High Court of Punjab and HaryanaFAO/347/2006allowed

(O&M) Jasmail Singh v. Sushil Kumar & ANR

2023-03-24Mr. Justice Harminder Singh Madaan7 pages

!"# # $#"%& "

' &%

( &)#"*+& , %

!"# %& "

' &% - &.-*&/ 0" /

% % #1%2&* .&"

% .&""

#1%2&* .&"

%.&"

45 &"%"1) % &&. 6&

.%&7 .&.

8* % .%&7 .&.

9( &)#"*+& 5, % 7&

2"&# &. 6"%

4".5 %1.* &. *" &"8* %.%* &#%"* &

&. & &"

** 1:

". "".""% & * " &%

# $#"9%"2"*#&6"%( &)#"*+& 5 , % #"" &. & &"*5* 7" " " & (& 04;1 **& &&**&# &.% &. #*' & &"2 *#"**%

2"&&. &"8* 1' 6 7* &"%6"%6 * 16 &

6<& 1' %*%&6 =#>( %$"

6 "% *&& " 7" " " & (& 04!

& ."& 2#> 6 &6"%2-.&" %5*

%2< *&& "67%"275=#>( &*&""* .

%%&. "&%&&" %6 " *"%*# &<6

%*&& ""* % "&.2- &% *."& %"1 & &"*5*7"" " &(& 04;* ."& 7 % 7 %"2 75 # $#" " % "< "&6 &"% & &"*5*<# $#"7"&#

"& &"*5* " & *&& "% &"%"&. & &"*5* .&" #"

&&. &

*&& "&. %*% %*# " &.*&& "%"2"=#>( <"# 5 & &"*5*%"275# $#" "#*> *&& "16 * 67%"275 =#> ( %%# & * 1' %*%.& "&%& 6 =#>( %$" <' %$" #.."%

%?#"16 "=#>( "*2%# "2&#?#" )

6 1%2 ."&2-"* % & 1 # $#"%"2"&. &..%& &"*5*"65 @ ?#"% 6" > &+2=& 1(7 ."&6 "' 16 &6 ?#"%*&% &6".""% &'?%"=& 10 7# 6 > & " =& 1 0 1 6 " "% % % ."& &

% ". " 6% %'?%" =& 10 ."& & 1 &62"&

%A "%

**&"% & &"8* 1 **% % >

*%# &" % %"2&.& &"*5*7"" " & (& 04;75# $#"9" %*" * .&"&.)'(& % % .&" &..*#%"

* &:11 )0+6" "%6 0&* &%"1 (7 1- "* 0 &." " &&. )'1?#"% =#>( %2 & &"*5* % "#*> *&& "7# &**&2*6 % & "*&"%% 2"& "& "5

**&"% & &"8* 1%*%'

6"' 1 8 "& %#&.' 1 86 &

%* " +2 =& 1 (7 % " =& 1 0

72& *17& &%

"%% .% " 6"

) 6" .%75" # $#"1 %%7%"2"&. & &"*5*&" 7

2&2% **% 1 " " *& %% 6" " &% 77#&.$"5% 6& "

& &.**% <=#>( #% & >$"5" * ."& %#&.' 1 86 5775 & 6" " &% # & .&" #"* &.$"5" *&*"% 7%.&" %"&=#>( 2&2% 6" " &% *.5

) 6" .%&7 .&." #"**& 5 %% "*%**%

* & 7 6"&5 .% % & &"*5* 7" " " &(& 04; 7.5 * % && "

6"&"%

4& " &% "5% .&" % &. *

&&6#6"."%75 & &"**% + @"7#10

". "".""% & @"7#/ ;

"%*%' %%%# &" % * &.

&..%%"2"# $#"%& B 0

;

"* % &*& &.& C# #% ."&6 &B0

;

* & % &"*25*& & .&"6 &.*"5 " 5% "(& %&.

%% 7?* &B0'

;

%"2"&. & &"*5*( 04;6&

22%%..* 2%"2**%B0' ;

* &7%.&"?&%"%&?&%"&.

*"5 " B0'

)&"%" & "&2 *1 * & "*&"%%+;7%A%2 +; & " %1 " &% A% #" 1+">';%" # $#"& &6 "*&"%%';

. " " "# 1 @"7# 2% 6"% % % %% * &#%"* &

&. * 7# "&.* & &. * 1' 1 86"6"%% & * #%"&.# 7 5 ' &% (& %6" % &7?& 5 %2"57 & 5 5 &6 " D:E "

#."& % &.6"% * #"F &&. 6"%% &#

@ &"8* 6" #"* *& 5. "2%75 %6"%% 5 2.% "

) .%75 &"8* 1 > * &.*& &16 " 1

#"**& 5 "5.&"%&. * &% %&. #%6"%" *& &&.' 1 8 & * #%"&.# 7 5

(& * & * 2" &% 7&

216 & #

"* "&# *&#

) 2 "%"%*&#.&" " 7%&

"&# "*&"%

"#&. #%6"%& & &6 "% @"7#75*&%" .* # & &62%*7"&#

&"*&"%75 " 1 &. & & %" #"% .% **% 6 * ' %%% %& > * %# & " % %"2 &. & &"*5* 7" " " & (& 04;75" # $#"

;

*& &

*&*#&2"&#.* &"6" > &*&%" &*#% # $#""%"&. & &"*5* % "% &* * &%&."%"&

. %*&& "1"# 51 7*&. *&& "& # % "%".%&6 ' @"7# %*& & *&*#& &7&%56 .#

&. **% &# *&.

" 6 & &"*5*6& 2&2% **% % %7"& %&**&# &. .* =#>( % &

5' 1 8 & 16 * *&#%& 5%" "2&2% *.*7# #* 6" 5"?* %75 @"7#

@ .%"*&"%%75 @"7# "%"2"&.

& &"*5*&"&.. %*&& "6 .#

**% 75" % %"2&. * 22 **& 7 %.."% 6

) 7 &1 @"7# 6 ?# .% 6"% *& &#%"&.# 7 5 4# 26&.* & &.

* *& "&%"&%%**% "&# &.#&. & &"2 *1*& &&.' > &76"%% & ,' &. 2* @ &# * & &. * 6& "

* &6%?#%* %7# *& &7%#"

%*5&.

) 7 *&.6." & &7 27" "

" & @ ".&"1 * .&#% % & *& &&.' > %&.&# &.' 1 86"%% 75 @"7#16 " %*& 1 57757& &% ?& 5%2"5

@ ".&" .% 75 * #**%

" 5 @ #%6"%&%.%%*& &&.' > 6"%% &"8* 6 " D E "#."&

% &..&. * & * #"F &&. &# 7%*& &. * & 57757& &% ?& 5 %2"5 ; 7&2&%.* &1 % &% &.**&"%5

;

" .%75 #"**& 5 > %&. #%6"%%"# %&.

* &%%**&"%5

* % &% &. 6 7&2 &%.* &% %%%1 *&#

* & 1.51

%% &%&.**&"%5 4"?

!"#$ %&"'

!()$* "&#

'# !+,

"&#