High Court of Punjab and HaryanaCRM-M/24919/2025allowed

Rampal Kadyan v. State Of Haryana

2025-08-25Mr. Justice Sumeet Goel5 pages

< < "# $% #6,(,$ '

"# $% #6,(,$ '

"# $% #6,(,$ ' /-/(" < /-/(" < /-/(" < /-/(" <0 1< 0 1< 0 1< 0 1<

E*#",",$ #& & =#&(/( !""# $% E*#($ # "

&#(# "'

9) * !

! ) ) ) ) &* ,(+, ) 0 >$6"# %$& "+# #",",$ #&* &* /&##" !, -+0 & * &* ? 0 >$6"# %$& "

"+# 6$ , "* @@@@@ @@@@@ @@@@@ @@@@@ ) ) ) )0 * 3):

0 * 3):

! ! ! ! * &#(# " (#6$ #",",$ +( 5## %, / #& !#6",$ 72 $% "+# +&", -&,. !/&.(+ ! +,"0 12 3 3%$& (+$&" 4 !!9: %$& -& " $% % &#-/ "

"$ "+# #",",$ #& , 6(# 5#&, - - $*28 18*12*10 &#-,("#&# %$& & "+# $%%# 6#( / ,(+5 # / #& !#6",$ 21A $% "+#

, #

$ #0 781 3 3%$& (+$&" 4 9: !#6",$ ( A B 21 $% "+# &( 6"0 <0 "

$ ,6# !"",$ !#6"$&0

/("&, &#0 ,("& &,6" ,"* *

+# 6(# (#" / , "+# , C/ /#(",$ 3( (#" $/" , "+# &#(# "

#",",$ 5 "+ +# #",",$ #&: ,( ( %$

$;('

D$ $% 6$ , " ,( ""6+# ,"* !,& ?, " ,( (/5,""# "+"

= &#(, # " $% =,

-# !#;+0 ,("&,6" , #># , - ",# &$/ '< , , -$, - %&$ $/& +$# %$& "#"+#&, - !$ $% +

# ;( (" 6&$((# "+# "+# ("&"

;# (.# +,0 ;+ +# ,( /(, - %, "+ "+,( ;# 6&$((# ;# " %$&;& (, #0 %,&# (+$" $ 5&$"+#& -# 5/

#" %"#& ,#&6, - , "$ "+# & $% %,&# "+# (+$" ;,"+ , "# " "$ .,

* /(+# +, +# %#

$; + !

!+5 $ ,6# !"",$ !6"$&0 =, $ !$ $% !+&, +/ !, -+0 0 0 ,"* #("#& 1<*12*10 ,-+"* 5&$"+#& -# #& ;#&# $/& 6""

# , "+# $"* "+# ;0 , - , %&$ " $% +/ 0 ;+# ;# - .

&"# -,>, - %, "+ -/-# "$ /(* + -/-# -, (" /( 5 (, -

+# 5 6$, - %&$ 56.

#& ;,"+ , "# " "$ .,

+,* +" "+# 5&$"+#& # "#&# , "$ "+# 56.* +( ($ "&,# "$ %,&# -, *

( +, ;#$ ( ($ %#

$; %&$ +,(

+ +# +# % ; %&$ "+# ($"* %"#& +,( #>, - %&$ "+# 6# $% $66/&&# 6#0 + (## +,( ;#$ 0 ;+,6+ ;( , - " "+# 6# $% $66/&&# 6#* + ".# "+# ;#$ ".# 5 5&$"+#& " $/& +$#

%&$ +$#0 + ".# 5&$"+#& "$ &.

$(," %$& "&#"# " $ 5,.#* " "+# (# ",#0 +># -,># "+# &#>$ >#& "$ $6"$& !+5 $% &.

$(," "+# ,-+"0 ;( 5/( , "+# "&#"# " $% 5&$"+#&* +># -,># "+# 6$ , " , ;&,""# "$ $/* &#C/#(", - "$ $/ "+" ("&,6" "$ ("&,6"

#- 6",$ 5# ".# -, (" 66/(# *F 2* )#& # %$& "+# #",",$ #& +( ,"#&"# "+" "+# #",",$ #& ,( , 6/("$ (, 6# 8*12*1* )#& # +( %/&"+#& ,"#&"# "+" "+# #",",$ #& +( 5## % (# , ,6"# , "$ "+# , C/#(",$ * )#& #

+( ,"#&"# "+" "+#&# ;( ,# ,(/"# 5#";## "+# #",",$ #& "+# 6$ , " (, # $ 66$/ " $% ;+,6+ , C/#(",$ ;( -$" &#-,("#&#

-, (" "+# #",",$ #&* )#& # +( %/&"+#& ,"#&"# "+" "+# #",",$ #& +( (/%%#&# , 6&6#&",$ %$& $&# "+ 1G #&(* )#& # +( &-/# "+" "+# &,# &,>"# &$(#6/",$ ;," #((#(0 ,*#*0 H6$ , "

"+# >,6", (" #I, # +/(0 &#-/ ,( &# %$&* * )#& # !""# 6$/ (# +( $$(# "+# &#(# " #",",$ 5 &-/, - "+" "+#

#-",$ ( &,(# -, (" "+# #",",$ #& &# (#&,$/( , "/&# "+/( "+# #",",$ #& $#( $"

#(#&># "+# 6$ 6#((,$ $% "+# &#-/ * )#& # !""# (##.( "$ 6# $ &#6$& "+# 6/("$ 6#&",%,6"# *17*1<0 , "+# $/&" "$ 0 ;+,6+ ,( ".# $ &#6$& <* )#& # %$& "+# 6$ , " +( >#+## "

$$(# "+# -& " $% &#-/ "$ "+# #",",$ #& 5 &-/, - "+" "+#&# ,( 6 #&0 6$-# "

6$ >, 6, - #>, # 6# -, (" "+# #",",$ #& , "+# %$& $% "#(",$ $% "+# H 6$ , "H >,6",0 ;+$ +># ;,"+("$$

# -"+ 6&$((#I, ",$ +># "#(",%,# "$ "+# -/, " $% "+# #",",$ #&* )#& # +( %/&"+#& &-/# "+" , 6(# "+# #",",$ #& ,( &# #(# $ &#-/ 0 "+#&# ,(

,.# ,+$$ "+" +# "+&#"# "+# H 6$ , " ( ($ "+# >,6",* "+# ("&# -"+ $% "+#(# (/5,((,$ (0 ,(,(( $% "+# &#(# " #",",$ ,( # "&#"# %$&*

+># +#& %$& "+# &,> &",#( +># -$ # "+&$/-+ "+# >, 5 # &#6$& ( $% "+# 6(#* A*

+# #",",$ #& ;( &&#("# $ 8*12*1 ;+#&#, %"#& , >#(",-",$ ;( 6&&,# $/" 6+

;( &#(# "# $ *1<*1* $"

A &$(#6/",$ ;," #((#( +># 5## 6,"# 0 5/" $ 12 +># 5## #I, # ",

"#* " ,( $" , ,(/"# "+" &,# &$(#6/",$ ;," #((#(0 ,*#*0 H 6$ , "

"+# >,6", (" #I, # * /&"+#& $"+, - #&6#",5 # +( 5## 5&$/-+"

%$&"+ "$ , ,6"# "+" "+# #",",$ #& % ## %&$ "+# &$6#(( $% ?/(",6#* #",",$ #& +( (/%%#&# , 6&6#&",$ $% $&# "+ 1G #&(* +# &,>

6$ "# ",$ ( &,(# " & -,># &,(# "$ #5"5 # ,((/#(0 ;+,6+ (+

5# &",$6, "# /$ /&, - "+# 6$/&(# $% "&, +,( $/&"

$#( $"

## ,"

&$&,"# "$ ># ## , "$ "+#(# &,> 6$ "# ",$ (0 " "+,( ("-#0 #(" ," &#?/ ,6# "+# "&, $"+, - " -,5 # +( 5## 5&$/-+" %$&;& "$ , ,6"# "+#

,.# ,+$$ $% "+# #",",$ #& 5(6$ , - %&$ "+# &$6#(( $% ?/(",6# $& , "#&%#&, - ;,"+ "+# &$(#6/",$ #>, # 6#* A**

/5,"5 0 "+# &#(# " #",",$ ,( "+# (#6$ ""#" 5 "+# #",",$ #& "$ (#6/&# &#-/ (" 5, # &#%#&&# 5 "+# #",",$ #& ;( ,(,((# ( ;,"+ &; $ <*1*1* $;#>#&0 .##, - , >,#; %/&"+#& , 6&6#&",$ $% "+# #",",$ #& %$& #&,$ $% $(" 1 $ "+( (/5(" ", &$-&#(( , "&, 0 "+,( $/&" ,( , 6 , # "$ %>$/&5 6$ (, #& "+# , (" " # %$& 5, * &$%,"5 # &#%#&# 6#0 , "+,( &#-& 0 6 5# # "$ ?/ -# " $% "+,( $/&" ((# , !22 22 22 2212 12 12 12 ","

( %,C + %,C + %,C + %,C + >#&(/( !""# $% & $"+#& >#&(/( !""# $% & $"+#& >#&(/( !""# $% & $"+#& >#&(/( !""# $% & $"+#&J &# #> " ;+#&#$% &# ( ( / #&'

D1* ( #, $-/# "$ "+# 5$># ,(6/((,$ 0 "+# %$

$;, - &, 6, #( ##&-#'

!#6$ H(/66#((,># &#-/

#",",$ 3(:

,( , ", 5 # , ; B +# 6# (/6+ #",",$ $/-+" $" "$ 5# &#?#6"#

($ $ "+# -&$/ $% , ", 5, ," "+#&#$%*

!/6+ (#6$ H(/66#((,># &#-/

#",",$ 3(:

,( , ", 5 ;+#"+#& ,#& #",",$ ;(

,(,((#

(

;,"+ &; H ,(,((# ( $" &#((# ,(,((# %$& $ &$(#6/",$ $& #& ,#& #",",$ ;( ,(,((# $ #&,"(* $& "+# (#6$ H(/66#((,># &#-/ #",",$ 3(: "$ (/66## 0 "+# #",",$ #&H ,6 " (+

5# #((# ",

H#&", # "

&#C/,&# "$ (+$; (/5(" ", 6+ -# , 6,&6/(" 6#( (+$;, - $% #&# (/#&%,6, $& $("# (,5 # 6+ -# ;$/

$" (/%%,6#* #"+$&,6 #I&#((,$ $% (##., - (#6$ H(/66#((,># 5, #3(:

$/-+" $" 5# 5("&6"# , "$ ,"#& ,"#&",$ ( $% #",",$ 3(: ;,"+$/"

(/5(" ", 0 #%%#6",># 6$ (#C/# ", 6+ -# , 6,&6/(" 6#(*

$ #I+/(",># -/, , #( 6 $((,5 5# ,

$; ( "$ ;+" ;$/

6$ (","/"# (/5(" ", 6+ -# , 6,&6/(" 6#( ( #>#& 6(# +( ,"( $; / ,C/# %6"(H6,&6/(" 6#* ., - (/6+ ""#" ,( $"+, - 5/" /"$, # #>$/&* &-$0 "+,( ,((/# ,( 5#("

#%" "$ "+# ?/ ,6, ;,( $

,(6&#",$ $% "+# $/&"

# ;,"+ (/6+ (#6$ H(/66#((,># &#-/ #",",$ 3(:* =

6(# $/&" 6+$$(#( "$ -& " (#6$ H(/66#((,># &#-/ #",",$ 3(:0 6$-# "

/6, &#($ ( &# #&", # "

&#C/,&# "$ 5# &#6$& %$& -& ", - (/6+ # #(,"# (/6+ # 5#, - (#6$ H(/66#((,># #",",$ 3(:* $"+#& ;$& (0 "+# 6/(# %$& $/&"

+>, - (/66#((%/

6$/ "# 6# H# "#&", #

(/6+ (#6$ H(/66#((,># #",",$ 3(: $/-+" "$ 5# &# ,

#6,+#&5 # %&$ "+# (, $& #& ((# *F A** ( #& 6/("$ 6#&",%,6"# *17*1< %, #& # !""# 0 "+# #",",$ #& +( &# (/%%#&# , 6&6#&",$ %$& #&,$ $% 1 #&0 1< $ "+( 1< (* /&"+#&0 "+# (, 6/("$ 6#&",%,6"# &#% #6"( "+"

"+# #",",$ #& ,( , >$ ># , $"+#& $*2 *1*10 %$& 6$,((,$ $% $%%# 6#( / ,(+5 # / #& !#6",$ ( 70 0 220 20 <180 2<0 21A0 < $% 0 &#-,("#&# " $ ,6# !"",$ + , -+0 ,"0 5/" ,"

+( 5## 5&$/-+" %$&"+ "+"0 >, # ?/ -# "

1<*17*1<0 "+# #",",$ #&H +( 5## 6C/,""# , "+# (, * !/%%,6# "$ (0 %/&"+#& #"# ",$ $% "+# #",",$ #& ( / #&"&, ,( $" ;&& "# , "+# %6"( 6,&6/(" 6#( $% "+# 6(#* 7*

>,#; $% 5$>#0 "+# &#(# " #",",$ ,(

$;# * #",",$ #& ,( $& #&# "$ 5# &# #(# $ &#-/ $ +,( %/& ,(+, - 5, H(/&#" 5$ ( "$ "+# (",(%6",$ $% "+# ) * 6$ 6#& # H/" -,("&"#* $;#>#&0 ,

,",$ "$ 6$ ,",$ ( "+" 5# ,$(# 5 "+# 6$ 6#& # H/" -,("&"#0 "+# #",",$ #& (+

&#, 5$/ 5 "+# %$

$;, - 6$ ,",$ ('

< 3,:

+# #",",$ #& (+

$" ,(/(# "+# ,5#&" -& "# 3,,:

+# #",",$ #& (+

$" "#& ;,"+ #>, # 6#0 $&

$& $6/# "&0 /&, - "+# "&, 3,,,:

+# #",",$ #& (+

$" 5(# " +,(# % $ "# 5#%$&# "+# "&, 3,>:

+# #",",$ #& (+

$" 6$," $%%# 6# ;+, 3>:

+# #",",$ #& (+

#$(," +,( (($&"0 ,% 0 ;,"+ "+# "&, $/&"* 3>,:

+# #",",$ #& (+

-,># +,( 6#

+$ # /5#& "$ "+#

>#(",-", - %%,6#&H!

$% 6$ 6#& # $ ,6# !"",$

$" 6+ -# +,( 6#

+$ # /5#& ;,"+$/" &,$& #&,((,$ $% "+# "&, $/&"H

C -,("&"#* 3>,,:

+# #",",$ #& (+

$" , #& "& "$ "+# "&, *

6(# $% 5&#6+ $% $% "+# %$&#(, 6$ ,",$ ( "+$(# ;+,6+ 5# ,$(# 5 6$ 6#& # H/" -,("&"# ( ,&#6"#

+#&#, 5$># $& /$ (+$;, - $"+#& (/%%,6,# " 6/(#0 "+# !""#H6$ , "

5# "

,5#&" "$ $># 6 6#

",$ $% 5, $% "+# #",",$ #&* 1* & #&# 66$& *

$"+, - (, +#&#, 5$># (+

5# 6$ ("&/# ( #I&#((,$ $% $, ,$ $ "+# #&,"( $% "+# 6(#* * !, 6# "+# , 6(# +( 5## #6, 0 # , - ,(6#

#$/( ,6",$ 0 ,% 0 (+

($ (" ( ,($(# $%%* 3! ) ! ) ! ) ! ):

/-/(" < /-/(" < /-/(" < /-/(" <0 1< 0 1< 0 1< 0 1< +>,& K+#"+#& (#., -H&#($ # '

#(H K+#"+#& &#$&"5 #'

#(H