High Court of Punjab and HaryanaCRM-A/797/2023disposed of

Karambir v. Sushil

2025-08-28Mr. Justice Rajesh Bhardwaj5 pages

##$ % & '&($

! ! " * +

,,,,, #$%&'

'#()*#$+ ,(#-.

-(##$($)(# ##$&) '

. / $0$##$/(!#&/) ) ))

#) "1 $ ) '&" 0$ 2&)$ / 3( 4()35( "13( $& (6&) #)

&)!#$&) ' )5('.( +/"$7 &! 3

( 38( 9

:9"$'&# !& /& %-%&0123 14#451#- 6& 4#4#&%7#(#4 05 + , .

,(1314#-.

+ ) "$ )&)!# 0 # ' )

. 3$&))((0!( /($##$&) ' " (& ' $0# () ;&)/!&)

-( ("0) )"$" )$$5 = $13(0! !!&(0"$& /(# ##$5((" &! ") "11)# ) 7(30!

&) ' ( 3 3#1 (($) (6&# 5((& )(!# (!!)"1# 5(( /)( 3!$13(&)35((6&(" )(& ) ')$13( /(0! !!&" #$)# 5(( /(&)5(( & )035(3! /(# ##$&) ' .(

# 0) !(( /(# ##$ &) ' .! /()"/ &";) 1 ) '!$ $13 0! !3 5(0 " ( & ( !3 &)$$1!&(0 /(# ##$ -( )$13 ( ((* $! (&/( (# 0&"

5(&!)/1)# )"&$$$) "1 ( 0! 3 5(( ># $ $&)($/$ # 0))0! 5(# ##$ ( 13/ ) 6&$3 ('3( &/((*&"$* & # ##$0(!#$)# &( ##$3(&/(& &(##$5(($0 (& :50 3$51 1 ( ' !#$# ##$ ?&5(

! 0!@ /( # ##$3 ( 4/#$$0##$ !( :/(& &) '

.( 5&$)" 15(("))"1(* $!"1 (# 0' ( =& ($13(* $!(!))'

&! "(0!@ /(# ##$ ;&(5( / )!#$ (' $/##$ (( ()3(* $!( )(# 0' 0/ &# /( (0!# ##$(/ &)!)( !# ) !#$

=($13(0$0!(' # &) ' ( #&& "1" -("&(!#$$)&) (# 0(& # 0!#$ # '( )'.( "1># # (# 0( (! $&()!) ) !$ -( 3(!#$3 5((0!)(& (6&!&" &)"0! !(# 0' )5( ()0!&) ' 5(

=& ( 3 ##$1/ ( ) # #0 0 &$/3 :9"$'&# !& 1(%508(#0% %6%42% 40%--1:%45% 6& #$ ;23#( (8(# (1314#- <<%#- 8

*10'

(1314#- <<%#- 8 = )%51)%)

= + 5($$ 1/(

;&)/!($$"##$"$ #0$13(($)&) < -()$ &)$/5(&"0 /(3"1($/$& 3) )"# #0&$ ># $1 "1 1 !#$ !) (0 #0# -($/$!>!B+0& =&& = !7!# "3+* B)/ (5$5&/( /&$5($$5)( #3 5(# &!## #01)( # &!#/ $$1)# &$( 1 (5 "1 ># # 0 ( & ( #01 ( 5 ) "$ ( &/( 1 !#$ -( "& &( & 5&$) (0 ( 6&/0) /(3!

#5"& ) !# >/ "$/ :50 3 5( ) ) /# / )( # #$ # 0&"6&$10 &$)"1()$ / "(3(6&(0 &$/ 4$1) )"1)&$3 #0 '1& 1& >%5#2&% 1& &%00-%) -#* 0'#0 0'% -#* )%5-#(%) >?

0'1& 82(0 1& (%0(8&<%5016% #4) 1& 48(3#--?

#&&23%) >% 0'% -#* 9(83 0'% 145%<0184

-(# 5$1)& &$!&" &) 5( ( ;&)/! $2):3%40 8( )%51&184 *'15'

140%(<(%0& # &0#020% 8( <(861&184 0'%(%89 )%5-#(%& 0'% 3%#414:

0'% &0#020% #& &'82-) >% 584&0(2%) 9(83 0'% )#0% 10& %4#503%40 4 80'%( *8()&+ 0'% $2):3%40 )%5-#(%& *'#0 0'% -%:1&-#02(% '#) &#1) #0 0'% 013% *'%4 0'% -#* *#& <(832-:#0%) #4) 0'%(%98(%+ '#& (%0(8&<%5016% %99%50 ( 13(& ( &$ 5((# &!)"# #0&$># $1!) #0 C($$5 !(!3()

;&)/!&/# #$$5##$"$$$ #0(/#)1" ) &!5(("&)(!/( $55((>) !(#( )& # 0 C((")$ )"($5($) !&"($)(0$51"($5($) -( $&$! !( $(()&1( & B# &5$5"&!) >#&)($)B !#())) .

-( 305(;&)/! ) )"1(:9"$ '&# ! & %-%&0123 14#451#- &# ) 1(%508(#0% %6%42% 40%--1:%45% &# 3 $ ) ' 2&)/3 )3 ) ) (# $0##$##$$)&) ' ) &(!(## # & )#$ !

/ 1) ))(!#$## "4)( )($ )'2&)/3 )3 (5(

#)3 )/$1 *)/##$313$ ))#)

,! ".

C(( '#4/E ) FE+ C(( # "$ FE+