Bimla And ORS v. State Of Haryana And ORS















 

  !



 
    
 

 "#$ %$&'(')* 

 '+,"")%#-$.($#'#')$.( /$.(0( 1#"#$ ".2")"")%#-$.($(3)%$)#( 



 
   


   
 


   .4".#'5$2"6 %/&"#$6

.#-$3$#'#')$.(')
 

 . .0) "')61$)'. %/&"#$7'#- .10)',1-".+"6 %/&"#$6

.#-$3$#'#')$.')


8 . )50.'##",6 %%'#')", %/&"#$$)$.",6".2")"6 .1-'/$)%."17".3")%.")9 -")5".6 (('(#")#

%/&"#$$)$.",(6".2")" . +'#"."(-".6 %/&"#$6

..$(3)%$)#8')
 

 .10)'(-')%,'(-6 %/&"#$6

..$(3)%$)#( # ')
 

 .1")9"2:'96 %/&"#$6

..$(3)%$)#')
 

  
  !
 -'(.%$.7',,%'(3($ #77.'#3$#'#')(;$".')<
  


 

  

 

"
")%


8 
  

 



 

 

 

 

 
,"'++"%$;2#-$3$#'#')$.('(#-"#"&=0'('#') ,")%') =0$(#')-"(,"3($%6')/'$7 #-$3./'(')( 1$&#') >  #-$'<-# # "'.
+3$)("#')")%.")(3".$)&2')?")% &=0'('#')6$-";','#"#') ")% $($##,$+$)#  &#6

 .(-.#@#-$

 &#A6"()$'#-$.#-$ 3(($((') #-$"&=0'.$%,")%-"(;$$)#"5$)).#-$&+3$)("#')#-$.$

-"(;$$)3"'% )


86,$".)$%($)'.&0)($, .#-$ 3$#'#')$.(0;+'##$%#-"##-$.$7"(&)(#.0&#')$B'(#')<)#-$"&=0'.$% ,")%6  3.'.  #  '((0")&$    )#'

'&"#')  0)%$.  1$&#')  >    #-$  ?")%

&=0'('#') &#6CD> .(-.#@#-$CD> &#A-$'((0$7"(."'($%$/$) ')#-$;9$&#')( ',$%0)%$.1$&#')  #-$CD> &#

( "."( #-$&)#$)#')."'($% ;2,$".)$%&0)($,  .#-$ 3$#'#')$.')


8.$<".%')<$B'(#$)&$ &)(#.0&#')) #-$"&=0'.$%,")%63.'.#'((0")&$ )#'

'&"#')0)%$.1$&#')> #-$ CD> &#6#-$ "&#'()#%'(30#$%;2#-$,$".)$%&0)($, .#-$1#"#$ ?$".)$%  &0)($,  .  #-$  1#"#$  "'.,2  (0;+'##$%  #-"#  #-$ )#'

'&"#')0)%$.1$&#')> #-$CD> &#7"('((0$%) D

6 7-$.$;2#-$,")%+$"(0.')<88>"&.$(3$.#"')')<##-$.$/$)0$$(#"#$(  /',,"<$("('6")<",4",")640)%,'")%"#-030.67"()#' '$%:'%$ )#'

'&"#')'((0$%0)%$.1$&#') 8 #-$CD> &#%"#$% C

>8 "&.$( ,")%7"()#'

'$% .#-$"&=0'('#')-$?")% &=0'('#')
,,$&#./'%$"7".%%"#$% >

>  ')",,2"&=0'.$%> 

"&.$(

,")% .#-$.$(# #-$,")%6#-0<-)#'

'&"#')0)%$.1$&#')8 #-$ CD> &#7"('((0$%6;0#)"7".%7"("))0)&$%-$##","+0)#

&+3$)("#')%$#$.+')$%;2#-$
,,$&#. 7"( 
>6DC6 >6

E6 0#

 7-'&-6)$ #-$,")%7)$.6)"+$,261"#;'.() 3
-")%-"( .$&$'/$%"(0+ 
6D68E)##",6),2"(0+ 
6D 6>

E-"( ;$$)3"'%"(&+3$)("#')##-$,")%7)$.(67-($,")%7"("&=0'.$%# &+$(0## >F #-$##","+0)# &+3$)("#')%$#$.+')$%;2#-$
,,$&#.#-$.7'($6'#'(&,"'+$%#-"##-$"+0)# &+3$)("#')'(,2')< %$3('#$%')#-$"&&0)#7'#-#-$?")% &=0'('#')
,,$&#.-$"7".% 7"(3"(($%7"2;"&5) >

>',,%"#$6)%$/$,3+$)#"&#'/'#2-"( ;$$)&"..'$%0#6#-0<-3(($((') #-$,")%7"(#"5$) $".%,$".)$%&0)($, .#-$3".#'$(")%3$.0($%#-$3"3$.

;5 1$&#') >  #-$

 &#3./'%$(#-"#"&=0'('#') ,")% 70,%,"3($')&"($(7-$.$"7".%-"%;$$)"))0)&$%;2#-$
,,$&#. '/$ 2$".(3.'.##-$$)"&#+$)# #-$

 &#'$

>6')&"($$'#-$.#-$ &+3$)("#') .#-$"&=0'.$%,")%-"()#;$$)3"'%.#-$3(($((') #-$.$ -"%)#;$$)#"5$) )#-$&"($')-")%6'#'(#-$"%+'##$%3('#')).$&.%#-"##-$ 3$#'#')$.(-"/$)#;$$)3"'%#-$"+0)# &+3$)("#') .#-$"&=0'.$% ,")%  )  "%%'#')6  ') 
   

 

86  "%+'##$%,2  $/$)  #-$ &)(#.0&#')7"($B'(#')<3.'.##-$'((0")&$ )#'

'&"#')0)%$.1$&#') > #-$CD> &#")%#-$3$#'#')$.(#-$.$')".$(#',,')3(($((') #-$ &)(#.0&#$%3.#') )/'$7 #-$"

.$("'%%'(&0((')6')0./'$76#-$')<.$%'$)#( "(,"'% %7) ') 1$&#')  >  #-$

  &# -"/')< ;$$) ("#'( '$%6 "&=0'('#') ,")%7)$%;2#-$3$#'#')$.(-"(,"3($% 7$/$.6#-$1#"#$(-",,;$"#,';$.#2#$'#-$.')'#'"#$ .$(- 3.&$$%')<( ."&=0'('#') ,")%.)$<#'"#$7'#-#-$,")%7)$.( .

> 30.&-"(')<E.$#"')')<#-$,")%')"&&.%")&$7'#-,"76')&"($#-$,")%') =0$(#')  '(  .$=0'.$%  .  &+3,$#')    ")2  3.9$&#  .  #-$.7'($  -$ 3$#'#')$.((-",,+"')#"')(#"#0(=0.$<".%')<#-$,")%')=0$(#') ."

3$.'% ('B+)#-(#$)";,$#-$1#"#$##"5$%$&'(') -$7.'#3$#'#')(".$%'(3($% "&&.%')<,2  "9$(-')%",  0%<$  

 0./')%$.1')<-',, /(  0%<$ -$#-$.(3$"5')<E.$"()$% !$(E -$#-$.$3.#";,$ !$(E