( ! + %

, & 0$ "!

" %+ ) % + & 0! % 57"

& &":6 , "

!, &&5 &

"+ % " ": , & &": 6 , "

!, &&5

+ " % 57"

& " %0 "

& J + 5 %%; ": 0 ? 070 "

+ !57%!

+ " !, && 5 "! +

&+ ! "

& ! 5

" !

& 6 ! "

&&; + + 5; "15& :, 7% ( * + 87+:0 +

+ >( $; 6, , ! 5

" $&

+ " % %+ J % ,

+; 0 $%

" , ! 7!

+; !75!

D7 + !( 3

( & > , + + "+ , % 2 ! 6 0$&

+ * + %+ % +

+ < ! %!

&, &%

+;5

"+ !$!

+5; "15& :, 7% ! $

" ": & ! 5

0 :

$%$ % %

" ":

% !, 970 % )

&( , ,7!5 "+(6, ! &!"

7% &:7 %+ "+ %"

7% & %!3

5 "! :"

%"7"

+ 3+E4. * / 7% ( * %'( ++& !

7+:

I $; +%+ %, !5

"$&

+"% %+ ""

?7% 4= !$

5* !

+ %+ %!( " $ ;0 ! 0 5; ! !7,

%! , + & + % $%

?7% 4'( 4 4< "/( , , %0 " "/ ": 057+!0 " 57 ! 0 + , 5*

%! ,

6, , ! * ": "/+ !$; &

%0 "/ ": 057+!0 "%

+! !&&6!#4

9 ) 3)

%* "/"+ 7 &+ ":G &%H

%'(, "+ :

%,4=' L ''( ''<( G?

"! " ( ' M H 40 &# 5, "+ :

%,C%5 %: " GH0$@@E>E4 7"

( )

* M. / !7$

N@>(3

@( 7%5 ?&";(

%3 %E) 0( "/ ": 3 %* !O0$& GHE00E @@E4 :

(

;7% 5* 0$&

/ ": 7$ 0

% 6 5 "/( 6 ,

" "%0

@ !6 0 "=@<< %+ %!++& !

7+:

%%; ":%

C@A, 6 !"7% 1!%+ %!% & !!$ 5 "/1!$& ;( " !,0 * %+7

%0 + ( "

% * %+7 % +!, &&5

* ":5 "/+ > " * 6 5* " $7%!7 ":

%7% "+, &!

7"+ %& 7!

> H 3(= , ! ! !!7 ! $ % %+ %! "/ ": 057+!0 " @ 70 ;"

!&!

+7"+ %& 7!

>G H

7%!

,7&&;( 3+E4

%0 "+ %3 ":,( $7 ;3

%;I 7"!

&% !, !* &;"

C@A0$7"+ ":D7

%&;"&;%

%! " ":$ % +0

7% ;( !5

, 5

"/ "!

* ": 7"

"+6 &&"

, "

6, , !$ ;

" !+ ! , "! + "

"!7"!

!6 && !7"!

&% ! 6 &&" 5 7 $&

:7 + & "

! )

% %7& %+

+$% &(6, ,+

&!6

"* %! "

%0 + "+ $%* +

5 "/! !,7&+ &&6 "* %! "

%0 + !( + &; + ! % % 7%% ": +

%! 00

&;% "* &; ": " % ! 6 !

5 "/ " "

%0! + , 5 "/! D7 % $ ; "

"% !$

!7,

%0+ !6 ,7 +7 ":

5;6 ;$ ;($%* +

"!6 5

% % "* % % + &":

" ": $ % + % : "

& "

, $& ;

%* "/ "+ 0 + " )"

%; & ;3

+! !&&6!#4 F"* %! " %0+ !( &; !%% 7%% ": !%

"* " %0 ! ! $ ?

:7 + & "

!( 5 "/! !,7&+ &&6 "* %! "

%0!+ !(+ &;+ !%% 7%% ": %! 00

&;% "*

&; ": " % + + ! 6 !

"/ " "

%0+ "/! D7 % $ ;

"% !$

!7,

%0+ !6 ,7 +7 ":

5;6 ;$ ;($%* +

"! 6 5

% % "* % % + &":

" ":$ % + % : "

6 ?

:7&

%;"%0! "+ "%+

4& 5 & ;0 :

G2)H( ! $%$!

$ %0 5 "/! %07&

% 6" $& 6 %+!"* %! "+ !I , %

& "/ 00 4 % , & !!7 J "!1,

!$ + %

%* "/"+ , "/ ":+ "+3

"+ %+! %+"+ 5

" %7&

& "/00 " "7 %;

' %0

+! !&&6!#4 F'

!"#$"

, " ;7 $&

%0 + , 7!( 6 6 && 5

" "!

%7 "!%0;7 " 7"

$ " ":%0 % + !$!

&;7%+

7% ; 5 , " "!

%7 "!%+ !$!

7% ;(6 6 && "%0;76 && " +*

,%7:,&

%E0 &E3)3 57 ! 0$ "+ ":+

7% ; " 6 &&+"

"; "!

%7 "%0 ;7(6 6 &&% 6 ?&7+ ":+ !& /

* ":!+

(% % +

7% ++

$% & ":%

+ 6 && "%0;7 $% +7% %6 ,+% &

%0 + 5 % 0

7% ; , ! "%0

" 6 &&

&! 5 0 " 7"

$ " ": %0 E )E% %!

6 && "%0;7

"+, %:

!%$%

7% 6 ,+% &

%0+ 6 && $ %0 $%

7% ,+% &!

%0 ! " %+ 0 "+

P %0 % % 37%* *%E %%37%* *%1($%* + +;7, : * 7! !$ 8 "

0 "+

%0 && %!% $7%$!

6 && $%* + % !7, 0 "+

$ " ":%0 : 6 && "%0;7(

%0! "+ "+ "! "+ "

" ;7% 6 !"

7% ;, ! "%0

"6 && &!5 0

" 7"

$ " ":%0E)E% %!

, 6 && +* !

;7$%* ! "!"0 ?

"0 %7 ": ;7" ;7% + !( 7% 5& :

"! 7"+ $%* ! "! ;7%!

/ ": ?

0$ "%0 ? +7 "

37% 6 &&5

%0@%@ %0;7

" ;7 " & ;

?";7% "

"0 70 ;!750 7! !7, %0$ % + &&; !% D7 % +( ;7 " &

$ ;

?";7% "

"0 6 && /"6& +:

!7, %0! 8 6 && !!7 D7 !

, " $7&

+ $ % + 6 + +7

? %0 "

+ E

%7 +";7%+ ! / 6 && "+

? + +7

+( ";( "

%0 + ! %

;7% 3 * ":! E 7%% 7"

" !!5/E!

I , %%0 %

& "/00 "

%0+

%&; "

"! !

$7&

" +

, "; + %( $%

7% ;0 67&+ 5 0 !7%* *% , &! 5

"; "!

%7 "!: * "(+ 6 &&5 % +% % +

$% & ":%

"* 6 "!

%7 "!%

/ ": "! +

" + %

"!6, ,, +5

" !!7 :,7% * + %+ %+

%;<(<<

+6 % 57"

& !, &&5 $7 " ! ""

& J +5 %%; ":0 ? 070 "

+ !57%!

!!, &&5 "! +

&+ ! "

& , ! , 5

" 0

@A "

0$7"+ ":D7

%&;0 / 0 "+

%; 5 :%

C @A 0$7"+ ": D7

%&; ! $ %+ % $ !!

+ 5; ?

": 7% "* %'(( + %

"6 ! !!7

&":6 , "

!" + !$7

@ +, 5* %+ &; ":6 "/* 6 " +%0 % "; "!

%7 "!6 " !!7 !$

'GH(% !& %

0 ": ! , * ": 5

" % + % !

% + %0 6

+ 0

7% ++ $% & ":%

@A0$7"+ ":D7

%&; ! &!" 7 $&

0 ",

!$ 5* ++ %

& "/00 "/ !% D7 % +7"+

'G5H "%0 6 && " +* ,%7:,&

%E0 &E3)3 57 ! 0$ "+ ":+

7% ; "+ " " "!

%7 "! , * ": 5

" %

+ %0 % ; & % 6 ?&7+ ":+ !& /

? * ":!+

% % + 0

7% ++

$% & ":%

" * 6 5* %70!

!( , ! $

" ! &&6 ,!

!@E4+ %

" ! !!7 %

! !( ( ( > &7&

&& $% & '( = 6 , "

C @A 0$7"+ ":

%&;6 , " % +"

+$;

%+ % $% &'(' G))3H !

"8 ; ,

%!$

/ ":E%

+# !E ,

%% $%

# !E