Ram Chander Poonia v. State Of Haryana & ORS.

   

       

!"# $#%&'&()
 !* +!($#,(&!

#"&"&(#, '

-#,'.'

/"!"# !,!0(!!($"+#,'

#'1($#(" '

)  23  / 4 3/  ,#'#(")5 ,+,.6/&+!78$6%!"#8 ,"+#1#"&"&(#, , !.,!6 #98''&'"!(" !,0!(! ,/+!,!$77!,:!98$6%!"#8 ,8 ,/!7!,#':!98$6%!"#8 ,,#'1($#(";  +#"+#,"+##1,"#,' 9%!9(#:'1!1#,*!0<#!99:#$" '##"+#=.$7*#(">
 <#,# #,,#$""+##1,"#,,(" ? +#"+#,"+#=.$7*#("'+.9$<#,#1,"#$&("+#$&7#'"> 55 55 3/ 

3 +#1#"&"&(#,'##@'"+#:,&" %#,"&,!,& ,A.!'+&(7"+# &*1.7(#$  ,$#,  $!"#$  ?B
  ((#C.,#55  !($  "+#  *!($!*.'8 $&,#%"&(7"+#,#'1($#("'"%.(""+#1,#6&.''#,6&%#,#($#,#$<0"+# 1#"&"&(#,&( &,9'/#(&,/#%($!,0/%+98&'!, ,#'1($#("

?+#,#&( !($ 6#,(*#("&$#$!"&7+/%+98&'!, ,#'1($#("

;+#,#&(  ,"+#1.,1'# 1#('&(!($"+#,,#"&,!9<#(# &"' +#1#"&"&(#,:!'!11&("#$!'!3!<""#($!("(!$+%<!'&' &( &,9'/#(&,/#%($!,0/%+98&'!,8(
;DB
 &' '#,6&%#'!'!3!<""#($!(":#,#,#7.9!,&E#$(;BDB?+#1#"&"&(#, :,@#$!'!3!<""#($!("&("+#'!&$ &,9'/#(&,/#%($!,0 /%+98&'!,8"&99BD;#%9!&*'"+!"+#+!$!119&#$"+,.7+1,1#, %+!((#9&("+#!"&7+/%+98&'!, +#1#"&"&(#,:!'!11&("#$( BD;!'!!"+!'"#,&(!"&7+/%+98&'!,8 ! 6#,(*#("!&$#$

5
5 1,&6!"#90  *!(!7#$  '%+9 8  :+&%+  :!'  !7!&('"  !(  .(!&$#$  1'"  # %("&(.#$":,@!''.%+#:!'9!"#,(!11&("#$!7!&('""+#!&$#$1'"   !"+  !'"#,  (  ;DD  !($  .9"&*!"#90  ,#"&,#$  ,*  '#,6&%#  ( ?
 :8"+#1#"&"&(#,:!("'"+!"+&''#,6&%#,#($#,#$!7!&('" .(!&$#$1'"!'!!"+!'"#,&(!"&7+/%+98&'!,8 ,*BD;" ?DD'+.9$<#%.("#$":!,$'7,!(" 1#('&(!,0<#(# &"'!($+&'

'#,6&%#!'!3!<""#($!("&( &,9'/#(&,/#%($!,0/%+98 &'!,8 ,*
;DB
"BD;'+.9$!9'<#%.("#$ ,"+#7,!("

1#('&(!,0<#(# &"' +#/"!"#8&("+#,#1908+!'"!@#("+#'"!($"+!""+#1#"&"&(#, +!$9# ""+#=< 3!<""#($!("&( &,9'/#(&,/#%($!,0 /%+98&'!,8:&"+."!(0&("&*!"&(!($:&"+.""+#1#,*&''&( "+# %*1#"#("!."+,&"0!($=&(#$!'!"+!'"#,!7!&('".(5'!(%"&(#$ .(5 !&$#$ 1'" &( !" &7+/%+98&'!,8:+&%+ :!'!1,&6!"#90*!(!7#$

6#,(*#("!&$#$'%+9(BD;+#1#"&"&(#,:&"+$,#:+&' ( ;
D+#1#"&"&(#,:!'!11&("#$<0"+#'!&$!"&7+/%+98&'!,8 !7!&('"'!(%"&(#$1'"(90(;DD&#! "#,!7!1 *,#"+!( ., 0#!,'":!'19#!$#$"+!"!'1#,"+#!,0!(!&$#$/%+9' /#%.,&"0

/#,6&%# %"8DB;8+&''#,6&%#!7!&('""+#!&$#$1'"&'"<#%.("#$ ,"+# 1.,1'# 1#('&(!($"+!"'&(%#"+#,#:!'!7!1 *,#"+!( .,0#!,'&( +&''#,6&%#&("+# &,9'/#(&,/#%($!,0/%+98&'!,8!($ !7!&('""+#!&$#$1'"&("+#!"&7+/%+98&'!,8"+#,# ,#8"+#'!*# %!(("<#%.("#$ +!6#+#!,$"+#9#!,(#$%.('#9' ,"+#1!,"&#'!($+!6#!9' %!,# .9907(#"+,.7+"+# &9# +#1#"&"&(#,+!'("19!%#$( &9#!(0$%.*#(""'+:"+!"

5?5 +#+!$!119&#$"+,.7+1,1#,%+!((#9 ,"+#1'" !"+!'"#,&("+#!"

&7+/%+98&'!, +#1#,.'!9 "+#&*1.7(#$,$#,$!"#$?B


((#C.,#55 8  ,#=#%"&(7  "+#  %9!&*    "+#  1#"&"&(#,8  '+:'  "+!"   ( 6#,& &%!"&(8&":!' .($"+!""+#1#"&"&(#,9# ""+#=< 3!<""#($!("&(

&,9'/#(&,/#%($!,0/%+98&'!,8:&"+."!(0&("&*!"&( !($=&(#$!'!"+!'"#,&(!"&7+/%+98&'!,8!7!&('".(5!&$#$!($ .(5'!(%"&(#$1'"8:+#,#+#:,@#$"&99?DD'1#,.9# ; 

"+#!,0!(!&$#$/%+9' /1#%&!9#('&(!($ (",&<.",0,6&$#("

.($ .9#'8
8(90"+#'#,6&%#,#($#,#$(!&$#$'!(%"&(#$1'"&( !("+#,!&$#$'%+9&("+#/"!"# !,0!(!&'"<#%*1."#$ ,"+# 1.,1'# 1#('&(   ($#,.9#    "+#!,0!(!&$#$/%+9'

/1#%&!9  #('&(  !($  (",&<.",0  ,6&$#("  .($   .9#'8 
8  "+# &("#,,.1"&(    '1#99    '#,6&%#  .($#,  "+#  '!*#  *!(!7#*#("  *!0  <# %($(#$:&"+"+#!11,6!9 &,#%",!($<#",#!"#$!'A.!9& 0&(7'#,6&%#

,,#"&,!9<#(# &"'  :#6#,8.($#,"+#1,6&'8&"&'1,6&$#$"+!"&

&("#,,.1"&(&'%!.'#$<0"+#,#'&7(!"&(8$&'*&''!9,,#*6!9 ,*'#,6&%# #"%8"+#'!*#'+!99("<#%($(#$ #,#8"+#1#"&"&(#,+!$9# ""+# '#,6&%#&("+# &,9'/#(&,/#%($!,0/%+98&'!,8:&"+."

!(0&("&*!"&(!($"+#,#&'(1, ""+##

#%""+!"+#+!$!119&#$"+,.7+ 1,1#,%+!((#9+#,# ,#8"+#'#,6&%#,#($#,#$&("+# &,9'

/#(&,/#%($!,0/%+98&'!,8!($!7!&('""+#.(5!&$#$1'"&(!"&7+ /%+98&'!,8%!(("<#%.("#$ ,%*1."&(7+&'1#('&( ('#A.#("908 "+#1,#'#(":,&"1#"&"&(&'$&'*&''#$

3/   


 '=@' +#"+#,'1#!@&(7 ,#!'(#$ ) #' +#"+#,#1,"!<9# )